Intel Extreme Edition v AMD Athlon™ 64

JMack986

n00b
Joined
Jan 1, 2006
Messages
32
Intel Extreme Edition v AMD Athlon™ 64 which one out of these 2 would u preffer


AMD Athlon™ 64 X2 Dual-Core 4600+ with HT Tech.

or

Intel Extreme Edition 4.26 dual core like in XPS 600 Renegade
 
First of all, AMD never had, and never will have, HT.

A couple months ago, I would have been all about the X2... now however, the P4 955EE kills it stick, and OCs easily to 4+ ghz on air, even more on water or phase I imagine.

65 nm is giving Netburst its swansong, a shame it has to go away now, I can only imagine how it would have done on 45 nm or lower.
 
first off, the processor isnt NORMALLY 4.26ghz its overclocked to that.

second, the AMD Athlon 64 X2 doesnt have HT, its dual core, like the intel, and when push comes to shove performs better all circumstances being equal :)

personally id take the AMD because it runs cooler, tend to overclock easier and without such high heat out put and they perform better in gaming and such most of the time :)
 
0megasecond said:
the AMD Athlon 64 X2 doesnt have HT, its dual core, like the intel, and when push comes to shove performs better all circumstances being equal :)

Check the Xbit labs review, the P4 Presler kills the X2.
 
Damn Flame war started i was hoping on posting in each b4 it starts hehe. :D AMD vs Intel will always start a war just like nVidia vs ATi.
 
ReDgUaRd008 said:
Damn Flame war started i was hoping on posting in each b4 it starts hehe. :D AMD vs Intel will always start a war just like nVidia vs ATi.

Who is flaming? I am speaking only facts. Check them for yourself.
 
can you use those trademark symbols? lol is that legal?

anyway, i'd take intel, just to try an EE cpu, and say you have an extreme edition cpu, not many gamers use them compared to amd's.
 
ReDgUaRd008 said:
Damn Flame war started i was hoping on posting in each b4 it starts hehe. :D AMD vs Intel will always start a war just like nVidia vs ATi.
http://www.xbitlabs.com/images/cpu/presler/charts/pcm-1.png

doesnt look like it kills it at all to be honest. and its not really a fair comparison... its next gen...

who plays PCMark anyway? and form the looks of it the 955 gets whipped in encoding regardless...

and if you want an SMP comparison in actual gaming...

http://www.xbitlabs.com/images/cpu/presler/charts/quake4-2.png

:)
 
TheJackal said:
can you use those trademark symbols? lol is that legal?

anyway, i'd take intel, just to try an EE cpu, and say you have an extreme edition cpu, not many gamers use them compared to amd's.

The EE isn't meant for gamers. If you want to game only, buy an FX-57, if you want a CPU that does real work, buy an EE.
 
NulloModo said:
The EE isn't meant for gamers. If you want to game only, buy an FX-57, if you want a CPU that does real work, buy an EE.
actually isnt the EE supposed to be for gamers? meh i dont follow intel for obvious reasons. im a gamer and overclocker. 'Nuff said.
 
What it is marketed to and what it does are two different things. The EE is awesome for encoding and real work, not that awesome for wasting time on PC gaming.
 
why are people so passionate about who made their cpu?

I wouldn't feel insulted by someone just cause they said their tv was better than mine
 
Fawkes said:
Wonder how that 955 would do against my 2.8ghz opteron...

clock up to 4.5Ghz and destroy it. AMD wins right now for performance per Mhz, but the new Intel chips OC much better.
 
NulloModo said:
First of all, AMD never had, and never will have, HT.

A couple months ago, I would have been all about the X2... now however, the P4 955EE kills it stick, and OCs easily to 4+ ghz on air, even more on water or phase I imagine.

65 nm is giving Netburst its swansong, a shame it has to go away now, I can only imagine how it would have done on 45 nm or lower.

Think the HT its reffering too is HyperTransport. Something Intel really wish they had.
 
