Iron Man's Suit Defies Physics - Mostly

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Wired magazine decided to take on the task of debunking Iron Man’s suit…you know, just in case some of us thought it was real. Damn you Wired! Damn you!

Tony Stark got his super powers by means of his engineering genius. But just how realistic is Stark's amazing suit? Sadly, nearly all of the features of the Iron Man suit, with one important exception, are not likely to be realized anytime soon. Let's look at each of the suit's major elements in turn.
 
The only reason any of us were going to see the movie next week was so we could build our own armor. :( What next Wired? Santa Claus and the Easter Bunny???
 
whaitdaminute...


how DOES that suit turn electrical energy into thrust? :confused:
 
the title contradicts the first sentance

"Tony Stark's amazing suit is a long way from realization, mostly due to practical energy constraints."

So in 50 years when another Albert Eisenstein is born and invents a new power source the size of apple , it wouldn't be possible?
 
Anybody see that discovery channel special when Superman returns came out talking about this stuff? There was that great quote in the promos from a guy talking about Superman. "It would be 1000x's more painful for Superman to save you falling from a building than it would be to hit the ground."
 
The same way Mr. Garrison can ride really fast with his specially made vehicle.

Are you suggesting the means to solve our world's energy crisis is to smoke a prosthetic cock and take it up the butt ?
 
So they think IronMan is unrealistic.Duh! We're talking about a comic book superhero! (Well,in IronMan's case the hero part is debatable,after all,he did get Captain America killed :mad:). If anything,I think comic mags are struggling these days because they tried to get too realistic.
 
"IT'" was Garrison's ride, <3 South Park
I thought movies and books were all real.
What's wrong with Santa and The Rabbitt?
 
What a surprisingly pointless story, next he'll want to tell us why Superman can't fly and spider-man can't climb wall, or Batman can have a relationship with a woman.

The answer is simple, Tony Stark is smarter and drunker than you, moron.
 
So they think IronMan is unrealistic.Duh! We're talking about a comic book superhero! (Well,in IronMan's case the hero part is debatable,after all,he did get Captain America killed :mad:). If anything,I think comic mags are struggling these days because they tried to get too realistic.

Good riddance. Captain America sucked. Dead Pool FTMFW!!!!
 
Popular Science did an article this month on the "Real Iron Man" that the government is funding. They are a lot closer than most think. I'd give it another 5 years before we have a decent prototype, and probably another 10 before we have soldiers wearing them.
I believe their ultimate goal is a simpler version of the nano suit from Crysis. Increased strength, speed and endurance.
Although in 100-200 years I envision that we'll have suits similiar to those in the Starship Troopers book.
 
I love it how people say things aren't possible... just as they said in the past that eletricity, wireless power, and the earth was round was impossible.
 
One of the things I liked about the latest Batman movie (and will enjoy about Iron Man) is how they are striving for a bit of believeability.

"Billionair-Cave-Diving-Spelunkers"


And this 2 minute Iron Man clip just looks great...
 
I love it how people say things aren't possible... just as they said in the past that eletricity, wireless power, and the earth was round was impossible.

Yarr, the scientists and engineers who spend their lives working towards making crazy shit possible are always way more interesting than the clowns who sit around saying stuff is impossible.

I mean, do we remember the names of the "eminent" scientists who said Newton was wrong, or Einstein, or Hawking?
No, we don't.

Do we remember the guys who said planes would never go faster than the speed of sound?
No, we don't.

Do we remember the guys who said computers would never need more than 640k of memory?
Well, yes, we do, but he, like, owns god now, or something.

I know one thing for certain, if a guy comes up with decent flying boots, it sure as hell won't be one of the "It can't be done!" guys.

Those guys suck.
 
..and the earth was round was impossible.
You do know that at the end of the great ocean, the world falls off into the void?

Kids and their fancy science!

Next you'll tell me that dirt doesn't protect me from germs!
 
My favorite part is everyone screaming about how it is possible and using other fantasy tech as examples... Errr.. Hello? McFly? It's a sci fi based super hero.. leave it be! Yes in the really real world as of today it isn't possible but yet it is... feasible because we can see where the restraints are that gives us a path to target development to. Deal with it! But who knows about tomorrow?
 
2440620533_37297e4b68_o.gif
 
This made me think about a show I saw on Discovery channel about car accidents. In head on collisions, people usually die not from the impact itself, but from internal bleeding/injuries due to going fast in a forward direction, having an almost immediate stop upon impact, then being pushed in the opposite direction by the larger vehicle (like if you smashed into an 18-wheeler). It's like playing soccer with your guts. How is this related?

