Has the Plasma Display Reached EOL?

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
At a media meeting held in Leipzig, Germany last week, experts agreed that the plasma screen is “a phased-out model.” A professor of screen technology at the University of Stuttgart said that LCD screens are getting larger while response times are getting shorter, greatly improving motion playback. With Pioneer joining Panasonic in developing displays, perhaps the stories of PDP's death are greatly exaggerated. Thanks to [H] reader protias for the link!

Norbert Frühauf, Professor of Screen Technology at Universität Stuttgart (the University of Stuttgart), calculates that the market share for LCD technology, which is currently worth 100 billion US dollars on the world market, will rise 75 percent.

Edit: Story corrected and removed erroneous reference to Pioneer bowing out. Thanks to all of you who pointed that out and I apologize for the error.
 
Why would I want a TV that will be washed out within a few years? My friend owns a timeshare in Vegas and they put brand new 42" plasmas in every room. Within two years, they were essentially black-and-white TVs from all the use they got. That convinced me to never buy a plasma.
 
I think the biggest problem plasma faces was the colors dieing after 5 or so years and they really never found a fix for this.
 
You really can't beat the black level though. Fortunately LCD's are getting continually better with LED backlighting and laser is just around the corner with Mitsubishi's prototype.
 
I think the biggest problem plasma faces was the colors dieing after 5 or so years and they really never found a fix for this.

It's not really a problem. After about 75,000 hours of use, the set becomes half as bright as it was on the first day of use. So, if you left the TV on for 8 years straight, without ever turning it off any single day, you'd have a TV that was half as bright as the day you bought it.

However, if you watch TV that much, you have much larger problems than whether or not you'll wear out your set...

Normal use would put it on par with any other conventional technology out there.

Also, I think the article is full of crap. Panasonic owns the Plasma market. Although LCDs are much improved, Plasma is still the better technology for TV use. LCDs seem to be owning the sub 42 inch market, with Plasmas owning the larger sets. If anything, the trend toward larger sets would bode better for Plasma than LCD, since LCDs are more expensive the larger you go (hard to make a set with zero dead pixels).
 
Plasma will be around another 5 years and possibly longer. By then, OLED might be affordable and have the issues with them ironed out.
 
The whole summary is certified garbage when Pioneer's "exit" is stated. They outsourced their tech to Panasonic. Pioneer will continue to sell plasmas but the panels will be made to their specification by another firm. Has nVidia "bowed out" of the add-in PC videocard market since they do not make their own cards?

The tired, BS, anti-plasma agitprop planted by the LCD manufactures is the biggest problem plasma faces. It's been regurgitated in this thread and will be ad-nauseum until the superior technology has finally been killed.

You want the best PQ and set, buy plasma. End of story.
 
Look, at sizes of 50" or less, TFT-LCD is cheaper than plasma. And while it's true that the issues that plasma faced (elevation, burn-in) have been mostly or completely solved, the fact is that TFT-LCD has gotten a lot better too.
 
I've never liked plasma. They always suffer from dot crawl and with the exception of the 15k+ sets they never even looked acceptable to me.

With that said, LCD's are almost universally awful. For me the saddest day for HD was when Sony decided to stop making SXRD (LCoS) XBR sets. The 60 and 70" XBR2's looked incredible out of the box and by all accounts were nothing short of stunning when professionally calibrated (though in fairness, every obtain dramatic improvements when calibrated). Saddest of all is that the XBR5's that never came out were only 14" deep. Unless you're hanging an LCD on the wall, you won't save much space, once you put the panel on a table. Figures that as soon as they get a technology that's almost as good as a RP CRTs it dies.

At this point, I'm not sure what I'd buy. I haven't looked in a while, but i've heard some good things about some of the Samsung DLPs.
 
