im also on a budget :D

klowngoblin

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Oct 28, 2001
Messages
1,087
i was looking at the Gigabyte GA-K8NS Ultra-939 + A64 3200 or 3500

i currently have a Barton 2500@3200 that i can probably sell, the cpu was good at the time but its being beaten by my laptop which i think is TOTALY unacceptable so its time to upgrade, would the gigabyte be good? im a diehard ASUS fan, ive had 4 mobos by them and even my laptop is by asus, i have never used a gigabyte board before just wondering if they had high failure rate? none of the asus boards that i have owned have had any kind of problems.
 
From what I've heard, this is the order of motherboard quality:

1. Asus
2. Intel
3. MSI
4. Abit
5. Gigabyte

I may be wrong.
 
personally i think gigabytes are pretty darn crappy .I say get an Asus board deffinetly ( comes from a Msi and Asus fan )
 
yes sir you are very wrong..

1. MSI
2. Asus
3. Abit
4. Gigabyte
5. Intel

Intels are shit. I will never buy one, EVER.
When I was a noobie, i was about to buy one, the store manager litteraly told me plain and simple, they are shit.
 
hmm i guess i'll pay $20 more for the Asus, although the Asus has less features and 2 less SATA ports. oh well
 
chrom3titan said:
yes sir you are very wrong..

1. MSI
2. Asus
3. Abit
4. Gigabyte
5. Intel

Intels are shit. I will never buy one, EVER.
When I was a noobie, i was about to buy one, the store manager litteraly told me plain and simple, they are shit.

Then you are wrong sir, very wrong. And so is the store manager, who is clearly an idiot as well. Intel makes some of the most reliable and rock stable boards on the market, some even have limited overclocking features. While thier low and mid-priced boards don't feature overclocking, even the bottom of the Intel heap now supports adjustable RAM timings. I have built dozens of systems on Intel boards and they are excellent. I'd take one over Abit and MSI any day. Here is a great rule of thumb, never take advice from a retail store manager. Motherboards should be chosen first for stability and everything else is a secondary consideration.

1. Asus
2. Intel
3. Gigabyte
4. Abit
5 MSI
 
I would agree with splinter on this one. Gigabyte makes some damn good boards and in the 2 that I have owned in the past have had no problems.

Intel boards are not shit they have next to no overclocking features at all but they are very very stable.
 
Stick with whatever you think is good, you have had good experiences with ASUS, I would say go with an ASUS. As for the person who is bashing Intel motherboards, you are massively wrong. I have owned a 865PERL and a 865GBF and it simply owned for everything I wanted to do until I got addicted to overclocking :p. Intel makes rock solid boards with great features/layout and an awesome warrenty.
 
I know this is the motherboard forum, but if I were you I'd go with the 3200+ and overclock it the 200mhz to 3500+ speed rather than spend the extra $80 or whatever it is now.
 
kirbyrj said:
I know this is the motherboard forum, but if I were you I'd go with the 3200+ and overclock it the 200mhz to 3500+ speed rather than spend the extra $80 or whatever it is now.

i was thinking that too, the 3200 is almost $100CDN cheaper. since my cpu is running 200MHz right now to from 166 with no problems, im gonna guess the a64 can do the same. i can spent $45CDN more on the zalman flower fan and OC the hell out of it. hmm , descisions, descisions
 
I just picked up an Epox EP-9NDA3+ and I will be honest this thing is stable as hell (so FAR) and has more overclocking features than I will ever use. This is of course an NF3 board for those on a budget who want to keep there AGP high end cards.

I had an Abit NF-7s version 2 with a Barton 2500+ overclocked to 3500+ speeds and the Epox EP-9NDA3+ with the 3500+ chip blows it away without any overclocking. The difference was startling, and this is with the same memory and video card.
 
First of all, Intel does not make a socket 939 board. Second of all, Intel makes EXCELLENT motherboards, some of the most stable motherboards out there, they only "suck" in that they typically do not have any BIOS options or features for overclocking. They are meant to be stable and they do that quite well. I'd also like to mention that all the Intel-chipset machines I've used boot and shutdown faster than any machines I have ever used.

Second of all, making a "Top 5" list of board manufacturers is rediculous, there are way too many factors in deciding which motherboard is best for you.

If you are building a basic, budget system that will not be heavily overclocked a Gigabyte board will work great for you. Another budget option would be the Chaintech VNF4, however I like the layout of the Gigabyte boards MUCH better than the Chaintech, especially considering the placement of the ATX connector on the Chaintech.

From experience and from what reading I've done on many forums for the past few months, most people have had MANY problems with the Asus NF4 boards, some fixed in BIOS updates, others not. That's the only one that I would personally shy away from at this point.
 
i built my buddy a gigabyte based system (xp 3000+ nforce board) i thought it was pretty shitty ... always crashing an fucking up , temp sensors never have been right or anything id stay away , go asus , abit or msi
 
yeah, gigabyte boards suck... go for an Asus, Abit, or MSI... i wish AMD made boards too :(

edit: but stay the hell away from VIA!! i dont care who makes it, VIA boards blow!
 
Stellar said:
If you are building a basic, budget system that will not be heavily overclocked a Gigabyte board will work great for you. Another budget option would be the Chaintech VNF4, however I like the layout of the Gigabyte boards MUCH better than the Chaintech, especially considering the placement of the ATX connector on the Chaintech.

I'd get the Chaintech over the Gigabyte anyday. I can't believe how cheap that chaintech is. I'm almost thinking of getting one just to play around with :).
 
kirbyrj said:
I'd get the Chaintech over the Gigabyte anyday. I can't believe how cheap that chaintech is. I'm almost thinking of getting one just to play around with :).

This is why their ATX placement sucks.. same placement as my Epox NF3 board..

http://www.tarleton.edu/students/st_bostick/images/RateMyCables.jpg

Terrible.

The Gigabyte also has 6-phase power regulation and a backup BIOS. Chaintech makes good boards but they are not very feature-rich.
 
lithium726 said:
yeah, gigabyte boards suck... go for an Asus, Abit, or MSI... i wish AMD made boards too :(

edit: but stay the hell away from VIA!! i dont care who makes it, VIA boards blow!

My Asus has a VIA K8T800 pro and I couldn't ask for more. Since you don't seem like you're planning to overclock like crazy, VIA would be alright so I wouldn't rule that out if I were you. I too wanted an NF3 Ultra when I was shopping for a motherboard but this A8V-Deluxe has swung me the other way. Even if it's 4-5 fps slower in CS:S, that's something I'd sacrifice for stability, something this Asus board owns at.
 
Back
Top