help with old PC

speedlever

Limp Gawd
Joined
Sep 29, 2006
Messages
447
I have an old PC (replaced with a new C2D build) that I'm trying to rework for other uses around the house. I bought an additional Vista license to use on it.

Specs are:
Asus P4S533 mobo with BIOS 1010 beta 5
1.5 Gb ram (3x512 Mb sticks PC2700 DDR)
EVGA 6600GT AGP
1.8GHz P4 Northwood running at 2.4 GHz
60 Gb Seagate drive

I had XP home on it but it had become somewhat unreliable with random BSODs for various reasons I never could tie down. Some errors I saw were:
page_fault_in_nonpaged_area
IRQ_not_less_or_equal_to
bad_pool_caller
bad_pool_header

I've run memtest 86+ for serveral hours with no memory errors found.

Thinking I had driver issues, I decided to put Vista on it. I yanked all the pci cards, leaving the AGP video card installed, formatted the HD and installed Vista clean (using an update DVD). The first install went well, but the 2nd install fails (where I enter my key) with either a BSOD or I get a msg saying Windows found an unexpected error... and terminates the install. I've tried 4 or 5 times with some variation of the failures mentioned above.

Once I got a memory management error from a BSOD. Another time I think I saw something about a driver overrun... but the BSOD booted away before I could read it all.

So I ran Memtest 86+ again for 3+ hours with 0 errors found.

I am currently formatting the HD again and am going back to XP at the moment to see if I can get that cleanly installed.

One other thing... I see some hardware failures detected during boot... check HW monitor for details. I check it in BIOS and find nothing except a low fan speed BIOS doesn't seem to like. I tell it to ignore and it seems ok for a while. The PSU is about a year old Fortron unit that replaced an old Antec 300w PSU. I have no reason to suspect it is bad.

Before I could complete this post, the computer had another BSOD during the XP load process. Nothing in the BSOD to tell me why it crashed.

Any suggestions how to smoke out the issue(s) I'm running into on the old PC?
 
Update: the XP install failed with the following system setup log error msg:
*************************************
Error:
Iinstallation failed: D:\i386\asms. Error message: The parameter is incorrect.

Fatal error:
One of the components that Windows needs to continue setup could not be installed. The parameter is incorrect.
*********************************

How can I find the problem?
 
Try a different DVDROM drive, maybe. You could also try clearing the CMOS, then go in to BIOS and clear the ESCD (or something similar to that, anyway, may have misspelled) data, which is the PCI IRQ autoconfig data. Reset BIOS to defaults, reboot, enable only what you need to get through the install process for Windows -- no onboard anything but IDE and maybe SATA, more than likely. Then try to install. If it still BSODs, buy a cheap board that'll take that hardware, I think it's dying on you. Might consider booting it with the PSU from your C2D machine just to rule that out, though I agree, doesn't sound like a power problem, more an IRQ or failing motherboard problem.

And clean / scratch-check your install discs.
 
I can only echo silent-circuit's comments and add that a lot of these types or problems can never really be tied down, the simple and obvious suggestion to check your windows cd is free of marks, scratches etc is a good one.

The most likely suspects are dodgy dvd/cd-rom, power supply (fluctuations), failing hardrive and mobo, in that order. Though don't rule out vid card and ram incompatabilities, i've had ram in the past that ran memtest fine, yet the mobo just didn't like the RAM for some reason and i had to ship it (pny ram).

Sorry i can be of more help.
 
May i suggest getting new ide cables and zero filling the hard disk (dban) to get rid of any truncated data or file system error?
 
silent-circuit said:
Try a different DVDROM drive

Alas, I do not have another DVD drive. This one is brand new... bought specifically to do the Vista install. Phillips SPD2413BD.

I think I will clear the CMOS and reset the BIOS. There may be a later BIOS for this old board too. 1011, I think. No SATA on this board either.

I was having some random reboots a long time back... changed the PSU thinking that might help... but it didn't. So whatever is wrong has been there for a while.

