I need another 1TB drive, which one for performance?

I am buying those at work. I think I have about 15 now. They work great. As for performance I have not taken the time to benchmark and in most cases they are in a raid.
 
i have one of those WD black drives as my primary drive in my newest PC. certainly worth it for only $100. (cheaper if you wait for a newegg special, which they run all the time, this drive often has a discount).

dont get hung up on the 6GB vs 3GB SATA- i have a mobo that supports SATA 6gb, and it might be marginally faster then the same drive in SATA2 format in some instances, but its not twice as fast. a normal hard drive cant saturate a SATA2 connection anyway. if all else were equal, sure get the newer one, but dont make it a primary decision factor.
 
a normal hard drive cant saturate a SATA2 connection anyway.

Or a SATA1 connection. Unless there is some 150MB/s drive out there that I do not know of... Getting close though.
 
Samsung F3 1TB

Price is certainly lower for this one, although still being 7200 rpm unlike the WD green edition. If performance is practically the same between this drive and the WD black, I'll buy this one. Will go look for a comparison.

Thanks.
 
dont get hung up on the 6GB vs 3GB SATA- i have a mobo that supports SATA 6gb, and it might be marginally faster then the same drive in SATA2 format in some instances, but its not twice as fast. a normal hard drive cant saturate a SATA2 connection anyway. if all else were equal, sure get the newer one, but dont make it a primary decision factor.

Very true, but the new WD blacks are more than just an upgraded SATA interface. They have 64MB cache and some kind of funky new two-stage heads that are supposed to settle out faster on seeks. I don't know how they compare to the Samsung F3 but I've seen some reviews that put up some good numbers (especially the 2TB, but it's really pricey).

I just got a WD1002FAEX for $89 w/ free ship from Newegg (unfortunately it also came with Newegg's usual incompetent bubble wrapping, but seems to have survived so far). I haven't benchmarked it, but I had it in an external eSata dock while I was copying over my old drive, and it barely got warm, and also had very little vibration.
 
The Blacks have had the dual actuator system since the original 640GB ones. AFAIK it's not changed much since, and it knocks 2ms or so off average access time, making them basically the fastest 7200 RPM drives around in terms of seek performance, and with 500GB a platter in the 2TBs they're very competitive in sequential transfer as well. They are louder while seeking than any other 7200 RPM drive though. If it's an OS or gaming drive, go for it. If it's for storing large media files, you have little to gain from the Black, other than noise and a bit more expense. Oh and a 5 year warranty.

Dustin
 
Although the 1TB black for $100 is not bad... the 2TB Hitachi's have been trending really close to that pricepoint. I would personally pick up two 1TB drives or one 2TB drive instead just because after moving to SSDs hard drives slowest to fastest all seem slow in comparison (even my old 15k SAS drives).
 
You could get a seagate one, they're pretty cheap for the performance

Actually, the Seagate is a mediocre value overall even at its street price. The 7200.12 is slower than the Samsung F3 in sequential transfer speed while its seek speed is no faster than the Samsung.
 
well since the OP is looking for performance, i would suggest that WD black drive he linked. i did a few benchmarks on it last night, mid 140's mb/sec transfer speed for small files (10mb). 94mb/sec average for a 4GB file. a few of these in RAID would be fantastic.
 
Back
Top