Help to upgrade cpu/mobo/ram/psu (?)

Jones2504

n00b
Joined
Apr 1, 2007
Messages
61
Hi all,

You may remember from this thread, that I've been having some gpu problems lately!

On last week's episode, it transpired that the monitor received no signal at all from my newly purchased ASUS ENGTX560 DC/2DI/1GD5.

The main suspects were the motherboard (compatibility) and PSU.

So I'd like your suggestions on what to replace these parts with.

Of course, replacing the mobo will mean getting a new cpu and ram as well! :(

The mobo/cpu/ram doesn't have to be top of the line - I just want good value for money, and I don't have immedate plans on oc'ing. I'm sticking with WinXP 32 bit for the moment, and I think that means a max of 4 GB ram.

Tom's guide suggest the Pentium G860 as a good budget CPU, but I've no idea what motherboard/ram to get?

However, if I am to replace the PSU, I would like a quality one.

Of course, the new parts should be compatible with my old ones (see sig. + the ASUS ENGTX560) ;). So an atx mobo. (To fit in my Antec N.H.)

Thanks for reading, and looking forward to your thoughts!
 
Can you answer the sticky questions, so we can get a better feel for your requirements/budget?
 
Forceman said:
Can you answer the sticky questions, so we can get a better feel for your requirements/budget?

Sure! :)

1) What will you be doing with this PC? Gaming? Photoshop? Web browsing? etc

Skyrim!


2) What's your budget? Are tax and shipping included?

About $200 for mobo/cpu/ram

3) Which country do you live in? If the U.S, please tell us the state and city if possible.

Denmark

4) What exact parts do you need for that budget? CPU, RAM, case, etc. The word "Everything" is not a valid answer. Please list out all the parts you'll need.

mobo/cpu/ram / possibly psu


5) If reusing any parts, what parts will you be reusing?

Antec Nine Hundred case, sata drives, WinXP os., my new gpu (Asus 560 non-ti)! then, if the gpu still doesn't work, i'll change the psu.


Please be especially specific about the power supply. List make and model.

Corsair 620HX-EU


6) Will you be overclocking?

No

8) When do you plan on building/buying the PC?

Now!

9) What features do you need in a motherboard? RAID? Firewire? Crossfire or SLI support? USB 3.0? SATA 6Gb/s? eSATA? Onboard video (as a backup or main GPU)? etc.

USB 3.0 might be nice, if the price difference isn't too big. Otherwise no, I don't really need any of those things.

10) Do you already have a legit and reusable/transferable OS key/license? If yes, what OS? Is it 32bit or 64bit?

XP home 32 bit. It's certainly legit - I'm not sure how many parts you can change in a PC, before MS's anti-piracy measures kick in?
 
Last edited:
What online stores are you buying from?
What's your budget in Euros?
Also have you tried your video card or PSU in another PC to rule those out as being issues?
 
What online stores are you buying from?
What's your budget in Euros?
Also have you tried your video card or PSU in another PC to rule those out as being issues?

I usually just buy from Danish online stores, such as www.proshop.dk or www.bj-trading.dk

My budget would be about 160 Euros (1200 DKK) for the mobo/cpu/ram. For the psu, I don't have a fixed budget - I've heard too many horror stories about cheap psu's, so I'd want a quality one.

Unfortunately, I don't have access to another computer built in the last few years with a sufficient psu, so buying new parts are my only way to investigate the problems. :/

Of course, I'm also hoping that upgrading from a Q6600 to a Pentium G860 will give me a noticable performance boost. That is reasonable to expect, right? (Even though I payed much more for the Q6600 back in the day than I will pay for the Pentium.)

In general, do you think the Pentium G860 is an OK choice? And could you recommend a good, cheap mobo for it?

Cheers,
 
My budget would be about 160 Euros (1200 DKK) for the mobo/cpu/ram.
.....
In general, do you think the Pentium G860 is an OK choice? And could you recommend a good, cheap mobo for it? ,
It's an OK CPU but a tad overpriced. The better bang for the buck choice would be the G840:
http://www.proshop.dk/CPU/Intel-Pentium-G840-2277007.html
http://www.proshop.dk/Bundkort/Intel-DH67BL-B3-Sandy-Bridge-2249664.html
http://www.proshop.dk/RAM/Kingston-4GB-DDR3-1066MHz-DDR3-2156186.html

For the psu, I don't have a fixed budget - I've heard too many horror stories about cheap psu's, so I'd want a quality one.
Go with this PSU:
http://www.proshop.dk/Stroemforsyning/Antec-High-Current-Gamer-HCG-520-520W-2234754.html
 

Thanks, Danny Bui, much appreciated!

Meanwhile I found this cpu comparison chart that lists the Q6600 and the Pentium G840/860 in the same tier (and with the Q6600 apparently on a higher level within the tier).

So getting the pentium wouldn't in reality be an upgrade, but maybe even a downgrade!

At this point I should confess that my decision to update the cpu was based on the noobtastic misconception that LGA775 boards had gone out of production. Now that I have realised this is not the case, I'm thinking I could just update the mobo (and ram, if the new one doesn't support it).

A mobo like this one has pci-e 2.0, so if my problems were caused by a pci-e incompatibility this one should solve them, right?


Nice! If I were to keep the Q6600, then maybe its bigger brother, HCG-620, would be better?

Is this series on par with my corsair? I couldn't find any info on their site about how many amps it outputs on the 12V rail.

I know we've beaten this dead horse to an even deeper state of death, but what do you think is the most likely cause of my new Geforce 560 not outputting any signal, the PSU or a motherboard incompatibility? (Which part should I try replacing first?)

Thanks again for your help!
 
Meanwhile I found this cpu comparison chart that lists the Q6600 and the Pentium G840/860 in the same tier (and with the Q6600 apparently on a higher level within the tier).

So getting the pentium wouldn't in reality be an upgrade, but maybe even a downgrade!
Yeah, this is why I don't like Tom's Hardware a lot of times: They don't tell the whole story.

Check this:
http://www.anandtech.com/bench/Product/53?vs=405

In most of the gaming benchmarks, the G840 was faster than the Q6600 even in games that scales well with multiple cores like FC2 and L4D.
At this point I should confess that my decision to update the cpu was based on the noobtastic misconception that LGA775 boards had gone out of production. Now that I have realised this is not the case, I'm thinking I could just update the mobo (and ram, if the new one doesn't support it).

A mobo like this one has pci-e 2.0, so if my problems were caused by a pci-e incompatibility this one should solve them, right?
I honestly do not believe it's a compatibility issue. I've seen that same mobo used with many other PCI-E 2.0 video cards. In addition, it's simply not worth spending addtional cash on a dead socket. THe motherboards aren't actually in production any more but simply leftover stock.

Nice! If I were to keep the Q6600, then maybe its bigger brother, HCG-620, would be better?
No but if you want to spend the extra money, go for it.
Is this series on par with my corsair? I couldn't find any info on their site about how many amps it outputs on the 12V rail.
The HCG-520 has 40A on the +12V rail whereas the 620HX had 50A on the +12V rail. In terms of quality, the HCG lineup is comparable to the old Corsair 620HX.
I know we've beaten this dead horse to an even deeper state of death, but what do you think is the most likely cause of my new Geforce 560 not outputting any signal, the PSU or a motherboard incompatibility? (Which part should I try replacing first?)
There have been a few more posts than usual of people saying that their 620HX are dying. With that said, the Abit IP-35E doesn't exactly have the best of track records lately. So flip a coin to be honest.
 
Back
Top