How Facebook Could Get You Arrested

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
How Facebook could get you arrested. Well, not counting the fact that you should be arrested just for using Facebook. :D

The police are also finding powerful allies in Silicon Valley. Companies such as Facebook have begun using algorithms and historical data to predict which of their users might commit crimes using their services. Here is how it works: Facebook's own predictive systems can flag certain users as suspicious by studying certain behavioural cues: the user only writes messages to others under 18; most of the user's contacts are female; the user is typing keywords like "sex" or "date." Staffers can then examine each case and report users to the police as necessary. Facebook's concern with its own brand here is straightforward: no one should think that the platform is harbouring criminals.
 
Facebook is acting as an agent of the state. That means that they are bound by the fourth amendment.
 
It implies if you look @ a bunch of bitches online, are attracted to the numerous 16 year olds with better bodies than 30 year olds that pose half naked on fb for attention, have no friends, and google sex facebook is basically going to flag you as a potential rapist, fwd that assumption the state and authorities and you'll be guilty until the public pretender finds you innocent. It means America's digital frontier is moving towards a marxist socialism basically.
 
It implies if you look @ a bunch of bitches online, are attracted to the numerous 16 year olds with better bodies than 30 year olds that pose half naked on fb for attention, have no friends, and google sex facebook is basically going to flag you as a potential rapist, fwd that assumption the state and authorities and you'll be guilty until the public pretender finds you innocent. It means America's digital frontier is moving towards a marxist socialism basically.

That's nothing close to what I was expecting in regards to the 4th Ammendment.
 
Facebook is acting as an agent of the state. That means that they are bound by the fourth amendment.

Not really ... even if FB works in collusion with "The State" they are still a private company and your interaction with them (including privacy) is regulated by the "terms and conditions" of the service agreement that none of us using online services ever read

That said, I think any private organization (including FB) should be very cautious about passing unsolicitated information to a government police body (whether in the USA or anywhere else) ... I would prefer they flag you as a violator of their service policies (unless there is something blatently wrong) and drop you from the service rather than passing your info to a police group who hasn't requested it
 
Facebook is acting as an agent of the state. That means that they are bound by the fourth amendment.

As usual, you're wrong. They are a private organization and they can do with that information as they please. Users have agreed to the terms of service for using their website. The 4th Amendment restricts the Federal Government's power over the citizenry which in this case the government is not going after the citizenry but rather Facebook informing the government of a possible issue. The information that the government decides to do with, it is still bounded by the 4th Amendment as well as the whole criminal process has to be done properly still.
 
It implies if you look @ a bunch of bitches online, are attracted to the numerous 16 year olds with better bodies than 30 year olds that pose half naked on fb for attention, have no friends, and google sex facebook is basically going to flag you as a potential rapist, fwd that assumption the state and authorities and you'll be guilty until the public pretender finds you innocent. It means America's digital frontier is moving towards a marxist socialism basically.

Which this has nothing to do with the 4th Amendment but rather how many layers of tinfoil you've used in your hat.
 
LOL I immediately started thinking about "pre-crime" from Minority Report. FB knows what you're doing to do before you do it apparently.
 
What girls like is when you go through their entire photo album and one by one like each photo. Do that at about 3am.
 
It should just be for college students again. But since that will never happen...

If John Doe or Jane Smith opts out of FB, can an enemy create a profile for him and PM kids lewd messages until he/she gets flagged?

Why don't they just block the message and "protect" the kids?

And will a 18 year-old get flagged for doing this with a 17 year-old?
 
Now I want to get flagged! "Achievement Unlocked".

How could they prosecute? If the law gets involved, there is no crime to prosecute for. Facebook could drop you from service, but that's it.
 
It all seems too easy and logical; who wouldn't want to prevent crime before it happens?

If you read this part of the article you begin to see the motivation. Remember that line out of the matrix?

"I see you before me and you have no why, no power"

How could they prosecute? If the law gets involved, there is no crime to prosecute for. Facebook could drop you from service, but that's it.

Maybe they can't, maybe it's just enough that they can justify initiating surveillance. Perhaps as they watch you they will discover a crime but because they have no proof yet, they just keep watching and cataloging your minor transgressions. Perhaps after the standard one-month time limit they decide that your 57 counts of jaywalking are worth issuing citations for at $250 a piece that comes to $14,250 USD for the city of wherever, USA.

They are the same people, the ones who want to take the guns, eliminate violent movies and video games, stop crime before it happens. They are the "We want to make a better world" people.

Remember Serenity?
 
GUILTY! You are under arrest for crimes you will be thinking of committing!!!

So what if you have a tendency to play GTA V or any open world game where the objective is to complete missions that require criminal behavior. Furthermore, what if you get all the achievements for every crime that has an achievement for? Does that throw off the algorithm?
 
Stop overthinking this. Facebook only can turn over information. The criminal process must go through the same process from charges to arrest to trial. There is no 4th Amendment violation because Facebook has the right to use your information as they see fit in their terms of service. It's no different than saying "Hey cops, I see a robbery in progress across the street."
 
It's no different than saying "Hey cops, I see a robbery in progress across the street."

Actually, it is. It's like saying "I think this guy is going to commit a crime, because he said Miley Cyrus was hot before she turned 18.".

If they were discussing a crime that was already committed or in progress of being committed, I can understand. But, by guessing they will based on some algorithm? I don't see it going far.
 
Back
Top