Google’s Knol Open To Everyone

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Google’s Knol is now open to the public. It’s sort of like Wikipedia but instead of a free for all with people editing stuff like crazy, the original author can accept or reject edits or content additions. Anyone tried it yet?

With Knol, we are introducing a new method for authors to work together that we call "moderated collaboration." With this feature, any reader can make suggested edits to a knol which the author may then choose to accept, reject, or modify before these contributions become visible to the public. This allows authors to accept suggestions from everyone in the world while remaining in control of their content. After all, their name is associated with it!
 
Hmm I'm not too sure. This forum proves everyone has their own opinion even when facts come to play. Image someone like panhead making a Knol about Vista, and people are trying to set facts straight, but he refuses to modify his stance because he's a conspiracy theorist.

Just an example.
 
my thoughts too azhar. you could do that with any topic. you'd end up with some asshat that only accepts edits by other asshats that see his way.
 
Cool. I am going to create a ton of topics and then I can choose what to accept.

Sounds like a bad idea IMO. What if the creator doesn't contribute anymore... I've written a lot of things that I abandon and let them take a form on their own.
 
You can start whatever topics you want, but what's your name?

Knol is to Wikipedia as Facebook is to SecondLife.

The former of each pair is useless without a name attached--the name defines (or should define) the value of the content.

So go ahead and try to 'hijack' topics on DNA sequencing. Unless you have 'Venter' or 'Watson' or the like in your name, I'm unlikely to care.
 
You can start whatever topics you want, but what's your name?

Knol is to Wikipedia as Facebook is to SecondLife.

The former of each pair is useless without a name attached--the name defines (or should define) the value of the content.

So go ahead and try to 'hijack' topics on DNA sequencing. Unless you have 'Venter' or 'Watson' or the like in your name, I'm unlikely to care.

*Thinks about someone like Emma Watson creating an article about DNA sequencing and you running with it*
:p

As for your comment on DNA sequencing, there are many diffrent methods and many diffrent viewpoints, so while your "watson" might have his own method, it does not mean it's the most appropriate or best method. Which is why this whole thing about the creator approving things is lame.
 
They should rather have a revolving approval vote system in place. So that if say 80% of the public approves of it or more after a certain period, it will get posted. At least it can override the OP and no rouge poster can post his own views.
 
The sense I get is that they are seeking to establish a base of experts on topics. Meaning if you can't prove you are an expert on the topic they won't allow you to claim the topic. That way legitimate experts get recognized, and asshats get shown the door.

I imagine in the case of a topic not being updated there is some sort of moderation system in place so that changes can be made if an author doesn't accept or deny changes to their topic.

In theory it should work well...but as we all know...theories don't always work out.
 
The sense I get is that they are seeking to establish a base of experts on topics. Meaning if you can't prove you are an expert on the topic they won't allow you to claim the topic. That way legitimate experts get recognized, and asshats get shown the door.

I imagine in the case of a topic not being updated there is some sort of moderation system in place so that changes can be made if an author doesn't accept or deny changes to their topic.

In theory it should work well...but as we all know...theories don't always work out.

The site allows anyone to create a topic, not just experts. How also do you define an expert on a topic? If you asked a doctor (we can assume doctors are experts) on how to cure the common cold, we would have many diffrent awnsers.

Unless if they allow multiple articles of the same topic, then I think that would add some value.
 
The site allows anyone to create a topic, not just experts. How also do you define an expert on a topic? If you asked a doctor (we can assume doctors are experts) on how to cure the common cold, we would have many diffrent awnsers.

Unless if they allow multiple articles of the same topic, then I think that would add some value.

After looking over it...they do allow multiple "knols" on the same topic, but there is also some sort of verification system in place to verify the profiles of authors (such as to verify a person who says they work at a certain university, does indeed work at that uni).

The major problem I've noticed on the site is, except for the featured knols none of the content is searchable. There are numerous people who have written knols but there's no way to find them unless they are online, or you go directly to the knol. If that's the way it's supposed to work...then it seems like they are trying to create a panel of experts that are only searchable when they are online. No way in hell will that compete with wikipedia.

The way it should work is exactly as it is now, but with a community voting system in place and articles limited to one post about the same subject. Also the knols should be searchable all the time, not just when the author is online.
 
The major problem I've noticed on the site is, except for the featured knols none of the content is searchable. There are numerous people who have written knols but there's no way to find them unless they are online, or you go directly to the knol. If that's the way it's supposed to work...then it seems like they are trying to create a panel of experts that are only searchable when they are online. No way in hell will that compete with wikipedia.

The search works fine... You realize there are only a few hundred articles at this point, right? Additionally there's no reason to believe that there isn't some kind of moderator review before articles are released to thwe search engine.
 
No way in hell will that compete with wikipedia.

I don't think their intention is to compete with Wikipedia at all. It seems to me they're wanting to build a database of articles from knowledgeable people, with the opportunity for those people to collaborate if they desire. The articles that are worth their salt will naturally rise to the top through visibility and popularity.
 
The search works fine... You realize there are only a few hundred articles at this point, right? Additionally there's no reason to believe that there isn't some kind of moderator review before articles are released to thwe search engine.

Well I haven't tried to post a knol but from the comments on the help page it seems there are quite a few people complaining about the search:
http://knol.google.com/k/knol/knol/Help#

There's no reason to believe there IS a moderation review...nothing on the site mentions anything of the sort. Why even let a knol be public via a url if it still has to go through a moderation queue to be searchable? I would think if there was a moderation queue...they would let people who post knols know about it. Seems pretty silly to keep that kind of thing secret...that lends more credibility to the service.
 
Back
Top