Gotta have those elves pretty...

fhey

Limp Gawd
Joined
Jul 5, 2005
Messages
152
Greetings all.

I was curious to see which particular component is holding me back - CPU vs GPU.

Current Build:
Proc: Opty 165 running at 2.7 Ghz on air
GPU: eVGA 7900GT CO PCI-E 256MB
RAM: 2 Gigs
Mobo: DFI Lanparty UT NForce4 Ultra- D
HDD: 150G Raptor 10kRPM 16MB Cache
PS: Antec true power2 ATX2.0 550W
OS: Vista SP1 Ultimate 32bit

Now - I can of course upgrade the GPU - was looking at:
EVGA 512-P3-N884-AR GeForce 9800 GTX+ Superclocked Edition 512MB 256-bit GDDR3 PCI Express 2.0 x16 HDCP Ready SLI

The CPU is of course much harder since it's already dual-core, stable at 2.7 and the hardest part - S939 which means new MB/CPU/RAM which may be outside my interest range considering I don't PC Game near as much anymore.

I did however for some odd reason start playing Lord of the Rings Online lately and hooked up to a 1280x1024 I can't max the graphics without some very ugly hitches. I mostly have it at second highest and it's "mostly" smooth. Enough to play at least. I am however a graphics whore somewhat.

I was curious if moving from the 7900GT 256 to the superclocked 9800GTX 512 would allow for a smooth run on the highest settings of LOTRO. Additionally I'm very interested in enabling the DX10 features of the game - which the 7900 unfortunately doesn't support.

My reason for doubt comes from glancing at the Vista Experience Index (an idiotic thing to use to tell you about your hardware, I know). I'm 5.9 on all the scores except the CPU which is at 5.2.

Is it my CPU bottlenecking me here? (That'd be a shame since it's been a wonderful piece of hardware) Or will the GPU still grant me a significant performance increase in this game?

I'm not currently playing any other PC games than that - though I'll play Diablo 3 whenever (ifever) it comes out. Possibly Battlefield 3 (again ifever) it comes out. So it's mainly maxing out LOTRO that I'm interested in here.

Additionally - any idea if my Power Supply can handle the 9800GTX I listed? I'll research more on this - but was hoping for some feedback on that as well.

Any ideas?

Oh.. and just in case the "haven't answered the build advice question police" come, the answers to the stickied questions follow


1) What will you be doing with this PC? Gaming? Photoshop? Web browsing? etc
Gaming, LOTRO. Media Center - sending Amazon Unbox / other videos using Vista's Media Center to Xbox.

2) What's your budget? Are tax and shipping included?
Sub-$200

3) Where do you live?
Rural MN


4) What exact parts do you need for that budget? CPU, RAM, case, etc. Please be very specific.
Hopefully just GPU - if CPU/RAM/Mobo - then beyond my current interest possibly until tax rebate time comes.

5) If reusing any parts, what parts will you be reusing? Please be especially specific about the power supply. List make and model.
Reusing everything listed above except hopefully video card

6) Will you be overclocking?
CPU - casually, GPU - nothing that's not automated.

7) What size monitor do you have or plan to have?
General gaming - 1280x1024 19", occassionally 88" 1600x1200 projector, somewhat rarer 1920x1200 42" HDTV.

8) When do you plan on building/buying the PC?
If Problem = "GPU" Then
Time = Immenently
End If

9) What features do you need in a motherboard? RAID? Firewire? Crossfire or SLI support? etc.
Nothing specific given that I'm not looing for one at the moment, but if you find one that generates money, doesn't argue much and likes long walks on the beach let me know.


10) Do you already have a legit and reusable/transferable OS key/license?
Who's asking?! What have you been told? Whose been talking?!!

ahem

I mean - yes.


Thanks in advance for the help. (Presumptuous I know - but oh well =P )
 
9800GTX is a huge upgrade over the 7900GT. If you want to upgrade your GPU and CPU/mobo/RAM, you'll probably need more like $300 or $400 to spend.
 
8) When do you plan on building/buying the PC?
If Problem = "GPU" Then
Time = Immenently
End If

9) What features do you need in a motherboard? RAID? Firewire? Crossfire or SLI support? etc.
Nothing specific given that I'm not looing for one at the moment, but if you find one that generates money, doesn't argue much and likes long walks on the beach let me know.


10) Do you already have a legit and reusable/transferable OS key/license?
Who's asking?! What have you been told? Whose been talking?!!

ahem

I mean - yes.

Thanks in advance for the help. (Presumptuous I know - but oh well =P )
LOL!:D Funny.

