Google's iPhone Tracking

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Can we just go ahead and amend Google's damn mantra to "Don't get caught being evil" and call it good? That way, when they get busted doing this kind of stuff, no one is surprised.

The companies used special computer code that tricks Apple's Safari Web-browsing software into letting them monitor many users. Safari, the most widely used browser on mobile devices, is designed to block such tracking by default. Google disabled its code after being contacted by The Wall Street Journal.
 
No one is going to take a shot at the whole "Safari the most used browser on mobile devices" comment? No one!?!?
 
*Yawn*

They all do this. Who cares. Get over it.

The prevalence of evil doesn't actually make evil acceptable or justified. If anything, it's an argument in favor of preventative measures to keep every single web browsing characteristic from becoming a quantified metric that can be sold to advertisers.
 
That makes it all ok?

The prevalence of evil doesn't actually make evil acceptable or justified. If anything, it's an argument in favor of preventative measures to keep every single web browsing characteristic from becoming a quantified metric that can be sold to advertisers.

This is the digital world we live in. The Internet is monetized by tracking users to show relevant ads. How do you think Apple iAds works or Bing or Facebook or Twitter? Guess, what...if you're using the [H] right now and not blocking ads you're being tracked in some way.

The articles out about this whole "controversy" even state that Google isn't the only company who's supposedly "bypassed" Safari's so called "security". Yet, Google is the only one in the frying pan. Nobody can actually prove Google did this on purpose because we don't have the source code for Safari or Google's code. This is all he said - she said bullshit that's getting almost as bad as patent trolling.

Bottom line is this: They all track us. At this point does it really matter anymore? This isn't going away. Facebook is about to make a lot of people filthy rich overnight and all they do is track everything you do. It's their whole business model just like...wait for it: Google and so many others.

I'm not saying it's right, but at some point people just need to fucking accept it and move on. It's not like their stealing your bank account information or sending your home address to banks and mortgage companies so you get a pile of shit Bulk Rate Mail. They just want to show you an ad for Dr. Scholl's because you were at the Walgreen's website and purchased a set of shoe liners. I guess some people are scared they'll get ads for Debbie Does Dallas on BluRay or something because Google saw them go to a pr0n site. :eek:
 
This is the digital world we live in. The Internet is monetized by tracking users to show relevant ads. How do you think Apple iAds works or Bing or Facebook or Twitter? Guess, what...if you're using the [H] right now and not blocking ads you're being tracked in some way.

The articles out about this whole "controversy" even state that Google isn't the only company who's supposedly "bypassed" Safari's so called "security". Yet, Google is the only one in the frying pan. Nobody can actually prove Google did this on purpose because we don't have the source code for Safari or Google's code. This is all he said - she said bullshit that's getting almost as bad as patent trolling.

Bottom line is this: They all track us. At this point does it really matter anymore? This isn't going away. Facebook is about to make a lot of people filthy rich overnight and all they do is track everything you do. It's their whole business model just like...wait for it: Google and so many others.

I'm not saying it's right, but at some point people just need to fucking accept it and move on. It's not like their stealing your bank account information or sending your home address to banks and mortgage companies so you get a pile of shit Bulk Rate Mail. They just want to show you an ad for Dr. Scholl's because you were at the Walgreen's website and purchased a set of shoe liners. I guess some people are scared they'll get ads for Debbie Does Dallas on BluRay or something because Google saw them go to a pr0n site. :eek:

You have too much trust for corporations.
 
As I said in the other post, this is the exact reason/scenario why I don't trust Google with my personal information and avoid most google services like the plague.

Everyone knows that they track users, that's the business that they're in and alot of users are okay with that... it is what it is (to each their own). What bothers me is that they actually used an exploit to get around a privacy setting in the browser to track users anyway without their consent. Not only does that toe the line of unethical, it's borderline criminal IMO. While it's not necessarily malicious (depending on who you ask), how is this different than malware or rootkits?

That's a really shady practice for a company who's motto is "don't be evil"
 
The problem is people blindly hit accept or sign off on hundreds/thousands of use agreements that permit this, but act shocked when their "privacy" is violated. Yet, they never care to actually ensure their privacy is protected when they sign these - in addition, its usually these models that allow us "free" access to so much of what we're used to in society. Advertising and marketing isn't such a huge industry for no reason.

That being said, the core concept of so much of this is just what life is, and provides us with a lot of the conveniences we expect. The internet would not be half of what you are used to in content and ease of use without this general type of activity - the multitude of news outlets alone are a perfect example of content we expect for free, but don't give a second thought to how its funded. As long as the tracking doesn't fundamentally damage you - identiy theft, cc #'s, etc. - its really not the end of the world. People have some sort of weird sense that everything they do online is shielded from ever being seen, and that's just not feasible.
 
I don't like the fact that anyone is tracking anyone, and I wish we could enact some legislation to stop it.

That being said, I feel better being tracked by Google then I feel being tracked by just about any other entity. At least they have a clear privacy policy and come straight out and tell you what they do with the data (use it for targeted ads).

Other companies/organizations/entities - for all I know - could be up to something more nefarious, but I feel less concerned with Google.

I don't trust Facebook at all.
 
As I said in the other post, this is the exact reason/scenario why I don't trust Google with my personal information and avoid most google services like the plague.

Everyone knows that they track users, that's the business that they're in and alot of users are okay with that... it is what it is (to each their own). What bothers me is that they actually used an exploit to get around a privacy setting in the browser to track users anyway without their consent. Not only does that toe the line of unethical, it's borderline criminal IMO. While it's not necessarily malicious (depending on who you ask), how is this different than malware or rootkits?

