Group Wants Canada Blacklisted

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
We love our Canadian brothers and sisters but it seems not everyone shares our sentiment. Apparently a group of U.S. software, movie and music producers are pushing to have Canada added to the blacklist of intellectual property villains. If that doesn’t work, they are going to write Canada a letter…or something.

Canada's chronic failure to modernize its copyright regime has made it a global hub for bootleg movies, pirated software and tiny microchips that allow video-game users to bypass copyright protections, the International Intellectual Property Alliance complains in a submission to the U.S. government.
 
I thought this was already on the front page before a few months back(or something like this).

Saying Canada is the "global hub for bootleg movies" is just plain BS. You can literally go to china and buy burned movies off the street!
 
I'm all for being on the blacklist!!!

Then we'll turn off the power in June and watch California go dark. PFFFTTT.:p
 
Fine!

This is a list of Canadian invention/things that Canada wants back:

-Blackberry
-Squarehead screws
-Canadarm
-Boat propellers
-Zipper
-Poutine
-The Montreal Expos
-Wonderbra
-Standard 24 hour day
-Plexiglass
-ATI Technology
-AA batteries
-Basketball
-Telephone
-Snowblower
-Paint Roller

The USA will have 72 hours to give that back to Canada.

In all seriousness, I'm not serious :D

But still, this is a load of BS.
 
huh
i highly doubt the politician are gonna get deep into this or they are in deep shit. The tax on cd, dvd and tapes. I mean they still owe us a lot of electric bill and softwood lumber tariff.

Still this isn't a big of a issue and they need to get laid
 
also why modernize something when there was a court ruling that allows file sharing and meet the expectation of the majority (Democracy) :D
 
sorry but the MPAA/RIAA/USofA does not own the internets...or Canada.......
 
LOL

Yeah... Washington Expos are a perfect match to their new city and the federal level that resides there: Terrible, crappy, hated by most, always loses, unpopular.

Lousy no edit option.

And as I wanted to conclude, they, like me, are hypocrites.
 
This is such a bu!@#@it. Another example of American hegemony. (do not want to direspect average US brothers but US is run by private interests)Putting us in the same basket with China and Russia is simply wrong. I feel offended. Piracy is everywhere and it will always exist. But you can buy all legit dvds, music here. I will suggest to the US government that they clean up their own backyard first and deal with obvious monopoly in movie and music industry. Business is entitled to profits, afterall that what making business is all about, but monopoly creates "excessive profits" and movie and music industry makes excessive profits. Simple as that. They want to diminish piracy. Lower prices. Simple as that. Instead of charing $20 for a movie. Charge $10 etc. and the problem will go away by itself.
 
Canada's chronic failure to modernize its copyright regime has made it a global hub for bootleg movies, pirated software and tiny microchips that allow video-game users to bypass copyright protections, the International Intellectual Property Alliance complains in a submission to the U.S. government.
As you might expect, this turns out to be a big steaming pile of bullshit.
 
This is defintely one time that Canada should tell the US to F***-OFF. :mad:
 
So when are they going to blacklist Mexico. I mean come on...all the illegals draining our social welfare programs over here is many more billions than any stolen IP from Canada, China, and Russia combined.
 
Fine!

This is a list of Canadian invention/things that Canada wants back:

-Blackberry
-Squarehead screws
-Canadarm
-Boat propellers
-Zipper
-Poutine
-The Montreal Expos
-Wonderbra
-Standard 24 hour day
-Plexiglass
-ATI Technology
-AA batteries
-Basketball
-Telephone
-Snowblower
-Paint Roller

The USA will have 72 hours to give that back to Canada.

In all seriousness, I'm not serious :D

But still, this is a load of BS.

You forgot Stargate.
 
WWWWWhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Keep Crying the river :p
 
tiny microchips that allow video-game users to bypass copyright protections

Oh no, tiny microchips... good thing they aren't macrochips, people might spot macrochips easier.

I like people who do that, describe something, and call it the same thing as they described.

I want an LCD Display! Liquid Crystal Display Display!
 
WWWWWhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Keep Crying the river :p

wahhmbulance1dd0.jpg
 
Seriously, how will they do that? Politically impossible to do. It's like telling your brother he's out of the familly.

