Is Honeycomb Android's Vista?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Before you guys get all bent out of shape, when the author of this article said "Honeycomb is Android's Vista" it wasn't meant as a slam.

So what was wrong with Vista? There were a number of individual problems such as incompatibility with older devices, and a penchant for asking for security permission on many common operations. But I think the biggest one was perception.
 
Finally, a tech journalist that gets it about Vista instead of slamming it outright. I agree with all of his points about Vista and it's comparison with 7. I don't have any experience with Android of any version to comment on his Honeycomb perception however.
 
Yeah, I agree with the article. Google's own admission that Honeycomb isn't fully ready and that's why they won't release the source code confirmed this version of Android didn't quite get the same amount of time to be finished as previous versions did. Basically this part is spot on:
'Google withheld the source code to Honeycomb because it wasn’t ready for prime time. IceCream will be open. That means more ports, more custom ROMS, and better bug reports, bug fixes, and other contributions. I predict that reviewers that panned Honeycomb will love IceCream. Eventually the memory of Honeycomb, like Vista, will fade into history.'
 
I never had any problems with vista, I got vista ultimate when it came out, a year later I got another copy. I think the main reason that vista did so poorly is because of bad marketing I cant remember many if any vista commercials the only ones I remember are the Mac commercials bashing vista. Now windows 7 had loads of marketing, on the web an on TV. I remember seeing probably 1 or 2 ads a day for windows 7 in the months leading up to its release.
 
Vista was a damn good OS. Anyone who said otherwise was computer illiterate.

I used Vista from beta's, to RC1, to RC2, etc...I never had problems with it. When 7 rolled around and Vista was fully upgraded (I think that was ~SP2 days), it was the same god damn thing.
 
Vista was a damn good OS. Anyone who said otherwise was computer illiterate.

I used Vista from beta's, to RC1, to RC2, etc...I never had problems with it. When 7 rolled around and Vista was fully upgraded (I think that was ~SP2 days), it was the same god damn thing.

Your opinion of Vista really depended entirely on how much RAM you had. What ran Windows XP just fine would horribly choke on Vista. I had 8GB so Vista worked better than XP for me, but try to put in on a computer with only 1-2GB and it was terrible.
 
Vista was a damn good OS. Anyone who said otherwise was computer illiterate.

I used Vista from beta's, to RC1, to RC2, etc...I never had problems with it. When 7 rolled around and Vista was fully upgraded (I think that was ~SP2 days), it was the same god damn thing.

/agree i have been running vista business (64bit) for quite some time, just recently switched over W7 Pro 64bit (got it for 29.95 thru MSDNAA) and i cannot tell a bit of performance difference between vista sp2 and w7 sp1. Just goes to show you that stupid ppl will believe anything they hear :rolleyes:

As with honeycomb, i think its a fine os, i have it running (sort of) on my galaxy tab, besides the fact that wifi is iffy and video can lag at times (none of which is honeycombs fault) its great os just waiting for xda guys to get a better rom build out but so far i like it.
 
Your opinion of Vista really depended entirely on how much RAM you had. What ran Windows XP just fine would horribly choke on Vista. I had 8GB so Vista worked better than XP for me, but try to put in on a computer with only 1-2GB and it was terrible.

Really cant knock an OS or any program when you are running the minimum requirements...
 
Really cant knock an OS or any program when you are running the minimum requirements...

You can't? I'm pretty sure most people did. Heck, maybe that's why everybody was so welcoming of Windows 7, between the time Vista and Windows 7 came out most PCs started having double the RAM they use to.
 
The sheeple hated on Vista because that's what competitor marketing told them.

Their aunt's cat tells them that too. The trouble with Vista is with the advent of blogs and forums and social networking writ large, everyone's suddenly a computer expert.
 
The funny thing is all the things we heard about Vista we heard about XP when it came out.
 
Only problem I ever had with Vista was that the print spooler was fucked up when it first came out.
 
Only problem I ever had with Vista was that the print spooler was fucked up when it first came out.

That's about the only problem that still persist to this day on various printers, especially sleeping network printers. Documents won't clear itself from the queue sometimes if you cancel it after it fails - sometimes rebooting or restarting spooler service doesn't even do anything. Majorly annoying, especially when you have a boss who likes to blame all woes on the IT guy. Well sorry big guy, I didn't write Vista. :-P
 
The children of a lessor god don't get it that Vista is Windows 7, minus what amounts to a service pack, but at least one writer knows better. And, why does anyone with more than three brain cells like the default taskbar of Windows 7?

Anyway, the Xoom tablet will get polished and new OS versions will come out. Look at all the nimrods who bought the iPad, which isn't half the computer the Xoom is. And, why is it that ditching the useful keyboard in favor of a Micky Mouse touch-layer over the screen causes the price of a netbook to double?
 
The children of a lessor god don't get it that Vista is Windows 7, minus what amounts to a service pack, but at least one writer knows better. And, why does anyone with more than three brain cells like the default taskbar of Windows 7?

