iPhone 3GS Performance Compared

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Anandtech did a brief performance comparison of the iPhone 3GS with the iPhone 3G, Palm Pre, and T-Mobile G1 and found that the 3GS is definitely a speed upgrade over the previous iPhone. I wonder why there are no Blackberry phones in this comparison though?

The iPhone 3GS uses an ARM Cortex A8 processor running at 600MHz, much like the Palm Pre. Many weren't confident that the 3GS used the new ARM A8 core instead of a higher clocked ARM11, so after waiting in line to grab a 3GS this morning I decided to run a few tests (the iPhone 3G tests were using OS 3.0 and the Pre tests used OS 1.0.2).
 
I wonder why there are no Blackberry phones in this comparison though?

RE: Comparisons by Anand Lal Shimpi, 10 hours ago
The only reason I didn't include the Storm? I don't have one :) I was a blackberry user long before the iPhone, there's a special place in my heart for them - although I think I still do favor the older blackberries thanks to their larger keyboards. I loved typing on them.

Take care,
Anand

In the comments.
 
well the storm with all the OS's up to .122 has been crap, Ill be switching myself and my entire office over to iphones when the contract is up on these storms, they suck

there very slow, the app store makes the phone so slow you can wait 2-3 minutes for it to "un freeze" just to click an icon or app to wait for that all over again

Ive used my friends iphone a few times and its so much faster, so much smoother, i feel like im using windows 98 and a 486 on the storm vs windows w7 and an i7 on the iphone, so much faster/smoother and after using his a few times, my storm makes me want to pull my hair out lol

sadly im only blocks from RIM HQ in Waterloo and its nice to support local but this thing sucks and doesnt deserve to be compared vs an iphone IMO

perhaps v5 OS will fix that, but i doubt it
 
The Storm also doesn't have wifi, so it couldn't have been included in the same experiment. Perhaps the Bold would've been a good choice.
 
...and i HATE Apple. lol

I also hate Apple and I just bought an iPhone 3GS. I was really looking forward to the Pre, but the larger screen and better app selection on the iPhone sealed the deal since the plan rate was the same (texting doesn't matter to me).

Last week BestBuy was practically giving away the Storm. I spent a while with it in store and it was just slow, clunky, and seemed very inaccurate with my finger clicks.

I really detest the Apple "we control everything" philosophy, but in two years only the Pre has been a decent competitor to the iPhone and isn't quite as good either. I would have bought a Pre last week if there were any available though. Sprints loss for not actually having enough.
 
The Meizu M8 would have been a nice contender too, especially with a firmware > 9.0.5., it is really quite fast now. 600mhz cpu, 720x480 screen, WinCE-based smartphone from china - and quite cheap to get. Unfortunately not the best choice for the US (most versions I've seen were GSM 900/1800 only).
 
well the storm with all the OS's up to .122 has been crap, Ill be switching myself and my entire office over to iphones when the contract is up on these storms, they suck

You need to upgrade to a .148 OS. If your carrier doesn't officially support it, download Verizons official .148.

All the complaints I had with my storm are basically void with that OS. Bells official .122 sucks... Couldn't change the ringtone, it would stop playing mp3s prematurely, among other problems.

Did some research on beta OSs and found people were having better experiences with the newer beta OSs, and sure enough they were right.
 
it doesn't matter which phone is faster, people will still buy an iPhone because of the large app library.. Why by i phone that you can't get any cool apps for
 
it doesn't matter which phone is faster, people will still buy an iPhone because of the large app library.. Why by i phone that you can't get any cool apps for

Because I already seem to have all the 'apps' that the iPhone ads are claiming in their "there's an app for that" commercials without having to download anything or purchase software for. On a Windows Mobile phone. And anything that I have needed, I seem to be able to find for free somewhere. Legitimtely free on top of that.

Only thing I don't have is an automatic tip calculator. And even then, I don't care. If you can't work a calculator, your problem isn't having an app, I can assure you.

No offense to those who do have an iPhone, but I just don't see what apps are deal breakers for the phone, at least through the commercials. I will admit that I haven't seen every app in the library, but even still, I just don't see the big appeal behind them.
 
Apps were never a deal sealer for me but an added bonus. When I was shopping for a phone I didn't make that a buying point, but I went with the iPhone because I like the GUI the best.
7221e5c8ec6b08ef6d3f9ff3ce6eb1d1.gif
 
You need to upgrade to a .148 OS. If your carrier doesn't officially support it, download Verizons official .148.

