Help me decide...

The options:


#1:
AMD FX-60 (939) - $439.00
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16819103608

EVGA 8800GTS - $419.00
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16814130071


DFI LanParty UT RDX200 - $59.99 ---- Used to complete rig for father ----
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16813136165

Kingston Hyper-X 512MB DDR400 PC3200 - $56.99 ----- Used to complete rig for father ----
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16820144112

Total: $974.98



#2:
Intel C2D E6400 - $222.00
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16819115004

EVGA 680i 775 Motherboard - $249.99
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16813188009

BUFFALO Firestix 2GB (2 x 1GB) DDR2 800 PC6400 - $249.99
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16820150054

EVGA 8800GTS - $419.00
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.asp?Item=N82E16814130071

Total: 1140.98

(If I did this, My Father would be getting my current setup as a gift)
 
im a little confused as to what you want

are you trying to build a new comp or simply upgrade an existing one?

option two is clearly superior, im unsure why anyone would buy anything but C2D atm
 
Well, currently I am using:

Aerocool Masstige (with 2x added 120mm fans)
Aerocool 620w ZEROdba 20+4pin SLI Certified PSU
4400+ X2 (939) @ 2.45GHZ
DFI NF4 Ultra-D (939) Mobo
Zalman 9500 (Blue LED)
2x 1GB OCZ S.O.E PC3200
Gigabyte 7800GT
2x 74GB Raptor HD's
Audigy 2 ZS


So If I go with #2. I would pull CPU, Mobo, Memory and Video Card, and install it in my fathers case.

If I go with #1, I stay under budget by a tiny bit. I swap out CPU/Video card and give him the new Mobo/Memory and my 7800GT/CPU
 
im a little confused as to what you want

are you trying to build a new comp or simply upgrade an existing one?

option two is clearly superior, im unsure why anyone would buy anything but C2D atm

Also, I was partial to AMD. Pre-C2D I was always on the AMD side of things and I dont consider myself a person who jumps onto the bandwagon.

I am only considering C2D, because of obvious performance differences.


But, I see option #1 as easier, but it leaves me behind in technology. DDR2 is obviously the new standard, and 939 Processors arent in production anymore.

I want others opinions on the matter, so that way I can see how others feel. I know the C2D is far more superior currently, I just like to consider my options, and budgets.
 
Your current system is still good. Unless your father needs a new pc now, I'd hold off for a while, at least until around Q2'07. This way, you'll be able to get an even better CPU for your money (new core2's will be out, along with core2quad), and most likely a better vidcard (since the R600 and lower end dx10 cards will be out). Regardless whether you build it now or later, get the c2d for yourself and give your father your 4400+. You should be able to get more juice out of that 4400, though (like around 2.8Ghz).

To keep yourself under budget, you could go for an nF 650i SLI solution instead of 680i SLI. What's your current monitor size? Unless you have a 24" or larger LCD, you really don't need SLI at all, and its not that great of an upgrade path. I'd suggest goin with a P965 board, to help keep you inside your budget (the Gigabyte DS3 or Asus P5B-E come to mind).
 
Your current system is still good. Unless your father needs a new pc now, I'd hold off for a while, at least until around Q2'07. This way, you'll be able to get an even better CPU for your money (new core2's will be out, along with core2quad), and most likely a better vidcard (since the R600 and lower end dx10 cards will be out). Regardless whether you build it now or later, get the c2d for yourself and give your father your 4400+. You should be able to get more juice out of that 4400, though (like around 2.8Ghz).

To keep yourself under budget, you could go for an nF 650i SLI solution instead of 680i SLI. What's your current monitor size? Unless you have a 24" or larger LCD, you really don't need SLI at all, and its not that great of an upgrade path. I'd suggest goin with a P965 board, to help keep you inside your budget (the Gigabyte DS3 or Asus P5B-E come to mind).


Yeah I could go DS3 and save myself $115.00.

I have been using CRT's forever, 1 year ago I got a Samsung SyncMaster 997df for 100$ new..and I am considering going with an 24" Widescreen LCD. We will see.
 
go with the 680i SLI solution, and OC that E6400 to 3.2GHz-3.5GHz and have a machine that will last a while. DS3, no SLi, and with DX10 and Vista, SLi will take shape..

Also, I have the Dell 2405fpw, and it is the best monitor out there. It's actually a samsung, re-branded by dell.
 
Neither:

E6600
Asus P5B-E or wait for Abit QuadGT (looking to be a monster)
2x1GB of G.Skill (excellent and cheap RAM)
8800GTS

Will stomp the FX-60 at stock speeds, and slaughter it at 3.2GHz.

The "buy one video card and SLI later" mentality does not work. The gain is minimal, and the savings are none; its cheaper to sell your current card and buy a new one instead of buying a second old card. Get a good P965 board and 8800GTS and enjoy it for the next three years.
 
The Firestix memory is higher quality, and better than the GSkill ram in my price range.
 
Back
Top