is ground necessary in a system like this?

wayne

2[H]4U
Joined
Aug 4, 2003
Messages
2,726
right now, i got a system i slapped together using parts i found and its pretty decent

specs:
Tyan Trinity 400
PIII 633Mhz
around 128-256mb of ram (i have a couple sticks so im not sure which ones yet)
6.4gb WD Caviar
52x cd-rw
raidmax 420w psu
Radeon 7000
NIC, sound card, cables, etc

this is currently not in a case... i do not have an available case right now and i do not plan on buying one no matter how cheap it is because im just gonna keep it this way for a couple months before i make it into a server for a network... then when i make it into a server, it'll be modded... for now, im not too worried about the future of this case but as of now, its gonna be caseless inside a wooden desk and would have a cardboard fixture holding the motherboard, cards, hdd, and cd drive

this desk has an outlet thats the closest to it but it doesnt have ground... the next closest outlet that has ground would be all the way on the other side of the room... do i need to ground this computer?... this is pretty much just inside a drawer-like compartment of my table and everythings either wood or cardboard inside so i dont think anything will short.... is it still important to have ground?... i understand grounding a chassis to prevent getting electrocuted but theres no chassis and no one would be touching this computer except me and when i do, chances are, its gonna be off

everything works, i already tested this as a system in another room so i know theres no stray wires sending hot power to the psu chassis or something

so yea, thats my situation... is ground really necessary as of now?... this is a computer that no one would touch for a few months... the monitor has a plastic chassis so minimal chances of getting electrocuted touching the monitor

what do you guys think?... in a situation like this, what is there that needs to be grounded?... or am i good without ground?... i dont wanna pull an extension to the nearest grounded outlet because that one already has a computer on it and i dont want an overload or anything

thanks
 
ive tested many pc's with just the guts on a piece of foam for days, you should be ok.
 
Blauman said:
ive tested many pc's with just the guts on a piece of foam for days, you should be ok.
isnt foam bad because it creates static electricity?

im keeping this longer than a few days but not long term... more like a couple weeks to a few months
 
it's never a great idea to cut the ground pin off a power cable....

I am not sure about it, but the ground may also be for static discharge.... so if you touch your PSU for instance and zap it, you won't fry something in the drawer.... just a thought, no expert
 
try a piece of wood instead of cardboard. cardboard can conduct under certain circumstances. I'm running my folding farm on a nice piece of 2'x8' hardwood plywood.

As to cutting the ground pin off the power cable, NO. buy a new extension cord, buy a spike stik, buy something else. don't cut off the ground pin.
 
AMV said:
it's never a great idea to cut the ground pin off a power cable....

I am not sure about it, but the ground may also be for static discharge.... so if you touch your PSU for instance and zap it, you won't fry something in the drawer.... just a thought, no expert
i didnt cut off the ground pin... im saying that my outlet doesnt have a ground... and i have a single extension that happens to have a broken ground pin... which is perfect for that socket

im not cutting off any ground pins btw

to sum up everything, this is simply what im asking:
is ground necessary in a non-chassis setup?
 
it is not strictly required to earth ground a comptuer. Earth provides no benifit under normal operating conditions.
If you have a static discharge near the case, or a short cicuit (probably more likley in hacked together case than in a proper one), you may be sorry you didn't earth it.
 
ATX switched PSUs require ground for proper functioning. They'll work without ground, but will be less efficient and won't take surges very well, if at all.
 
Elledan said:
ATX switched PSUs require ground for proper functioning. They'll work without ground, but will be less efficient and won't take surges very well, if at all.
cough cough...bullshit.
 
Met-AL said:
cough cough...bullshit.
seems like it... but at least give people a lil explaining time before shooting stuff down again like that

explain?

i understand a lil about the surge part altho if there really is a surge, grounding it wont do much
 
Met-AL said:
cough cough...bullshit.
Not exactly:

It should be noted here that the ground on the printed circuit board is floating, but the enclosure is connected to earth. This arrangement reduces HF current flow on the enclosure, which would lead the box to act as a noise radiator instead of a shield! The power transistors and diodes are mounted in a special way too, for the same reason. This will be described in the construction section.
http://www.qsl.net/xq2fod/Electron/PS40/PS40.html

Improper use of the FET heat sink can sometimes increase noise by acting as an antenna. Connecting it to bulk negative or earth can help minimize its effect.
http://www.electronicproducts.com/ShowPage.asp?SECTION=3700&PRIMID=&FileName=marglo1.mar2001

Basically, a connection to earth is used to decrease EMI in the circuit, which otherwise would decrease performance.. It also helps to prevent the enclosure (and attached conductive components) from becoming 'live'.
 
