Illegal Downloading = Scumbag Theft

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Whether or not you agree with this guy, you have to admit the term "copyright kleptomaniacs" is kinda catchy. ;)

News Limited chief executive Kim Williams wants tougher laws to stop "scumbag theft" by the "copyright kleptomaniacs of the digital age'', saying piracy was undermining the business of cultural production more than ever.
 
Oh look, the news article is behind a login/paywall. *sigh*
 
According to the chairman of the company that owns the site the source article is on, you're violating their copyright by linking to them and pasting a snippet of their story.

By extension does that make you a scumbag and a kleptomaniac in their eyes?
 
According to the chairman of the company that owns the site the source article is on, you're violating their copyright by linking to them and pasting a snippet of their story.

By extension does that make you a scumbag and a kleptomaniac in their eyes?

He should change his title to Steve Scumbag kleptomaniac.
 
I read over the [H] posts first then decided to read the article (part there of) just so I could be a Scumbag Kleptomaniac, too!
 
Reading stuff like that makes me want to get all of their content (without paying for it of course) and put it up on a server hosted in Venezuela for the world to read for free (not that anyone actually would, but still).
 
At some point sooner or later the 1% are gonna have to take a step back and ask themselves "How much is enough?" :mad:
 
Agree! Death penalty for illegal watching/listening to content you didn't pay for!

Last night I had to shoot 52 people because I accidentally turned the speakers up too loud.
 
Agree! Death penalty for illegal watching/listening to content you didn't pay for!

Last night I had to shoot 52 people because I accidentally turned the speakers up too loud.

Dammit, DP you're supposed to use the Neuralyzer!
 
At least you cleaned up your own mess.

The secret is wearing PVC/Kevlar blend. Then burning the houses afterwords (the vibrations from the speakers would have moved the particles in the houses, thus the houses also listened to the music illegally and should have been terminated). The law is very clear on the issue. :D
 
Rebel scum.

Real reason couldn't be that they aren't producing any content worth paying for? I don't mean getting it for free, I mean getting it at all. Why is it that great movies/books/music still make millions of dollars and shitty stuff is always blamed on "digital klepto's"?
 
Obligatory: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IeTybKL1pM4

Piracy != copyright infringement. If you're pillaging someone on the high seas, that is piracy. If you downloaded your favorite TV series from a torrent site, that's copyright infringement. Don't let the copyright kingpins frame the debate in their favor with loaded language.

The best way to deal with a troll is to ignore, ignore, ignore. Don't give these empty suits the satisfaction of pointing to copyright infringement as a "cause" for their lost sales; just ignore their products. If it's not worth paying for, it's not worth your time.
 
Obligatory: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IeTybKL1pM4

Piracy != copyright infringement. If you're pillaging someone on the high seas, that is piracy. If you downloaded your favorite TV series from a torrent site, that's copyright infringement. Don't let the copyright kingpins frame the debate in their favor with loaded language.

The best way to deal with a troll is to ignore, ignore, ignore. Don't give these empty suits the satisfaction of pointing to copyright infringement as a "cause" for their lost sales; just ignore their products. If it's not worth paying for, it's not worth your time.

Yea, and a dork is a whale penis. A fag is a cigarette. Shall I go on? The word "piracy" has come to mean multiple things, including copyright infringement or stealing digital items. Get used to it. Yes, it is meant to sound mean and eye-patchy.
 
Tougher laws? Huh? Forcing someone into bankruptcy over 5 songs isn't tough enough?

He can't possibly think they need prison time. It's bad enough we put non-violent mild drug offenses in. I can see the pre-rape seen now ..

"What're you in for?"
"I downloaded 5 songs .. you?"
"I raped a lot of people ..........."
 
Tougher laws? Huh? Forcing someone into bankruptcy over 5 songs isn't tough enough?

He can't possibly think they need prison time. It's bad enough we put non-violent mild drug offenses in. I can see the pre-rape seen now ..

"What're you in for?"
"I downloaded 5 songs .. you?"
"I raped a lot of people ..........."

Well, you don't get pregnant from real rape, so you're good.

I agree. They've got WAY too strict laws as it is now, and their way of twisting peoples arms to settle out of court in fear of the HUGE fines to only pay "minimal" fines for $5K a song is a bit much. Especially for Grandma that gets the email from her grandkids with pictures.... No downloading of anything else... Yup, she's GUILTY!
 
When something is stolen, the thing is no longer in possession of the owner.
 
He said film piracy alone costs the Australian economy $1.37 billion last year.
Oh yea cause people working in Theaters won't be able to feed their children now. :rolleyes:

Sadly, piracy brings more jobs then legitimate ownership does. Think about it. Torrenting needs high speed downloads, storage like DVDs and hard drives, as well as people who know how to get around DRM.

If we all used Netflix and bought DVDs, who would benefit? The clerk at the store? The IT staff running the servers at Netflix?
 
When something is stolen, the thing is no longer in possession of the owner.