All the complaints I had with my storm are basically void with that OS. Bells official .122 sucks... Couldn't change the ringtone, it would stop playing mp3s prematurely, among other problems.

Did some research on beta OSs and found people were having better experiences with the newer beta OSs, and sure enough they were right.

plan on doing that tomorrow when i have my cable (its at the office)


read lots of +'s on the .148, this .122 blows
 
plan on doing that tomorrow when i have my cable (its at the office)


read lots of +'s on the .148, this .122 blows

Please report on the outcome. I want to stick with Verizon and want to get a Storm but if the iPhone is much faster than I will make the switch to the horrible ATT. I have to wait until October either way but more knowledge is power when making these types of decisions.
 
Because I already seem to have all the 'apps' that the iPhone ads are claiming in their "there's an app for that" commercials without having to download anything or purchase software for. On a Windows Mobile phone. And anything that I have needed, I seem to be able to find for free somewhere. Legitimtely free on top of that.

Only thing I don't have is an automatic tip calculator. And even then, I don't care. If you can't work a calculator, your problem isn't having an app, I can assure you.

No offense to those who do have an iPhone, but I just don't see what apps are deal breakers for the phone, at least through the commercials. I will admit that I haven't seen every app in the library, but even still, I just don't see the big appeal behind them.

I have come from a long line of WinMo phones and not a one of them released in the US compare to the iphone. HTC has been on a slow downward spiral. They release a decent competitor to the iPhone, Touch HD, but neglect to release it in the US. Still lots of bugs. I probably would have gone with the Touch HD if they released it here in US but now kind of glad after hearing some of the bugs.

I detest Apple, I really do. I hate what they stand for and how they operate. But I love my iPhone. Sure a lot of the apps can be found on WinMo phones, but many don't compare. Shazam is awesome. Directv app is slick, White Pages app is nice with reverse directory, etc. Main seller is the interface. At first I didn't like it as it was too simple, but after getting used to it I like it. And Touch Flo is nowhere even close to the iPhone's touch interface.

My opinion.
 
Please report on the outcome. I want to stick with Verizon and want to get a Storm but if the iPhone is much faster than I will make the switch to the horrible ATT. I have to wait until October either way but more knowledge is power when making these types of decisions.

Well, there are rumors of a Storm2 coming out sometime this fall. Might want to keep your eye on that.
 
I wonder why there are no Blackberry phones in this comparison though?
Probably because a decent one (like the Bold) would kick iPhone ass?? :D
Touchscreen and Web Browser are the two things I'll concede the iPhone bests at.



The Storm, IMO, the worst device RIM is putting out right now. Storm v2 might improve on it.
 
Didn't know that it was actually that much improved, but I don't think it would make so much difference in real world usage, though nice upgrade still. But how much is this effecting battery life? I would have hoped that to be better also.
 
Wow, I wouldn't mind a speed bump on my phone.... havn't looked into upgrading, but I suspect it would cost me 600$ to move to the new one so... no thanks.
 
Please report on the outcome. I want to stick with Verizon and want to get a Storm but if the iPhone is much faster than I will make the switch to the horrible ATT. I have to wait until October either way but more knowledge is power when making these types of decisions.

it helped alot


but with storm 2 coming and a replacement to the bold, id wait
 
The Bold is still faster.

The Bold is an amazing phone, pretty much the only one I would consider aside from the iPhone, but what are you basing this assumption on (aside from your regular Apple hateboyism)?

Specs versus the old iPhone 3G:

BoldvsiPhone3Gbig.png


As you can see, specwise it is in line with the old iPhone. An important difference is that the BB API is still mostly locked down by Blackberry. Notice how the best apps are all by RIM? Until they open it up like Apple opened up the mobile version of OS X, give developers better tools, OpenGL, etc, it'll still be falling short in that area.

And now you have the 3GS which is significantly faster than both the old iPhone and the Bold. No, the Bold will not be faster until (surprise!) there is an updated version.
 
Here are actual numbers with a 3D test app and actual framerates: http://www.taptaptap.com/blog/iphone-3gs-blows-away-iphone-3g-in-3d/

The OpenGL test shows that there is a huge speed boost with the new model. Interesting quote here, although I'd expect the performance delta between both devices to be similar just based on the boost in hardware specs.

I mentioned this in the video, but it’s worth reiterating here… plasma’s currently unoptimized and the final frame rates on all devices should be significantly higher than what you’re seeing here. The app configuration we setup for the video is pretty rigorous and we wanted to see how the new phone would fare in a situation where we knew the older devices would choke. But when all is said and done and we release the optimized plasma into the wild, it should run very well on all devices.
 