And clean / scratch-check your install discs
Anyway, I've used the XP install CD's format routine to format several times. I'm comfortable that the XP and Vista discs are good.

zombiebeat said:
the mobo just didn't like the RAM for some reason
Now the 3 sticks of RAM could be a question... all different brands, but all PC2700/DDR333:
Mushkin
Kingston
PQI (bought just for Vista)

OldMX said:
zero filling the hard disk (dban) to get rid of any truncated data or file system error

Does DBAN run from a floppy? Would file system errors survive multiple formats?

I thought about trying to get updated chipset drivers... but there's not much there for Vista w/r/t SiS645DX chipset. IDE cables would be cheap enough to replace.... may be a thought there.

I've replaced every component in this old PC except for the floppy drive at some point or other... well also except for the cables.

It may be worth it to get a mobo that will take the DDR RAM and replace the processor too with a more modern but inexpensive CPU. I just wish I could narrow down the problem issue so I don't end up just throwing money at it in a vain attempt to salvage the box.
 
Not necessarily suggesting it as the thing looks frankensteined together, but...

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16813157107
ASRock 4CoreDual-VSTA LGA 775 VIA PT880 Ultra ATX Intel Motherboard - Retail - $60
(there's an open-box of the same board for $40 I think)
+
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?item=N82E16819115013
Intel Core 2 Duo E4300 Allendale 1.8GHz 2M shared L2 Cache LGA 775 Processor - Retail $115

= $175.

You can only use 2 sticks of DDR in that board, and it has 2 DDR2 slots as well. Truly strange beast, but it's hard to find AGP-compatible C2D boards that aren't micro-ATX and thusly only 2 slots of RAM, or all DDR2. (Tried AMD socket AM2, no luck there at all)

It would be an odd little thing. Probably should ask around here before buying that motherboard.
 
Now the 3 sticks of RAM could be a question... all different brands, but all PC2700/DDR333:
Mushkin
Kingston
PQI (bought just for Vista)

Have you tried running Memtest+ on each stick of RAM separately? You may have just one bad stick but the two other good ones are covering up for it. So to fully rule out any RAM problem, run Memtest+ on each stick of RAM for 24 hours EACH. At least do this before going out and buying a new board,.
 
Yeah, I should call this FrankenPC or something. Then again, what's a custom PC except selected components put together. Heheh. That's how I built my C2D system too.

Yes... that Asrock is an odd board with the mix of ddr and ddr2 ram. I'll put that in the back as a possible option if all else fails.

I didn't know Memtest could be fooled by multiple sticks of ram.

OK, I cleared the CMOS and yanked all but one stick of RAM and am testing it now. This could take a while.

Separately, in the P4S533 manual, there's something on page 17 that says the board only supports 4 banks of PC2700 ram. But there are only 3 DIMM sockets on the mobo. Page 18 says you can install any combination up to 1 Gb in each of the 3 sockets.

This thread seems to indicate that each slot is two banks. And yet when I have all 3 slots populated with 512mb of PC2700 ram, the system sees 1.5 gb ram. Not sure what this is all about.

Wish I could find an online guide to setting the BIOS on the old P4S533. No luck thus far
googling it.

Here's pdf of the P4S533 user guide:
http://www.unitycorp.co.jp/support/download/manual/478/p4s533_e.pdf
 
Also, wasn't thinking about this at the time, but if you aren't going to be gaming on this machine much once it's back up and are willing to lose Aero in Vista, you could go with one of the inexpensive (~$40-50) micro-ATX boards with integrated graphics (I saw an MSI with a 6150(?) integrated) but you're still going to run in to the "only 2 RAM slots" issue, so... hmm....
 
After 4+ hours and 14 runs with 0 errors, I yanked that ram (PQI) and stuck another one in. We'll see how this one fares.

It shouldn't matter which DIMM slot I use, should it?

Edit: actually, the kids will be using it to game on. So I want to stick with the 6600GT card.
 
So pull 1 stick and install, see if it gets through. If it does, you need to replace the board with one compatible with running all of your RAM at once. Seems clear enough, if unfortunate.
 
