Is 2gig really worth it?

eddie500

Gawd
Joined
Jan 23, 2003
Messages
1,009
OK, I'm going back to about a year and a half ago, and there was almost no difference between 1gig and 2 gig of memory. I think the first game that noticed any difference was battlefield 2041 or something.

Well a lot of people back then would say 2 gig was better, but a lot of real testing showed no improvement with 2 gig of memory, and actually it was slower in certain circumstances.

But today people are saying my 1gig is really bad and slowing me down. My question is is this true? Is 2gig a very important upgrade for my computer?

I have a total of 4 memory slots on my computer, 2 of them are taken for the dual channel. SHould I go with 2 more sticks of 512meg? or should I upgrade to only 2 sticks of 2 gig? I'm thinking that 4 sticks of memory my run slower then only 2 sticks?
What do you think??
 
It will make a HUGE difference.
I know that when i ran BF2 on 1gb it ran slow, like it was using the page file.
2gb's just works awesome. If you have the cash you could go with 2 1gb sticks for 3gb's. (Maybe good for vista and games)
 
1GB is fine for normal every day use and even gaming. But nowadays there are quite a few games that are more RAM hungry. Supreme Commander, Call of Duty 2, Battlefield 2142, and Elder Scrolls: Oblivion are some of the more RAM hungry games out there today.

AS for whether or not you should upgrade to 2GB, it depends. Can you play all your games just fine? Can your PC keep up with your multitasking?
 
with a s939 setup, you're using ddr400. with ddr, the 2x1gb kit would be better since you could run it at 1T. if you go with 3gb or 2 more 512 sticks, you'll be forced to run at 2T command rate, which would hinder performance. would you notice this hindrance? that all depends on you. most people find that 2x1gb runs better than 4x512mb or a mix of 2x512mb and 2x1gb, which is mainly due to the command rate.
 
Pretty huge difference in games such as UT2k4 and Supreme Commander.

My map loading times decreased 75% after adding 2GB.
 
There is no doubt in my mind that having 2GB of RAM in your rig would be better than 1GB. Newegg has a really good deal on 2GB DDR400 sticks right now - check it out. Having 3GB in your rig would help you for Vista, though 2GB is currently fine for gaming. Personally, 1GB is fine for games like Counter Strike, etc. but for newer games like BF2142, FEAR, STALKER, etc, you really want 2GB.

Here is the newegg link: (You could even go cheaper, but I have these and they are nice)

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16820220079
 
The question today: "Is 4gig really worth it?" 2GB has been the standard for performance/enthusiast machines for a while now, and Vista craves all the ram it can get. 2GB is definitely what I would default to for a new machine.
 
for everday stuff like web and word processing, etc, 1 gig is fine. I noticed a big jump in Call of Duty 2 performance, and if you're running MS Outlook, it'll be very noticable.

zv
 
The easy, not-so-direct answer is - it depends. It depends on what you use your computer for, how many background processes are running, how much multi-tasking you ask the system to perform, how much caching your programs do, etc. etc. etc.

Back in the day when I knew pretty much squat about computers, a pretty smart guy explained memory to me with a great analogy. Think of your memory as the top of your desk. More memory = bigger desktop and more room to put your files. Not everyone needs a bigger desktop, but if you find you're putting stacks of files on the floor (i.e. virtual memory), it would be a smart idea to get a bigger desk.

So, your question is "is it worth it?". I personally have 2GB in my machine and I think it's woth it because I need it for how I use it. But, we can't really answer whether it's worth it for you. You'll have to determine that for yourself.
 
Yes it is worth it, especially if you run Vista or if you multitask a lot...
 
Back in the day when I knew pretty much squat about computers, a pretty smart guy explained memory to me with a great analogy. Think of your memory as the top of your desk. More memory = bigger desktop and more room to put your files. Not everyone needs a bigger desktop, but if you find you're putting stacks of files on the floor (i.e. virtual memory), it would be a smart idea to get a bigger desk.

Thats a damn good analogy. I should use that one myself. Thanks man!
 
That is a great way to explain it.. I might know the smart guy who shared this with you, as I was given the same analogy many moons ago by an old guy myself:)

I installed Vista on one of my machines with 1g, ran it for a few weeks and then added a second gig and I can tell you that, from a "seat of the pants" perspective, the difference was very noticeable, and definitely worth the investment, in my opinion anyhow.
 
FPS benchmarks of games running 2GB vs 1GB could answer your question well. If you game I would even say 2GB is a necessity now. 4GB is overkill, first you'd need a 64bit OS and games aren't really optimized for so much memory.

1GB will suffice for every day computer use (office, email, surfing...).

DDR2 is becoming so cheap nowadays anyway, I'd get 2GB! ;)
 
I love my 2 gigs!
I am not sure if it was just the beta VS RTM of Vista, but with 2 gigs it runs 1000X better and i have seen a lot of other things run a LOT better too
 
FPS benchmarks of games running 2GB vs 1GB could answer your question well. If you game I would even say 2GB is a necessity now. 4GB is overkill, first you'd need a 64bit OS and games aren't really optimized for so much memory.

1GB will suffice for every day computer use (office, email, surfing...).

DDR2 is becoming so cheap nowadays anyway, I'd get 2GB! ;)

The FPS measurement isn't always the be all end all. For example, 2GB of RAM will surely decrease your loading times in games, but you can't measure that in FPS.
 
Back
Top