Yeah, that's the old 3G iPhone spec...

He was comparing it to the new 3GS, you know, the one faster than the 3G (which is still plenty fast and provides actual deep API support for developers, thereby letting them exploit the power of the device...)

Fail whale ahoy!
 
I couldn't resist. I was curious how a fanboy would respond in a way that they would disagree that 624 is a bigger number than 620...
Yeah, that's the old 3G iPhone spec...

He was comparing it to the new 3GS, you know, the one faster than the 3G (which is still plenty fast and provides actual deep API support for developers, thereby letting them exploit the power of the device...)

Fail whale ahoy!

Hey, smartass...
http://www.engadget.com/2009/06/10/iphone-3g-s-processor-specs-600mhz-cpu-256mb-of-ram/
Of course there's nothing official from Apple yet, but I'm willing to bet that's a pretty damn accurate leak that someone at TMobile didn't catch.

The speed increase is actually mainly due to something similar to what Vista does, by offloading some of the rendering to an improved GPU.
 
The Bold is an amazing phone, pretty much the only one I would consider aside from the iPhone, but what are you basing this assumption on (aside from your regular Apple hateboyism)?

Specs versus the old iPhone 3G:

BoldvsiPhone3Gbig.png


As you can see, specwise it is in line with the old iPhone. An important difference is that the BB API is still mostly locked down by Blackberry. Notice how the best apps are all by RIM? Until they open it up like Apple opened up the mobile version of OS X, give developers better tools, OpenGL, etc, it'll still be falling short in that area.

And now you have the 3GS which is significantly faster than both the old iPhone and the Bold. No, the Bold will not be faster until (surprise!) there is an updated version.

Specs inline? Did you close your eyes in the "Yes" and "No" comparisons? Processor speed is relative anyways. You of all people should know that it highly depends on how well an operating system is coded. After all, your precious Apple computers with equal specs of a PC blows it out of the water according to you.

That said, I have not done a side by side comparison with a Blackberry and iPhone, nor do I care to. But to compare spec for spec is just silly. I currently have an older BB Curve 8310 and my sister has a iPhone 3G. I think they're both very good phones, but I'd never get myself an iPhone only because I can't get used to the touchscreen QWERTY keys. Being deaf makes me heavily dependent on texting and emailing, so a Blackberry's thumbpad makes it a huge plus for me.
 
I haven't had my hands on a 3G S yet, but I can tell you without a doubt the Bold is quite a bit faster than the 3G...
 
I couldn't resist. I was curious how a fanboy would respond in a way that they would disagree that 624 is a bigger number than 620...

Right, because as we all know, a 2ghz Athlon XP, Pentium 4, Core 2 Duo, and Core i7 are not the same thing.

The mobile CPUs in the Bold, the 3G, and the 3GS are all different, and the 3GS is actually clocked the slowest out of the bunch, yet you are going to claim that the Bold is the fastest phone simply based on clock speed alone?

Holy crap.

Hey, smartass...
http://www.engadget.com/2009/06/10/iphone-3g-s-processor-specs-600mhz-cpu-256mb-of-ram/
Of course there's nothing official from Apple yet, but I'm willing to bet that's a pretty damn accurate leak that someone at TMobile didn't catch.

The speed increase is actually mainly due to something similar to what Vista does, by offloading some of the rendering to an improved GPU.

I read that article the day it came out. Again, if you read the new specs then you'd also see that its also due to a completely new CPU in the 3GS. The one in the 3G was state of the art in 2007, the one in the 3GS and the Palm is ARM's newest. Did you look at the 3D benchmark comparison I posted earlier? HUGE improvement even though the 3GS is clocked slower.

http://www.taptaptap.com/blog/iphone-3gs-blows-away-iphone-3g-in-3d/

Also, rendering was offloaded to the GPU in OS X way the hell back in 2002, years before this was present in Vista, and OpenCL (an open standard developed by Apple) continues this even further in Snow Leopard with built-in GPU computation for everything. The plus is that it is an open standard, nvidia has already issues OpenCL drivers for XP and Linux (now its up to developers to use them). Don't use this to slip in an example of Microsoft innovating and other people following, this isn't one of them.

Again, I think most knowlegable people know that clock speed doesn't mean everything. I guess you missed that day of class at DeVry. :rolleyes:

I haven't had my hands on a 3G S yet, but I can tell you without a doubt the Bold is quite a bit faster than the 3G...