Well... still testing the ram, one stick at a time. Have 1+ hours on the Kingston ram... 3 passes, 0 errors.
 
Update: spent 2.5 hours on the phone with MS support trying to get Vista activated. No luck. I finally disabled the video driver (that Vista installed) and managed to finish the 2nd Vista install with keys and activation.

I tested each stick of RAM individually, never saw any errors. I ran a chkdsk on the drive: no errors. I also tried to run: sfc /scannow but didn't see any activity. I think this works in Vista.

Looking at the system logs, I see an event a couple of hours ago:
Machine Check Event reported is a fatal memory hierarchy error.
Transaction type 2
Memory Hierarchy Level:1
Request Type:8
Address: 26547840

Source: Kernel-WHEA
Event ID:6

Googling the above error, I didn't see much. EventID.net had nothing on it.

And yet, the system seems to be running ok... sorta. One odd thing, the user ID I put in for a user account is there, but the system boots right to the desktop. Not sure what to make of that.

Also, I just tried to restart the system to effect a change in the computer name and got a BSOD - Memory management. I've seen that several times.

Another BSOD I've seen is: a driver has overrun a stack-based buffer.

And, a couple of times during the reboot, I see this msg:
Primary master drive fails. (and yet chkdsk shows nothing)

Any more thoughts what to look for?

BTW, I left all 3 sticks of PC2700 RAM in the machine. Maybe I should pull one out since I may have a mobo issue with exceeding 4 banks of PC2700 ram, although the system recognizes all of it.
 
About your hard drive, google, download, burn and run Drive Fitness Test. Run it and see if your hard drive isn't dying or anything.

Also, what PSU are you using to power this PC?
 
Pull one stick. It's clearly not addressing some of your memory properly. I'd do it now, and hope it hasn't written garbage to disk at some point already due to this.
 
silent-circuit,

I meant to yank a stick but forgot... and... just didn't want to give up that ram anyway!

So I just pulled a stick, cranked up the PC and immediately got:
a driver has overrun a stack-based buffer
followed by:
Primary master drive fails

Give it the 3-finger salute and tell it to boot normally, and all boots right to the log on screen... perhaps a bit slower.

Running the DFT now. It passed the quick test.

More later..
 
Xeth,

I believe everything is at stock. I changed the CPU back to 1.8GHz earlier. I think that was the only thing out of stock. Vcore changed to auto (from 1.6v).

Anything else I missed?
 
Running with just 2 sticks of RAM now (1 Gig). Just had a BSOD with memory_management as the fault. I restarted the system and got a Primay Master disk fails msg. I did a ctrl-alt-delete and restarted again, chose boot normally and it starts right to my Vista log-on screen.

With the HD having passed chkdsk and drive fitness test, any clues where to look next? Should I change out the HD and reinstall Vista once again? Is this likely a mobo issue? Maybe CPU?

I'm stumped as to where to look next.
 
Was running Orthos to stress the system and see what would happen. Orthos stopped after a few minutes with a rounding error. I restarted Orthos and left if for about 30 minutes. Came back to find a BSOD with IRQL_NOT_LESS_OR_EQUAL error. MS says that's indicative of a driver issue.

The only drivers on here are the ones Vista installed.

Current config:
P4 1.8 running at 1.8
512Mb ram (one stick)
60 Gb Seagate
Fortron 450 watt PSU
6600GT with only Vista drivers
Vista Home Premium

Is what MS told me true?

Back to the system, I restarted... got the familiar drive fail indication... 3 finger salute and back to Vista logon screen.

Am running Memtest 86+ again... just to see what happens... and on the first pass (of ram that's already been tested... my newest ram) I have 2 errors already showing at test 5.

This system is jinxed!
 
I'm starting to think it's that motherboard, or at very least the motherboard/RAM combination. Which... isn't really great news, I realize.
 
Well thats means you have a RAM problem then if errors show up. So which stick is the culprit?
 
I ran memtest86+ for 2:26 and the new stick (PQI) showed 74 errors in 8 passes.

