HP ZR24w

I love this monitor so far, but I have not played enough to see if there is any serious lag (my main concern, though not a show-stopper for me).

Here are some pics from Dirt 2. The originals were about 6.5MB each, but saving them in jpg format decreased that almost 10-fold. They still show a lot of detail, imo. I can post an original with a size warning, if anyone wants to see it.

Honda

Magazine

Start of Race

Subaru

Subaru Intro

Water

This monitor also fits very well with my two Samsung 20" 1600x1200 monitors and Eyefinity at 4800x1200 is very cool. Not sure my single HD5850 overclocked will handle Dirt2 maxed out yet, but it can certainly handle super-wide spreadsheets and database browsers.

by the way, nobody is going to care how the screencaps look, because they will be the same regardless of what monitor they were taken on.

if you want to reduce the moire pattern of the monitor when taking photographs place the camera on the same plane as the face of the panel (ex: align all horizontals and verticals).
 
I'm still interested in seeing photos of a gray screen to see panel uniformity and of a black screen to see how much backlight bleed there is.
 
bb: what sharpness level are you running at?
Everything is at factory default settings still:

Brightness=90
Color=6500K-sRGB
Contrast=80
Sharpness=4 (out of 5)

I agree with your earlier observation, that the screen seems to run a bit bright, so after I take more pics I may turn that down.

by the way, nobody is going to care how the screencaps look, because they will be the same regardless of what monitor they were taken on.
Except for the boost in resolution given the larger size of the monitor, yes? I also wanted to post some action shots because a few people had asked for them, and those Dirt 2 have DX11 content. (I frequent a gaming forum, and it is much less technically oriented than this one, so again, I am pretty new at much of this.)

So I guess what you are saying is that a screen capture will never show a dead pixel, therefore use a camera.

if you want to reduce the moire pattern of the monitor when taking photographs place the camera on the same plane as the face of the panel (ex: align all horizontals and verticals).
Good to know! Thanks for the info.
Also, after cleaning my camera lens I think may have gotten rid of a dead pixel! ;) :p

I'm still interested in seeing photos of a gray screen to see panel uniformity and of a black screen to see how much backlight bleed there is.
Will do but I am not sure my camera will do it justice. This screen looks great, especially compared to my Samsungs.

To others who are looking for a comparison, I don't have a Dell U2410 (only a 5 year old 2405) upstairs. It's my wife, but unfortunately, not for long since she saw this one. ;)
 
Last edited:
These colors were chosen from Windows 7 Ultimate's screen background colors. So these are "solid color as background" shots with a camera - that definitely has a few dead pixels, as you can see in this first shot, especially in the areas off the monitor:

Color - Black

Color - White

Color - Grey

Color - Blue

Color - Other

Color - Other

Color - Other

Color - Other

Color - Black again, dead camera pixels and all.

I have stared at this all black screen a whole lot - and thankfully there is not a single dead pixel on it.
 
Last edited:
Thanks bb23!
The colour uniformity looks way better than on the Nec EA231WMi. The black level seems impressive as well, though it may look different to the naked eye.
 
Thanks bb23!
The colour uniformity looks way better than on the Nec EA231WMi. The black level seems impressive as well, though it may look different to the naked eye.
You are welcome.
It definitely looks better in person than the images posted here.

Also, I just edited in a grey one a few minutes ago, given your request - in case you looked earlier than the edit.

Edit: In comparing the black background with my Samsung, the Samsung actually looks blacker - but I think the brightness is just set too high by default on this ZR24W. The black is very uniform to my eye though.

Edit2: The Samsung is so black that when I turn it off, it doesn't change much in appearance. However, everything else is much darker on the Samsung too, so obviously they are hard to compare given the settings difference. The colors on the HP are much richer and vibrant looking.
 
Last edited:
These colors were chosen from Windows 7 Ultimate's screen background colors. So these are "solid color as background" shots with a camera - that definitely has a few dead pixels, as you can see in this first shot, especially in the areas off the monitor:

Color - Black

Color - White

Color - Grey

Color - Blue

Color - Other

Color - Other

Color - Other

Color - Other

Color - Black again, dead camera pixels and all.

I have stared at this all black screen a whole lot - and thankfully there is not a single dead pixel on it.

Thanks again, it looks good to me.... especially at $390 shipped from Cost Central.

Now, I just wish they would give me some kind shipping notice and a tracing number for the two ZR24W's I ordered.

EDIT: Cost Central post a tracking number on my account page, I am supposed to get mine on Tuesday. Still no email updates from Cost Central since the original "backorder".... I guess we know how they sell so cheap.... they save money on email.... LOL.
 
