Help me build a Norco 4020 system!

Mcavity

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jun 22, 2001
Messages
229
I wasent planing on going quit this big this soon, however...
It looks like I will be getting a birthday gift of a norco 4020.
Since I have been planing to build a better media / storage server for a while I might as well go ahead and start this out right.
Given that this is going to be a big system I want to do this right.
I could use advice on the following

Power supply.. this thing can run up to 20 sata drives!
What on earth do you use to power that?

Motherboard and drive controller
I currently have 7 sata drives [3-750 and 4-1Tb drives] and plan to add drives as time goes on.

power usage.. My current server is using a lot of juice.. idels at about 120 kwh. Id like to be a bit more efficient if possible.

I want to do this thing right! [but not break the bank if possible]
 
I have the same case and I love it but I would try and see if you can pick up the 4220. Why? Even though I heard it has the plastic handles (only matters if you use it in a rack system, I don't so it doesn't matter to me...I just have it sitting on the top part of my desk), you can benefit from the SAS connections (4 SAS cables vs 20 SATA cables). Either case, I'd definitely recommend replacing the fans. They are pure jet engines. I put in 3x120 P12 noctua fans and 2x80 noctua fans and it is DEAD silent, even with the fans on max (which is ~80CFM each).

I would search the Data Storage subforum and see if you could find Ockies Galaxy threads. Very well documented and for one Galaxy project, he used the Norco case. Turned out very well and I believe he only buys 2TBs now (last time I talked to him), so that would put a system like that up to 40TB. Sure it'll break the bank for most people, but over time, throw in a drive or two and they'll add up.

He uses a corsair PSU (around 750W), an AM2 Biostar MB, a low power CPU, and basic GSkill RAM (IIRC) which doesn't break the bank at all, and performs well for what you need to use it for (I'm assuming WHS?).

BTW, I would like to add that those Supermicro cards are absolutely wonderful. I have absolutely NO complaints with them and would recommend them anytime....as long as you find the correct drivers. The ones on Supermicro's site are incorrect and only upon finding the correct ones will you take full advantage of the SATA capabilities (in this case: hot-swappability), else you won't. I also heard really good things about the new Supermicro SAS cards to replace the SAT2s so you may want to look into those if you haven't already (they are PCIe x4 though).
 
Thanks guys. Odditoriy Ill be looking over those links.
4220 Might be a better deal however..I didn't buy the case, someone bought it for me! Its already being shiped so I doubt I will be able to upgrade to the sas system.
 
Ok been doing some reading on that thread. I do have a few questions..
I would prefer to go pcie rather than old style pci-x. Has anyone tried using the AOC-SASLP-MV8 sas controler in the 4020 box?[20 sata port back plane ] box? Is there a reason this wont work?
 
well iirc that card only has 2 sas ports so you can only break out to 8 sata connectors without either an expander or additional cards.
 
well i figure id probably need 2 cards.. unless theres something better out there.
 
Well the norco 4020 arived today . looks to be in good shape.
Most of the threads i have found go on for a hundred or more pages so its going to be fun tracking down all the info. [may need to swap fans for quiet ones ect..]
So far I have...

1 norco 4020 case

4.Hitachi HD31000 1TB drives [69 bucks each hard to turn down]

currently in use on my other system is a supermicro pci-x 8 port sata controler
also have a adaptec 4 port 2410sa pci controler [ugh dont like it. its slow]

I have a asrock k7vt4a ati motherboard and cpu I could drop into the box but honestly theres not enough cpu in that to trans code video like I want to do.

Trying to figure out what system board I should use to get enough hourse power to transcode as well as serve files.

Looks like I;m going to need to get a 600-750 watt power supply.
 
what do ya mean hundred+ page threads? you only need one page -- the one I gave you: http://www.avsforum.com/avs-vb/showthread.php?p=17984843#post17984844

You want a 700-750 Watt CPU which is good for a fully populated drive cage. Heck I have dual quadcore Xeons and 16Gb of FBDIMM, raid card and expander + 20 x 2Tb drives in one of my Norco 4220's with a 750W Corsair PSU and it does just fine. I'd also go with two of the AOC-SASLP-MV8 cards if you aren't interested in hardware raid. That gives you 16 ports + 4 SATA ports on the motherboard = 20 ports for 20 drive slots. Since you don't have that many drives you could start with only one Supermicro SAS card. Then you'll need a couple of miniSAS -> 4x SATA breakout cables. Search newegg for "Norco SATA" since they make some.