I love this country.
 
i love how modchips are targeted....hmmm the modchip i bought for my xbox doesn't allow me to play "pirated" games....only once a person alters the bios with a 3rd party - NOT DEFAULT - bios...and if anyone from those agencies actually did research on what they're saying, they may find that their stats are a little off on most things...

i'd like to know how a country with the population of canada could possibly be "exporting" the amount they're talking about...

as of 2005 StatsCan has canada's official population at 32,623,490 (only about 10 times the size of LA!!!!)....thats only a few of the major cities in the US....and your telling me that we're one of the "world leaders" in piracy....that would mean an ALARMING percentage of our population is HEAVILY involved in this illegal activity...:rolleyes: again, do some freaking research.

ARREST HARPER - I HEAR THE GOVERNMENT OFFICES IN OTTAWA HAVE BLAZING FAST CONNECTIONS! :D

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_population_of_Canada_by_years

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Los_Angeles - 3,844,829 (as of 2005)

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/New_York_City - 8,143,197 (as of 2005)

http://www.infoplease.com/ipa/A0762524.html - check this out....GO MUMBAI!!! the one city is a little under half of Canada's TOTAL population....again, research!!! the top 5 countries listed make up over 50 MILLION people....thats a few more than Canada has....
 
Oh please, how f'n stupid are these people, RIAA and MPAA included, they are out their damn mind for thinking this will work. The riaa and mpaa are failing on every front. Movies are being downloaded all over the world at an amazing rate, more songs will be downloaded everytime these fools try to sue someone. You have silly companies like viacom removing thousands of videos on Youtube a day. for what?

How does a music video on youtube which cannot be downloaded for personal use affect viacoms revenue? Matter fact it helps them by promoting artists since no one watches videos on VHI ,BET and MTV anymore, Im guessing the number of music video watchers online at Youtube suprasses the number of people who watch videos on VHI, BET, and mtv combined. These people are all dumb if you ask them, their like selfish babies who get mad when you touch their play toy. Also these guys are truely living in the stone age if they cant figure out cheaper digital distribution is the key.

Oh yeah, plus HD and Blue Ray have already been officially hacked.. hahahah
 
haha... Canada is simply adamant about human rights and freedoms. If the RIAA and movie industry had their way, they would be running a Big Brother 1984-esque world.
But again, the people in these companies are not bright. But rather more along the lines of greedy.
 
Show me sales figures to point out that sales are half from normal in Canada because of it's CONSUMER PROTECTING legislation.

The fact will be that sales are perfectly on the level in Canada despite leaving freedom to consumers. As it has been everywhere else. Nobody has ever managed to prove a relationship between increased sales and DRM technology usage anywhere. And they wont - simply because people who pirate would never buy the product at it's full cartel price anyway.
 
You can literally go to china and buy burned movies off the street!

You can literally go to a Times Square street corner and buy burned movies off the street!

I find it hard to believe poor quality cam recordings from Montreal is the root of declining cinema attendance. Perhaps look towards the high fees, lousy movies and the nazi staff not allowing movie goers the ability to bring in their own drinks or snacks. Going to the movies is no longer "fun".
 
If Canada is such a concern for piracy then why is Blockbuster making money in Canada, and losing money in the US? :confused:

Oh that's right, it's not about Canadians buying fakes or reducing consumption it's about Americans doing so and the RIAA and MPAA looking for someone to blame. :rolleyes:

Heck if they had any real influence in the US gov't then we'd have US troops up here like they have down in Columbia.

I guess it's all those failed US lawsuits, they've decided to use the money to try and buy-off st00pid politicians rather than train their members in economics and start selling Movie tickets and DVDs for reasonable prices. :mad:

It's only the threat of piracy that keeps things even at their almost reasonable level right now, otherwise we'd all be paying $50 per DVD, and $20 per movie. Cracking BR and HD-DVD is another good step towards the balance of pricing power. :cool:
 
This is mostly about the fact that it is 100% perfectly legal to not only download music in Canada but also to copy your music CDs for your friends.

Now some of you might think that makes no sense! I mean, OBVIOUSLY it's a violation of copyrights... RIGHT?!

Well, back when CD burners were becoming popular the music producers decided they wanted a cut of the profits from all these CDs being copied. To be honest, they were right in that argument. So, they went to the government and bribed whatever official was in charge at the time.