Stealing is avoiding payment when it is necessary.

Is it theft of services (stealing) when you rip off a mechanic that fixed your car?

Sure, it's a fuzzy line to draw when dealing with digital items. But, was the original owner really in possession in the first place?
 
Stealing is avoiding payment when it is necessary.

Is it theft of services (stealing) when you rip off a mechanic that fixed your car?

Sure, it's a fuzzy line to draw when dealing with digital items. But, was the original owner really in possession in the first place?

Funny thing about that - it's like saying managers and CEO of Wal-mart owns the merchandises on their shelves. They really don't. But that's stealing too. But hey since there's like 10 of the same item on the shelves, it's just a copy, and thus not stealing, right? :D
 
Stealing is avoiding payment when it is necessary.

Is it theft of services (stealing) when you rip off a mechanic that fixed your car?

Sure, it's a fuzzy line to draw when dealing with digital items. But, was the original owner really in possession in the first place?


The difference between theft of service, ie car repair and copyright infringement is simple. The mechanic cannot perform a service once for a virtually unlimited number of people. The mechanic has to perform the service for each customer. With a song, once the original is created, it can be sent to millions with no effort from the creator.
 
The difference between theft of service, ie car repair and copyright infringement is simple. The mechanic cannot perform a service once for a virtually unlimited number of people. The mechanic has to perform the service for each customer. With a song, once the original is created, it can be sent to millions with no effort from the creator.

Well, with no effort from the creator, I could photocopy a book and pass it around. When does it become stealing? When I start charging for it?

If I download a pirated game, I do consider it that I'm stealing it. I'm getting a paid item without paying for it. Yes, it can be distributed without any effort from the creator. But, it still had a price tag on it and I took it without paying for it.
 
Stealing is avoiding payment when it is necessary.

What about this scenario:

Company A produces an item which is distributed by Company B, Company A gets money via license fees or products sold. Company C, takes these license fees from all products sold or distributed, and stores the money in it's bank accounts, even though it doesn't pay for distribution or licensing nor has any form of signed, written contract with Company A or B. Company C may also choose to distribute products of A without paying the licensing.

To get this money Company A must go through a lengthy process to get back it's money from Company C, of which a fee is subtracted. Company C does offer (paid) membership to reduce these fees. Is Company C committing theft?
 
Obligatory: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=IeTybKL1pM4

Piracy != copyright infringement. If you're pillaging someone on the high seas, that is piracy. If you downloaded your favorite TV series from a torrent site, that's copyright infringement. Don't let the copyright kingpins frame the debate in their favor with loaded language.

The best way to deal with a troll is to ignore, ignore, ignore. Don't give these empty suits the satisfaction of pointing to copyright infringement as a "cause" for their lost sales; just ignore their products. If it's not worth paying for, it's not worth your time.

http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=pirate&allowed_in_frame=0

pirate (n.)
mid-13c., from O.Fr. pirate, from L. pirata "sailor, sea robber," from Gk. peirates "brigand, pirate," lit. "one who attacks," from peiran "to attack, make a hostile attempt on, try," from peira "trial, an attempt, attack," from PIE root *per- "try" (cf. L. peritus "experienced," periculum "trial, experiment, risk, danger," see peril). Meaning "one who takes another's work without permission" first recorded 1701; sense of "unlicensed radio broadcaster" is from 1913. The verb is first recorded 1570s. Related: Pirated; pirating.

So the first recorded use of the word in the current context is from 1701!

http://oxforddictionaries.com/definition/english/pirate

Hate to break it to you, but it IS piracy, that's one of the definitions of piracy by currently used english, so it is what it is!
 
What about this scenario:

Company A produces an item which is distributed by Company B, Company A gets money via license fees or products sold. Company C, takes these license fees from all products sold or distributed, and stores the money in it's bank accounts, even though it doesn't pay for distribution or licensing nor has any form of signed, written contract with Company A or B. Company C may also choose to distribute products of A without paying the licensing.

To get this money Company A must go through a lengthy process to get back it's money from Company C, of which a fee is subtracted. Company C does offer (paid) membership to reduce these fees. Is Company C committing theft?

So, stealing from the developer, distributor or reseller? Yea, the process itself sucks, and I agree with that completely. And it is stealing from the developer. But, that is between the developer and the contract with Satan they signed. Sucks that is the delivery method and the way to make big money. Same with all media outlets. But, if I download a game without paying, I am taking from the developer. Yes, if I bought it from Steam or Walmart, they would love that commission, but the final seven cents is still taken from the developer.

If the digital bits have value, then yes they can be stolen. Even if no transfer of physical property ever happened. If I don't want to pay for it, I can steal it. It's easy. It's a quick download and crack (and cracks are SO much easier than the forced DRM of something that I legitimately bought and paid for). I took something that wasn't mine without paying the rightful people (or contracted people) for it.