The tired, BS, anti-plasma agitprop planted by the LCD manufactures is the biggest problem plasma faces.
Most consumers are not geeky fans. LCDs are winning by far due to price, which can scale down a lot more than plasma can, and features because there's a lot more competition. Plasma used to be a very profitable niche when flat screen HDTVs commanded huge price premiums. Plasma makers are finding it hard to compete even when they drop prices by 50-66%, and the field of offerings continues to dwindle.
 
When i researched getting a hdtv i looked at every available format. I originally bought a sharp lcd on a "whim" on black friday, in other words i had been thinking about an hdtv and had some money from a side job. I did not research that set and i hated it, and it was making my girlfriend sick (with the refresh time). It went back.

For the longest time i outright expected to get a samsung lcd tv, as i use their monitors and love them. I had not even really considered projection because i always saw the older gen and they looked like crap, or i would see the ones right at the entrance to circuit city and i would be so close to them that they looked like crap. This changed when i started seeing things like the higher end sammy dlp's and such. In the end it came down between dlp and plasma for me. No lcd, not even the really expensive ones could match the picture qualities i was seeing. Ultimately i got my panasonic plasma and i think it is the best looking television i have seen (now that its calibrated its damn close to the kuro elites).

The bottom line is, look around all you want, you won't match plasma quality for a while on lcd. It's a real shame the development sector does not want plasma anymore. Because the "issues" are just the same reiterated stuff from years ago that have been fixed over time.
 
I would choose a Plasma over an LCD anyday. In fact, I have a 42" Plasma in my garage. (has a bit of burn-in :D )
plasma01.jpg
 
a plasma is the only screen that almost made me fall over when i watched a train pass on a large 1080p model at a high end store.
 
all unwanted obsolete EOL plasma screens can be forwarded to my address..

thanks guys... :)

will reimburse 50% of shipping costs for 50" 1080P Plasma good condition screens
 
a BIT of burn in... i can see that from that photo... i can almost read the giant letters burnt on the screen...
 
I think the biggest problem plasma faces was the colors dieing after 5 or so years and they really never found a fix for this.

I don't know about that but what I do know is that LCD TV's have come a long way and are more appealing than ever. DLP also delivers near the picture quality but without all the downsides. The only problem with DLP is that it has a large depth compared to Plasma and LCD units.

I've got a DLP TV that's a couple years old now and its' still badass.
 
OLED > Plasma so i dont see why this is such a big deal. Wait a few years untill LED LCD's are being phased out, and the same people will be crying. Its a never ending train.
 
Of course, once you get a 50" plasma (or higher), watch your electricity bill skyrocket. In today's seemingly never-ending quest to conserve power, plasma displays are big power hogs.
 
Of course, once you get a 50" plasma (or higher), watch your electricity bill skyrocket. In today's seemingly never-ending quest to conserve power, plasma displays are big power hogs.

AFAIK, they use about the same about of power as a CRT, so unless you're moving from an LCD, your power costs probably won't change that much.
 
OLED > Plasma so i dont see why this is such a big deal. Wait a few years untill LED LCD's are being phased out, and the same people will be crying. Its a never ending train.

O'rly?

Maybe it will be someday, but I don't believe it is now.

A lot of the anti-plasma stuff being spewed is FUD-based. It's too bad; there are plenty of good reasons to choose a modern plasma, and while LCDs aren't bad, they have their own set of flaws.
 
O'rly?

Maybe it will be someday, but I don't believe it is now.

A lot of the anti-plasma stuff being spewed is FUD-based. It's too bad; there are plenty of good reasons to choose a modern plasma, and while LCDs aren't bad, they have their own set of flaws.

All monitor technologies do.
 
All monitor technologies do.

Agreed...I just hate the plasma-hating going on. Especially those who continue to talk about burn-in; certainly it was a problem, but new displays have automatic pixel-shifting technology that eliminates this, and some people react based on dated information as if the market never changed.

I chose a plasma for better blacks, better viewing angles, less ghosting during fast-action, and because I saw a number of LCDs that were very "washed out" in comparison.