That's a really shady practice for a company who's motto is "don't be evil"

So then what services do you use that don't do the same thing? I am sure all of us would love to know.

The problem is people blindly hit accept or sign off on hundreds/thousands of use agreements that permit this, but act shocked when their "privacy" is violated. Yet, they never care to actually ensure their privacy is protected when they sign these - in addition, its usually these models that allow us "free" access to so much of what we're used to in society. Advertising and marketing isn't such a huge industry for no reason.

That being said, the core concept of so much of this is just what life is, and provides us with a lot of the conveniences we expect. The internet would not be half of what you are used to in content and ease of use without this general type of activity - the multitude of news outlets alone are a perfect example of content we expect for free, but don't give a second thought to how its funded. As long as the tracking doesn't fundamentally damage you - identiy theft, cc #'s, etc. - its really not the end of the world. People have some sort of weird sense that everything they do online is shielded from ever being seen, and that's just not feasible.

This hits the nail on the head, people blindly accept user agreements and the internet would be a shadow of its current state without tracking. I don't like it any more than the next person and I take steps to mitigate it as much as possible, but the reality is the Free internet wouldn't exist without it. Everything would be pay for access in some what shape or form. Nothing is free and everything has a cost. So you either get anonymous paid for content, or you get largely free just let us track your habits content.
 
So then what services do you use that don't do the same thing? I am sure all of us would love to know.

That doesn't use browser exploits to track you? I would hope that nothing I use online would do that (and if they did and I found out about it, I wouldn't be using them for very long), although I also take preventitive measures to protect my privacy online with noscript and such. I generally take my privacy pretty seriously... it's that reason why I don't use facebook and all those other types of data mining sites. It amazes me how quick people are to give that up in the name of 'free stuff'.

Just about all of the stuff I do on my machine is local. I don't use online document editing and storage services, picture storage, youtube accounts or anything like that. I do have dummy accounts in the one-off chance that I need a file or image hosted, but that's about the extent of my reliance of web services like the ones that google and others offer.
 
not surprised actually, On the privacy Department we all know how Google now works. its like a "lets do this til we are caught" kind of thing for them. that's why I don't trust them that much. lol. on a side note I notice on most forums (not just [H]), alot of people tend to be.. if Google does it. its okay, but if its MS, Apple, or anyone else.. its not okay :D
 
God this is so ridiculous. I wasn't sure if Apple was up to these sudden articles within the last two months about Google this Galaxy Nexus that but I'm sure about it now.

This whole "controversy" if you read the article is about FREAKING COOKIES. There is nothing evil about it unless you believe that Google is the only one using cookies. Cookies which allow websites to track where you've been, what you've clicked are about as old as dirt.

Safari's Privacy setting allows cookies if you interact with any web object. So Google uses this to install cookies which is exactly what the browser is supposed to do unless it's set not to allow cookies at all.

From the article:
Mr. Garg said when he developed the Safari workaround he didn't consider the privacy angle. He came up with the idea simply to "ensure a consistent experience" for a group of people accessing a chat system from different Web browsers, he said.

The coding also has a role in some Facebook games and "apps"—particularly if the app wants to store a user's login information or game scores. In fact, a corporate Facebook page for app developers called "Best Practices" includes a link to Mr. Garg's blog post.

"We work to educate our developers on how to deliver a consistent user experience across all browsers," said Facebook spokesman David Swain.
Ooooooh evil Google....and Facebook, Twitter, Bing, and every other website you'll use.
 
I think it is pretty fucking annoying to be tracked by a bunch of greedy fucking companies. I think tracking cookies should be totally illegal.
 
They've built up a lot of good will with their customers. They should be very cautious with that; they're in a very tiny group: large corporation that people kinda like.
 
http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/...cepting-tracking-cookies-microsoft-claims.ars

looks like Apple users aren't the only victims in this. MS is claiming that Google was also using this method to track IE users.

And MS is saying this AFTER they used the security hole in Safari to tout the security of IE. :rolleyes:

Again...just because this needs to be repeated: Who gives a flying fuck. If Google did indeed do this on purpose (we don't know for certain and will never know), then what they did was dirty but it in no way compromised any personal data.

We should be more worried about the fact that these so called "secure" browsers aren't secure at all. In typical fashion the sheep of the world are more worried about an anonymous cookie that shows them ads relevant to the sites they've been visiting instead of asking MS and Apple what the hell they're doing to fix their "secure" browsers.
 
Again...just because this needs to be repeated: Who gives a flying fuck. If Google did indeed do this on purpose (we don't know for certain and will never know), then what they did was dirty but it in no way compromised any personal data.

I, for one, do give a fuck and so do a lot of other people. Thats all well and good that it doesn't bother you... more power to ya, but you can't actually be surprised that people are up in arms about it. Regardless of what the people defending google say, most people value their privacy, both online and off.

At this point, I don't think there's any question of "if google did it on purpose". They got caught red handed circumventing two different browsers security twice in the last week. That's like saying that Google didn't intentionally record router SSIDs et.al a while back. Of course they did... the technology the're developing heavily relied upon it. Even if it's not malicious, it doesnt exactly give people a warm and fuzzy feeling that they have their best interests at heart.

It was a really retarded move for Google and I'm honestly a little surprised they did it. This can turn into a PR nightmare for them.

As far as insucure browsers, I do agree with you and hope it gets fixed soon (and others hopefully fix their browsers if their vulnerable). This shouldn't of been possible in the first place, but that doesn't make what Google did right or ethical.
 
Back
Top