Help me guyz!

Qulzam

n00b
Joined
Sep 14, 2006
Messages
54
Hi, i am puzzled between these two setups.

A: Great Gaming PC (E6600, 8800GTX, 2GB RAM, etc) , Dell 2407WFP and Xbox 360.

B: Great Gaming PC (E6320, 8600GTS, 2GB RAM, 21" CRT etc) , Samsung 32" LCD and Xbox 360.

Both setups cost me the same, tell me which would be the better buy? i will be using my setup mostly for Xbox 360 gaming and CS gaming (PC).

With the first one, i'll be using Dell 2407WFP with 360, which is smaller than 32" HDTV and the picture on Dell will be a little bit stretched.

What setup would be overall better for me? will 32" HDTV provide near as good Picture Quality as 24" Dell?
 
Why would you get a 21" crt with that second setup when you can get a 19" flat panel for the same or less money?

Better yet why even consider a CRT?

I have a 2407 WFP and i love it, i dont do consoles but for my pc it knocks the socks off my old Viewsonic 21" CRT
 
whats wrong with crts, i prefer them for many things, the only prob is size and heat.

The first setup i think would be better for gaming, the 8600 in your second setup isnt a very good card and wont handle upcoming games like the 8800 will.
 
Well LCD's have really caught up with CRT's in most aspects.

Damm I missed the 8600gts, DO NOT BUY IT for gaming. :p
 
The resolution on the 32" LCD is horrible for a PC, so I guess thats what the CRT is for? Look into the Westinghouse 37" if you want to use an LCD TV as a monitor. You'll only get 720P out of the 32", but the Westy is 1080P. Theres a huge thread on it in the display subforum.

Whats your overall budget? Option A looks best, imo.
 
Number 1 is the better choice as it has a better video card and better display.
 
CRTs are still king if you're not transporting it around and your desk has more than 1sqft of room (seriously, my desk is an average-sized POS and it has plenty of room for my 22" CRT).

More colors, better color accuracy, no banding, no image persistence (burn-in/uneven wear exists on CRTs, but I've never had it happen to me, while I HAVE had LCDs get some rather stubborn image persistence), cheaper

They're not quite as sharp but you wouldn't know it without comparing side by side. And they draw more power. Big deal.


Also, yeah, 8600GTS fails. Hard.
 
Don't agree with dandragonrage at all. I've had several high-end 21" CRTs (Triniton and Mitsubishi tubes that would do 1800x1440+) and can no longer even look at them without getting huge headaches. LCDs cause far far less eyestrain, and image persistence is a near dead issue with newer 8ms and faster panels. I cannot see any ghosting on my 5ms 204B panel. I'm sure it's there, but even looking for it, can't see it. I can however see the fuzzy image on my HP P1110 (Triniton) and NEC 21" (Mitsubishi).
 
I still love my CRT. The funny thing is, my eyes got weaker when I went to all LCDs at work, lol.

silent-circuit, your sig is too long now (2 lines too long).
 
Back
Top