This is really odd since the tests I ran yesterday showed no errors on this stick. I put my original stick of Mushkin back in an am running Memtest86+ on it now... again.

I have Memtest86+ v1.65 which is the latest afaik.

And if it's the mobo... so be it. At least I'll know what the culprit is. I hate to buy more ram or another processor and still find the same errors. All the caps look healthy on the mobo... but that's not a very good assessment of the board itself.

It's always been behind a UPS, so I have no reason to think it's ever been damaged by a surge or power issue.

Right now it looks like the vote is split between mobo and ram. ;-)

(what do you bet if I put the PQI ram back in and test again that it would pass?)
 
It's most likely the motherboard if you're getting weird errors like that. If you have another system you can test the memory in, I'd try it there and see what happens. Luck!
 
That sounds logical since the memory tests were all good yesterday. I ran the Vista memory tests too, fwiw... no errors.

Right now, the Mushkin has 27+ minutes into it and no errors through pass 1 and test 6 on pass 2.

I think I'll start looking for an AGP/mobo and not worry too much about saving the DDR ram, unless I can find something that'll take it too. I'd rather save the AGP 6600gt than the ram, methinks.

All my custom computers have always used Asus mobos. I'm not a fanboy, but that's just what I've used. I'm open to other quality boards. Any Intel boards out that will handle my AGP/DDR combo? I ASSUME the CPU is still good... but could it even be that?

I believe the P4/Northwood is a socket 478 chip.

Yeah, I know there's that oddball board that silent-circuit mentioned early on. Not sure if I want to go that route or not... I think I'd rather stay more conventional, if possible.

As an aside, my new C2D is a quiet running machine. Interestingly, the old P4 quieted down some when I replaced an intake fan with a Nexus 80mm case fan... and then really quieted down when I removed the PCI board in the slot next to the 6600GT. Still no comparison to the new C2D machine though (which runs an Asus Tri-cool on low, dual 92mm Nexus intake fans and a Noctua NH-U12F cooler with the 120mm Noctua fan and ULN adapter).
 
Hmm. Put the new stick of ram back in (PQI) and memtest has lots of failures on it. I am a bit surprised at this.

I give up. I'm taking this turkey into the shop and will let them diagnose it for $50.
 
Yeah, I plan to RMA it... but I'm gonna let the local shop diagnose everything and see if they confirm it.

Still, the box was giving me memory-management and IRQL BSODs with Mushkin ram that checked good.

It's jinxed, I tell ya.
 
That sounds logical since the memory tests were all good yesterday. I ran the Vista memory tests too, fwiw... no errors.

Right now, the Mushkin has 27+ minutes into it and no errors through pass 1 and test 6 on pass 2.

I think I'll start looking for an AGP/mobo and not worry too much about saving the DDR ram, unless I can find something that'll take it too. I'd rather save the AGP 6600gt than the ram, methinks.

All my custom computers have always used Asus mobos. I'm not a fanboy, but that's just what I've used. I'm open to other quality boards. Any Intel boards out that will handle my AGP/DDR combo? I ASSUME the CPU is still good... but could it even be that?

I believe the P4/Northwood is a socket 478 chip.

Yeah, I know there's that oddball board that silent-circuit mentioned early on. Not sure if I want to go that route or not... I think I'd rather stay more conventional, if possible.

As an aside, my new C2D is a quiet running machine. Interestingly, the old P4 quieted down some when I replaced an intake fan with a Nexus 80mm case fan... and then really quieted down when I removed the PCI board in the slot next to the 6600GT. Still no comparison to the new C2D machine though (which runs an Asus Tri-cool on low, dual 92mm Nexus intake fans and a Noctua NH-U12F cooler with the 120mm Noctua fan and ULN adapter).

You can get this ASUS mobo from ZipZoomFly. Kind of expensive now since it's sort of rare to find, but it accepts LGA775, DDR and AGP. It also accepts Core2Duo chips, you could drop in an E4300 in there for a perforance boost.

http://www.zipzoomfly.com/jsp/ProductDetail.jsp?ProductCode=247092
 
Buckus,

That Asus P5PE-VM is actually attractive to me in some ways for $90. Although I could use 2 sticks of my PC2700 ram, I'd be tempted to pick up a 1 gig stick pf PC3200/DDR400 if I could find a good price on it. Although I'd limit the system by putting one of the PD2700 sticks in the other slot, wouldn't I?

