Help me Decide on my Next Upgrade!

XboxodX

Gawd
Joined
Jun 26, 2006
Messages
704
Okay, first off, I do not have enough $$$ to buy the new video cards that are coming out in a couple of weeks (unless I get a summer job), so please do not suggest that I wait. I can't really decide on what else to upgrade to. I have narrowed it down to what I want to get, though. I either would like to get a new mobo or a new hard drive. I would either get the ASUS P5Q Deluxe or the Western Digital 640gb HDD. I am trying to decide what would be best for me in the long run. I don't plan to upgrade to Nehalem as soon as it comes out, and I might even wait until the follow up to Nehalem comes out as I graduate High School in a year and will need to get a laptop. In college, a gaming PC wont suit me as I need to live on campus first year and I don't want my expensive gaming PC getting jacked and also because I will need to focus on my classes. So, what would you guys do: get a Mobo or a HDD. I will ALSO upgrade my GPU if I get a summer job. Thanks for your input.
 
Ok why do you think you need a new motherboard? Or a new drive? Basically what are you trying to accomplish with this planned upgrade? And what's your total budget for this upgrade?
 
Why do you need to upgrade your motherboard? I can understand additional storage but motherboard??
 
Ok why do you think you need a new motherboard? Or a new drive? Basically what are you trying to accomplish with this planned upgrade? And what's your total budget for this upgrade?
I would like a new mobo because the current one I have is a piece of crap. Unstable and runs very hot. A new HDD would be good because I only have about 100 Gigs left on my current drive and that will fill up fast. The MAX i'm looking to spend is around $250 (with tax and shipping).

Why do you need to upgrade your motherboard? I can understand additional storage but motherboard??
Same reason as above.

Both the reasons I just posted hold about the same weight. A new mobo means better stability (hopefully). A new drive yields more storage. Either way, whatever I don't get I will either get at the end of summer (if I get a job) or for Christmas.
 
Well why not get both a new drive and new motherboard? You may not neccessarily need that the $210 Asus P5Q Deluxe motherboard. Here are some other motherboard recommendations:

Gigabyte GA-EP35-DS3L Intel P35 Motherboard - $90
MSI P35 Neo2-FR Intel P35 Motherboard - $110
DFI BloodIron P35-T2RL Intel P35 Motherboard - $110
Gigabyte GA-EP35-DS3R Intel P35 Motherboard - $120
DFI LanParty DK P35-T2RS Intel P35 Motherboard - $130
Asus P5K-E Intel P35 Motherboard - $140
Gigabyte GA-EP35-DS3P Intel P35 Motherboard - $150
Asus P5K-E/Wifi-AP Intel P35 Motherboard - $150
Abit IP35 Pro Intel P35 Motherboard - $170
Gigabyte GA-EP35-DS4 Intel P35 Motherboard - $170

Just to help you out: If you don't need RAID, more than 4 SATA ports and only need semi-decent overclocking, check out the DS3L. If you need 5 SATA ports, 2 eSATA ports, slightly better overclocking, and a second PCI-E x16 port, then get the Neo2-Fr. If you want heavy overclocking options and six SATA ports, check out the Blood Iron. If you like the BloodIron but want significantly better overclock stability and options, go for the LanParty. If you want 8 SATA ports, RAID, legacy ports and high overclocks and optional eSATA, than the DS3R is a good choice. If you want the DS3R but need Firewire and a second PCI-E x16 port, then go for the DS3P. If you like the DS3P but need 3 PCI slots instead of the DS3P's 2 PCI slots and like having non-optional eSATA, go for the Asus P5K-E. If you like the P5K-E but need wifi, then go for the P5K-E/Wifi-AP. If you want something that can overclock pretty damn high along with RAID, eSATA ports and firewire connections, than the IP35 Pro. If you like the DS3P but want better cooling for overclocking, then go for the DS4. Do note that the Asus website can be slow sometimes.

Depending on what mobo you pick, you may have enough cash for the following drives:
Seagate Barracuda 7200.10 500GB 7200RPM SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive - $70
Samsung Spinpoint F1 HD753LJ 750GB 7200RPM SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive - $110
SAMSUNG Spinpoint F1 HD103UJ 1TB 7200 RPM SATA 3.0Gb/s Hard Drive - $185

(Best deal would be the Seagate drive IMO since you can get two of those for 1TB of storage for only $140.)
 
