Intel Reportedly Blocked an ARM-Based Surface Go

Megalith

24-bit/48kHz
Joined
Aug 20, 2006
Messages
13,000
Thurrott has learned that Intel may have petitioned Microsoft to use their Pentium Gold processors instead of Qualcomm’s Snapdragon ARM chips for their recently released Surface Go, which has been criticized for having poor battery life. An ARM version of the Go would have certainly improved on this area, but some say the Pentium was the right choice, as Qualcomm’s offering only runs 32-bit apps and is allegedly lacking in performance.

Microsoft could have, in the long term, figured out it probably wouldn’t have been worth the bad press to push out an underperforming Surface Windows 10 on ARM device. Intel seems to be the best bet for Surface devices for now, but we’ll just have to wait for the next wave of Windows on ARM devices powered by the freshly announced Snapdragon 850 processors.
 
How is this news? They say the Intel chip was the right fit so why the clickbait title?
 
Windows on ARM was pretty much doomed from the get go, it never made any sense, performance was awful even in tightly controlled and rehearsed demos - the MS firstparty apps were bad and the Win32 emulation even worse. A few months ago, Thurrott reported on a a particular female MS exec that had made statements throwing Qualcomm under the bus, and it was apparent that MS had shelved WoA internally.

There was also an expectation on MS's part that Qualcomm's next chip was going to bring some huge performance gains which would help compensate for WoA's poor performance particularly with Win32 emulation, but then once the early Snapdragon 850 was tested and only had minimal improvement, the die was cast.
 
Last edited:
Im not sure how far away we are from x86 running efficiently and snappy on arm but i feel we are still a few if not several years off.
 
I don't necessarily see this as a bad thing, Windows on ARM was terrible not to mention confusing for the average consumer regarding software compatibility.
 
Windows on ARM was pretty much doomed from the get go, it never made any sense, performance was awful even in tightly controlled and rehearsed demos - the MS firstparty apps were bad and the Win32 emulation even worse. A few months ago, Thurrott reported on a a particular female MS exec that had made statements throwing Qualcomm under the bus, and it was apparent that MS had shelved WoA internally.

There was also an expectation on MS's part that Qualcomm's next chip was going to bring some huge performance gains which would help compensate for WoA's poor performance particularly with Win32 emulation, but then once the early Snapdragon 850 was tested and only had minimal improvement, the die was cast.

I thought the 850 was about 50% faster than the 835? I was watching it because a chomebook running linux with an 850 and LTE and 20hrs of battery life would be awesome...
 
Question is .. How they 'blocked' it? ...
Pretty please? Or pretty plea$e?
 
This... so much this...

Bottom line, even thought the Go ships with S mode on, what makes a device of this size interesting is its ability to run full desktop applications at least within the performance constraints of the device, which can be surprising. The Go isn't at all a fast device but I've been surprised overall how well it runs a number of more complex desktop apps.

The tradeoff is battery life. Getting the Go in at 18 ounces required a smallish battery which in addition on an x86 CPU leads to pretty bad battery life especially relative to other mobile OS/ARM tablets. But better battery life probably isn't worth the tradeoff with the desktop app compatibility.
 
Back
Top