Infuriating PC woes, please help!

TheBlank

Limp Gawd
Joined
Nov 15, 2006
Messages
164
Okay, a budy of mine a few months ago had a massive failure with his system. His PSU went and took with it the mobo and CPU. Seeing as it was an older DELL machine, I suggested just saving the components we could and placing it into a new case.

Purchase new mobo, cpu, psu (he did this part beforehand and it wasn't working... that's when I found out the old one had taken out the IDE ports on the mobo as well as the CPU) and Antec 180 tower.

So far so good... till we find out that the new mobo was infact a refurb (wasn't listed anywhere on the site as such). It was wonky from the get go, constantly giving us "CPU has been changed or is unworkable" errors before allowing us to boot. It was an Abit IS7-E2 with a 2.8ghz northwood. So when I finally rebuilt my machine, I replaced his refurb with my tried and true IS7-E. Threw in my extra ram (now 3 gigs). HOWEVER... pulling the Zalman heatsink off the old mobo pried the CPU out of the socket without the lever ever having been lifted. That bent a whole row of pins slightly. I checked, and the layer of AS5 should have been more than thin enough to keep this from happening.

Bent the pins back (he wanted to use the CPU he bought rather than my faster spare Northwood) and installed the system. I also had to replace his PSU with my old Antec NEO 450w because the cables weren't long enough on the other PSU. It worked just fine except for the integrated sound card. That and we were now getting the "CPU has been changed..." error again. So, last night, I brought my old Audigy2 and my GeForce FX5900 to replace his components to try and finally fix the problem.

Installed the cards, no problem. Installed the new drivers, no problem. I shut down the PC so I could clear the CMOS to see if that got rid of the CPU error... tried to startup... and the fans spun for a second... stopped... and a wisp of smoke rises out of the case near the optical drives. Filling the room with the pleasant smell of seared electronics.

I pulled everything out of that system to see if just one thing had gone. No luck booting. I would have replaced the CPU with my spare which I had there if I hadn't forgotten my AS5 at home. When I pulled his CPU out (which again came away with the cooler) I found areas along where the die meets the board had what seemed to be hardened AS5 that was also darkened. Nothing else in the system has scorch marks. The LED on the mobo lights up when supplied power. I'm going to go test my spar CPU in the system tonight and see if that CPU was the problem...


BUT WHAT THE HELL??? This comp is starting to make me look bad.

If that CPU has taken that 475 chipset mobo out with it, what should I suggest? I can't find any cheap Abit boards that have Ethernet built in, and I'm rather leery of suggesting he rebuild yet another antiquated system. I'm tempted to tell him just to start over with newer parts.

Is there anything else that could be causing this? A bad surge protector? Faulty house wiring? Something else to be looking for so we don't end up killing yet another system?


Oh... and on a side note... I noticed the Zalman cooler I was using seems to be magnetized around the center of the fan... rather strongly magnetized too because ever time a screw falls near it, it gets pulled in and sticks. I'm assuming, this isn't a good thing.


Thanks for any insight and suggestions. This has been driving me and buddy insane for months now. He really needs his machine working, he's a web comic artist and cannot work on them without it.
 
I'd really like to help you out, but I can't read all that. Could you (or someone else) post a summary? Thanks.
 
*sigh*

Seeing as it took me close to 2 minutes total to re-read that whole post, I'm not quite sure why the equivalent of a "tldr" was needed. If you really want to help me out, please take it on faith that I wrote it as I did for the reason of posting the pertinent information that would affect the solution and correctly convey the issue.

In any case, as it turns out, my friend's recently purchased Northwood seems to have been the recent problem source, as it fried my IS-7E motherboard as it went. I placed a new chip in the motherboard, no go. Placed old chip in the IS-7E2 motherboard and again, no go. My chip and IS-7E2 motherboard brought us back to life however.

But that doesn't explain why it started going bad in the first place. Bad CPU? Bad electrical wiring? Any suggestions would be helpful, seeing as I'd rather not have to start from scratch... again...
 
Maybe he the Northwood's pins were bent, one of the pins may have come loose. When did your friend buy the northwood? Was it OEM, Used, or retail?

Quote from Wikipedia:

"Overclocking early stepping Northwood cores yielded a startling phenomenon. When VCore was increased past 1.7 V, the processor would slowly become more unstable over time, before dying and becoming totally unusable. This is believed to have been caused by the physical phenomenon known as Electromigration, where the internal pathways of the CPU become degraded over time due to excessive electron energy. This was also known as Sudden Northwood Death Syndrome"

Maybe SNDS may have been the problem?
 
It was OEM and it was purchased 2 months ago. Wasn't used as far as we know (purchased from Newegg). It was never overclocked on our end either. Maybe it was just a bad chip... or falsely advertised as new...
 
Back
Top