I'm not sure what the current rates are, but here are the 2004 values... (P.S. Pay attention to their proposed rates, some of them are quite hilarious. If they had their way that 80GB iPod would have a $1700 levy on it.)
Code:
Medium				Current				Proposed
				2003-2004			2003-2004
				levy 				levy 
Audio cassettes 40 
minutes or more in length	29¢ each 			60¢ each

CD-Rs and CD-RWs		21¢ each			59¢

CD-R Audio, CD-RW 
Audio and MiniDisc		77¢ each			$1.23 

Removable electronic memory
card, removable flash memory
storage medium of any type,
or removable micro-hard drive	no levy				0.8¢ per megabyte

DVD-R, DVD-RW, DVD+RW, 
DVD-RAM or any other 
type of recordable or 
rewritable DVD			no levy				$2.27 each

Non-removable memory (memory
of any kind including hard
drive or flash memory)
permanently embedded in
a digital audio recorder
that can record no more than
1 gigabyte of data		$2 per recorder			$21 maximum (2.1¢ per megabyte)

Non-removable memory (memory
of any kind including hard
drive or flash memory)
permanently embedded in
a digital audio recorder
that can record no more than
10 gigabytes of data		$15 per recorder		$210 maximum (2.1¢ per megabyte)

Non-removable memory (memory
of any kind including hard
drive or flash memory)
permanently embedded in
a digital audio recorder
that can record more than
10 gigabytes of data		$25 per recorder		over $210 (2.1¢ per megabyte)

So, in fact, they get paid EVERY time a Canadian buys a CD-R, MP3 Player, etc. Then they turn around and try to sue some Canadians for downloading music. Unfortunately for them their previous scam backfires on them and some judge bitch-slaps them into submission.

Now, apparently, we're "pirates" because they only get paid once for their product. Boo-$#!#ing-hoo.



On a side note...

If a copyrighted product is legally obtained in one country, then brought to the U.S., it is still legal, even if the way it was obtained would be illegal in the U.S.

Wouldn't that mean that you could have your Canadian friends make you any music CD you want and simply mail it to you in the U.S.? There is no restrictions on transfer of MP3...
 
yeah blacklist canada....delay new movies from coming to us, go for it i dare them. watch the piracy shoot through the roof then.

on a side note, if a GOOD movie comes out (rare now) i myself and everyone i know will pay to see it in the theater. so how about making some good flicks for a change? nothing worse than paying over $10 to see a movie and feeling ripped off.
 
Whats funny is that as much as they want to do that, they can't. Canada supplies us it's Uranium, Lumber, and Power.

It would be cutting your leg off to spite your foot.


Oh and what I find interesting as well... who does the recording industry think they are going to get support from? Us? HAHAHAHHAA that will be the frosty Friday.
 
Is this story even factually true? When I think pirate I think Singapore. :rolleyes:
 
How does a music video on youtube which cannot be downloaded for personal use affect viacoms revenue? Matter fact it helps them by promoting artists since no one watches videos on VHI ,BET and MTV anymore, Im guessing the number of music video watchers online at Youtube suprasses the number of people who watch videos on VHI, BET, and mtv combined.

They'll tell you "we don't get to sell advertising on youtube, which we do on VH1 and BET and MTV." Balls to that I say, it's an economy based on litigation and advertising. Advertising is incredible. During the superbowl, it costs millions of dollars to play a mini-movie - they don't even advertise! millions of dollars to basically say "look at me".

Anyways, they blacklist us, we keep the oil they were going to use to power their Hummers?
 
I'd shed some light on the real reason :

I read on newspapers recently that it's in Canada that it's easiest for ppl to go to a movie theater with a camcorder, rip the movie then distribute around. There are numerous complaints from the USA on this issue and asking the canadian government to do something. That's the only thing which explain this...
 
thats a total steaming pile, how is it easier in canada to cam a movie? should we start patting people down in the theater? do they do that down in US movie theaters? its easy anywhere if the staff/management is lazy enough.
 
its all those frenchies and their piracy. such an arrogant bunch... build the wall around quebec, fill the fucker with water. problem solved!
 
I'd actually have zero problem paying these, and heftier levies if they would just do that, then say, download all you want. As they would then collect all of their monies, not from the download of legal content, but the sale of legal discs. I'm sure some online retailers wouldn't agree, but they would go from 15% of the population that burns discs paying for legal music/movies, to 85% of disc buyers unavoidably paying.