NulloModo said:
clock up to 4.5Ghz and destroy it. AMD wins right now for performance per Mhz, but the new Intel chips OC much better.
have fun paying for the cooling.

it may be able to hit those marks, but with what cooling? -_-

why does everyone say thigns but provide no proof?

and good question, why is everone so passionate? i could care less, if I could have gotten an equally priced intel at about the same level i would have. it just fit my budget and did what i wanted :)
 
NulloModo said:
clock up to 4.5Ghz and destroy it. AMD wins right now for performance per Mhz, but the new Intel chips OC much better.

Ok, on that same token, lets overclock at 4800+ to 2.8-3GHz with the 955 at 4.5GHz. The 4800+ @ 2.8 or 3GHz would still beat the P4 @ 4.5Ghz. It's not a true comparison overclocking a cpu, and then pit it against another cpu thats not overclocked. When AMD brings out 65nm here in a few months, i predict you'll be seeing 3-3.5GHz overclockability.
 
AMD is going to have a performance lead over Intel for the next one to two years. Intel's 65nm process is just now catching up to AMD's 90nm as far as performance per watt goes.
 
if your going to spend that much get the 4800+ X2 and be done with it best of both killer SMP + it still owns in at single threaded stuff
 
stealthy123 said:
why are people so passionate about who made their cpu?

I wouldn't feel insulted by someone just cause they said their tv was better than mine
Oh yeah? Well my Sony 32" TV gets VHF, UHF and cable (sometimes) and it has a slot for memory sticks (if I only had a memory stick). I hope to overclock it to 36" or maybe more if I can. Try doing that with your Toshiba or Gold Star....
 
NulloModo said:
The EE isn't meant for gamers. If you want to game only, buy an FX-57, if you want a CPU that does real work, buy an EE.
i see the 955 being whipped by the much lower clocked 4800+ at stock speeds. if they showed an overclocked 4800+ against it itd be over, but they don't.
 
Also, the P4 EE is OC'ed, you are comparing to a stock 4800, if the 4800 was OC'ed that far it would decimate the 955. only reason I would like the 955 is because of 4 (2 logical) processors.
 
The ignorance in the first 10-15 posts is astounding.

- The 65nm Preslers kill the X2's.
- Intel's EE line is not for gamers.
- Netburst could be good on a smaller process.
- Pentium 4's at 4GHz are better than Athlon 64's.

Simply amazing.
 
Bona Fide said:
The ignorance in the first 10-15 posts is astounding.

- The 65nm Preslers kill the X2's.
- Intel's EE line is not for gamers.
- Netburst could be good on a smaller process.
- Pentium 4's at 4GHz are better than Athlon 64's.

Simply amazing.

1. They are looks at the reviews, more performance all around with granted, more power, but who cares?
2. It isn't. Gaming is still best for single core CPUs, Multi-core and multi-core + HT is for apps that can take advantage of it, not games right now.
3. It is beating AMD right now on 65 nm... imagine what another shrink could do.
4. Better in that they perform better
 
no shit a 4GHz p4 will beat a 2.4GHz 4800, this is also comparing 65nm-90nm, i agree intel has made some good gains and is competing with amd now, but i cant see them winning when amd releases 65nm
 
Yes, netburst NEVER WAS AND ALWAYS WILL SUCK for games, you are also comparing OC'ed CPUs to stock ones. Good job, captain obvious, finding that a 4 GH'z CPU will beat a 2.4 GH'z one.
 
-=JacKaL=- said:
no shit a 4GHz p4 will beat a 2.4GHz 4800, this is also comparing 65nm-90nm, i agree intel has made some good gains and is competing with amd now, but i cant see them winning when amd releases 65nm

Again, which will be in another year, at which point Intel will have out Conroe, which will really take it into the streets. AMD's little time in the sunshine is over.
 
Some things that havent been stated:

  • The 955 is $1250, versus $780 for 4800
  • The 955 @ 4.26 idles at 65C and loads at 79C
  • 955 requires substantial investment in new mobo/ram (M2 will be the same when it's released though)
  • Power consumption is 156W vs 96W for 4800+
  • FX-60 will be out very soon.
  • All these results are from a cpu running damn near 2GHz faster per core...where's the optimizations?!?!