The worst of all is that most grounds[Meaning leading to earth], is not good anyway.

A decent copper ground under the house foundation will set you back another houses price.

I still have this theory that poor earths used, just invites Lightning if you are in such a area, and then cannot dissapates the surge, leaving your stuff crumpy and black.

I would.nt worry too much in your case. :D
 
Is a car with top electronics grounded ?, no not to earth, but to it's frame, but thats to save wires.

In case of your PC, the connectors from PSU to MB and other HW has all the references in the pins, so your voltages should be OK.

Your only lead to the outside is your AC input and tel line for modem, and if you ask me, you are better off without a probable poor earth. :D

:D You are not inviting lightning at least :D


The only problem I see is that your setup is not shielded, but at least your PSU is closed by metal surroundings.
 
Moto Guzzi said:
Is a car with top electronics grounded ?, no not to earth, but to it's frame, but thats to save wires.

In case of your PC, the connectors from PSU to MB and other HW has all the references in the pins, so your voltages should be OK.

Your only lead to the outside is your AC input and tel line for modem, and if you ask me, you are better off without a probable poor earth. :D

:D You are not inviting lightning at least :D


The only problem I see is that your setup is not shielded, but at least your PSU is closed by metal surroundings.
huh, my setup is closed by wooden and cardboard surroundings
 
Elledan said:
Not exactly:


http://www.qsl.net/xq2fod/Electron/PS40/PS40.html


http://www.electronicproducts.com/ShowPage.asp?SECTION=3700&PRIMID=&FileName=marglo1.mar2001

Basically, a connection to earth is used to decrease EMI in the circuit, which otherwise would decrease performance.. It also helps to prevent the enclosure (and attached conductive components) from becoming 'live'.
interesting... thanks for the info

but this computer isnt really pushing for performance... its jus another computer thats sticking around for now... would it really matter?
 
putting it this way to you: Your metal enclosed loose lying PSU is more screened than some blue perpex see trough models available on market.. Sleep tight :D
 
Moto Guzzi said:
putting it this way to you: Your metal enclosed loose lying PSU is more screened than some blue perpex see trough models available on market.. Sleep tight :D
waht do you mean more screened?

blue perpex see thru?
 
The ground wire is for safety. Without a ground any current that comes in contact with the power supply case would give you a shock if you touch the case. With a grounded circut current would go to ground instead of through you. This is why items made with plastic (insulated) handles (power drills, hair driers) do not require ground and metal (conductive) ones do.
 
jtnik said:
The ground wire is for safety. Without a ground any current that comes in contact with the power supply case would give you a shock if you touch the case. With a grounded circut current would go to ground instead of through you. This is why items made with plastic (insulated) handles (power drills, hair driers) do not require ground and metal (conductive) ones do.
yea but i wont be touching this and even if i do, the most would be wood/plastic/or cardboard

im guessing ground-less in this situation should be ok, ill just run it like this then... i figure if i do get ground, then the only thing that will be grounded is the psu chassis cus its the only metal chassis in there but i wont be touching the psu much so it should be ok
 
You can run it without earth ground, just don't touch the PSU case. As for sheilding, there won't be any... all computer cases are metal for a reason, it helps block interference... going into and out of the computer.

processors create a lot of emi which might have some odd effects on other electronics around a computer without a case. on the flip side, other electronics as well as lightening, etc... could have some adverse effects on the performance of a computer without a case. will a computer work without a case though? of course. just make sure you got some air circulation inside that desk though... don't wanna fry your board inside a wooden case.

and don't set it on cardboard either... just put it on wood.
 
there is a ground wire in the socket, drill a hole into the socket and connect the groundwire through it (if yo uaren't an electrician than dont try this at home! get an electrician to do it)

~Adam
 
wayne said:
interesting... thanks for the info

but this computer isnt really pushing for performance... its jus another computer thats sticking around for now... would it really matter?
What you're doing is pretty much the same as putting a system in a plexiglas case and then hooking up this system to a non-grounded outlet. It'll work, but if you've got any strong sources of EMI nearby (a big subwoofer, fluorescent lighting, etc.), the chance on data corruption (cables and traces on the PCB act like antennae) is very real.

