Intel Compute Stick Review

I wonder how well one of these would perform as an XBMC/MythTV frontend.

Are the baytrail Atoms good with HD video decoding?
 
Zarathustra[H];1041562239 said:
I wonder how well one of these would perform as an XBMC/MythTV frontend.

Are the baytrail Atoms good with HD video decoding?

It's too bad there is no wired gigabit Ethernet. I guess you could use a USB adapter, but it's only USB2, and now you are adding cost.

I try to avoid using Wifi whenever possible, something that is going to sit stationary connected to a TV would fit the "whenever possible" condition.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041562252 said:
It's too bad there is no wired gigabit Ethernet. I guess you could use a USB adapter, but it's only USB2, and now you are adding cost.

I try to avoid using Wifi whenever possible, something that is going to sit stationary connected to a TV would fit the "whenever possible" condition.

Agreed. Wired connections are always preferable in my house. I've got three access points sharing the load with different networks, but they are still overused when there are perfectly good ethernet ports nearby.

I really like the idea of these "sticks" but I also worry about the HDMI connector taking the full weight of the device. I realize that many TVs have a port or two in a recessed area and are oriented vertically, so the strain would be somewhat minimized. It still makes me cringe though... :D
 
Zarathustra[H];1041562239 said:
Are the baytrail Atoms good with HD video decoding?
Yeah this is what I what I was wondering too. Half the performance of core M processors which makes me doubt...


Also it has 32GB of "storage" is that available, or does windows 8.1 take up some of that space as well.
 
In the video he said that certain streaming services wouldn't work because of the limitations of the integrated 802.11n wireless adapter (he stated that it peaked at around 40 Mbps out of 54 Mbps possible), but shouldn't an 802.11n device be fully capable of handling the bandwidth necessary for 1080p streaming? I am a bit rusty on my wireless specifications, but I thought Wireless G capped at 54 Mbps, with the same applying if running an N-device in G-compatibility mode. Otherwise, N should be capable of 150, 300, or 450 Mbps, depending on the device that is broadcasting the signal, shouldn't it?
 
Zarathustra[H];1041562239 said:
Are the baytrail Atoms good with HD video decoding?

I should clarify, yes I know they do some cursory testing in the review, but I need more detail, especially since he mentions high bitrate bluray backups may be a problem.

Also, 23.976 hz accuracy and bitstreaming would be of interest here.
 
Also it has 32GB of "storage" is that available, or does windows 8.1 take up some of that space as well.

That's where that ethernet port would come in handy. :D Then you'd only need the space for applications and not content. I'm sure the WiFi will work fine under most scenarios, but I've got a very high wireless load in my house. I've had to QoS my kids. :D
 
Yeah this is what I what I was wondering too. Half the performance of core M processors which makes me doubt...


Also it has 32GB of "storage" is that available, or does windows 8.1 take up some of that space as well.

I assumed that it's 32GB - Windows install. That's usually how these things work.
 
In the video he said that certain streaming services wouldn't work because of the limitations of the integrated 802.11n wireless adapter (he stated that it peaked at around 40 Mbps out of 54 Mbps possible), but shouldn't an 802.11n device be fully capable of handling the bandwidth necessary for 1080p streaming? I am a bit rusty on my wireless specifications, but I thought Wireless G capped at 54 Mbps, with the same applying if running an N-device in G-compatibility mode. Otherwise, N should be capable of 150, 300, or 450 Mbps, depending on the device that is broadcasting the signal, shouldn't it?

Your numbers are pretty spot on I believe. Not that anyone ever sees the peak throughput, but yeah, N should be a lot higher than 40-54Mbps. I get around 100-120Mbps between floors on average on the desktop machine on my top floor. (using N)
 
Agreed. Wired connections are always preferable in my house. I've got three access points sharing the load with different networks, but they are still overused when there are perfectly good ethernet ports nearby.

Exactly.

And since I'd be running XBMC/Kodi on mine, I would be interested in the Linux version. The 8GB of storage (instead of 32GB) is perfectly fine for a linux install, but I would have preferred if the Linux version also got 2GB of RAM like the Windows version. 1GB might be limiting...

If I were to go for one of these, it would thus have to be the Windows version, and then zap windows and install Linux (unless it has a locked bootloader)

I really like the idea of these "sticks" but I also worry about the HDMI connector taking the full weight of the device. I realize that many TVs have a port or two in a recessed area and are oriented vertically, so the strain would be somewhat minimized. It still makes me cringe though... :D

I hadn't thought of this. That's a really good point.
 
Your numbers are pretty spot on I believe. Not that anyone ever sees the peak throughput, but yeah, N should be a lot higher than 40-54Mbps.

That's the understatement of the day.