This monitor seems like the new best way to escape TN hell without breaking the bank, judging by those pics alone it seems like one of the best bargains of 2010.
 
You are welcome.
It definitely looks better in person than the images posted here.

Also, I just edited in a grey one a few minutes ago, given your request - in case you looked earlier than the edit.

Edit: In comparing the black background with my Samsung, the Samsung actually looks blacker - but I think the brightness is just set too high by default on this ZR24W. The black is very uniform to my eye though.

Edit2: The Samsung is so black that when I turn it off, it doesn't change much in appearance. However, everything else is much darker on the Samsung too, so obviously they are hard to compare given the settings difference. The colors on the HP are much richer and vibrant looking.
The problem with posting a screen cap is that it doesn't show off your monitor. Images will be displayed differently on each monitor, that's the whole purpose of asking people to show photos of the monitor.

What you see on your screen is not what I see on my screen... even if you take a screencap. All that does is save the image. Imagine if I have a digital photo and I displayed it on my a shitty monitor and took a screen cap. It would save the same digital photo despite my monitor displaying it like poo. So when I send it to you it could look better on your monitor.

Here's another example. If you turn your brightness all the down down and your Red all the way up it would look like shit on your end. But if you take a screen capture and send it to me it would like fine on my monitor.

What you are posting in no way shows the strengths and weaknesses of the monitor. The reason people are asking for solid color stills of the screen (black, white, grey) is so they can get an idea of color uniformity.

For example: Black. Two things you can measure.. how black it actually is and if there is any backlight bleed.

White: How bright and solid is the white. Many cameras have trouble with this.

Grey: Many monitors have trouble displaying grey. One of the things people are looking for is color uniformity.

Posting a screenshot of your desktop is no different than downloading any picture off the internet and posting it here for others to view on their monitor.
 
What you are posting in no way shows the strengths and weaknesses of the monitor.

You understand that his last two sets of images were not screen captures but taken with a camera, right?
 
Last edited:
Thanks, sheesh721, for the further clarification about screen captures. As bofors is indicating, the only screen captures I did were the ones from Dirt 2 - all the others, including the Windows Landscapes, Tests, and background colors were done with my old 5 megapixel Canon camera which saved them as they are posted, in jpg-format.

I am very enthusiastic about this monitor, but as you all must know by now, I am not any kind of expert about this.

Most of the camera pics were taken mainly in a dark room with the other monitors off, using only the auto-focus setting on the camera. Only for the Lagom tests for lag did I change the settings to its highest shutter speed of 1/400.

By the way, did those lag test results say anything to anyone?

The monitor on the left is the Samsung, 5ms response time (unknown input lag by me at least), and the HP (also 5ms rated g2g response time) is on the right. I put them in clone mode as instructed by the site. I am wondering if not having the HP at its native resolution (due to clone mode), but at 1600x1200, might affect those results?

Here are some of the Lagom lag test results reposted here:
Lagom Test
Lagom Test
Lagom Test
Lagom Test
Lagom Test

This was probably a shot from a restart of the test:
Lagom Test
 
Last edited:
Ditto on pictures not been a valid way to compare stuff...ideally you'd also have the Dell U2410 to compare against. The different panel sounds promising though...hopefully it won't have the tinge or uneven lighting issue the old HP and Dell U2410 panels had...
 
Thanks, sheesh721, for the further clarification about screen captures. As bofors is indicating, the only screen captures I did were the ones from Dirt 2 - all the others, including the Windows Landscapes, Tests, and background colors were done with my old 5 megapixel Canon camera which saved them as they are posted, in jpg-format.

I am very enthusiastic about this monitor, but as you all must know by now, I am not any kind of expert about this.

Most of the camera pics were taken mainly in a dark room with the other monitors off, using only the auto-focus setting on the camera. Only for the Lagom tests for lag did I change the settings to its highest shutter speed of 1/400.

By the way, did those lag test results say anything to anyone?

The monitor on the left is the Samsung, 5ms response time (unknown input lag by me at least), and the HP (also 5ms rated g2g response time) is on the right. I put them in clone mode as instructed by the site. I am wondering if not having the HP at its native resolution (due to clone mode), but at 1600x1200, might affect those results?

Here are some of the Lagom lag test results reposted here:
Lagom Test
Lagom Test
Lagom Test
Lagom Test
Lagom Test

This was probably a shot from a restart of the test:
Lagom Test
No problem man. I just saw your initial post and the rude comments in return and thought I would explain why everyone was acting so immature towards you. I didn't actually finish reading the thread. Good job with the additional pics;)
 
I ordered one...a month or so ago I was about to pull the trigger and get the Dell U2410, saw this thread and decided to wait.

