Google Now Hates Socialism Too

FrgMstr

Just Plain Mean
Staff member
2FA
Joined
May 18, 1997
Messages
58,694
There has been a lot of talk online about Google and its policies when it comes to politics and fake news, but even the New York Times takes notice when it is a socialists website that says it is getting the shaft. The simple solution to all of of this is to Duck to the left, Duck to right, then just Go.


In an open letter to Google last month, Mr. North traced his site’s traffic decline to Project Owl. Mr. North said he believed that Google was blacklisting the site, using concerns over fake news as a cover to suppress opinions from socialist, antiwar or left-wing websites and block news that Google doesn’t want covered.
 
There are low quality news sources on both extremes of the political spectrum.

This just shows that they are doing their job.

News-Quality.jpg
 
LOL, that entire chart 'skews left'. The AP and NPR have even banned use the legally correct term "illegal alien", the AP in particular has had to issue public retractions many times for filing false stories, and 99% of the time the 'error' is one that either attacks conservatives or defends liberals. There's a new version of that chart, and nearly every "Hyperpartisan Left" media sources is a regular contributer to the "reliable" sources in the middle, while NONE of the "Hyperpartisan right" sources are.

Google is unquestionably liberal, so this carefully designed 'news' is likely the story that the left will point to as conservative speech is squelched and finally banned from the Facebook, Google, etc forever.
 
Last edited:
There are low quality news sources on both extremes of the political spectrum.

This just shows that they are doing their job.

News-Quality.jpg

That chart is rather subjective. I have found NPR, CNN and (MS)NBC to be liberal leaning.

Yet Fox has more viewers than the rest of them combined.

I'm not saying I'm right or wrong, but it's something to question how this data was subjectively put together.
 
Should not have even posted it, because there is so much bias on either side it is not worth it at all. People aren't going to go, hmm, infowars is telling me that tap water is making frogs gay, so maybe it isn't news. The people who watch it will be like, the government is making frogs gay. This thread should be locked before the insults start.
 
I'm not saying I'm right or wrong, but it's something to question how this data was subjectively put together.

It wasn't put together subjectively.

Be smart and read as many of all of that you can find to make up your own mind.

The worst thing someone can do is only read things that already confirm their side of things. Try reading what the other side has to say every once in a while with as open a mind as you can then truly form your own opinion. It's the only way to see that everything is actually bullshit.
 
We are going to have to agree to disagree on this one.

When someone's personal views fall so strongly on one side or another of the political spectrum, fact based non-partisan reporting will seem biased by comparison. It all has to do with the norms of the group you find yourself in.

Over the last 20 years the myth of the "liberal media" has been pushed so hard in conservative circles that many just take it for granted, and blame any news story they don't like as "liberal bias" by people who haven't even read (or listened to) the sources they are accusing of bias.

You live in a strongly conservative part of the country, and likely find yourself surrounded by conservative friends, family and colleagues on a regular basis, just like many, myself included, find ourselves in strongly liberal portions of the country. These norms color our views.

IMHO, when news sources piss off both extremes, (like many of those in the center grey circle do) it probably suggests that they are getting something right.
Your graphic was made by some chick on Facebook. Really.
 
That chart is rather subjective. I have found NPR, CNN and (MS)NBC to be liberal leaning.

Yet Fox has more viewers than the rest of them combined.

I'm not saying I'm right or wrong, but it's something to question how this data was subjectively put together.


Fox does have a lot of viewers, but when it comes down to brass tax, it was created as an intentional propaganda outlet for right leaning views, and a lot of the material they present as fact, has a very loose basis in reality. MSNBC is pretty much their equivalent on the left. Similar loose regards for the fact, and instead presenting a mix of propaganda and "edutainment" to their viewership. In between the two fall a lot of very reputable news organizations which are frequently maligned by the people they expose as being biased.

But yes, you are right. These things are totally subjective, as there is no good way to measure anything like this objectively.

I feel like I have a pretty good insight (based on having been raised strongly conservative, but having lived in, and had many strongly liberal friends, pulling me more to the center , so I have and continue to experience both sides) but then again, we all have our norms from our communities, and we all think we have a good insight on these things, so I could be just as wrong as anyone else :p
 
The Huffington post is just kinda liberal here, I have no frame of reference. What would classify as the middle in American news (because I thought the graph was kinda bang on barring NPR and CNN).