Anyway, see if this helps you out:

[A good way to find out if your GPU or CPU limited]
First drop the resolution to as low as it will go, and turn all settings on low. You may even be able to tweak the game to stop rendering some objects, and really drop the graphics quality. If your frame rates don't improve whatsoever, then your CPU/platfrom is limiting your performance. So you would then know, that upgrading your GPU will not bring that game to playable levels.
However, if you find that by lowering your settings to such a disgusting degree, actually brings the game to a playable level. Then an upgrade of the GPU will let you turn the settings up, and your CPU should remain up to the task.

Oh I would not trust the 98000GTX with that PSU. The Smartpower series were well known for their above average failure rates due to a poor combinations of caps and cooling design. If that PSU is making any sort of whine or squealing sound, I highly recommend RMAing that PSU back to Antec. They'll send you a Earthwatts 500W PSU in return.

BUt just to make it clear though: A good quality 500 to 550W PSU will be enough for that system. But the Smartpowers are NOT good quality.
 
9800GTX is a huge upgrade over the 7900GT. If you want to upgrade your GPU and CPU/mobo/RAM, you'll probably need more like $300 or $400 to spend.

Yeah I was hoping to avoid upgrading the holy 3 (CPU/mobo/RAM) as long as possible, hoping the GPU upgrade would let me float by until something worth overhauling my PC for comes along.
 
Thanks for the replies guys.


LOL!:D Funny.

Anyway, see if this helps you out:

[A good way to find out if your GPU or CPU limited]


Oh I would not trust the 98000GTX with that PSU. The Smartpower series were well known for their above average failure rates due to a poor combinations of caps and cooling design. If that PSU is making any sort of whine or squealing sound, I highly recommend RMAing that PSU back to Antec. They'll send you a Earthwatts 500W PSU in return.

BUt just to make it clear though: A good quality 500 to 550W PSU will be enough for that system. But the Smartpowers are NOT good quality.

I'll try this out when I get home from work tonight - thanks.

Curious, you mention Smartpowers - my PS was a truepower - same thing I'm guessing?

It hasn't made any noises yet - for what it's been given it's done great, but I don't ask alot out of it. Just simply to slave away thanklessly 24/7 =P
 
... Curious, you mention Smartpowers - my PS was a truepower - same thing I'm guessing?

It hasn't made any noises yet - for what it's been given it's done great, but I don't ask alot out of it. Just simply to slave away thanklessly 24/7 =P

Heh, I had nearly the exact same system... Opty165 @ 2.6Ghz, 2GB DDR-500 OCZ Gold, DFI Ultra-D, and the SP-500 (2.0), 7800GT 256MB, WD1500ADFD.

Anyhow, about 2.5 years after it was built, my SP-500 starting whining, and it irritated the hell out of me, so I RMA'd it and was given a NeoPower 500W as the replacement (EA500 isn't modular).

Oh, back to your question... yes, the TP2.0 and SP2.0 lines of PSUs from Antec used the same OEM, ChannelWell Tech. (CWT). These units used the infamous fuhjyyu caps which have a very low tolerance to heat. Combine that with Antec's "smart" fan cooling design and you get a high failure rate for your PSUs. Antec has since learned its lesson and cools their units properly, as well as using Seasonic and Delta for their Earthwatts and Neopower lineups. CWT has also learned its lesson and no longer uses fuhjyyu caps, IIRC.
 
Curious, you mention Smartpowers - my PS was a truepower - same thing I'm guessing?

Enginurd pretty answered that question but yeah same thing. My Smartpower SP-450, after a year and a half of use, began to whine like crazy, long after the PC was OFF. So RMA'd the thing and got a Earthwatts 500W PSU in return. My SP-450 wasn't modular.
 
So... went to turn the computer on today - Wouldn't boot - was a buzzing, left it for a bit.. started to smell smoke. Unplug it - smoke smell goes away.

Talk about being cursed - Powersupply was beautiful for years - find out it wasn't the best PS - it immediately stops working. That's.. uncanny...

I'd left it running for - probably close to a year minus power outtages - first time I intentionally shut it off - go to work.. it won't boot back up.

Time to see what the warranty was like on this thing.
 
Ouch, sorry to hear that the PSU died. Luckily the PSU has a three year warranty.
 
 
Intel alternatives would be the...
Gigabyte GA-EP43-DS3L for $80, and the
Intel Pentium Dual-Core E5200 for $80 (or E5400 if you can find it for the same price)
Same RAM as hossdaddy listed.
 
Hmmm. I really didn't want to do a rebuild - but starting to really think about it.

I'm admittedly prejudiced toward the nvidia side - I know I know, for some reason I just have a hard time not buying evga/nvidia - which seems to point at the superclocked 9800GTX being the best performance for the price - given that the 260s are still in the 200 range.

Starting to research the motherboard/cpu/ram combos - thinking I'm liking the intels this gen - but not having luck on finding the E5400 series.

As for power supply I saw Corsair 750W TX Series. Saw the 650 listed in another thread - and the 750 was only slightly more.