Well, here's the thing, if I'm gonna upgrade, i'm gonna spend some money on what I want. I'm not gonna budget to get both. I can buy one thing now and get the other thing I wanted later, as I am patient. Not to sound rude, but that's just not what I want to do. Thanks anyway, though.
 
Hmm, I see. Well get a new mobo then. Stability is more important than storage space IMO. You can hold off on downloading anything.

However be sure that you actually want that $210 P5Q Deluxe motherboard. It is somewhat expensive for a P45 mobo IMO. For that much, I'd get a proven X38 motherboard.
 
Okay, first off, I do not have enough $$$ to buy the new video cards that are coming out in a couple of weeks (unless I get a summer job), so please do not suggest that I wait.
Here's a different reason to wait: when the new cards come out, the current stuff will get cheaper.

Well, here's the thing, if I'm gonna upgrade, i'm gonna spend some money on what I want. I'm not gonna budget to get both. I can buy one thing now and get the other thing I wanted later, as I am patient. Not to sound rude, but that's just not what I want to do. Thanks anyway, though.
Sorry, I can't support your desire to waste money, but here's my suggestion.

Get a cheaper motherboard and the 640GB WD unless you can give us a real reason for needing the P5Q. The MSI P35 Neo2-FR would give you pretty much the same features but for $100 less (and it's in stock). Newegg has open box MSI P35 Neo2-FR's for $59.99 which is an outrageously good deal. Here's a link to a Newegg comparison of the Neo2-FR to the P5Q. The Neo2-FR will likely run at 1600 FSB just like the P5Q.

mwave.com has the 640GB WD for $97 + shipping which could end up being slightly cheaper than newegg.

The Neo2-FR from newegg and 640GB WD from mwave would cost $223.41 including shipping.
 
I agree with Danny and dhc. The P5Q Deluxe is ridiculously overpriced right now, and definitely not worth its price, IMO. The only thing it provides that a cheaper P35 doesnt have is PCI-E2.0, which isn't even worth $100 alone. At least with an X38 board, as Danny suggested, you'll get dual 16x Crossfire -- while you may no't use it, its still added functionality, so you'll be getting more for your money.

I also agree with the Neo2-FR suggestion -- great price, great board, great overclocker.

The only difference between PCI-E2.0 and PCI-E1.1 is the increased power delivery through the slot and the increased bandwidth. PCI-E2.0 cards are backwards compatible with PCI-E1.1 slots. However, current PCI-E2.0 cards do not saturate the bandwidth of PCI-E1.1 slots. Therefore, theres no point in spending a huge amount of money for the sole purpose of getting a PCI-E2.0 slot right now. By the time PCI-E2.0 cards are severely limited by the lower bandwidth of the PCI-E1.1 slots, it will be time for a new motherboard anyhow (by which time PCI-E3.0 will be out; which would put you back into the same predicament).

You said you're a patient man. So, wait for the more reasonably priced P45 boards, get the one you want, and you'll likely be able to afford both, mobo and hdd.

We can't tell you what to buy, cuz its your money. However, we just want to give you enough information to make your decision.

Why do you need to upgrade your motherboard? I can understand additional storage but motherboard??

The answer was obvious if you looked at his sig: ASUS P5N32-E SLI Deluxe :p -- not known to be a good/stable/reliable board.
 
Gigabyte GA-EP35-DS3L Intel P35 Motherboard

Bought that a week or 2 ago, runs great with my e8400 and 3870 ( waiting to upgrade)
Good board
 
Well, I think i'm gonna wait a couple of weeks before i make my decision. That'll give time for the prices to come down on mobos and the new cards to be released. That'll also give me time to hopefully get my summer job. So we'll see what happens.
 
You can buy based on your money. Try searching in computer store online on your maximum budget
 
Well, my grandfather decided to generously give me some money as a gift today. I originally had about $400 and I only wanted to spend between %50-%60 of it MAX, but since he gave me some money, I went ahead and ordered the P5Q Deluxe and the WD 640gb HDD. I was originally going to wait, but his gift allowed me to get what I truly wanted. When I receive the shipment and install the stuff i'll let you guys know how they fare. Thanks a lot!
 
Back
Top