I'm sure that if I could have done some calibration on those LCD sets that might have improved, but in my price range, I got a set I'm very happy with. I have an upconverting DVD player and a media extender (both using HDMI, a ReplayTV and a Wii (using component cables), and a basic 4-head HiFi VCR (for moments when the wife needs to preview VHS tapes for classes she teaches, which is rare) and all of them work great with it.

To everyone who went the LCD route, I hope you're enjoying your set as much as I do mine; there's definitely some good sets out there. I just get sick of rhetoric that is parroted because someone else put it on the Internets, rather than researched, informed opinion. I really hope plasma doesn't go away until next-gen technology is around that has improved beyond it AND current LCDs.
 
I don't know about that but what I do know is that LCD TV's have come a long way and are more appealing than ever. DLP also delivers near the picture quality but without all the downsides. The only problem with DLP is that it has a large depth compared to Plasma and LCD units.

I've got a DLP TV that's a couple years old now and its' still badass.

AND DLP is much cheaper. My wife and I picked up a 50" Samsung in January of '07 for $1000. I don't think either Plasma or LCD will be that cheap any time soon.
 
when my plasma set finally gives up the ghost i would probably go to the latest dlp set (if plasma is gone). I mean yeah after professional calibration and such my panny is really close to the pioneers, but after seeing some of the high end samsung dlp sets available i will fully admit it was a really hard decision.
 
AND DLP is much cheaper. My wife and I picked up a 50" Samsung in January of '07 for $1000. I don't think either Plasma or LCD will be that cheap any time soon.

Well my DLP cost quite a bit but I got mine several years ago. It isn't even a 1080p unit. Its' 1080i or 720p. At the time mine was I think $2,400 or something like that. Though I did see a 60"+ Mitsubishi at Fry's one day and I seriously had to think about it as it was something like $1399.99 or something.
 
Agreed...I just hate the plasma-hating going on. Especially those who continue to talk about burn-in; certainly it was a problem, but new displays have automatic pixel-shifting technology that eliminates this, and some people react based on dated information as if the market never changed.

I chose a plasma for better blacks, better viewing angles, less ghosting during fast-action, and because I saw a number of LCDs that were very "washed out" in comparison.

I'm sure that if I could have done some calibration on those LCD sets that might have improved, but in my price range, I got a set I'm very happy with. I have an upconverting DVD player and a media extender (both using HDMI, a ReplayTV and a Wii (using component cables), and a basic 4-head HiFi VCR (for moments when the wife needs to preview VHS tapes for classes she teaches, which is rare) and all of them work great with it.

To everyone who went the LCD route, I hope you're enjoying your set as much as I do mine; there's definitely some good sets out there. I just get sick of rhetoric that is parroted because someone else put it on the Internets, rather than researched, informed opinion. I really hope plasma doesn't go away until next-gen technology is around that has improved beyond it AND current LCDs.

I would have prefered plasma to DLP honestly but the I couldn't justify the cost at the time. A 42" plasma at the time cost almost $1,000 more. I figured I'd go with the DLP which was cheaper, still looked good, and was 10" larger.
 
I would have prefered plasma to DLP honestly but the I couldn't justify the cost at the time. A 42" plasma at the time cost almost $1,000 more. I figured I'd go with the DLP which was cheaper, still looked good, and was 10" larger.

Thats what was going through my mind. Cost to Size ratio.:D
 
I was looking at DLP screens when I went new HDTV shopping a few months ago. The price for 1080p models was very attractive for the screen size, but it just wasn't sharp enough for one of the uses I was upgrading for (HT/gaming PC).

It may have been perfectly usable, but the lack of perfect sharpness like LCDs (and Plasmas) provide would always bug me. I wound up getting a 5ms LG 1080p S-IPS LCD. After about 3 months I still have no complaints or regrets.
 