I'm not arguing the process and the warped industry, just the actual theft of the bits and whether or not it's "stealing" (which to me means taking something that isn't yours without due compensation).
 
It doesn't matter what you want to call it, you are charged with copyright infringement in court.
 
TL;DRer's - :rolleyes: - To pirate, one takes - I dispute anything is taken. -KA

http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=pirate&allowed_in_frame=0

pirate (n.)
yada yada ..
Meaning "one who takes another's work without permission"
... yada yada

So the first recorded use of the word in the current context is from 1701!

http://oxforddictionaries.com/definition/english/pirate

Hate to break it to you, but it IS piracy, that's one of the definitions of piracy by currently used english, so it is what it is!

Tudz, notice the word 'takes'. To become a pirate one must take another's work ( http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=take&allowed_in_frame=0 or in the vernacular 'to lay hold of' ) or something they have particular claim to. When an individual illicitly copies something, all of the atoms, time, and other intangible specifics the owner has ( other then sole right to produce copies of, ie. copyright ) are kept in the entirety by that owner. The new holder of the bit-stream usually does, or pays for, all of the work to manufacture the copy. No work lost by the owner, no taking, no pirate.

That said, there will always be people who want to buy extremely low, add a few pennies worth of additional materials, and sell high. And indeed those people will search for any remedy to other people circumventing their highly profitable activities. Spinning public opinion of course will always be one of the tools in these questionably moral people. [ Rights holders profiting from next to no work I mean. ]


Snazzy Signature [ full of specs, comedy, and trivia ]
 
It doesn't matter what you want to call it, you are charged with copyright infringement in court.

True. I was mostly responding to the post above which stated "When something is stolen, the thing is no longer in possession of the owner.", which I don't agree with.

It is copyright infringement in court.
 
TL;DRer's - :rolleyes: - To pirate, one takes - I dispute anything is taken. -KA



Tudz, notice the word 'takes'. To become a pirate one must take another's work ( http://www.etymonline.com/index.php?term=take&allowed_in_frame=0 or in the vernacular 'to lay hold of' ) or something they have particular claim to. When an individual illicitly copies something, all of the atoms, time, and other intangible specifics the owner has ( other then sole right to produce copies of, ie. copyright ) are kept in the entirety by that owner. The new holder of the bit-stream usually does, or pays for, all of the work to manufacture the copy. No work lost by the owner, no taking, no pirate.

That said, there will always be people who want to buy extremely low, add a few pennies worth of additional materials, and sell high. And indeed those people will search for any remedy to other people circumventing their highly profitable activities. Spinning public opinion of course will always be one of the tools in these questionably moral people. [ Rights holders profiting from next to no work I mean. ]


Snazzy Signature [ full of specs, comedy, and trivia ]

You kinda missed my point and/or didn't read the Oxford dictionary link I posted and/or ignored the very next sentence as well "sense of "unlicensed radio broadcaster" is from 1913".

Usage is what makes a word mean what it means. The word is and has been used in the context of copyright infringement so therefore that is what it means. It's even in the dictionary. You can argue the semantics if you like, but the fact is I can go out on the street and ask someone what "software piracy" means and they'll respond by saying copyright infringement of software, not stealing wares of the soft variety on the high seas.
 
You kinda missed my point and/or didn't read the Oxford dictionary link I posted and/or ignored the very next sentence as well "sense of "unlicensed radio broadcaster" is from 1913".

Usage is what makes a word mean what it means. The word is and has been used in the context of copyright infringement so therefore that is what it means. It's even in the dictionary. You can argue the semantics if you like, but the fact is I can go out on the street and ask someone what "software piracy" means and they'll respond by saying copyright infringement of software, not stealing wares of the soft variety on the high seas.

And I say liberal Aussie means commie infiltrator. We got 'im, boys! :cool:
 
smh at that youtube video about "copying is not stealing". I hope that's supposed to be a parody.
people are still arguing semantics.

stealing, pirating, copyright infringement, copying........ all have the same results- they all deprive someone of money or goods.

Instead of subscribing to HBO, you download the show and deprive HBO and tv crew of money/salary.

Copying and pasting an [H] hardware review on another website and diverting thousands of readers away from the original source, depriving [H] of ad revenue and commissions, is scumbag theft.

therefore, whether downloading or copying, piracy = scumbag theft, because either you were supposed to pay for it, or someone else was supposed to get paid for it.

someone is getting robbed. I don't see what there is to argue.


disclaimer: I'm a pirate. and hypocrite.
 
And I say liberal Aussie means commie infiltrator. We got 'im, boys! :cool:

You have to get it in common usage and then in the dictionary first there, mate ;) Isn't english a wonderful language :p

This is why people like lawyers and engineers and scientists have to invent their own language, english is just a little bit too adaptable and flexible, even then you can read engineering papers from years gone by things and it's clear the meanings of certain technical words has changed over time.
 
Yea. I went through some old D drawings at work not too long ago from the 60's... some of it didn't make sense.
 
Back
Top