If you ARE interested in hardware raid then manipulating large video files really benefits, because you're going from 100-120MB/s transfer speeds, to 600-800MB/s. Tossing around 25-40Gb bluray files, not to mention large multi-hundred-gig HDV files gets a whole lot faster. Hardware raid is a separate discussion.

Lastly, for transcoding on the server side, WHS isn't really ideal for that -- Microsoft really intended for people not to use the server console much. I'd go with Windows 2008 R2 - that's what I run because again I'm also one of those people doing a lot of recoding/remuxing of big video files.

As for mobo/CPU, it all depends on your budget. I run Xeons and a server class (Supermicro) motherboard, but you could also go for one of the new Clarkdale CPU's. Maybe like an i5-650 -- if you have a Microcenter store near you, they're $149 on sale right now for in-store pickup.
 
odditory,
thanks.
I don't have a Microcenter, but I do have a Frys. Speed is always good, as I am mostly dealing with video so if you have suggestions for that on a budget I'm all ears.

I am currently running a WHS system and while I like the back up functions [a lot] I have to say it does seem a bit flaky. if you start moving data around directly on the system. [I picked up some weird errors that required some nasty stuff to fix] I'm hopeful that the next gen WHS is better.

Mainly this box will [hopefully] be a file server / transcodeing box to my ps3 that's the heart of my home theater system.

Current to buy list

1 750W Corsair PSU
1. cpu. I think odditory is right the intell core i5 650 should be enough for my needs.
1. motherboard. with at least 2x pcie slots.

[ I'm looking at DFI LANParty DK P55-T3eH9 right now. http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813136070 will look at some gigabyte /and asus boards too. ] This one has 8 on board sata ports so could eliminate the need for one of the sas controllers I think.

[anything I should look for?]

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813136070
 
I'd look into AMD stuff right now. For what you need it for, you don't need a Nehalem CPU. A more stable board (I have a Biostar AM2 board and never had ONE issue with it, its been rock solid) would be a more suitable offering than a DFI.

As far as onboard SATA ports, you have to watch out. The Biostar that I have doesn't allow single drives in those ports controlled by the RAID controller (rather than the chipset). If drives are plugged into the ports, they have to be in some sort of RAID configuration else windows will not see it. As far as the SAS cards, you could get a SAS -> 4xSATA cables and still save case room from cables.

750W should be sufficient

The thing is with Windows Server 2008, it does not drive pooling like WHS does IIRC.

I'm running a low powered dual core AM2 on a biostar board and have no issues. The CPU is a 45W. A higher end CPU isn't necessary unless if you're doing a lot of encoding, in which you would want a higher end CPU (obviously).
 
I am currently running a WHS system and while I like the back up functions [a lot] I have to say it does seem a bit flaky. if you start moving data around directly on the system. [I picked up some weird errors that required some nasty stuff to fix] I'm hopeful that the next gen WHS is better.

Can you give us a better idea of what you mean by moving stuff directly on the system? WHS is pretty stable for most people, so I am willing to bet that someone here could diagnose the problem and help you fix it.
 
DangerlsGo
Well I want enough CPU to be able to transcode video on the fly. My current server system an amd 64 3400 on a asus K8V-X and that is not quit enough.. so I need something faster than that.
If you have anything to suggest with enough speed I'll be happy to look at it.
Im not currently up on AMD cpus and system boards.

Leagle
Well I got the "Tag present in the reparse point buffer is invalid" error. very nasty and Microsoft does not list a fix. I eventually had to go in with a linux live cd track down the offending files and delete them. [no windows tools would work] this makes me a bit Leary of whs.. I had directly accessed the system to move a bunch of files [probably about 500 meg or so] from one directory to another [rather than copy over the network] and I think that is where things went wrong.
 
Did you access the files thru the network share from the drive? //servername/share/ If you didn't then that's why you got those errors since drive extender does not work well if you mess with your files without going thru the network share. IIRC, there are numerous warnings in WHS to avoid directly accessing files for this reason.
 
Please buy the biggest drives you can. There have been 1.5TB seagates advertised for nearly the same price per GB in hotdeals. HDD's running over a period of years will start becoming an issue of power consumption. Getting an extra 50% more storage per watt consumed is not trivial after ~2 years.