Between interference from other wifi access points, cordless phones and microwave ovens, walls, etc and the fact that wifi bandwidth is shared between all connected clients and is only half duplex as opposed to wired ethernet, most people are lucky if they get a handful of percent of the advertised wifi speeds.

I've more or less given up on Wifi for anything but phones and temporary laptop use.

Everything else gets wired ethernet.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041562292 said:
That's the understatement of the day.

Between interference from other wifi access points, cordless phones and microwave ovens, walls, etc and the fact that wifi bandwidth is shared between all connected clients and is only half duplex as opposed to wired ethernet, most people are lucky if they get a handful of percent of the advertised wifi speeds.

I've more or less given up on Wifi for anything but phones and temporary laptop use.

Everything else gets wired ethernet.

Yeah, I've had to compensate this with more networks. I've got one for mobile devices, one to connect a bridge between floors, and then another one for misc. It works well enough, but between all these devices, Wii-U, 3DSes, phones, laptops, and any machine that's too far from a wired connection... My house is pretty well irradiated with waveforms modulating our brains. I've been trying to wire things more lately.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041562252 said:
It's too bad there is no wired gigabit Ethernet. I guess you could use a USB adapter, but it's only USB2, and now you are adding cost.

I try to avoid using Wifi whenever possible, something that is going to sit stationary connected to a TV would fit the "whenever possible" condition.
Wireless AC routers are so damn fast now, its not that big an issue unless you have a big home.

And with 5Ghz, I have no interference issues.

I think a ceiling mounted projector with one of these plugged into it would be perfect. I bet it would boot to windows in the same time the projector takes to warm up, and then you don't have to run anything except power to the projector from the ceiling!
 
I really like the idea of these "sticks" but I also worry about the HDMI connector taking the full weight of the device. I realize that many TVs have a port or two in a recessed area and are oriented vertically, so the strain would be somewhat minimized. It still makes me cringe though... :D

Could use a short hdmi extension cable to take the pressure off.
 
Wireless AC routers are so damn fast now, its not that big an issue unless you have a big home.

But the spect says 802.11b/g/n :p

I've never played with AC, but my tests with previous versions have all been disappointing.

I wouldn't feel comfortable using Wifi for anything that relies on real-time data (like video streaming), and I also wouldn't use it for NAS.

For browsing and email its fine though.
 
I refuse to run wireless in my home... so... yeah, this device probably isn't for me.

Anyways, I recently built a cheap PC to run a 3d printer at home (Lulzbot Mini). Went with a Celeron G1840, el cheapo MB, memory scavenged from another computer that had 12GB for some reason (2x2 and 2x4; took the 2x2), case and power supply scavenged from an old P3 system I haven't used since my Smoothwall days. Cost me around ~ $115 and its performance is probably an order of magnitude better than this Compute Stick would be.

I'm sure this is useful, just be sure of your use case. You can build a real PC for around the same price and not have all the limitations.
 
Well, the nice thing about a device like this is that all you need in your living room is the TV. You won't have a full size PC sitting there attached to your TV via a cable. Much cleaner.
 
I refuse to run wireless in my home... so... yeah, this device probably isn't for me.

That's probably what I'm thinking too.

You could use a cheap USB Ethernet adapter, but those don't have great performance either, and now you are using your only USB port, which you probably want to use for your Logitech K400 and/or WMC Remote, so now you have to get a USB hub too, and suddenly what was a neat little stick computer is a mess of usb connected devices.

I had been eyeballing the Asus Chromebox though.

With a Celeron 2955U you get a Haswell desktop chip instead of an Atom, and it comes with 2GB of RAM and a 16GB SSD for $159, perfect for a Linux + Kodi/XBMC install

You have to hack it to install an OS other than Chrome OS, but it doesn't look TOO difficult.

It's larger, but still very small, and a great deal for what you get IMHO.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041562276 said:
I should clarify, yes I know they do some cursory testing in the review, but I need more detail, especially since he mentions high bitrate bluray backups may be a problem.

Also, 23.976 hz accuracy and bitstreaming would be of interest here.

Anandtech's review of the Intel compute stick states that the Bay Trail refreshes at 23.973 hz. Here's a link to page 4 of their review that covers some of the HTPC stuff you're asking about.

http://anandtech.com/show/9167/intel-compute-stick-review/4
 
Well, the nice thing about a device like this is that all you need in your living room is the TV. You won't have a full size PC sitting there attached to your TV via a cable. Much cleaner.

True.

I use a Silverstone SG06 mini ITX case right now, which isn't too bad though. it fits nicely in my entertainment stand.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041562362 said:
I had been eyeballing the Asus Chromebox though.You have to hack it to install an OS other than Chrome OS, but it doesn't look TOO difficult.

