Intel vs AMD systems on reliability/longevity

deanx0r

Limp Gawd
Joined
Apr 24, 2005
Messages
274
I have built 5 AMD and 3 Intel systems over the past 15 years and I have noticed a trend with the AMD systems, they all died overtime. I have a clean track record on the Intel side. In most of the failures, the CPU was not the culprit but the supporting motherboard. Maybe it's just a strike of bad luck, but I've never really paid attention to my system failure until my most two recent AMD systems died on me. I've been a die hard AMD supporter until Core 2 Duo came out, but the recent system failures I had make me shy away from future AMD builds. Now this is a very small sample, and I was wondering if it was the case for other people as well.

Please post a history of systems you've built overtime and whether or not they are still running today.

Here's my list:

-Pentium II 266MHz, ASUS P2B Intel 440BX. Still running.
-Pentium 4 2.83GHz, Gigabyte Titan Intel 845E. Still running.
-Core 2 E6600, Asus P5B-D Intel P960. Still running.

-AMD K6-3 500MHz. Epox MVP3G2 VIA chipset. Dead system after 3-4 years.
-AMD K7 900MHz & 850MHz, MSI MS-6167 AMD 750. CPU failure, then motherboard failure after ~5 years.
-Athlon XP 1800+ & 2200+, Abit NF7 nVidia nForce2. CPU failure, then motherboard failure after ~5 years.
-Opteron 146, MSI K8NGM2 nForce 430. Dead motherboard yesterday after 5 years (HTPC).
-Athlon 3800 X2, eVGA 133-K8 nForce 4. Dead motherboard last month after about 5 years.
 
Too many to list. The sad fact is that the alum electrolytic caps that until recently where all that where used on motherboards have a typical life of about 7 years. Not having any design data from motherboard manufacturers makes it a guess but IMO its mostly about the design of the voltage regulation circuitry for the cpu and the specs of the caps used in that application as there is where a cap gets stressed the most.

The longest living in continous operation (server boards not included) was an Abit NF7-s with a mobile Barton water cooled and OCed to an inch of its life. Lasted just about the proverbial 7 years, I assume the motherboard died, it just quit one day.
 
I have no experience building a AMD rig, but the rig I'm using now is the one I built 10+ years ago, with a few upgrades along the way of course...

ABIT VL6 mobo
PIII 750MHz CPU >>> PIII 1GHz now

I only swapped the CPU last week. The 750 was running fine, just wanted to switch.
 
Those first 2 AMD builds you list of MOBO's were not so great.

I had bad caps on my MSI Slot 1 mobo back in the day! Known issues with either Intel or AMD for the time!

My last 2 AMD builds have been the most stable AMD systems I've built to date. I previously had a Athlon 64 X2 4200+ and a ASUS A8N32-SLI that worked great till I replaced it.

Just 2 weeks ago I was replacing caps in a Gigabyte mobo for a Pentium D system that went bad (currently a server at work running 24/7), I replaced those and it works again, but keep getting complaints it is running flakey so probably need to replace the rest of them. The system is like just over a year old build. This is not a Ultra Durable series though.

I'd say that either Intel or AMD can be a reliable build these days given that quality components are used. Personally have been happy with ASUS motherboard for years! Still have a running PIII Tualatin Mobo by ASUS! Only other manufacturer I've bought was a Albatron for a P4/PCI-E 16x mobo which has also been working great for me!
 
Back
Top