Hopefully it doesn't disappoint...I got to play with 4x28" HannsG config at work and was thoroughly impressed...but I'm coming off of a 17" Viewsonic VP171B that is like 5+ years old.

This HP should make my computer feel brand new again. Real interested to see how well it works with SolidWorks.
 
Just been digging around trying to put bb23's input lag screenshots into context (cheers loads for posting them buddy - a lot of people *are* very grateful, so ignore the whiners!).

According to those screen grabs, am I right in interpreting the HP to have similar but slightly faster lag (some of the screenshots look almost the same, and others appear to be ~10ms faster, ie the stopwatch on the ZR24w has reached a higher number than the 204B. But I'm not sure I'm interpreting this right from the screenshots) than the Samsung 204B he's comparing it against?

Anyway, if my interpretation is right, I found a post on this forum http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?p=1029433265 with someone measuring about 35-40ms input lag for the Samsung 204B compared to a CRT. So by comparison it looks like the HP probably has less than 35-40ms input lag.
The greatest difference between the two screens looks ~10ms (difficult to tell!) which would put the ZR24w roughly the same as the HP LP2475W input lag of 25ms (according to tftcentral, which would make sense if the ZR24w is replacing it.

Looking at the tftcentral review for the Dell U2410 http://www.tftcentral.co.uk/reviews/content/dell_u2410.htm it has input lag of 33.8ms in normal mode, and 14.4ms in gaming mode.

So... this seems to indicate that the ZR24w has input lag faster than the U2410 in its normal modes, but slower than the U2410's gaming mode. Does the ZR24w have a gaming mode like the U2410 to reduce the input lag? I'd be grateful if someone else who's more familiar with the Lagom testing and screenshot comparison could have a look at the above screengrabs and web links to confirm this preliminary conclusion.

Pete.
 
Last edited:
Thanks for those links, Pete. I mentioned several pages back that input lag may be an issue with this screen because I read somewhere it is an issue for IPS screens in general. (Don't know if this is true, I just remember reading it somewhere.) This is not a show-stopper for me, but I have mentioned it here because it may be for others.

Currently, I am on my "bare" gaming computer and don't even have Adobe reader installed yet, so here is the link to the manual I posted a few pages back. I don't remember a Gaming mode option and have not seen one in the OSD options.

http://h20000.www2.hp.com/bc/docs/s...c02049456/c02049456.pdf?jumpid=reg_R1002_USEN

I will try Dirt 2 for a while longer and see if it seems the same as the Samsung - my initial impression is that it is similar (like Chris also mentioned in terms of a 30ms lag). Not sure if a Thrustmaster steering wheel (mid-priced around $130) qualifies like a gaming mouse, but I will at least post my subjective findings. Dirt 2 does require very fast responses at times.
 
In case anyone read my ramblings about input lag above, I suggest re-reading it because I have seriously edited it since first posting it, with my conclusions radically changed (based on my stupidity at intepreting results) ! :D

Also, I noticed that the (UK) Lambdatek website listing for the ZR24w (not in stock or pre-order'able yet) has gone down from £309 to £291 overnight, which would make this monitor a bargain in comparison to the U2410 (in the UK).

Pete.
 
bb23, thanks for the pics. I was loling last night though when you posted screen caps. Started to bust your balls for it but decided not too :p

Looks like it has some slight banding on the gray screen, but nothing as bad as a lot of others one out there. All the other colors look great. Looks to have little backlight bleed. If any, it just appears uniform across the bottom.
 
Sorry if these questions were asked before, but I haven't seen any answers so far:

1.) In the specification sheet, I see that the monitor supports 1600x1200 resolution. If you enable that resolution, is it stretched or is viewable 1:1 with black bars on the side?
2.) How's the anti-glare coating of this screen? With the Dell U2410, people complain that the anti-glare coating is 'grainy' and 'dirty'. How's it compared to that screen?
 
What you say sounds right based on what the site said in their example:

"If the highest frame numbers were different, e.g. [39] (top) and [41] (bottom), it would mean that the top screen is the one with most input lag; more accurately: 2×16.67 = 33.3 ms."

Though most of the screenshots I took showed almost identical counters, this one shows something very similar to the site's example I just quoted.

http://allphasesoftware.com/OB/SS/Misc_ZR24W/IMG_7739.jpg

I assume that is the one you are also noting in your analysis, Pete.
 
Those lag photos are no good for analysis. Using an inaccurate JavaScript timer in one part of the screen in clone mode with a slow shutter speed is every possible problem at once. You can't get accurate results that way.

Use this program: http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1423433

When using clone mode, one monitor will tear. Wait for the tearing to roll off the screen, then take a picture. That will give you much more accurate results.
 