I have an Asus ChromeBox running win 8.1; the bios hack wasn't too hard (just be sure to undo the bios protect screw before trying to flash, or it does a partial flash and gets really weird). But you might want to consider getting the HP Stream Mini instead, it's almost the same thing, but you don't have to hack the bios, and there's more storage; if you want more than 2gb ram, double check that the mini has a second slot, I know HP wasn't populating all the ram slots in their chromeboxes.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041562239 said:
Are the baytrail Atoms good with HD video decoding?

That depends more on the GPU, drivers, and software being used for said HD video.

Yeah this is what I what I was wondering too. Half the performance of core M processors which makes me doubt...
This doesn't mean anything.
A Raspberry Pi can decode and playback 1080p video easily, and in very high quality, and that ARM11 CPU has the processing equivalency of a Pentium II.
 
In the video he said that certain streaming services wouldn't work because of the limitations of the integrated 802.11n wireless adapter (he stated that it peaked at around 40 Mbps out of 54 Mbps possible), but shouldn't an 802.11n device be fully capable of handling the bandwidth necessary for 1080p streaming? I am a bit rusty on my wireless specifications, but I thought Wireless G capped at 54 Mbps, with the same applying if running an N-device in G-compatibility mode. Otherwise, N should be capable of 150, 300, or 450 Mbps, depending on the device that is broadcasting the signal, shouldn't it?

Also, remember all of these data transfer rates are half-duplex, so you can cut those speeds in half, even in the best scenarios.
 
In the video he said that certain streaming services wouldn't work because of the limitations of the integrated 802.11n wireless adapter (he stated that it peaked at around 40 Mbps out of 54 Mbps possible), but shouldn't an 802.11n device be fully capable of handling the bandwidth necessary for 1080p streaming? I am a bit rusty on my wireless specifications, but I thought Wireless G capped at 54 Mbps, with the same applying if running an N-device in G-compatibility mode. Otherwise, N should be capable of 150, 300, or 450 Mbps, depending on the device that is broadcasting the signal, shouldn't it?

Your numbers are pretty spot on I believe. Not that anyone ever sees the peak throughput, but yeah, N should be a lot higher than 40-54Mbps. I get around 100-120Mbps between floors on average on the desktop machine on my top floor. (using N)


Not in this instance it is not. The difference between what you're seeing and what this device is capable of has to do with the configuration abilities of N. If you have 100mbps+ then I safely assume you are using 5ghz, 40mhz wide channels, and have a 2x2 antenna configuration. That gives you the theoretical connection speed of 300mbps. This device however is limited to 2.4ghz, which in turn means only 20mhz channels, and it is also only using 1 antenna. If you remember back to cell phones from 4 years ago most of them only connected to an access point at 65mbps when using N. This device mirrors that type of configuration hence the huge limitations on wireless.


This device is still a pretty hard sell for anyone simply because it's such a niche market. You have to be tech savvy enough to know what to do with it, yet not want to deal with cabling or other mini htpc solutions. I could see someone who in a apartment who wants to surf the internet and stream shows from a browser as being one of the few people who could make use of it. As stated it might be a bit slow for using it for HTPC or an in home streaming steam pc. If you can run wires you pay $50 and use a usb and HDMI extender and have access to a much better system remotely.

I think the business case where this could make a lot of sense is for digital signage. If you need to loop a powerpoint presentation on a bunch of tvs, this device is much cheaper than getting a full pc or some type of 3rd party player. There would be plenty of bandwidth to pull down new slide shows and there wouldn't be a need to have data run to the tv.
 
I think those talking about business uses are spot on particularly, for those users who travel.
 
Looks like a great device for a SageTV client or other media center front-end.

I could easily replace my parents' PC (that I gave them) with one of these too.
 
Also, remember all of these data transfer rates are half-duplex, so you can cut those speeds in half, even in the best scenarios.

Duplex cookies are like the best kinds ever, but I agree that you need full duplex cookies so you can have both sides AND the creamy stuff inside all at once or they're probably not as fun.
 
I have an Asus ChromeBox running win 8.1; the bios hack wasn't too hard (just be sure to undo the bios protect screw before trying to flash, or it does a partial flash and gets really weird).

Were you able to do the bios mod so you don't have to hit ctrl-y (or whatever keypress combo it was) to boot ever time?

it could be annoying to boot it like that every time, especially for non-techy household members and parents.

That being said, with a ~5W idle, who needs to ever turn this thing off? :p


But you might want to consider getting the HP Stream Mini instead, it's almost the same thing, but you don't have to hack the bios, and there's more storage; if you want more than 2gb ram, double check that the mini has a second slot, I know HP wasn't populating all the ram slots in their chromeboxes.

Thanks for the suggestion.

Wow, that looks like something I might bring my lunch to work in :p

From a specs perspective, it hits the spot though.

I'm usually a function trumps form type of guy, but I'm not sure I want that blue tupperware under my TV :p That's a little much...