Wow, and your initial response ("The Bold is still faster.") was to note235 who claimed that the "3gs is one of the fastest phone on market".

Yet another "I don't set Dell's prices" moment from TechieSooner where he backtracks from his original point after wasting everybody's time, take a bow. :rolleyes:
 
Specs inline? Did you close your eyes in the "Yes" and "No" comparisons?

Wrong, that is an old chart, OS 3.0 brings nearly all of the yes and no columns (cut/paste/tethering/MMS/stereo bluetooth) in line with the 3G model. All it can't do functionally that the 3GS does now is voice, video, and compass.

Processor speed is relative anyways. You of all people should know that it highly depends on how well an operating system is coded. After all, your precious Apple computers with equal specs of a PC blows it out of the water according to you.

This is absolutely correct. I like and use them both but OS X still smokes Windows 7 in terms of both speed and battery life (Win7 RC1 is still benchmarking worse than Vista, which itself had crap battery life :() on all the machines I have them dual booted on.

That said, I have not done a side by side comparison with a Blackberry and iPhone, nor do I care to. But to compare spec for spec is just silly. I currently have an older BB Curve 8310 and my sister has a iPhone 3G. I think they're both very good phones, but I'd never get myself an iPhone only because I can't get used to the touchscreen QWERTY keys. Being deaf makes me heavily dependent on texting and emailing, so a Blackberry's thumbpad makes it a huge plus for me.

People compare based on specs all the time. They don't affect my decisions 100% but its good for a first glance on what they offer. I do understand about the keyboard, at that point it become about personal preference. Some people will prefer touchscreen soft keyboards and some people will prefer a physical one. Fortunately there are best in class products that offer either option, it could be much worse!

That said, I'm not a big fan of the Curve, not after using the Bold. You should really check it out, spoils every other Blackberry for me. :)
 
To sum up:

3gs is one of the fastest phone on market

TechieSooner: The Bold is still faster.

624>620........

Because as we all know, clock speed is everything. That old 2ghz Athlon XP of mine is just as fast as a 2ghz Core 2 Duo, duh!

I haven't had my hands on a 3G S yet, but I can tell you without a doubt the Bold is quite a bit faster than the 3G...

Don't ever breed.
 
Wrong, that is an old chart, OS 3.0 brings nearly all of the yes and no columns (cut/paste/tethering/MMS/stereo bluetooth) in line with the 3G model. All it can't do functionally that the 3GS does now is voice, video, and compass.



This is absolutely correct. I like and use them both but OS X still smokes Windows 7 in terms of both speed and battery life (Win7 RC1 is still benchmarking worse than Vista, which itself had crap battery life :() on all the machines I have them dual booted on.



People compare based on specs all the time. They don't affect my decisions 100% but its good for a first glance on what they offer. I do understand about the keyboard, at that point it become about personal preference. Some people will prefer touchscreen soft keyboards and some people will prefer a physical one. Fortunately there are best in class products that offer either option, it could be much worse!

That said, I'm not a big fan of the Curve, not after using the Bold. You should really check it out, spoils every other Blackberry for me. :)

I have my eyes on the Bold. I recommended it to my mother who used a Pearl in the past and she loves it. My younger brother uses a Bold too. I use a Curve only because I bought it about a year and a half ago. I don't get into the habit of buying every generation of phones unless I have to lol

I really envy my mother and brother.
 
I have my eyes on the Bold. I recommended it to my mother who used a Pearl in the past and she loves it. My younger brother uses a Bold too. I use a Curve only because I bought it about a year and a half ago. I don't get into the habit of buying every generation of phones unless I have to lol

I really envy my mother and brother.

Only thing you might consider a Curve over a Bold for... The Bold is bigger (bigger screen) and heavier.

That said though, happy with my Bold... Whereas I can find stuff to complain about in Win Mo, Palm, and iPhone... Haven't really had much to complain about on the Blackberry arena, aside from the cost.
 
wow
comparing the Cortext A8 to a processor a little faster
no dude- the 3GS IS faster than the BOLD
spec for spec
 
oops sorry idk if bold is faster than 3g or not but not 3gs

Ummmm... All the specs sheets that have been released have the Bold having a faster processor. Apple hasn't released anything to the contrary.

Now, what might help the 3G S is Apple offloading some of the rendering to the GPU. But being how simple the Bold's interface is, RIM doesn't really have a need to do that yet.
 
Back
Top