...Well, I saw a trailer of the movie, and I had to think of what in the hell this is doing to Iron Man's insides when he appears to be fleeing from jet pilots, coming to almost instant stops, then dodging and flying away in a different direction faster than the jets are moving. So maybe this wouldn't be possible due to the limitations of our fragile human bodies rather than physics/technology?
 
So they think IronMan is unrealistic.Duh! We're talking about a comic book superhero! (Well,in IronMan's case the hero part is debatable,after all,he did get Captain America killed :mad:). If anything,I think comic mags are struggling these days because they tried to get too realistic.

Bah, Iron Man was right, Cap. dug his own grave!!! JK... but seriously, I'd be hard-pressed to decide if that whole thing were real.
 
What a surprisingly pointless story, next he'll want to tell us why Superman can't fly and spider-man can't climb wall, or Batman can have a relationship with a woman.

my beef with spiderman isn't his ability to walk on walls, it's the absolutely MASSIVE amount of super strong spider webbing that comes out of the wrists of this puny little guy.. then again, it's stupid to even try to rationalize any superhero abilities.. lol
 
The only reason any of us were going to see the movie next week was so we could build our own armor. :( What next Wired? Santa Claus and the Easter Bunny???

But the tooth fairy is real right? I mean its gotta be, I found coins under my pillow ITS GOTTA BE REAL!!!!
 
the title contradicts the first sentance

"Tony Stark's amazing suit is a long way from realization, mostly due to practical energy constraints."

So in 50 years when another Albert Eisenstein is born and invents a new power source the size of apple , it wouldn't be possible?

Prolly not, because us stupid humans will just make a bomb out of it and exterminate ourselves b4 getting around to something useful like that.
 
my beef with spiderman isn't his ability to walk on walls, it's the absolutely MASSIVE amount of super strong spider webbing that comes out of the wrists of this puny little guy.. then again, it's stupid to even try to rationalize any superhero abilities.. lol

If anything, that's the part of Spiderman that's believable.

http://abcnews.go.com/Technology/story?id=97539&page=1

How does a spider spin a web of silk that is five times stronger, on a weight-to-strength basis, than steel?

Five times stronger than steel and you think it's unbelievable that Spiderman has super stong webbing?
 
Spider-Man doesn't have webbing from his wrists in the comics. It comes from mechanical web shooters that he invented to dispense a webbing fluid which he also invented.
 
...Well, I saw a trailer of the movie, and I had to think of what in the hell this is doing to Iron Man's insides when he appears to be fleeing from jet pilots, coming to almost instant stops, then dodging and flying away in a different direction faster than the jets are moving. So maybe this wouldn't be possible due to the limitations of our fragile human bodies rather than physics/technology?

Um, inertial dampeners, hello! Some people...:rolleyes:
 
Solution: A small chunk of material from an outer space asteroid is found to emit enormous amounts of "safe" energy that is easily harnessed and is lightweight. Tony Stark easily puts it into his Iron Man suit and this mystery rock will power it for thousands of years. Tony Stark decides it is better used as an awesome battery pack for his suit rather than solving the world's energy crisis and global warming.
 
Why has no one suggested that if an Ironman-esque suit were to be made, you simply wouldnt fucking try to stop on a dime and pull all of the stuff Ironman does?

It wouldn't really be necessary to stop and dodge aircraft if he can outrun them and go as high. Speed and altitude happen to be very good protection when flying :)
 
This is almost as good as the guys making spiderman's webbing come out of his hands in the movies because a kid inventing mechanical webslingers wasn't believable. :confused:

In reply to the amount of web fluid it was found that Venom actually was shooting parts of his suit out as webbing. That is how spiderman defeated him the first time. He just dodged webbing until Venom was out of suit.

Articles like this should be how close we are to having something like Iron Man's armor. Not how far we are. Those people have no imagination. Its a comic hero btw. Things are much more interesting to try and find a way to do than try to tear down as impossible.
 
Comic books are fun to find ideas that might be possible then figure out how to make them work. I'd have more problems with the fact his legs don't get ripped off at the knees when the jets fire up. If the suit was strong enough to survive that kind of torque with out turning him into jelly, a working fusion bottle is no sweat.
Then again I'm an iron man fan from way back I'm going to see iron man even it turns out to suck.
 
Wow the only thing that needs to be posted less than this reply, was that article. I mean seriously are you shitting me, are article about jet boots and repulse rays being impossible.... gee why don't you just remove the text of the article, show a big picture of Iron Man, with the words "Comes to Theaters May 2nd" It seriously would have done the same thing they were really going for.
 
Back
Top