Anyway, the Xoom tablet will get polished and new OS versions will come out. Look at all the nimrods who bought the iPad, which isn't half the computer the Xoom is. And, why is it that ditching the useful keyboard in favor of a Micky Mouse touch-layer over the screen causes the price of a netbook to double?

Curious as to what a Xoom can do the iPad cannot. If I was to buy an Android tablet right now, it'd be the ASUS EEE Pad Transformer, or perhaps the Slider, depending on how thick it is.
 
Two things

1) vista the same as 7? Get me some of what you're smoking.
2) Honeycomb is ok. I'm posting this with my gslate. It does have issues.
 
Curious as to what a Xoom can do the iPad cannot. If I was to buy an Android tablet right now, it'd be the ASUS EEE Pad Transformer, or perhaps the Slider, depending on how thick it is.

Looking forward to good availability on the Transformer. I'll probably pick one up when it's possible to do so.
 
Two things

1) vista the same as 7? Get me some of what you're smoking.
2) Honeycomb is ok. I'm posting this with my gslate. It does have issues.

I have a nearly identical user experience with Windows 7 32-bit at work that I do with Vista64 at home.. Had windows 7 come out when Vista did, everyone would've faced the EXACT same "incompatibilities" with older hardware, etc because the driver model changed. Vista was just the whipping boy that got it done, and by the time 7 came out everyone had updated their drivers to the new model.

End of story.
 
Yes, if only in the way that it really wasn't ready at launch. ;)

I want to install it when Intel's x86 port is ready.
 
Two things

1) vista the same as 7? Get me some of what you're smoking.
2) Honeycomb is ok. I'm posting this with my gslate. It does have issues.

I've actually heard quite a few people refer to 7 as vista SP3. Its pretty much Vista with a modern day "MS Plus!" Installed. 7 Runs the exact same on my machine as Vista does.
Posted via Mobile Device
 
Vista got a few bad reviews. When something costs a few hundred dollars, a few bad reviews are all it takes to nuke it (unless you have Apple's marketing department backing you up, I guess). That and the increased system requirements.

Of those willing to give it a try, how many had a machine that could actually run the OS? How many installed it in machines that couldn't run it properly (lack of RAM, for example) and added to the negative reviews?
 
That was an article well worth reading. I actually agree with the guy. I thought Vista was great. Win 7 is of course better. I'm buying an Asus Transformer for the wife shortly so I'll get to really see what Honeycomb is about soon enough.
 
I've actually heard quite a few people refer to 7 as vista SP3. Its pretty much Vista with a modern day "MS Plus!" Installed. 7 Runs the exact same on my machine as Vista does.
Posted via Mobile Device

Vista reports itself as Windows version 6.0. Windows 7 reports itself as Windows version 6.1. Calling it "7" is a marketing ploy. (go to the command line and type: ver)

Windows 7 has been tweaked a little more (being a later release), but both Vista and 7 have the same system requirements. Yet, 7 was released almost three years later, meaning reviewers' first experiences with 7 were on a computer at least twice as powerful as their first experience with Vista.

Microsoft has had no "bad" operating systems, the way some are regarded, such as Vista and Windows ME (a good OS, but a lame duck of the inferior Win9x line).
 
It's nice to know that many others do understood the real story of Vista. Vista was a big step from XP, and there's no way you take a big step like that without some pain involved. I had some minor headaches early on (mostly driver bugs), but I quickly found it to be hugely better than XP. Vista "took the bullet" for 7, and paved the way for it to be a success. I'm glad that most people have moved on to 7. XP is a malignant disease on the Internet, which is finally being stamped out.

I'm encouraged by all the "it-getters" here. Very encouraged. As much as I enjoy thinking of myself as having superior knowledge, I enjoy even more not being surrounded by idiots.
 
I hate to break up the Vista love fest here, but it wasn't the best thing to come out of MS. Don't forget there were some issues. IIRC, MS had a deactivation server problem, there was a service pack installation problem (which got resolved), and it took a very long time to install. The press and perception did the rest.
 
Vista got a few bad reviews. When something costs a few hundred dollars, a few bad reviews are all it takes to nuke it (unless you have Apple's marketing department backing you up, I guess). That and the increased system requirements.

Of those willing to give it a try, how many had a machine that could actually run the OS? How many installed it in machines that couldn't run it properly (lack of RAM, for example) and added to the negative reviews?

Few? If it wasn't complaints that they would have to buy new equipment because of lack of drivers, it was complaints that the hardware requirements were too high. Not to mention the DRM complaints which in the end were way off base or the people who didn't understand UAC and complained about it. The vast majority of the tech population hated it with a passion and still do to this day. Ask a random geek about Vista vs 7 and the majority of them will mention one or all of the above.

This was a major source of the fud that people took as the gospel even when more competent writers proved how it was 100% wrong in several of it's slams. http://www.cs.auckland.ac.nz/~pgut001/pubs/vista_cost.html
 
Vista reports itself as Windows version 6.0. Windows 7 reports itself as Windows version 6.1. Calling it "7" is a marketing ploy. (go to the command line and type: ver)

Windows 7 has been tweaked a little more (being a later release), but both Vista and 7 have the same system requirements. Yet, 7 was released almost three years later, meaning reviewers' first experiences with 7 were on a computer at least twice as powerful as their first experience with Vista.