I'd also have to get a LGA775 processor. Is the e4300 the cheapest?

Looking at ZZF, I see e6600 prices have come down nearly $100 since I bought mine in January. They have the e4300 for $113.

Check out this $69 DDR2 ram. Can this be right? Maybe I should consider a board that takes DDR2 ram. I can't find any DDR ram this cheap. Corsair seems to stand behind their ram.

Any DDR2 mobo's that will take my AGP card? That may be a tall order. Let me look at that board silent-circuit mentioned early on...
 
This is truly an odd board.

I wonder how it would work if I put 2 gigs of DDR2 ram (from the above post) and 2x 512mb sticks of PC2700 in it?

How are the ASRock mobos? Good to work with? It's certainly cheap enuf!

$69 for 2 gb ram
$60 for this board
$115 for the e4300

For less than $250 I'd have an interesting setup with 3 Gb ram!

Worst case: I'd waste $60 for that mobo, but the DDR2 ram and e4300 should work on any current LGA775 mobo.
 
Very interesting articles... all-in-all.

I took the box into the shop today. We'll see what they say about my issues.

Reviewing the options of the Asus P5P-E and the ASRock 775 Dual VSTA, I lean to the ASRock board, odd as it is. I'd rather have an ATX over a micro ATX anyway.

I don't know about the via chipset though, but am willing to give it a try. Haven't had a VIA chipset for years... since I had an A7V mobo. (I think it was VIA).

Also, I'm open to AMD mobo solutions too ... AGP being the primary consideration.

I figure the ASRock mobo, e4300 CPU and 2 Gb ram (see below) will run me about $250.

I'm still trying to figure out if this ram is viable or not. Sounds too good to be true.

Both the Asus and the ASRock boards restrict me to 2 Gb. But for $60, it may be worth leaving my old PC2700 ram behind. But either of these boards will let me keep my AGP card.
 
Danny,

Interesting link about the e2100 series. For ~$15 difference, you can have the e4300.

What's the diff between them? I can wait, but am not sure what the e2140 will give me the e4300 will not, other than a few $$ savings.
 
I'm still trying to figure out if this ram is viable or not. Sounds too good to be true.

Actually that RAM doesn't look half bad. But you can get much cheaper RAM:
Corsair ValueSelect 2 x 1GB DDR2 667 RAM - $60

I think you'll barely notice the lower latencies of that Corsair RAM you linked to. Since this is just a simple gaming rig for your kids, I doubt they'll notice either. Also, you can overclock the E4300 with any kind of DDR2 667 or DDR2 800 ram, no matter the quality.

What's the diff between them? I can wait, but am not sure what the e2140 will give me the e4300 will not, other than a few $$ savings.

The only other difference between the E4300 and E2140 aside from the E2140's lower clock speed and price is a 1MB L2 cache. The E4300 has a 2MB L2 cache and it has been shown that a 2MB L2 cache does help performance a bit. Oh and the E2140 is going to be around $74 when it's launched.

Since this looks like a budget gaming PC, I say go for the E2140. If you think you or your kids need that extra bit of performance of the E4300, then by all means, go for it.
 
Thanks for the info.

Looks to me like there's a $5 diff between the ram. (free shipping on one) Toss up.

But if the e2140 goes for mid-$70, that may be worth waiting on. I thought it was going in the mid-$90s.
 
Got a call from the shop. They haven't had any more luck than I. They think the mobo is going bad. But nothing definitive. They also ran memtest with the ram installed and got no errors. I mentioned the motherboard limitation of 4 banks of PC2700 ram, but they said it would just underclock or something if it exceeded the specs... or somesuch.

Oh well, It was worth a shot I suppose.

I'm thinking pretty hard about just popping for the above mentioned gear.
 
Back
Top