Intel, FTC Settle Antitrust Case

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
As promised earlier, here are the details of the FTCs settlement with Intel. Nothing real exciting here:

Specifically, the settlement prohibits Intel from using threats, bundled prices, or other offers to exclude or hamper the competition in the sale of CPUs, GPUs, or chipsets. The settlement also prevents Intel from deceiving computer makers about the performance of non-Intel CPUs or GPUs.
 
because now nvidia isn't as hampered in the atom market for one. Intel was offering discounts of near 50% for atom + core logic bundles.
 
It doesn't much, since Intel doesn't compete with nvidia in IGP or discrete GPUs (yes, the wording is intentional). :p It mostly applies to competition with AMD. But this could change things in the future for nvidia:

Intel will be required to revise its intellectual property agreements with AMD, Nvidia, and Via Technologies so those companies can feel free to evaluate mergers or joint ventures with other businesses without fear of being sued by Intel for patent infringement.

For example, nvidia could possibly more easily make agreements with VIA, or more unlikely, AMD. It also reinforces that nvidia could do other things like make GPUs that use the Intel IGP to display, but not render, without fear of lawsuits. Without a bus licence, nvidia still won't have access to a big chunk of the Intel IGP market. And AMD doesn't have a need for nvidia at all for chipsets.

Tough times for nvidia, IMO. Handhelds with nvidia SoCs haven't taken off. GPGPU is a slowly growing market with one, and soon two competitors. Its chipset business is still in decline.
 
The problem with Atom is that Intel has almost completely shifted away from Silverthorne/Diamondville, and Pineview has on-die graphics and NB. The next Atom due next year (Cedar Trail) is even more highly integrated. There's little room for nvidia on Pineview now or in the future.
 
The settlement also prevents Intel from deceiving computer makers about the performance of non-Intel CPUs or GPUs.

i had to laugh at that part because its true
 
because now nvidia isn't as hampered in the atom market for one. Intel was offering discounts of near 50% for atom + core logic bundles.

Too late, Intel already moved to Pineview and it seems the settlement won't give nvidia rights to make a chipset for it.
 
it may be a decade too late but hey it is progress,
what disturbs me is that there is nothing really stopping them from doing it again. They can be just as anti-competitive again, make a butt load of money.. and then deal with the FTC and consequences at a later date.
Corporation need to be held more accountable for their actions, maybe a code of conduct, imprison the CEO's from questionable companies? I don't know, I'm no business lawyer. It just seems that I am held far more accountable for my actions than a huge company is, will be give a more severe sentence for my actions, and suffer more for my discrepancies.

That is certainly not justice for all.

We DO have the power to stop but it will take a MASSIVE swing in the way our society thinks. Unfortunately, the propaganda machine behind it all is very very persuasive, and will stop at nothing to keep their power.
Our adoration of the corporation has certainly been at the root of the evils persisting in Washington, from all sides, left, right, and center. Nobody is innocent when they know what is happening, and are not doing something about it.
 
Hope you have some *foil left. The conspiracy is growing!

http://www.eweek.com/c/a/Desktops-and-Notebooks/Intel-Wins-Court-Ruling-in-Antitrust-Case-514166/
last week said:
A special master appointed by a judge ruled that Intel's business practices, including giving OEMs discounts to limit their use of AMD products, did not harm consumers, and in some cases those discounts were passed onto consumers. He denied the request for class-action status for the lawsuit.
:p

Just a good companion story to go along with why Intel got a relatively small wrist slap by the FTC.
 
i had to laugh at that part because its true

From what I understand Intel does a great job at that with ICC. No Intel CPU, some optimizations won't work even though they could.

Ironically enough Intel did come out with a research paper about SSE v. CUDA not all that long enough. An article that actually has quite a bit of truth about it, and my experiences seem to mirror the article.
 
The problem with Atom is that Intel has almost completely shifted away from Silverthorne/Diamondville, and Pineview has on-die graphics and NB. The next Atom due next year (Cedar Trail) is even more highly integrated. There's little room for nvidia on Pineview now or in the future.

You're just making crazy words up now. I still think fluffbucket was going to be better than mordswine before they replaced it with chainhamperville. personally.
I still don't get the point on on chip graphics...to be honest, its not going to be amazing is it. And I know theres low power blah blah running 2080p video from a netbook, but games are going to suck.
but that said, hey, I thought the tegra was pretty decent?
 
You're just making crazy words up now. I still think fluffbucket was going to be better than mordswine before they replaced it with chainhamperville. personally.
I still don't get the point on on chip graphics...to be honest, its not going to be amazing is it. And I know theres low power blah blah running 2080p video from a netbook, but games are going to suck.
but that said, hey, I thought the tegra was pretty decent?

Tegra is not x86, its ARM based.
 
I still don't get the point on on chip graphics...to be honest, its not going to be amazing is it. And I know theres low power blah blah running 2080p video from a netbook, but games are going to suck.
but that said, hey, I thought the tegra was pretty decent?
On-die graphics are "good enough" for many users. It's not made for gamers. AMD's Llano will start to blur that line, but still is not in the handheld/netbook segment. AMD has a different CPU for that and it uses a standard chipset to handle video.

LOL, Tegra is a tragedy. nvidia was probably feeling pretty good about its prospects, then Apple released the A4 and Intel's handheld initiative flopped. Tegra will suffer for the same reasons all iPod competitors fail: it's not used in an iPod. When the refreshed iPod Touch comes out, that's pretty much another nail in Tegra's handheld market coffin. Tegra will probably be a niche product and there's nothing wrong with that if it does what you need. The only problem is attracting the software ecosystem to develop for a high graphics performance device when the others are 1/2 or less. The target will be LCD.
 
On-die graphics are "good enough" for many users. It's not made for gamers. AMD's Llano will start to blur that line, but still is not in the handheld/netbook segment. AMD has a different CPU for that and it uses a standard chipset to handle video.

LOL, Tegra is a tragedy. nvidia was probably feeling pretty good about its prospects, then Apple released the A4 and Intel's handheld initiative flopped. Tegra will suffer for the same reasons all iPod competitors fail: it's not used in an iPod. When the refreshed iPod Touch comes out, that's pretty much another nail in Tegra's handheld market coffin. Tegra will probably be a niche product and there's nothing wrong with that if it does what you need. The only problem is attracting the software ecosystem to develop for a high graphics performance device when the others are 1/2 or less. The target will be LCD.

When It was announced it was going to be all over the place, from portable media players, media streamers, handheld consoles, internet TV, tablets, and netbooks.

As of today only the Zune hd is tegra based. But even upcoming windows 7 phones will not.

AFAIK some android phones, a few slates and the boxeebox will be tegra based.
 
A particular gem in the ruling pdf:
Intel may continue to offer discounts to customers on parts in excess of a specified unit volume threshold, but the company may not offer a volume discounted price to OEMs on all parts contingent on total sales being above a specified threshold."
Really, it changes little. A company will still have to weigh buying extra "cheap" Intel CPUs vs lower volume/lower discount (due to smaller GM) AMD CPUs. Don't confuse retail prices vs what large OEMs pay. For desktop CPUs, AMD gets about $50 on average (including tiny market of single core, volume dual core and pretty large quad core segments) and Intel gets around $60 on average (skewed far more towards dual core segment).
 
Back
Top