Google To Fold Chrome Operating System Into Android

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
According to this article, Google is folding Chrome OS into Android so that the company will have a single OS across all its hardware.

Google engineers have been working for roughly two years to combine the operating systems and have made progress recently, two of the people said. The company plans to unveil its new, single operating system in 2017, but expects to show off an early version next year, one of the people said.
 
Cause nobody gave a damn about Chrome OS, so Google forces it onto people through Android. Google should just make a proper Linux distro already.
 
Google should just make a proper Linux distro already.

They use LTS versions of Ubuntu internally - known as Goobuntu, seriously - so I have to wonder after the past 5 or 6 years why they haven't just done that already. Would be interesting to see what they'd produce if they ever did that.

Can't say I'm surprised with this move considering Android is vastly more popular and not all that different in concept anyway, the surprise if there is one is what took them so long to do it.
 
I'm honestly surprised they didn't do this a long time ago.

Why did it ever make sense to maintain two separate operating systems, when they could just have had one unified one?
 
Zarathustra[H];1041939844 said:
Why did it ever make sense to maintain two separate operating systems, when they could just have had one unified one?

Windows 8/10 says hi. Pretty strong cautionary tale for keeping mobile and desktop separate.
 
Windows 8/10 says hi. Pretty strong cautionary tale for keeping mobile and desktop separate.

You don't have to have the unified UI.

You can have separate UI's running ontop of the same kernel/driver/framework.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041939844 said:
I'm honestly surprised they didn't do this a long time ago.

Why did it ever make sense to maintain two separate operating systems, when they could just have had one unified one?

Just want to point out that Apple has maintained OSX and iOS separately forever. I think there's been some mention of convergence, but not anytime soon.
 
Looks like they are looking at what MS is doing and see it as a good idea. I believe they are right because, unlike the windows store there are some things on Google Play that are actually useful or interesting. This could be an interesting opportunity for HTPC's.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041939922 said:
You don't have to have the unified UI.

You can have separate UI's running ontop of the same kernel/driver/framework.

Ahhh....the power of Linux, how I love the.
 
Sounds to me like PR speak for 'Chrome failed.'

Google has more fails than successes. They throw the dart and see if it sticks. If it can't, just fold it as quietly as possible and move on. They shudder something close to 4-5 different projects a year. At this point I assume Google's PR team is fairly well versed at this.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041939922 said:
You don't have to have the unified UI.

You can have separate UI's running ontop of the same kernel/driver/framework.

In theory perhaps. But you run into trouble when the framework for the mobile side doesn't scale for the desktop side -- see WinRT vs Win32, and how terrible Metro apps are on the desktop.
 
Google has more fails than successes. They throw the dart and see if it sticks. If it can't, just fold it as quietly as possible and move on. They shudder something close to 4-5 different projects a year. At this point I assume Google's PR team is fairly well versed at this.
There is something to be said for experimentation and not playing it safe. From such things innovation is born.
 
Zarathustra[H];1041939844 said:
I'm honestly surprised they didn't do this a long time ago.

Why did it ever make sense to maintain two separate operating systems, when they could just have had one unified one?

Which clearly shows that Google cannot make a good desktop OS to save their lives. :D
 
Just want to point out that Apple has maintained OSX and iOS separately forever. I think there's been some mention of convergence, but not anytime soon.

You're right, but Apple has been designing desktop caliber OS's for 30 years.
 
In my opinion, Google is becoming the guru of throwing crap on the wall and seeing what sticks. I'm starting to think all those Master's and Phd's at Google have no clue what they're doing.
 
IMHO the best part about Chrome OS devices was buying them dirt cheap, and hacking them to run regular operating systems.

My HTPC's all run on Ubuntu 15.04 on Asus Chromeboxes :p
 
In my opinion, Google is becoming the guru of throwing crap on the wall and seeing what sticks. I'm starting to think all those Master's and Phd's at Google have no clue what they're doing.

It might be better to say that nobody, even a Ph.D, can predict the future very well.

ChromeOS seemed like an interesting approach for non-technical computer users who just wanted to use the Internet... at least until mobile took off. Android and iOS pretty much took over that segment.
 
Google has more fails than successes. They throw the dart and see if it sticks. If it can't, just fold it as quietly as possible and move on. They shudder something close to 4-5 different projects a year. At this point I assume Google's PR team is fairly well versed at this.

Better to give their employees and team managers the freedom to experiment and fail on many different little projects, than do something like buy Nokia and lose 7 Billion dollars.

Let's keep the fails in perspective.
 
Sounds to me like PR speak for 'Chrome failed.'

More or less. The mobile space is about to enter maturity and while the desktop space is declining in new sales it's still important and beyond the educational market Chrome OS hasn't done much else.

But there's more to it. The 2 in 1 device market is very hot these days. Not big number but very high growth with a number devices commanding premium pricing. Google like Apple definitely want to get into the higher end hybrid/tablet productivity market as traditional tablet sales have sunk.