I can get by with the 16GB of the Asus though. I mean, my current HTPC has a 120GB SSD in it (because that is what I had handy that I wasn't using at the time) but the base install of Ubuntu Linux 14.04 LTS, minus the packages I don't need, plus Kodi only uses about 5GB, and my mythtv backend stores all content on my NAS.

The "boring black box" design of the Chromebox, and the $20 lower pricetag appeals to me so much more, as long as the bios hack isn't too bad, and I don't have to keypress on every boot.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041562560 said:
Were you able to do the bios mod so you don't have to hit ctrl-y (or whatever keypress combo it was) to boot ever time?
Yes, I used the script from here https://johnlewis.ie/custom-chromebook-firmware/rom-download/ I had to buy a new USB drive to run the windows installer from (it didn't like the drive i had with sufficient capacity, it would boot off my 32 MB drive though... but that wasn't very helpful for windows). In windows, audio over hdmi doesn't work on the Chromebox; it's probably fine in Linux, but you should double check. There's a page on the Kodi wiki about these guys too http://kodi.wiki/view/Chromebox

Zarathustra[H];1041562560 said:
Thanks for the suggestion.

Wow, that looks like something I might bring my lunch to work in :p

From a specs perspective, it hits the spot though.

I'm usually a function trumps form type of guy, but I'm not sure I want that blue tupperware under my TV :p That's a little much...

I can get by with the 16GB of the Asus though. I mean, my current HTPC has a 120GB SSD in it (because that is what I had handy that I wasn't using at the time) but the base install of Ubuntu Linux 14.04 LTS, minus the packages I don't need, plus Kodi only uses about 5GB, and my mythtv backend stores all content on my NAS.

The "boring black box" design of the Chromebox, and the $20 lower pricetag appeals to me so much more, as long as the bios hack isn't too bad, and I don't have to keypress on every boot.

Yeah, the asus is prettier.
 
Yeah, the asus is prettier.


lol

41kZeegaIPL._SY355_.jpg


HP-Stream-CM_rc_280x210.jpg
 
http://kodi.wiki/view/Chromebox

Thank you for that.

I knew I had seen something over there about setting up haswell celerons properly, but didn't realize there was something specifically for the chromebox. This will be useful!
 
I have a Bay Trail tablet with the same Z3735F SoC with 2 GB RAM/64 GB eMMC and it works great for 1080P streaming and even Windows Media Center playback of 720P/1080i shows but it has 5 Ghz AC WiFi and that really makes a big difference over N. No AC WiFi is the weak link here for any kind of streaming. Still, there's a lot more you can do with a full PC than a Chromecast or similar type of compute stick. Hopefully there be a Cherry Trail version of these coming out later this year with 64 GB of storage. 32 GB is actually a decent amount if you stick to mostly Windows apps and a few desktop apps.

Not entirely sure I get the point in this video review about the "10 foot interface" problem. A media center keyboard with an integrated track pad I think is a big help. Not as compact as a remote but come in very handy if you want to web surface.
 
I kinda like it,lol..... good price point too
 
Gizmodo destroyed this thing saying "No, hell no":

http://gizmodo.com/intel-compute-stick-review-don-t-buy-it-1699377058

The bluetooth and wireless share the same chips, not normally a problem, but if you are 100% on wifi AND heavy bluetooth the BT lags heavily. Plus in order to use a wireless keyboard/mouse you have to use that 1 and only USB slot to fill up an adapter, anything else and you have to get a POWERED hub as non-powered hub doesn't put out enough juice.


I'll take the HP stream mini for $30 more and get a helluva lot better performance, upgrade ability, wired ports, and a ton more:

Ars on the Intel Stick:
http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2015...a-full-pc-thats-tiny-in-size-and-performance/

Ars on the HP Mini
http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2015...s-stream-and-pavilion-mini-desktops-reviewed/
 
Gizmodo destroyed this thing saying "No, hell no":

http://gizmodo.com/intel-compute-stick-review-don-t-buy-it-1699377058

The bluetooth and wireless share the same chips, not normally a problem, but if you are 100% on wifi AND heavy bluetooth the BT lags heavily. Plus in order to use a wireless keyboard/mouse you have to use that 1 and only USB slot to fill up an adapter, anything else and you have to get a POWERED hub as non-powered hub doesn't put out enough juice.


I'll take the HP stream mini for $30 more and get a helluva lot better performance, upgrade ability, wired ports, and a ton more:

Ars on the Intel Stick:
http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2015...a-full-pc-thats-tiny-in-size-and-performance/

Ars on the HP Mini
http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2015...s-stream-and-pavilion-mini-desktops-reviewed/

So I'd really love to be able to stream, say, D3 from my PC in the bedroom to my TV screen. I've googled around a bit but outside of Steam games, don't see too many options. Sounds like you guys have done quite a bit of legwork, would you be able to point me in any direction/site that might be able to help me out?
 
Back
Top