Remember that every W of power running 24/7 costs you about ~$1.25 per year. Thus 3 1TB drives (assuming mostly idle) is ~18 watts or $22...2 1.5TB drives would be $15. That is the first year of $7 saved. Since 1's and 1.5's are the same price per GB...well, you know the answer..
 
See what Neb said. You cannot expect the system to be problem free if you do things like that. WHS is not like other Windows system, so you really have to stay out of the D: drive and use the network shares.
 
Neb
Thats probably what happened.. Now I'm using the file manager plugin to move data around. Its still slow but better than before and I don't seem to have quite so many problems.
What I really need to do is make a clean system and see how it goes. though performance speed is not great. I'm looking into doing the flex raid thing when I get the Norco system running [if i don't find a better solution. I really wish someone would figure a way to implement a beyondraid [DROBO] type brainless setup in Linux but untill then..WHS or Raid 5/6 might be the way to go.

Trepidati0n
Currently I have 3 750 and 4 1TB hard drives. At 69bucks a pop its hard to beat the 1TB drives that price, but I'll keep an eye out on the 1.5s and 2s as prices drop. Quick deals you say?. I have a lot of bays to fill. =)
The Hitachi specs says the drives use 4.4w when idle so that should help =)
 
Last edited:
Theres been a few other things going on with services crashing [indexer?] and it hates my printer.. but i think that's the printer driver.. [panasonic has really ticked me off on that one] It has been a lot more stable though.

on another note.. Anyone know what the risk of a raid 5 uing 1 TB drives failing a rebuild is?
 
Ok I went to frys and they had a AMD phenom II x4 925 and biostar TA790GX on sale so I grabbed those. [then had a intel core i5 but they ran out..

I'm in to the process of putting things together and I have noticed the corsair 750watt has 8 peripheral and 8 sata power connectors. Should i be using Y power cables to make sure i have enough plugs?
 
odditory,
thanks.
I don't have a Microcenter, but I do have a Frys. Speed is always good, as I am mostly dealing with video so if you have suggestions for that on a budget I'm all ears.

I am currently running a WHS system and while I like the back up functions [a lot] I have to say it does seem a bit flaky. if you start moving data around directly on the system. [I picked up some weird errors that required some nasty stuff to fix] I'm hopeful that the next gen WHS is better.

Mainly this box will [hopefully] be a file server / transcodeing box to my ps3 that's the heart of my home theater system.

Current to buy list

1 750W Corsair PSU
1. cpu. I think odditory is right the intell core i5 650 should be enough for my needs.
1. motherboard. with at least 2x pcie slots.

[ I'm looking at DFI LANParty DK P55-T3eH9 right now. http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813136070 will look at some gigabyte /and asus boards too. ] This one has 8 on board sata ports so could eliminate the need for one of the sas controllers I think.

[anything I should look for?]

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813136070

I don't know what you mean by WHS being flaky. But I had WHS running VERY stable for almost 2 yrs before I rebuilt a new one and it is NOW stable as well.

Why would you be moving things around directly on the server and not via the share folders?
 
Oh yeah I envy you and that new case you got. I will be moving to one come 2011. In the mean time I bought a Norco 450B to hold me over with my WHS till then.
 
I tried moving things locally for speed reasons.. moving a terabyte of data over the network / share folders takes a while. I suspect i may have a hardware problem on that system as well as I get some crashed service errors and lovely error messages in the logs.

Anyone have a posting of how exactly you plug everything in on a corsair 750w power supply to the norco 4020? Y cables? custom cables?
 
everything I read says to go for the 4220 for the easier cable management. however this was gifted to me so I'm not complaining =)
 
The 4020 is just fine -- plus it has 5 x 80mm fans pulling air through from the drive cage instead of 4 x 80mm on the 4220, so cooling is better at a lower noise level than the stock 4220. You can make the SATA cable cluster very clean with some small zip ties as well.
 
well coolness. I will be doing a bunch of assembly. I will also see about testing out the noise level of the box.
 
I would recommend you do some trolling on the forums.

took me almost 2 months of research before i had every question answered before i did my build

i also went though 4+ revisions of hardware before i got what i felt was the best build at the time.

You can see some of the chatter and build specs and pics here.

http://hardforum.com/showthread.php?t=1497224

Last thing you want to do is start buying hardware and realize its not what you want for the purpose that is needed.

Just my 2 cents.
 
Back
Top