CNN is very low quality news. They are more into single line headlines than in-depth analysis and coverage. They got that spot on. As far as their left/right skew? Well, again, that's very subjective.

As far as NPR goes, I think a lot of people who have been taught to hate NPR because of their liberal bias would be surprised if they actually listened to it. They bend over backwards to not do any politically motivated stories and try to stay neutral and do fact based reporting.

When I (as a strongly conservative young fella) started listening to NPR, I was surprised to not find any of that bias that was supposedly there. YMMV, though, especially since each member station has a lot of liberty in what they cover. My modern centrist self has come to trust my local NPR news station, WBUR, as having some of the highest non-partisan journalistic standards.
 
It wasn't put together subjectively.

Be smart and read as many of all of that you can find to make up your own mind.

The worst thing someone can do is only read things that already confirm their side of things. Try reading what the other side has to say every once in a while with as open a mind as you can then truly form your own opinion. It's the only way to see that everything is actually bullshit.

While not quite as cynical as you (I don't believe it is all bullshit), I agree with this whole-heartedly.

It is very important to expose yourself to ideas, opinions and news sources from across the spectrum, including those you disagree with and make up your own own mind, rather than relying too much on any one or a few organizations to filter and color the news for you. Then you never know what you are getting.
 
Google is there to sell advertisements , guess people that are not on the right not as interesting , for a good reason ;) .
 
We are going to have to agree to disagree on this one.

When someone's personal views fall so strongly on one side or another of the political spectrum, fact based non-partisan reporting will seem biased by comparison. It all has to do with the norms of the group you find yourself in.

Over the last 20 years the myth of the "liberal media" has been pushed so hard in conservative circles that many just take it for granted, and blame any news story they don't like as "liberal bias" by people who haven't even read (or listened to) the sources they are accusing of bias.

You live in a strongly conservative part of the country, and likely find yourself surrounded by conservative friends, family and colleagues on a regular basis, just like many, myself included, find ourselves in strongly liberal portions of the country. These norms color our views.

IMHO, when news sources piss off both extremes, (like many of those in the center grey circle do) it probably suggests that they are getting something right.

I see, so you've observed millions of conservatives and are certain there's no liberal bias in the media, it's simply that people like me don't actually read, is that right? Your arrogance has led you to this certain conclusion, because you, like so many liberals, feel that it must be true. Those poor uneducated conservatives, worthy off your contempt. NPR's own ombudsman has noted the left wing bias in her organization, and yet you deny it. They won't utter the words "illegal alien", a perfectly accurate legal term, and replaced it with the emotionally manipulative "undocumented worker", but no, no bias there or the AP right? Hillary Clinton didn't mishandle classified information, she just had an 'email issue'.

I read volumes every day, I think, analyze, reason, and have a long memory, and yes, the bias is clear.

I've listened to thousands of hours of NPR both domestically and via American Public Media while living overseas. I've observed what started as a mild left wing bias turn into full fledged overt bias. Their media guests are overwhelmingly from the Huffington Post, Salon, Slate, DailyKos, and other like minded liberal sources, so again, your "if they would just listen" assumption is wrong. You're the one who needs to open your eyes and observe critically, not conservatives.
 
CNN is very low quality news. They are more into single line headlines than in-depth analysis and coverage. They got that spot on. As far as their left/right skew? Well, again, that's very subjective.

As far as NPR goes, I think a lot of people who have been taught to hate NPR because of their liberal bias would be surprised if they actually listened to it. They bend over backwards to not do any politically motivated stories and try to stay neutral and do fact based reporting.

When I (as a strongly conservative young fella) started listening to NPR, I was surprised to not find any of that bias that was supposedly there. YMMV, though, especially since each member station has a lot of liberty in what they cover. My modern centrist self has come to trust my local NPR news station, WBUR, as having some of the highest non-partisan journalistic standards.

Agreed. BBC / NPR is in a good place. MSNBC/Fox are in the right places. CNN is in the low-quality central area.

I'd say there might be room for improvement, but it's all subjective and I think they did a decent job.
 
That graph is complete trash. It has no objective value whatsoever.
But it's most dangerous form of trash, it has just enough truth it in to seem legit.

And another question is the topic. one outlet doesn't cover all topics with the exact same standards. They can be spot on about one thing then completely biased on another.
 
Who came up with this chart?

CNN = minimal partisan bias? Should be on the bottom left.