Yes, that's the one with the greater difference. It's hard to tell though because the 30 is more distinct, but there's still a 28 visible in the background. Does the counter step up 2 at a time?

Pete.
 
bb23, thanks for the pics. I was loling last night though when you posted screen caps. Started to bust your balls for it but decided not too :p
LOL.

*Ahem* someone asked for pics of Crysis, so I figured they wanted a screenshot of ingame play. Plus I was looking for an excuse to post Dirt 2 shots anyway because technical stuff is what I gotta do all day long albeit in different areas. (Okay, I didn't know that about screenshooting vs. camera shooting...)

But most importantly, how do you know I have balls? I could be some very hot chick, you know.

Okay, I am just busting your balls a bit... :p ;)

So I am not a hot chick. But let's just say I am old enough to have seen every iteration of DOS and owned an IBM XT, and paid $3500 for my first laptop in 1986... so go easy. It is great to be old - I can always plead senility!
 
bb23: re:balls, you did mention your wife earlier! Although in these modern times, that could be quite ambiguous as to your sex! :)
ToastyX: thanks for posting that link for more accurate testing of input lag.

Pete.
 
Those lag photos are no good for analysis. Using an inaccurate JavaScript timer in one part of the screen in clone mode with a slow shutter speed is every possible problem at once. You can't get accurate results that way.

Use this program: http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1423433

When using clone mode, one monitor will tear. Wait for the tearing to roll off the screen, then take a picture. That will give you much more accurate results.
I looked at this yesterday, and didn't have time to get into it. I assume that it does not mess with any voltage settings, or anything like that, right? In other words, a dumb question - could those tests hurt the monitor in any way?

Haha, re:balls, you did mention your wife earlier! Although in these modern times, that could be quite ambiguous as to your sex! :)

Pete.
Hahaha! You are right. I plead senility!
 
All that program does is display moving vertical bars. It doesn't affect the monitor.
 
All that program does is display moving vertical bars. It doesn't affect the monitor.
Okay, thanks. I will look to get into this tonight or tomorrow, as I have some other stuff I gotta do this afternoon.

(It doesn't affect the monitor, though it may provoke seizures... Well, as long as my equipment is safe, that is all I care about. :p )
 
[X]eltic;1035513284 said:
bb23, if you enable 1600x1200, how is that displayed? Stretched or 1:1?
It fills the whole screen. For instance, I have Eyefinity going across the three screens (with the HP in the middle) and a Samsung 204B (native 1600x1200) on each side, and the resolution is 4800x1200. It lines up pretty nicely but not perfectly. Am still tinkering, so will let you know if I find something else out. hth.

Edit: The OSD does have a "Fill to Aspect Ratio" option that may allow flexibility here.
 
Hmm, that's disappointing. I was hoping it would display that resolution 1:1 with black bars on the sides. Are you sure there is no 1:1 in the menu?
 
When I put on the Fill to Aspect Ratio, two wide black vertical bars appear - one on each side.

There is only Fill To Screen, Fill to Aspect Ratio, and Overscan as the 3 options under Image control -> Custom Scaling.

Probably the manual will give you more detail. The link is a few posts up.
 
Thanks about the manual link, didn't see it. I guess 'Fill to Aspect Ratio' is what I am looking for. I assume the image is still crystal clear if you use that? No blur?

EDIT: Oh, and btw, how's the anti-glare coating? As said before, some people complained about the Dell U2410 screen coating, saying it was 'dirty' looking and 'grainy'. How does it compare to your Samsung 204B?
 
Last edited:
It looks good at first glance, but I can do a better compare a bit later. Gotta run.
 
[X]eltic;1035513433 said:
Thanks about the manual link, didn't see it. I guess 'Fill to Aspect Ratio' is what I am looking for. I assume the image is still crystal clear if you use that? No blur?

EDIT: Oh, and btw, how's the anti-glare coating? As said before, some people complained about the Dell U2410 screen coating, saying it was 'dirty' looking and 'grainy'. How does it compare to your Samsung 204B?

"Fill to aspect ratio" probably stretches the picture without changing the aspect ratio. It's not the same as 1:1.
Ati's and Nvidia's graphics drivers provide a 1:1 option anyway. Having it on the monitor is only useful with other sources than a computer.
 
Yeah, it's not entirely the same, but since the screen has a vertical height of 1200 pixels, and the resolution of 1600x1200 has a vertical height of 1200 pixels as well, it should give the same effect as 1:1. My current graphics card doesn't allow 1:1 with a software setting. At least, I haven't found any option in the ATI CCC that allows me to do it.
 
I'm trying to decide which one to get. HP or Dell U2410 what ever one has less of a grainy screen gets my money
 
Back
Top