The official reason they called 7 6.1 was because when they jumped from 5 to 6 a lot of programs broke when they expected Version 5. A lot of the early windows updates were hacks to allow those programs to work in Vista and they still occasionally update the list if you read some of the extended info for some of the updates. Windows 8 is called Version 6.2 for similar reasons.
 
Considering that I run vista on my laptop and am typing this on a xoom I agree with the article. I never had a hitch with vista in the many years I've used it and am enjoying honeycomb quite well. Could use some tweeks, sure, but overall it does what I want it to do. When the market gets more mature for honeycomb apps it'll be even better.
 
Vista pre-SP1 was very usable after a couple of significant patches that fixed odd behaviors were released.

But meh, I only used Vista on a daily basis, so what do I know. ;)
 
Vista always ran fine for me. I only ever chose to run Vista Basic 64bit and it worked very well. However I was using good kit.

However, I get a lot of folks Vista laptops to service and all of them are terrible. Constant HDD thrashing, slow to start up, just truly awful.

Then the 50/50 lottery of SP1/2 ever installing.
 
I dunno I thouught vista was kind of crappy at first. Then after some updates and a service pack it was pretty awesome. 7 was pretty awesome from the start. There were a few minor kinks, but they were worked out quickly. The only real issues I had were software developers dumb fault.
 
Vista was fine after some updating / SP1. Most of the problems were driver growing pains that like someone else said, we'd have now on 7 instead if it hadn't been done.

That said, one of the problems with Vista was it being installed by OEMs on systems that simply couldn't really handle it and/or didn't have enough RAM. 7 performs a lot better on older/slower systems than Vista ever did, but neither flourishes well on 512MB RAM machines.
 
Sounds like Obama. Obamacare is not well received because we didn't sell it well enough. God forbid anyone DISAGREE!!

I built a system just to run Vista. Waited three months after release for a bit of stability even. But after 30 days I formatted and lost my data just to get back to XP I was so frustrated. I got tired of fixing my computer EVERY DAMN DAY!

True, most problems were eventually fixed after SP1, but there are still the inexplicable changes. Settings playing musical chairs, or a chinese fire drill.

Mohave was a good idea, too bad it was just a marketing ploy. If they actually sold Vista configured the way it was for people showcased in those commercials, I think that would have gone a long way towards improving Vista's image. But as it was, bait and switch.
 
Curious as to what a Xoom can do the iPad cannot. If I was to buy an Android tablet right now, it'd be the ASUS EEE Pad Transformer, or perhaps the Slider, depending on how thick it is.

Yeah, the Transformer is the only tablet I've been even remotely tempted to buy... Their keyboard/port expander/battery concept was really well executed, good enough that it could replace my netbook in many instances (but still not all).

I like Android a lot, I've had an EVO since the day it came out, but tablets running a mobile OS still seem like way too much of a plaything for me. Yeah they're more comfortable than a laptop OR a phone when I'm laying on the couch, but beyond that I don't really see the value in them. I'd rather upgrade my laptop or do something else with the $400-600 that those tablets cost. Maybe I'm cheap or maybe I'm too attached to my desktop (and/or I need too much of my mobile system, can't open a compiler or watch ISOs on a tablet after all ;) ).

Now when they come down in price to $300-ish they'll probably start to become much more commonplace (like smartphones and iPods touch)... They'll probably supplant the family PC in the long run since most people's computing needs are pretty limited and a tablet w/a mobile OS is somewhat more secure and easier to use (and heck, easier for a parent to monitor/control even, etc.). Anyone that needs to get actual work done (or even school work beyond HS) still needs a regular laptop tho (or desktop), I don't see that ever changing.

The price point for current tablets just seems like a huge cash grab to me, Apple started it and others were more than happy to follow suit. If ASUS can sell the Transform at $400 I don't see how the Xoom w/an inferior screen was ever worth $600+, or the original iPad w/inferior hardware for that matter. Too much carrier meddling going on with these things, the VAST majority of people don't need a 3G radio in anything but their phone (god forbid people wake up and learn to tether and use up the data plans they already pay for).
 
As for Honeycomb... Haven't had a chance to play with it so I dunno if it's truly just suffering from teething pains and a PR problem like Vista was, but I doubt most consumers have even the faintest idea what version of Android any given phone/tablet is running... Geeks like us care, but that's about it.
 
Your opinion of XP really depended entirely on how much RAM you had. What ran Windows 98 just fine would horribly choke on XP. I had 512mb so XP worked better than 98 for me, but try to put in on a computer with only 128-256MB and it was terrible.

Fixed. ;)

Microsoft has had no "bad" operating systems, the way some are regarded, such as Vista and Windows ME (a good OS, but a lame duck of the inferior Win9x line).

Vista was fine, ME was a fucking turd. You clearly have no firsthand experience if you are trying to compare Vista and ME. Vista had poor driver support and a marketing campaign against it ME was a hunk of shit that couldn't stop crashing.
 
Back
Top