Help me choose a boot drive please

exe163

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Nov 15, 2005
Messages
1,366
I am looking for some fast drives for OS booting, apps, and maybe games. Right now I have already gotten a 1TB WD "green" drive for vid, pic, music storage. My old 74 raptors running raid 0 are not enough space for my use. Any suggestion.

PS my mobo is P6T, shouldn't have trouble running RAID or anything. I am thinking about velociraptor or something along the price line, heard 2 WD 640gb in RAID 0 just as fast as a single velociprator, but cheaper and with 4 times of storage :confused:.
 
I believe the popular choice these days are those 640gb WD drives: AAKS and AALS
 
Is the 500gb drive running the same speed as 640? If it is, is it possible to run mirror RAID 0 500gb with a 1TB green?
Also what's the point getting a velociraptor if semi storage drives run just as fast under RAID with more storage and fraction of the cost
 
Is the 500gb drive running the same speed as 640? If it is, is it possible to run mirror RAID 0 500gb with a 1TB green?
Also what's the point getting a velociraptor if semi storage drives run just as fast under RAID with more storage and fraction of the cost

The 500GB AAKS does not run as the same speed as the 640GB versions. Not sure about the 500GB AALS versions though. It might be possible to RAID 1 a 1TB RAID 0 setup and a 1TB drive.

Velociraptors have lower seek times so you can search and load files a bit faster. But not faster enough to justify the costs IMO.
 
There's a big difference between faster operation and faster performing, as crazy as it sounds. The WD 640GB drives can transfer data as fast or faster than a Velociraptor in some situations, but overall the Velociraptor wins on the biggest factor which is seek time. It can find the data and start transferring it faster then the 640GB models can, so it wins in that respect.

In day to day operation of the OS the Velociraptor is better - and I'm not talking about fuckin' gaming performance so don't bring that into the equation, I'm talking about using the OS itself for day to day stuff like surfing, working on documents, images, etc. It is a faster hard drive due to those low seek times and the 10K rpm spindle speed. It's an extreme product for people that want extreme performance.

Personally at this point I think I'd just go get 2 or 3 of the Patriot 32GB SSD drives and RAID 'em together for insane speeds (over 400MB/s average reads with writes approaching 270MB/s if you tweak your configuration) for about $300 or so. Only ~96GB of storage but, hey, it'll smoke a Velociraptor across the board, especially on seek times. Compare ~5ms with a Velociraptor to ~0.1-0.2 ms with the SSD hardware and you can see that quite literally everything gets to the point where it literally snaps onscreen...

Or better yet, grab a single SSD for the system drive and grab a 640GB for more space, or a 1TB model for that.
 
Thanks for the detailed reply, I think I will pick up couple OCZ SSD and use it for boot and apps. And what do you mean by "tweak your configuration"?
 
I'll make this short and sweet:

XP and Vista simply aren't designed for SSD hardware, but that's true for all modern OSes on the market today. None of them are configured or tweaked to allow for the particular idiosyncrasies that SSD hardware has, most notably the dreaded performance drops when doing random writes. MLC (multi-level cell) based SSD hardware (the vast majority) are the devices most critically affected by the random write performance, commonly referred to as stuttering of the OS in the middle of something, or outright stopping until a write is completely done.

SLC (single-level cell) based SSD hardware improves on this, but it still suffers a great deal from the random write issues as well, just nowhere near as severely as MLC-based devices do.

One way you can "work around" the issues with MLC-based SSD hardware (those cheap OCZ drives are MLC-based) is to use Windows SteadyState. It's software designed to keep a PC in a static condition, sorta like a kiosk computer someplace is, perhaps in a library, or some other public place.

Why SteadyState helps is this: because of how it works, all data you create/generate on a PC with SteadyState operational actually goes into a cache, and not directly to the hard drive or storage device. Because of this, when the cache is ready to be flushed and the data is going to be written to the storage device, it gets sequentially written to the device and not randomly. See where this leads?

Having a system-level driver that sits in between the OS and the SSD that converts all random writes - the Achille's Heel of MLC-based SSD tech - into sequential writes means the SSD can actually perform up to spec, nearly all the way. So when you read the specs on an SSD that says "175MB/s reads, 90MB/s writes, max" by using SteadyState (or some other way of converting random writes to sequential ones), you'll actually get damned close to the stated spec of 90MB/s write speeds, which is what makes the cheap low-end SSD hardware actually useful at this point.

And best of all, SteadyState is free, from Microsoft, for XP and Vista. There is a strong hope that Windows 7 will find some way to implement a system-level driver that can recognize when SSD media is being used and perhaps use a chunk of system RAM as a cache (unlike SuperFetch or whatever) that will then do the "conversion" and when it comes time to dump the cached data to the storage device, it'll be done sequentially and therefore maximizing the potential of any SSD hardware attached to the machine.

I'll shut up now... :)

There's more info over at the OCZ forums about this "work around" as well as making XP and Vista more SSD friendly and you can find them here:

http://www.ocztechnologyforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=43460 <<<--- Making XP SSD friendly

http://www.ocztechnologyforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=47183 <<<--- Generic fix for stuttering in XP and Vista 32 bit with SSD drives

Hope this helps...
 
Thanks for another well detailed reply! I am actually planning to get a cheap OCZ Core drive. I am not quite sure what I need to do to get a SSD fully working. My OS of choice will be Vista 64. From what I read so far I need to tweak the registry:

http://www.ocztechnologyforum.com/forum/showthread.php?t=47212

And then I am all set? Also is there any thing I need to do prior to install of windows?
 
Back
Top