Help me decide on a mobo/proc

S_G

Limp Gawd
Joined
Dec 17, 2005
Messages
358
Well, I haven't worried about my computers for a while. I'm not much of a gamer aside from a bit of Civ from time to time, but since seeing Alan Wake, Hellgate: London, Enemy Territory: Quake Wars, Operation: Flashpoint 2, Railroads!, Caesar IV, Tabula Rasa, Flight Simulator X, Vampyre Story, and The Splendiferous Zeppelin Escapades of Filliam H. Muffman, I figure it's about time to get back to gaming.

So, my fellow [H]ardons, I come to you for help. I do most my of my work on my laptop, but I have an old ass desktop running a Duron 800@1000. I plan on getting rid of the motherboard, processor and RAM, and replacing them. Maybe even a new PSU. Everything else is good enough for now, I'll grab a video card later on, but it's not really important.

Since I just bought a 7k100 and some RAM for my laptop, as well as saving a bit of cash on the side for a new car, I don't feel like burning a giant hole in my pocket.

Alrighty, then. I'm looking to spend around $200-$250 for the main three components: proc+mobo+ram. Of course, if you can convince me to spend more (or preferably less), I'll go with it. If AMD, I'd rather not get socket 754. Oh, and I'll be needing a board with PCI-E at the least.

I would really appreciate links to buy whatever you suggest, as it'd make things easier for me. They can be used, refurb, new... I don't care. I would prefer items for sale by [H]|F members. I live in Canada, so items from eBay must be available to me.

Newegg doesn't ship to Canada, so that's out of the question. I don't want to have to have something shipped within the States to a friend, and then shipped to me. However, if it's a store in LA (like Fry's), then it could be fine, as I can have someone buy it and ship it to me.

Here's what I've found so far:
  1. P4 D 920 + ECS 945P-A motherboard: $219.99US
  2. Opteron 144 $144.00US (I was looking to get an ASRock 939Dual-SATA2 with this, but couldn't find a good place with shipping to Canada. The ability to upgrade to AM2 on that board is interesting.)

Any ideas? I know I'm asking for a lot here, for you to go out and do my searching, but I'm really stumped and I make royally poor decisions when it comes to buying hardware. I'd appreciate any help I can get. Thanks!
 
dude there is no comparison, 920 is a DUAL core processor, Opteron might OC like crazy and all but in this age of SMP "thou shall not buy single coreth if you can geth a dual for a similar price" - this was in the original old testament but back then people didn't know what a core was so it was removed :p
 
Yeah, but dual core doesn't seem to help with gaming yet. It does amazing with applications, though. I also noticed a single-core 3700+ which simply KILLS the 920 in gaming (50fps according to benchmarks).

Damn the future and it's dual cores.

Well, unless I can get any other replies in this thread by tomorrow morning, I'm having someone buy the D 920 combo at Fry's for $220 and ship it to me (I live in Canada, so, no Fry's here). Still cheaper than the $320US + shipping I'd have to pay elsewhere.
 
NCIX has terrible prices. Well, I've been talked out of the D 920. I'm either going for a 3700+ or an Opteron 144. Opinions?
 
Both are good cpu's which oc very well. Depending on the stepping both can achieve 3.0ghz oc's. Its a tough choice. The 3700+ has a higher initial cpu multiplier and base speed (2.2 vs the Opty's 1.8) but is also more expensive. Decide you must how to serve you best. If it was me I'd probably lean toward the 3700+ San Diego but it wouldn't be by much.
 
Back
Top