Trying to find as much stuff as I can on Amazon - normally I'm a patron of newegg - but I'm on a trial of Amazon Prime meaning shipping is insanely cheap.

I still love my HDD and will keep that, I have an antec P180 case I'll reuse. Same with my optical drives. Could wish I could keep my Scythe Ninja Heatsink - it was such a beauty in its monstrocity.

Thanks for the suggestions guys - I'll be skimming the other posts in the interrum trying to find a combination of performance / price - re-researching socket types pin counts and all the wonderful stuff I've let go over the years.

If you have any other suggestions I'll happily look em over. I'll be trying to figure something out by tomorrow morning. Hate to be so hasty, but I'd like to try an assembly by the weekend.
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
You can keep the Ninja... if it came with the mounts. I use a ninja in my mom's system, and it works great. Since you already have it, you might as well re-use it. If you need mounting hardware, contact Scythe support. If you want a backplate, the Thermalright LGA775 Bolt-thru kit will work, but you'll need a screwdriver longer than 7 inches. ;)

The E5400 was newly released (monday), so I guess it'll take some time to reach everyone.
 
Alright - here is what I've come up with so far.

RAM: $58.99 $30 rebate $28.99 CORSAIR XMS2 4GB ( 2 X 2GB ) PC2-6400 800MHz 240-pin DDR2 CL5 Dual Channel Desktop Memory Kit - TWIN2X4096-6400C5
MB: $79.99 GIGABYTE GA-EP43-DS3L LGA 775 Intel P43 ATX Intel Motherboard - Retail
CPU: $164.50 Intel Core 2 Duo E8400 3.0 GHz 6M L2 Cache 1333MHz FSB LGA775 Dual-Core Processor
PS: $114.49 $20 rebate $94.49 CORSAIR 750w TX Series 80 Plus Certified Power Supply
GPU: $159.99 $20 rebate $139.99 EVGA 512-P3-N884-AR GeForce 9800 GTX+ Superclocked Edition 512MB 256-bit GDDR3 PCI Express 2.0 x16 HDCP Ready SLI

So - $585.96 up front - $70 in mail in rebates - yech
$37.03 overnight on the gpu/mb from newegg
$11.97 overnight on the rest from amazon

I'd appreciate any thoughts.
I'd especially appreciate any thoughts about my post =P
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
Hrmm kept the same parts - but added Vista 64 bit ult - decided to upgrade to that too - use the old version for the remnants of the old comp.

However changing things around, if I get same cpu bundled with vista through newegg instead of amazon I get $50 off up front for combining them - which brings the overall price down. Additionally supposedly a $50 gift card with that version of Vista in the form of a rebate.

Should be around $766.44 shipped with $70 in rebates and another $50 giftcard in rebate.
 
You could use Windows 7 Beta until August for free, then wait for official release instead of buying vista. You can try Vista for free for 30 days, btw. From the people I've spoken to, their win.7 setups run just as stable as their Vista systems -- heard its pretty good for a beta rls.

$60 up front for 4GB?!?!? I'd simply get the G.Skill from Newegg for $40 and no rebate instead. Rebates are never guaranteed. The PC Power & Cooling 750W QUAD Crossfire is on sale for $100 w/ $15 MIR... saves you an additional $15, or $10AR.
 
You could use Windows 7 Beta until August for free, then wait for official release instead of buying vista. You can try Vista for free for 30 days, btw. From the people I've spoken to, their win.7 setups run just as stable as their Vista systems -- heard its pretty good for a beta rls.

$60 up front for 4GB?!?!? I'd simply get the G.Skill from Newegg for $40 and no rebate instead. Rebates are never guaranteed. The PC Power & Cooling 750W QUAD Crossfire is on sale for $100 w/ $15 MIR... saves you an additional $15, or $10AR.

Yeah, I thought about the win7 beta thing - but I figured if I get Vista now - I can get the upgrade version of 7 when it hits in - well... whenever - guessing August or September myself.

I've tried the beta a bit, I threw it on my secondary comp at work - and found a few things that don't work with it yet that makes it hard to use for me at work - at home - I simply wasn't sure if it'd work with LOTRO or not - though I guess I can run some quick google searches on that.

But overall it gets me another copy of vista ult - this time 64 bit, which I use and love at work. Was $179 - $50 instant rebate at newegg for having bundled it with a CPU I was buying anyway - another $50 in a supposed gift card - but even without that $129 is a fair price for an OS I love.

Assumption of course being that there will be an upgrade version of win7 but either way, I'll gamble.

As for the RAM I'll definitely take a look - I'm not a huge fan of rebates really. Will try and get a build ready this morn.
 
Well - ended up doing the entire thing through newegg - Amazon had an unexpectedly strange definition of overnight - somehow it meant '5 days'.