The question of the hybrid OS is outstanding. Windows 10 is making a much better case for the idea than 8.x. 95% of the complaints I see of 10 are about privacy and telemetry concerns, not the UI or its appropriateness for keyboard and mouse use. I don't see a strong argument against the viability of Windows 10 as a hybrid. From the desktop side there are some complaints about the new Start Menu, Settings and Control Panel, where's my Aero glass and aesthetics. From tablet side some of the things from 8.x that were removed in 10 like the Charms Bar are bemoaned. But these aren't inherent UI issues like hidden and full screen elements or lack of touch capability. These are all things that can and no doubt will be tweaked in time.

So we're at a bit of a crossroads. Hybrids seem to be gaining traction and the complaints about 10's usability are no where near that of 8.x. Hybrid growth may sputter out in a couple of years. Or not.
 
Fine with me, this makes both ecosystems stronger. Chrome for Android will finally get extensions and Chromebooks will get access to a lot of native apps.
 
Better to give their employees and team managers the freedom to experiment and fail on many different little projects, than do something like buy Nokia and lose 7 Billion dollars.

Let's keep the fails in perspective.

True, and lets not forget why Google is taking this approach.


They are sitting on more cash than they know how to properly invest, so they ahve decided to allow experimentation. Sometimes a moonshot really pays off!
 
Better to give their employees and team managers the freedom to experiment and fail on many different little projects, than do something like buy Nokia and lose 7 Billion dollars.

Let's keep the fails in perspective.

Really? Then why did you not pull of the numbers for Google losses? :rolleyes: I have no issue with a company, any company, succeeding or having failures but, lets get real...... :cool:
 
No it's not.

What is it then? Both Google and Apple just announced flagship "2-in-1" productivity tablets that are about to hit market. You don't have to like it or be in the target market for one to see it's a hot area for product development right now.
 
What is it then? Both Google and Apple just announced flagship "2-in-1" productivity tablets that are about to hit market. You don't have to like it or be in the target market for one to see it's a hot area for product development right now.

That's called "hedging one's bets" and "trying desperately to create a new market to sell these things". Besides, those are not really 2-in-1s in the MS context. Tablets with keyboards have been around since... well since tablets have been around.
 
That's called "hedging one's bets" and "trying desperately to create a new market to sell these things". Besides, those are not really 2-in-1s in the MS context. Tablets with keyboards have been around since... well since tablets have been around.

A "2-in-1 in the MS context" requires an OS only Microsoft has built, because no other single OS is as seamless between a touch and mouse experience. The iPad Pro and the Pixel 3 are the very first keyboard-tablets from Apple and Google, and they are as close to a 2-in-1 as those companies are capable of producing right now.

The "tablet with keyboard" market is heating up, whether or not you choose to include MS's 2-in-1s as part of that or not.
 
No it's not.

Gartner predicts 89% year over year growth from 2014 to 2015 to about 15 million units. If the growth rate remains in the double digits for a few years they becomes a very significant chunk of the PC market. Considering the explosion of the number of 2 in 1 devices available the market must be growing.
 
Fine with me, this makes both ecosystems stronger. Chrome for Android will finally get extensions and Chromebooks will get access to a lot of native apps.

It'll be interesting to see how this impacts me - I use my Chromebook exclusively at home for everything I do / need. I'm hoping it'll be a positive impact.
 
A "2-in-1 in the MS context" requires an OS only Microsoft has built, because no other single OS is as seamless between a touch and mouse experience. The iPad Pro and the Pixel 3 are the very first keyboard-tablets from Apple and Google, and they are as close to a 2-in-1 as those companies are capable of producing right now.

Google will probably sell as many Pixel Cs as they sold Nexus 9s, which was a complete flop. I don't think the iPad Pro will sell many units either. Though I don't see how these are markedly different than ASUS Transformer Whatevers from back in the day, except with better keyboards.

Gartner predicts 89% year over year growth from 2014 to 2015 to about 15 million units.

15 million units does not constitute a "hot market" in my mind. That's about as niche as Chromebooks. Of course Gartner, et al were also predicting Windows Phone taking over a significant chunk of the smartphone market and in their analysis the PC market rebound has always been just around the corner for the past five years.

Maybe I just don't assent to all the hype from marketing departments and their amen corners on the various tech sites. I mean, I get that Microsoft and their drones in the media are saying that 2-in-1s are the bees knees and all, but I'm not sure that they're exactly objective sources.
 
15 million units does not constitute a "hot market" in my mind. That's about as niche as Chromebooks.

Hot isn't about the size but the growth rate. Continued double digit growth for a few years could put that number up past 50 million which is a big chunk of the PC market. And many of these devices command far more money than Chromebooks ever could. Microsoft without doubt has sold more a lot more Surface Pro devices than Google ever did Chromebook Pixels for instance. Indeed Google dropped Chrome OS on its latest pixel and went with Android. I think that was hint where this was going right there.
 
Hot isn't about the size but the growth rate. Continued double digit growth for a few years could put that number up past 50 million which is a big chunk of the PC market. And many of these devices command far more money than Chromebooks ever could. Microsoft without doubt has sold more a lot more Surface Pro devices than Google ever did Chromebook Pixels for instance. Indeed Google dropped Chrome OS on its latest pixel and went with Android. I think that was hint where this was going right there.

Double-digit growth isn't hard to achieve when the units sold is so low; especially for something as heavily marketed as Surface.

Steam Machines are a hot market too -- they went from selling 10 boxes to 15.
 
Back
Top