How hard is it to build a server?

kevineugenius

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Dec 9, 2006
Messages
1,415
Basically, I can build desktops for home/office users, gamers, hardcore, entry, whatever. I can do laptops, I can do networks, I can do wireless, bla bla bla. One thing I'm kinda scared of is servers. I put together a bunch of parts on newegg (I already have SBS 2003, got from M$ for free) so with all the parts and the software, its about $4000... For $4000 elsewhere, the specs are like 1/10th what I put together.

I got dual quad-core, 8gb RAM, 3tb HD, 104gb backup, 400+400 redundant PSU, a large tower case (server cases are really expensive... why?)... On ebay, for $4000 you get maybe dual dual-core, more likely dual single-core xeon, 2gb RAM, small single HD, no backup...

My first attempt at selections https://secure.newegg.com/NewVersio...p?WishListNumber=5101412&WishListTitle=server

So, what are things I need to watch for? I know that the PSU is probably going to be one major thing, but the case I picked looks like it has the right cutout for it. Also, the quad-core Xeons said active and passive on them... Does that just mean one comes with a fan and heatsink, one comes with heatsink only? Why would anyone want a quad-core with no fan? Seems risky to me... With SATA2, is there any reason to spend gajillions of dollars on 10k or SCSI hard drives? What operating systems are good alternatives to SBS 20003? There must be tons of Linux server options...
 
What are you planning to do with this $4000 server?
 
Some questions that your post didn't mention that would help others answer:

What are you serving? Applications? Database Queries? Kerberos Keys? Burritos? Stolen, er, uh "shared", mp3's? Streaming videos of mimes re-enacting Star Trek Episodes originally broadcast in Turkish? Windows Terminal Services?

How many simultaneous requests do you expect? Millions? Hundreds? Four?

How many clients does your Server 2003 license support? Which version is it? Enterprise? Data Center? Web? Standard?

What is your available electrical power? 20 Amp service at 240 volts? 12 V DC at 200 mA?

What will you be using for a physical layer network connection? Fiber? 802.11n Draft 2? Token Ring?

---

Without knowing any of those, my first impulse is to suggest using the lowest power consuming/heat emitting central processor you can stand, and offload as much of the work as possible into dedicated hardware, be it controllers, ssl accelerators, or fat clients.
 
Honestly, I don't even want one. But, I do advertise myself as a system builder on craigslist and whatnot, and I've had a few people ask about servers and I turned them down. The 1 server I do have was a Dell, and it works fine... Runs like SQL server and that's about it. So, I'm afraid I can't answer all of those questions, and from the amount of questions raised, I'd say I have a lot of reading to do?
 
I'd suggest you study the spec of the ML370 - a pretty standard server rig.

generally they (servers in general) have much higher L2 cache - which is a big price difference.
 
I should also mention that my build doesn't really reflect what I think people should "need". It's more of an example of home built getting way more for the money.
 
Yeah, the biggest watchouts are

1) Make sure you get a server case that will fit an EATX motherboard

2) PSU - make sure you get one with enough power (people on 2cpu.com recommend a 750w or a 1000w power supply. Not too many people go with redundant though). Also make sure it has the 24 pin + 8 pin power cables to avoid the hassle of buying converters.

3) Although SATA2 drives will work fine, if you truly want a server, you'll want to go SCSI due to the synchronous data transfer.

I just put together my main rig, which could be classified as a "server" about a month ago. Wasn't too hard to build.
 
Server = two rigs ago, if there aren't many users.

If you have serious traffic / uptime concerns, it gets more complicated, sometimes much more complicated, until you start running into clusters of servers. It really depends what it's for. Web != database != file != domain != accounting != appshare != computational != rendering != et cetera.

With servers that anyone gives a rats ass about, Dell is often the Best Solution (for any shop that has to bother to ask) even if it costs more or isn't quite as fast as you could custom build (although if you wave enough $$ I'm sure they'll get pretty custom). Support is where it's at, having an entire system cross-shipped overnight (or faster) to replace yours instead of having to troubleshoot it while downtime builds up can be invaluable.
 
We bought Dell the last two servers we've had, and I'm unimpressed. We paid extra for "rush shipping" (it would be shipped that day) and overnight because our first Dell burnt up. So, it didn't arrive until the third day. I called to complain and at least get my extra shipping money back, and three different guys down there said "we dont have any rush options, I dont see how they charged that". I called them, they called me back, himhaw whatever for 3 months, then I gave up. Was about $3500 total, and it's not really that beefy of a system. It overheats nonstop, the power button broke (have to reach in the front panel with a paper clip). It is definately much nicer than our last one, but I don't see why they cost so much money.
 
Back
Top