Things are looking up for the Intels future. All they have to do now is cut the price about $900 and they'll have a winner.
For my money, I'll take a $340 Opteron 165 oc'd to 2.7 ftw. The numbers should be damn close to the overclocked 955, if not better than in some instances, and still games better.
 
uhuh, you notice that the 4800 beats the 955 @ stock + takes less power. Imagine what the FX 65 will do on AM2. PLUS don't even talke about products that aren't out, look at intels history of product releases. OOhh here comes Tejas ;)
 
Once again, flameboi's rule the first page or so, until more cool headed individuals actually LOOK and COMPARE the data give. Wow.. you correctly stated that an overclocked p4 can beat a STOCK 4800+.. Just wow.. You say that AMD's time in the limelight is over...., who knows. The M2 is coming out, and I'm pretty interested in seeing how that compares to Intel's "Out in another year Conroe release".

I have started on on a P90, P2 450, P3 600 EB (Stupid rambus), AMD 2000+, 3.0C, and now Opty 175. Used both, loved them all for what they did, and when it was time to move on, bought the best that I could for what I do.

Put a fire extenguisher out of the fires that you are trying to ohhh so hard to flame on.
 
Intel said:
"Intel delivers two processors that serve up great performance and the speed you need to help you get your game on: the Intel® Pentium® processor Extreme Edition and the Intel® Pentium® 4 Processor Extreme Edition supporting Hyper-Threading Technology†. But be warned—these processors are not for the timid. Be prepared to experience the extreme realism, responsiveness, and intensity you can only get from next-generation Intel processors.

The Intel Pentium processor Extreme Edition gives you the dual-core processing speed you need to play intense, industry-leading multi-threaded games and applications, with added support for 64-bit computing. The new dual-core processing featured in the Intel Pentium processor Extreme Edition, delivers state-of-the-art multitasking performance and dependability to extend your gaming experience to new levels. You can use its two complete execution cores to play a multi-threaded game while running anti-cheat software in the background, or host a multiplayer game while watching a DVD."


obv the EE line is not intended for gamers.
 
Obviously... :rolleyes:

Intel said:
You can use its two complete execution cores to play a multi-threaded game while running anti-cheat software in the background, or host a multiplayer game while watching a DVD.

Notice that is the only real-world example given in the product brief.
 
The Intel Pentium processor Extreme Edition gives you the dual-core processing speed you need to play intense, industry-leading multi-threaded games



lol
 
NulloModo said:
1. They are looks at the reviews, more performance all around with granted, more power, but who cares?
2. It isn't. Gaming is still best for single core CPUs, Multi-core and multi-core + HT is for apps that can take advantage of it, not games right now.
3. It is beating AMD right now on 65 nm... imagine what another shrink could do.
4. Better in that they perform better


LOL, this is the same guy that posted this:
I never did buy that whole 'Mhz doesn't matter' argument

He's been staying underground in his top secret tinfoil lined bunker for the past few years just waiting for the IPC rating days to be over.

Link to his other display of insanity.
 
Nidhogg said:
obv the EE line is not intended for gamers.

They market it towards PC gamers because the have more money the brains. Just look at ridiculous and pointless products like the X-Fi fagality, gaming mice and keyboards, and 7800GTX 512s. The real benefit to this processor will be seen in encoding and content producing work, apps that can take advantage of 4 threads at once.
 
NulloModo said:
They market it towards PC gamers because the have more money the brains. Just look at ridiculous and pointless products like the X-Fi fagality, gaming mice and keyboards, and 7800GTX 512s. The real benefit to this processor will be seen in encoding and content producing work, apps that can take advantage of 4 threads at once.

For all the decrying you're doing of all the other high-end parts for making a top flight computer you just cant get off the ludicrous praise of an overpriced top-end Intel CPU that when overclocked beats a stock AMD CPU. I don't see what you're getting at - at all. The OCed bench is nice, but in reality that chip is neck and neck on PC Mark at stock settings and gets crushed in real multimedia applications by an older part, like the Quake 4 comaprison.

You imply that people that buy EEs are stupid for spending the money, but you also think its the greatest thing since sliced bread for "high end" work. Are video production encoders somehow more worthy of the part than gamers? Ask yourself who you're trying to convince because it doesn't work here.
 
Back
Top