If a CDR was $2, but I could download and burn whatever I wanted without fear of legal reprieve, I would do that in a heartbeat. Same with movies, make a DVD-R $4 and give me legal portals to download, and I'm there.

Is it too far fetched!!!


This is mostly about the fact that it is 100% perfectly legal to not only download music in Canada but also to copy your music CDs for your friends.

Now some of you might think that makes no sense! I mean, OBVIOUSLY it's a violation of copyrights... RIGHT?!

Well, back when CD burners were becoming popular the music producers decided they wanted a cut of the profits from all these CDs being copied. To be honest, they were right in that argument. So, they went to the government and bribed whatever official was in charge at the time.

I'm not sure what the current rates are, but here are the 2004 values... (P.S. Pay attention to their proposed rates, some of them are quite hilarious. If they had their way that 80GB iPod would have a $1700 levy on it.)
Code:
Medium				Current				Proposed
				2003-2004			2003-2004
				levy 				levy 
Audio cassettes 40 
minutes or more in length	29¢ each 			60¢ each

CD-Rs and CD-RWs		21¢ each			59¢

CD-R Audio, CD-RW 
Audio and MiniDisc		77¢ each			$1.23 

Removable electronic memory
card, removable flash memory
storage medium of any type,
or removable micro-hard drive	no levy				0.8¢ per megabyte

DVD-R, DVD-RW, DVD+RW, 
DVD-RAM or any other 
type of recordable or 
rewritable DVD			no levy				$2.27 each

Non-removable memory (memory
of any kind including hard
drive or flash memory)
permanently embedded in
a digital audio recorder
that can record no more than
1 gigabyte of data		$2 per recorder			$21 maximum (2.1¢ per megabyte)

Non-removable memory (memory
of any kind including hard
drive or flash memory)
permanently embedded in
a digital audio recorder
that can record no more than
10 gigabytes of data		$15 per recorder		$210 maximum (2.1¢ per megabyte)

Non-removable memory (memory
of any kind including hard
drive or flash memory)
permanently embedded in
a digital audio recorder
that can record more than
10 gigabytes of data		$25 per recorder		over $210 (2.1¢ per megabyte)

So, in fact, they get paid EVERY time a Canadian buys a CD-R, MP3 Player, etc. Then they turn around and try to sue some Canadians for downloading music. Unfortunately for them their previous scam backfires on them and some judge bitch-slaps them into submission.

Now, apparently, we're "pirates" because they only get paid once for their product. Boo-$#!#ing-hoo.



On a side note...

If a copyrighted product is legally obtained in one country, then brought to the U.S., it is still legal, even if the way it was obtained would be illegal in the U.S.

Wouldn't that mean that you could have your Canadian friends make you any music CD you want and simply mail it to you in the U.S.? There is no restrictions on transfer of MP3...
 
Oh no, tiny microchips... good thing they aren't macrochips, people might spot macrochips easier.

I like people who do that, describe something, and call it the same thing as they described.

I want an LCD Display! Liquid Crystal Display Display!

Then go to your local ATM Machine and get some money or, utilize your NIC Card to buy an LCD Display over the Interwebnetubes :D
 
Blacklist all of Canada ... now that sounds like a real thought out plan. Nothing like punishing everyone for the trespasses of a few.

Ok lets make a deal then. Canada will shut off all oil and natural gas in retaliation, because after all we are bound to screw over this group, amongst the millions of others who will be affected.
 
I'd actually have zero problem paying these, and heftier levies if they would just do that, then say, download all you want. As they would then collect all of their monies, not from the download of legal content, but the sale of legal discs. I'm sure some online retailers wouldn't agree, but they would go from 15% of the population that burns discs paying for legal music/movies, to 85% of disc buyers unavoidably paying.

If a CDR was $2, but I could download and burn whatever I wanted without fear of legal reprieve, I would do that in a heartbeat. Same with movies, make a DVD-R $4 and give me legal portals to download, and I'm there.

Is it too far fetched!!!

I agree, if they did this they would make a ton more money than selling crappy music or media.

Heck, I think what they should do is do what france is doing (or proposing) a $14 a month fee and you can pirate all you want.
 
Back
Top