Kept the PowerSupply corsair 750 - but went with the Gskill RAM instead. Further reading on the corsair was yielding too many bad reviews - though you can find bad reviews on anything so... oh well.

For better or worse it's all done - now just have to somehow get the order by the weekend and hope there's no DoAs

I appreciate the help guys. It only ended up being a good $500 beyond what I wanted to spend =P Went from a question to pretty much new guts of the comp in slightly less than 48 hours... go impulsiveness. *sigh*

The ironic part will be when I end up getting bored and quiting LOTRO in a week or two. *sigh* I wish I was kidding.
 
lolz! make sure u post pics pls! GL and remember to take the plastic off the bottom of the cpu cooler!! =p My buddy did that and he is a seasoned veteran builder, and couldnt figure out why the cpu hit 90c in 30 secs and shut off!! :p
 
If the bulk of those reviews are from NewEgg, ignore them. The long story short is that many (if not most) of those reviews are written by people who have no clue of what they're talking about. Trust the reviews given by hardware review sites and forums -- people there will tell you exactly what's wrong -- and in detail.

If you really want to, however, we can help you cut corners on you buil-- er, upgrade. Just tell us which things you can't live without (... we'll just try to convince you otherwise ;) ).
 
The Corsair unit is a great PSU. There were... what, 40+ bad reviews out of the 500+ good reviews? :p Not to mention all the people that were so happy with their PSU that they didn't even bother to post a review since it worked right out of the box... I'm pretty sure the failure rate is low on them. Even if you do get one thats DOA, just RMA it.
 
Well, seem to have hit a snag. All the parts came finally - after the wonder of having an entire airport close - so much for Overnight shipping.

Assembling the pieces - get it all together. No dice on boot. LEDs light up - fans kick in, phase lights show green,green, amber, red - which I'm still trying to find the meaning of. Very nice to put LEDs on motherboard. Not so nice not to tell you in manual what they mean.

More concerning is I'm starting to wonder if I ordered the wrong parts. The motherboard's manual states that you need to plug in the 4 pin 12ATXv by the CPU for the computer to boot. Well, I've found the 24 pin ATX and plugged that into the MB of course, but I've been over this PowerSupply 8 billion times and not finding a 4 pin molex.

I'm stripping it down and trying to boot it off a box - perhaps reseat the power supply - but I'm wondering if I screwed up and bought a power supply not meant for this MB - which I really didn't think was the case - but well... she's not working.

Any ideas?
 
More concerning is I'm starting to wonder if I ordered the wrong parts. The motherboard's manual states that you need to plug in the 4 pin 12ATXv by the CPU for the computer to boot. Well, I've found the 24 pin ATX and plugged that into the MB of course, but I've been over this PowerSupply 8 billion times and not finding a 4 pin molex.

On the 750TX, look for a 8Pin connector that can be broken up into two 4Pin connectors. There's your 4Pin CPU connector.
 
thankyouthankyouthankyouthankyouthankyouthankyouthankyou

*cough*

it posts... back to configuring

thank you =P
 
hehe no pics yet - not quite done, stuck on installation. The hardware all seems to be working, but can't get Vista 64 to actually go on the Internet - so she's still in pieces.

Updated the motherboard's drivers, reinstalled vista, tried setting static IPs, reset all the networking equip - modem and the router (DGL-4300). Swapped cords - confirmed cord works with another vista PC (laptop) - 3 machines running off network equip on Internet successfully.

Simply cannot get past "Access: Local Only" It won't even ping the router. Trying to figure out if I've got a hardware problem with the motherboard - or if Vista is just being insane.

Been googling for about 4 hours but finding some pretty screwy "solutions" from people who don't really know what they're talking about - people offering things I've already tried - or things that simply don't apply - such as uninstalling anti-virus - since it's a blank HDD with fresh OEM installation of vista ult 64 and the mobo's drivers - there's no 3rd party software getting in the way.

If I go insane soon and smash the thing to bits I'll take pictures of that =P Otherwise gotta make sure I have working parts before making her pretty =/
 
Nothing pretty - used my old Antec P180 case from my previous build 3 years ago. She was once pretty - but not so much anymore. It's what's inside that counts right?
 
Nothing pretty - used my old Antec P180 case from my previous build 3 years ago. She was once pretty - but not so much anymore. It's what's inside that counts right?

Yeah, that's fine. Although I hear the newer P180 are better, but I don't remember why...
 
Hrmm well - typing from it now.. bypassed the router straight to the cable modem and rebooted it - she went. Now the fun of trying to get the router to accept it. On the latest firmware, but maybe I have to downdate it to an older version.

It's a shame - it's been such a nice router... though if this comment is anything like the one that made my power supply explode earlier in the thread I'll have to replace this soon alas.
 
lol, gl, hope the worst is over. :p don't forget pics.

newer P180's are better because of the wire management features... minor updates in the design. ;)
 
Back
Top