GPU Upgrade with a limit (Wife...grrr)

mt_100

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jan 15, 2006
Messages
342
My wife has said I can upgrade my graphics card to a new one but I have a HARD $110 limit. That includes shipping.

My current card is a MSI 3850 256mb OC and my monitor is a 19" 1280x1024 and I game at that resolution or 1024x768 if I have to. Although I love to game I am not hard core, just a hobby.

So, with the price limit I have two choices. The ATI 4830 or the NVidia 9800GT. I have owned ATI for a long time and have had anything to do with NVidia for quite a bit, although it isn't a dislike, just always bought ATI.

I was thinking the Sapphire or HIS 4830 and then OC it a little per the Guru3D article here http://guru3d.com/article/radeon-hd-4830-review-his-technology/14 to get a bit more performance out of it. Although to be honest, I don't OC anything on my system.

Rest of my system specs are in sig. Running XP.

Thoughts?
 
I feel for you. I wanted to get a huge monitor but the wife's belief in Feng Shui resulted in just a 24" that is SMALLER than the 22" she gave the green light to and I am still getting grief about that.

Could you not sell another toy if you want a better vid card?
 
I put her by the curb with a sign that said $100 but no one stopped.


I could sell the 3850 for $50 or so to add to the money but she was already banking on that happening. I have a nice 160GB SATA HD and almost new QPack case I could potentially sell too. I guess if I did so the choice for me is the 4850 but honestly, too much of a hastle selling stuff.
 
Either one of those would be a good choice and performance is pretty similar. How does your wife feel about mail in rebates? You'll be hard pressed to get either one for $110 shipping included without a $20 MIR.
 
This is the second one so I guess I can't choose well! Kidding, she just says I have too many toys.

Tell her this is the way it is man! Then go treat yourself to a 260 maxcore or 280!:) This is srius business!
 
Nuts. OK, the limit INCLUDES selling the 3850, hate it when she is on the other computer watching me. I love her, and she knows I need limits ;)

So, I figure I can get $50 for a used 3850 without too much hassle and she is letting me add $65 to it for $115 after any rebates.

I know the 4850 is a great card, really, but after rebates they are still $130 and a mildly OD'd 4830 will keep up nicely. I figure the same for a 9800 GT.

The reason for the limit is because she also knows I will need a CPU upgrade down the road as my 4600+ X2 is older and I want to drop a 5600 or 6000 in the system so that will cost a bit of coin as well. I know $20 isn't a lot of money but really, I don't like spending more if I don't have to when I know the CPU is also an issue.

So, of the three choices?
 
The 4830 is over priced right now because it was just launched. What's worse, paying $20 more for the 4850 or $20 too much for a 4830?
 
What game is the 3850 not enough for you?
You said you're a lite hobby gamer. The other thing you can do keep your eye out for a deal on the 4850. They've been down to $129AR I think so you're only $15 away there. Black Friday is coming. If you can wait it out do so
 
So far all the games I play have been fine. Currently playing the Painkiller series and finished FEAR. Here is a lost of games I will be getting soon though. (Some not quite released yet)

Call Of Duty World At War
F.E.A.R. Perseus Mandate
F.E.A.R 2 Project Origin
Gears of War
Far Cry
Far Cry 2
Gears of War 2
Mercenaries 2
Left 4 Dead (Not released)
Hitman 5 (Not released)
Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Conviction (Not released)
 
If you could just pay a little more you can get the HD4850.
eeek.gif
ecstatic.gif
 
Do what I do and have a buddy order it, then give him the cash when you get the card. Think my wife would have OK'd a GTX280 for my Christmas gift ??

BaHAHAHAha .. Santa was very good to me this year.
 
Of the three - I'd probably stick my neck out and try the Galaxy if it were me. Looks like a good cooling solution and you can easily get that 35 Mhz overclock that the BFG has and more with it (if they include and OCing software app with it I'm sure they expect their customers to do more). Plus its a bit cheaper. Plus there's a Galaxy U.S. sales rep that hangs around the forums. Probably could get assistance if you ever need it from him.

The HD 4830 is compelling. I'm just somewhat leery of the current gen of ATI products. Have heard so many horror stories about driver incompatibilities, heat issues, micro-stuttering and large dips between high and low FPS in some games. It could be I just notice those posts more since ATI seems to be generating the most sales and interest at the moment. It probably is slightly faster on average at stock speeds.
 
I see it like this.As long as the bills are all paid and you have money left over as extra then buy whatever friggin card you want.Seriously I am sure she buys stuff for herself.

My wife did the same thing a while ago,I started spending and told her I dont give a shit about money.I may not have alot but as long as we have heat,a roof over our head I am gonna spend it like I got it.
 
I posted this thought in another thread. Wait for the Holidays to pass, pricing holds and is high from Late Sept., until after Xmas or the New Year. And this year with the economy and poor Xmas sales expected, discounts and price drops will no doubt happen. Wait for some eight weeks or less and the card may meet your budget or less.
 
Ahem perhaps the coveted wife 1.0 to girlfriend 0.95 downgrade is in order. that way you can justify upgrading one thing while downgrading another. its the responsible thing to do.
 
She dosen't understand that it's an insult to buy a $100 GPU, then buying $50 games that you can't play.

Sell more stuff, and get a GTX 260 216 Core and have some fun. ;)
 
I think you should similarly scrutinize HER personal purchases for a while. See how much is going out and for what. Might give you a bargaining chip or two. ;)
 
ya point out the difference in shoes expenses alone for the past year or two and see if she has the same stance on your computer purchases
 
Can you wait for a little bit longer? I mean, do you have to have it now? I'm sure that either A. the price of the good cards will be cheap as hell by the start of the new year and B. There might be some mad sales either for black friday or christmas.
Also, is Xfire out of the picture? Not that it'd be amazingly better, but it's something.
 
The OP's monitor only displays up to 1280x1024, so I think the gtx 260 and crossfire seem a bit wasted there.
 
Mail-in rebates are OK.

Here are the cards I am looking at


4830 (Actually a Powercolor)
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814131129

9800GT (BFG OC version)
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814143154
Or....(Never heard of this one)
http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16814162017

for real its not worth the 30 dollars saved for a crippled gpu (that is what the 4830 is BTW) The 9800GT is in the same boat, have you considered a used card? you can usually pick up a 4850 for a hundred.
 
So far all the games I play have been fine. Currently playing the Painkiller series and finished FEAR. Here is a lost of games I will be getting soon though. (Some not quite released yet)

Call Of Duty World At War
F.E.A.R. Perseus Mandate
F.E.A.R 2 Project Origin
Gears of War
Far Cry
Far Cry 2
Gears of War 2
Mercenaries 2
Left 4 Dead (Not released)
Hitman 5 (Not released)
Tom Clancy's Splinter Cell: Conviction (Not released)
I'm playing most of those on an 8800GTS 640 at 1280*1024 and everything runs fine.
So a 4830/4850 will be great for those. If you're looking for longetivity the 4850 will suit you better.
 
I say jump into the FS thread and buy a used video card. Unless it has to be new
 
I feel for you. I wanted to get a huge monitor but the wife's belief in Feng Shui resulted in just a 24" that is SMALLER than the 22" she gave the green light to and I am still getting grief about that.

Could you not sell another toy if you want a better vid card?

This sucks. I was going to post a link to a video of Penn & Teller Bullshit: Feng Shui / Bottled Water so you could show it to your wife.

Now all I can do is post the imdb site and hope you will aquire this episode yourself.
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0672530/
 
Go on strike until she allows you.

Or find another part time job, work for 1-2 weeks, and voila, you've got enough for a 4870!
 
Back
Top