High End 22" or Bargain 24"

woody1175

n00b
Joined
Mar 22, 2008
Messages
13
Right now, I am budgeting about $350 for a new LCD. With prices the way they are, I can get a 22 or a 24. I want a nice picture (using 19" Samsung 915N now) with high resolution (1280x1024 max now). My wife just got a Dell SP2208WFP and it looks great. Do some of the bargain brand 24" do as well at gaming? The BenQ or Soyo seem to have decent reviews and I was leaning that way or towards a LG 22".

Any input is appreciated and I am just looking to see if these 24" are good for gaming.
 
ALL the 22" are TN panels...pure and complete CRAP!! and some of the bargain 24" are PVA panels = better colors viewing angles and (in the case of the soyo) fats enough panels.

Go for the westinghouse or Soyo if u want a non-TN panel or pick up ANY 24" bargain over a 22" "top"!
 
save up a little more and look at the hanns-g 28" i'm still in awe after 3 months. 1080p/game/SDTV. everything looks awesome. but i'm not a videosnob so i cant tell the difference between the different panels anyway.
 
Lenovo L220x is a S-PVA 22 inch panel if you want to go for that. It's a bit scarce and it costs around 450 if you want to spend that much. Also includes 1900x1200 res as well
 
Eizo S2231W is another non-TN 22" display. Uses the latest S-PVA from Samsung and it apparently wipes the floor with everything else according to: http://prad.de/en/monitore/review/2008/review-eizo-s2231w.html

It is a bit more expensive than the Lenovo, and considerably more than everything else 22" but imo its worth it over TN. But at ~$800 it might be worth it to bump up to a high end 24" IPS or S-PVA.
 
I have a Dell SP2208WFP. Doesn't look bad at all. Actually, it looks pretty good. I don't know why people say these TN monitors are "crap". Maybe some are, but not all of them.

Seems like people are just spewing out what they've read or heard others saying, without actually having used one.
 
ALL the 22" are TN panels...pure and complete CRAP!! and some of the bargain 24" are PVA panels = better colors viewing angles and (in the case of the soyo) fats enough panels.

Go for the westinghouse or Soyo if u want a non-TN panel or pick up ANY 24" bargain over a 22" "top"!

Angles don't mean anything when he specifically said game, to say they are pure and complete crap is nothing but asinine.

TN panels are typically great at gaming, though this is just an opinion of a hardcore gamer.


edit: I also prefer to play at 1680x1050 rather than 1920x1200
 
Seems like people are just spewing out what they've read or heard others saying, without actually having used one.

I've used many and would prob say they definitely leave allot to be desired. Some are allot better than others though and without photoshop or high res gaming I'd use one. Narrow blanket opinions on TNs and *VAs are common here so get used to it.
 
i just went from a 22" to the cheap soyo 24", i'm extremely happy with the upgrade. when it comes to gaming monitors these days, real estate is king. the bigger you can afford the better. with gaming, angles aren't a concern and generally speaking ghosting and old complaints of lcd's are gone. bigger is better.
 
i just went from a 22" to the cheap soyo 24", i'm extremely happy with the upgrade. when it comes to gaming monitors these days, real estate is king. the bigger you can afford the better. with gaming, angles aren't a concern and generally speaking ghosting and old complaints of lcd's are gone. bigger is better.

I would rather not be forced to play at a resolution some games will not run at 90fps+

smooth>size ^_^
 
Not that it matters since there is not difference on an LCD except massive tearing.

Well uberbobover9000, I guess I should have said max frames. Because I can't tell the difference between 150 and 125 on a game unless 150 is the max. Because it always feels the same way. In the case of the current game I play 91frames is max. If it's not that I can tell you immediately. This applies to my lcd or my 24" crt.
 
Back
Top