Hyper-Realistic CGI Is Killing Photographers

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Check it out, half the picture below is computer generated, half is real. The article seems like a commercial for KeyShot but the tech involved is still pretty cool.
 
Ehh, i still can notice which half is real and which isn't, it is simple, look for the imperfections, or better said, the lack of them... like the lack of nose hair... gross but that should tell you fast which half is fake if you can't tell :p

Still, yeah, we may eventually get there, but i don't think that the real deal will be entirely phased,,,
 
Ehh, i still can notice which half is real and which isn't, it is simple, look for the imperfections, or better said, the lack of them... like the lack of nose hair... gross but that should tell you fast which half is fake if you can't tell :p

Still, yeah, we may eventually get there, but i don't think that the real deal will be entirely phased,,,

There are a few nose hairs on the CGI side. There is not sufficient skin translucency to realistically illuminate the nostril, and backlight the nose hairs and not enough of them to be very visible from front lighting. There's also aliasing of the eyelashes. Those are probably technical limitations of the renderer. Then there's the laziness of the creator. Big blurry areas that don't quite match between the bump map for the pores and the specular map for the pores in the skin. All the beard hairs are black or gray, not the variety of shades and hues of natural hair. Very few hairs actual tangle with each other, just mostly lay against one another. Then there's the big screaming obvious thing which is the CGI skin looks pearlescent, that could be the renderer or the artist.
 
To make hyper realistic CGI takes a few days at least... To take a photo takes a few minutes... There's no real reason to create real stuff while the effort to make it is so much more, but there is for stuff you can't easily make in the real world. :p
 
Technology must really have changed in the last two weeks. I've never seen any CGI software kill or even draw blood from a photographer. :eek:
 
The article seems to be focusing on product advertising images.

What you guys don't seem to be taking into account is how much airbrushing already goes into the real photos before consumers see them. By the time that process is done, I doubt you have much of a chance of being able to pick out the real photo from the fake based on being "too perfect" as things like unsightly nose-hairs would have been airbrushed out.

As for "To take a photo takes a few minutes". That just isn't true at a professional level. Setting up a professional product photo shoot takes a lot of effort and time in order to prep the scene and get the lighting perfect. In some cases, like food photography, the amount of effort that goes into making the food look perfect boarders on the absurd (ex. sesame seeds glued onto a burger bun to produce the ideal distribution pattern; cardboard under the burger patty to make the sandwich look firmer; etc.). With an all CGI setup, you could have a stock collection of scenes/actors and just swap up combinations and lighting settings once you have enough options created. As for the product itself, you can already import the actual 3D parametric CAD files created by the original design engineer. They usually include the actual material properties for each component making it a breeze to just render with total realism.
 
There are a few nose hairs on the CGI side. There is not sufficient skin translucency to realistically illuminate the nostril, and backlight the nose hairs and not enough of them to be very visible from front lighting. There's also aliasing of the eyelashes. Those are probably technical limitations of the renderer. Then there's the laziness of the creator. Big blurry areas that don't quite match between the bump map for the pores and the specular map for the pores in the skin. All the beard hairs are black or gray, not the variety of shades and hues of natural hair. Very few hairs actual tangle with each other, just mostly lay against one another. Then there's the big screaming obvious thing which is the CGI skin looks pearlescent, that could be the renderer or the artist.

Yup, all in all, hair is a bitch to make, and proper skin takes a couple extra shader passes to lose that way too shiny look.
And well, other details about proper wrinkling of the skin, but that could be secondary.
 
As for "To take a photo takes a few minutes". That just isn't true at a professional level. Setting up a professional product photo shoot takes a lot of effort and time in order to prep the scene and get the lighting perfect. In some cases, like food photography, the amount of effort that goes into making the food look perfect boarders on the absurd (ex. sesame seeds glued onto a burger bun to produce the ideal distribution pattern; cardboard under the burger patty to make the sandwich look firmer; etc.). With an all CGI setup, you could have a stock collection of scenes/actors and just swap up combinations and lighting settings once you have enough options created. As for the product itself, you can already import the actual 3D parametric CAD files created by the original design engineer. They usually include the actual material properties for each component making it a breeze to just render with total realism.

that is true. It "could" take a few minutes. Whereas CGI takes much longer as a minimum, so from a time/money perspective even if CGI is hyper realistic, photography makes more sense.
 
Why must they use this technology to kill people though? Why can't they just let the photographers be?!?!! :eek:
 
Why must they use this technology to kill people though? Why can't they just let the photographers be?!?!! :eek:

I agree ... if our CGI has become this hostile to photographers, who knows who they will go after next ... I think we need the first law of CGI before it is too late ... You shall not drop a CGI safe on Humans, EVER ... problem solved :D

Also, is the non-realistic CGI more easy going or are they just not as adept at killing the photographers ... I think we need a government study on this ... I volunteer to do this valuable research at the reasonable rate of FIFTY Million dollars :cool:
 
If find it hilarious that car sites like http://jalopnik.com Look at pictures of new cars coming out and everybody in the comments and on the website talks about it like it is the real car but it is just a render in 3d studio max based off the autocad data with a .HDRI file applied for the lighting from the sun of a real location.
 
Right side is obviously fake.

The weird blur of the beard shading is not right. Forehead skin looks like dirty Naugahide(TM).

Now, one could have photoshopped the "real" side to make it look a little fake and fool people into guessing the wrong side which is CGI :p
 
LOL, I use keyshot at work sometimes, but only for industrial design and single objects... try to do a complex interior scene or ANIMATION and it's severely lacking... but it's a nice fast easy tool for products...

FYI: Blender recently included a GPU accelerated unbiased renderer... it's pretty sweet (for free)... I still think VRAY and some other similar renderers will be used for overall speed... but these tools are QUICKLY becoming simpler and simpler to use, and that's really where the biggest advantage is...
 
If find it hilarious that car sites like http://jalopnik.com Look at pictures of new cars coming out and everybody in the comments and on the website talks about it like it is the real car but it is just a render in 3d studio max based off the autocad data with a .HDRI file applied for the lighting from the sun of a real location.

Many commercials are completely CG too... cars are relatively easy to pull off
 
was going to say the nose looks a little "too dark" inside on the right side, almost like it's a place that doesn't exist, rather than the cavern that is the nostril.
 
Is this something to tell us that we're being lied to?

It seems a step closer to "Looker"
 
If this really completes renders in under 5 minutes that's impressive, otherwise I'm not seeing anything that can't be done in Maxwell, Luxology, any number of other rendering engines.
 
The first pic is fake. There are no boogers in his nose.
 
While there may be no uncanny valley for still images, the fact that it looks so real when not moving will make it more disturbing than ever when someone animates one of those models.
 
Back
Top