AFAIK, they use about the same about of power as a CRT, so unless you're moving from an LCD, your power costs probably won't change that much.
Plasma uses the same energy per square inch as a CRT, if you go from a 40" CRT (did they ever make on this big?) to a 40" plasma your power'll stay about the same. IN the more realistic 25-30" CRT to 40-50" plasma you'll see a big hit.
 
Agreed...I just hate the plasma-hating going on. Especially those who continue to talk about burn-in; certainly it was a problem, but new displays have automatic pixel-shifting technology that eliminates this, and some people react based on dated information as if the market never changed.

I chose a plasma for better blacks, better viewing angles, less ghosting during fast-action, and because I saw a number of LCDs that were very "washed out" in comparison.

I'm sure that if I could have done some calibration on those LCD sets that might have improved, but in my price range, I got a set I'm very happy with. I have an upconverting DVD player and a media extender (both using HDMI, a ReplayTV and a Wii (using component cables), and a basic 4-head HiFi VCR (for moments when the wife needs to preview VHS tapes for classes she teaches, which is rare) and all of them work great with it.

To everyone who went the LCD route, I hope you're enjoying your set as much as I do mine; there's definitely some good sets out there. I just get sick of rhetoric that is parroted because someone else put it on the Internets, rather than researched, informed opinion. I really hope plasma doesn't go away until next-gen technology is around that has improved beyond it AND current LCDs.

I agree with you completely. If I was buying a new living room monitor it would definitely be a plasma. That said, hopefully plasma's inevitable replacement will be at least as good as or superior to it (unlike what happened with TN LCD panels dominating CRT and S-IPS LCDs in the computer monitor arena).
 
I'm thinking of getting a 1080p tv to replace my monitor since I use the pc mostly for movies and gaming these days. From what I've read the pixel-shifting has pretty much solved burn-in for normal tv use but might not be enough to prevent burn-in when used as a monitor since some elements like the taskbar or the browsers address bar will be onscreen constantly.
 
Plasma uses the same energy per square inch as a CRT, if you go from a 40" CRT (did they ever make on this big?) to a 40" plasma your power'll stay about the same. IN the more realistic 25-30" CRT to 40-50" plasma you'll see a big hit.

I believe someone did make a 40" CRT. But one could also compare it to CRT Based RP sets as well...though I have no idea how it'd compare.

I'm also not sure how big the hit would be, and I'm too lazy to do the math, but I believe 36" CRT's area is great than a than a 36" widescreen display, so I suspect a 40" plasma woudn't use much more power than the smaller TV.

With that said, I kinda think TVs should start at 60" (says the guy without an HD set ;))
 
Yup, Sony, I have their HD 40" CRT sitting in my living room. Beastly thing weighs over 300lbs. :(

Mitsubishi was the first company to bring a 40” CRT to market about 15 years ago. Years later Sony brought what the called a bridge 40” CRT to market. Bridge meant it would do 40” line doubling to those who still needed to view NTSC sources and it gave you a 36” HD picture on HD sources. The Sony was a pure flat tube set that for the bucks was a pretty good investment.

Where the Sony had had a huge advantage over anyone else was how they handeled the black bars at the top and bottom of the screen. Other companies simply took the HD signal and created the black bars from the original source. Sony created the black bars inside the TV and put the whole HD image in the remaining space.

If the Sony had any issues at all it was the weight, 450 pounds out of the box. It was and still is a fine set.
 
I'm thinking of getting a 1080p tv to replace my monitor since I use the pc mostly for movies and gaming these days. From what I've read the pixel-shifting has pretty much solved burn-in for normal tv use but might not be enough to prevent burn-in when used as a monitor since some elements like the taskbar or the browsers address bar will be onscreen constantly.

Every HD TV regardless of technology as a rule makes a bad or at best a less then acceptable computer monitor.

Two very different designs made for two very different purposes.;)
 
Back
Top