Because the PSUs enclosure is ungrounded as well, and a switching power supply happens to be one of the most noisiest components inside a PC in terms of EMI, I'd keep the PSU as far away from the rest of the system as possible.
 
CleanSlate said:
there is a ground wire in the socket, drill a hole into the socket and connect the groundwire through it (if yo uaren't an electrician than dont try this at home! get an electrician to do it)

~Adam
dont worry, i understand that... im kinda an electrician so yea... me and my dad already discussed that, maybe i ll give that a shot... i already got those plugs anyways so might as well use them
 
Elledan said:
What you're doing is pretty much the same as putting a system in a plexiglas case and then hooking up this system to a non-grounded outlet. It'll work, but if you've got any strong sources of EMI nearby (a big subwoofer, fluorescent lighting, etc.), the chance on data corruption (cables and traces on the PCB act like antennae) is very real.

Because the PSUs enclosure is ungrounded as well, and a switching power supply happens to be one of the most noisiest components inside a PC in terms of EMI, I'd keep the PSU as far away from the rest of the system as possible.
i do have a neon light inside (not a ccfl, it clearly says liquid neon).. does that cause EMI and how bad are the results?

i do know this has some kinda effect because when i first bought this neon light a while ago, i waved it over a solar-powered calculator and the numbers start jumping around like crazy
 
I have 8x temp guages, and if I put a PC-Neon light near them, say within 3-5 inches, they start giving all sorts of wrong readings, so I dropped that idea.

These guages has small IC on each working off 1.5V, but is not shielded themselves, has plastic casings.
 
wayne said:
i do have a neon light inside (not a ccfl, it clearly says liquid neon).. does that cause EMI and how bad are the results?

i do know this has some kinda effect because when i first bought this neon light a while ago, i waved it over a solar-powered calculator and the numbers start jumping around like crazy

yea, i'd take the neon light out while you're running like this.. they emit all sorts of crazy noise.
 
plot said:
yea, i'd take the neon light out while you're running like this.. they emit all sorts of crazy noise.
noise?

electrical noise or audio noise?... i dont hear anything tho
 
electrical. and you could also build it a "tinfoil hat" to reduce the noise, like a faraday cage.
 
wayne said:
i do have a neon light inside (not a ccfl, it clearly says liquid neon).. does that cause EMI and how bad are the results?

i do know this has some kinda effect because when i first bought this neon light a while ago, i waved it over a solar-powered calculator and the numbers start jumping around like crazy
Both neons and CCFLs operate on high voltages, so they'll produce quite some EMI, albeit less than a switching power supply. Just keep them away from cables and traces on the mainboard, expansion cards, etc., and it shouldn't give any problems.
 
Elledan said:
Both neons and CCFLs operate on high voltages, so they'll produce quite some EMI, albeit less than a switching power supply. Just keep them away from cables and traces on the mainboard, expansion cards, etc., and it shouldn't give any problems.
its like right at the tip of the motherboard on the top... about 5 inches or so away from the board.... i turned on the comp and all but i dont know how to tell in performance difference... how would it be noticed?
 
wayne said:
its like right at the tip of the motherboard on the top... about 5 inches or so away from the board.... i turned on the comp and all but i dont know how to tell in performance difference... how would it be noticed?
While I don't recommend putting potentially disruptive decorative components inside a system's case, if you run a couple of tests/benchmarks (HDDs, RAM, videocard performance) with good results, and the system otherwise appears to be unaffected, then there should be no reason to be worried.
 
Elledan said:
While I don't recommend putting potentially disruptive decorative components inside a system's case, if you run a couple of tests/benchmarks (HDDs, RAM, videocard performance) with good results, and the system otherwise appears to be unaffected, then there should be no reason to be worried.

Well this is true.. however over time your system's physical tolerances start to slip... perhaps later an ide cord could degrade in tolerance (happens all the time to me) and then you could cause massive issues.. eh

~Adam
 
CleanSlate said:
Well this is true.. however over time your system's physical tolerances start to slip... perhaps later an ide cord could degrade in tolerance (happens all the time to me) and then you could cause massive issues.. eh

~Adam
Good point.
 
Back
Top