Read the chart again, the Y axis is for "low quality / clickbait". Essentially, CNN occupies the area that says "they don't necessarily have a slant as long as they get them clicks". Have you been to CNN.com? It's all revenue driven bullshit articles designed to get you to click. So they may seem partisan, but they're just parroting whatever metric is going to get them more traffic.
 
I'd say its a pretty decent multi axis graph, although I would put AP and Reuters up there with NPR and BBC, not below NBC/ABC
 
Agreed. BBC / NPR is in a good place. MSNBC/Fox are in the right places. CNN is in the low-quality central area.

I'd say there might be room for improvement, but it's all subjective and I think they did a decent job.
BBC is a good place? An openly racist organization?
 
that's fucking hilarious after posting that graphic. Kinda of makes sense you would not check your sources.

You are right about the sources. I have no idea who actually created that chart. I do - however - consume a lot of news from many sources across the spectrum, and when I saw an image that mostly was in line with my experiences I felt it was worth sharing.

I would have done certain things slightly differently on that chart. I would have moved Huffpo further left and a little further down, and I would have moved Fox a little further right, and a good bit further down. I would probably have added a little bit more spread between the sources in the center grey circle as well. I'd move NPR a tiny bit left (but not much). Wapo a little bit right (but not much) NYT a little bit left (but not much) etc. etc.

It's also a bit challenging because bias doesn't solely exist on a strict left-right basis. We'd need some sort of multidimensional chart :p

I felt this one was already put together and close enough to the ballpark to make the point I was trying to make, that there are garbage news sources on each extreme, and it looks like Google is pursuing them. The stuff in the center was not even part of my argument. It just flew in as a bit of a bonus :p
 
We are going to have to agree to disagree on this one.

When someone's personal views fall so strongly on one side or another of the political spectrum, fact based non-partisan reporting will seem biased by comparison. It all has to do with the norms of the group you find yourself in.

Over the last 20 years the myth of the "liberal media" has been pushed so hard in conservative circles that many just take it for granted, and blame any news story they don't like as "liberal bias" by people who haven't even read (or listened to) the sources they are accusing of bias.

You live in a strongly conservative part of the country, and likely find yourself surrounded by conservative friends, family and colleagues on a regular basis, just like many, myself included, find ourselves in strongly liberal portions of the country. These norms color our views.

IMHO, when news sources piss off both extremes, (like many of those in the center grey circle do) it probably suggests that they are getting something right.
\

I will add that, as a native New Yorker, the NY Times is definitely on the liberal end of the spectrum -- this is the common consensus from all of my politically minded friends living in New York, from liberal/conservative to conspiracy theorist types (in addition, I actually know a few folks who work there). It's probably the one thing that they all agree on (besides a few restaurants, some sports, and the irritating traffic).

One useful thing is to see if the "political story" is designed to pull at your emotional strings by inflaming your emotions (while not making logical sense) -- that is usually a good sign of manipulative propaganda, which both sides are guilty of (and both sides firmly believe they are in the right; far more so, than any other time in recent American history).

Another thing of note is that another HardOCP'er mentioned (in another thread) that many of these "supposedly unbiased and independent" news organizations are actually all owned by a very few corporations/conglomerates -- that should give people an idea as to where these "newsgroups" loyalties really lie, and whose "masters" they actually serve.
 
Who came up with this chart?

CNN = minimal partisan bias? Should be on the bottom left.

I presume you are referring to our current presidents never ending feud with them?

Quoting a public official, and confirming that what he or she is saying is not in line with observable fact is not political bias. CNN doesn't even do much in the way of opinion pieces, which is what you'd need in order to have bias. They just do headlines with sparse details to support them.
 
how can you do sources on something so subjective. That is like saying, where are your sources for having the color orange as your favorite? No one will agree, because every human being on the planet is biased. This is a completely biased topic. You are better off arguing about Trump, abortion, climate change, helicopter blades and drones, freedom of speech, etc.
 
When Atlantic, Slate, HuffPo, Guardian, and Vox are categorized as skewed but reputable, complex, and analytical, then we have bona fide confirmation that this chart was made by someone that doesn't know how to read an article and differentiate between the buzzwords that enshroud blatant agenda-based opinion and bias, versus actual factual info. FFS, I have outspoken left-wing friends that won't touch Slate, HuffPo, and Vox because they consider them all to be sensationalist airheads.

Same for them categorizing Fox towards hyper-partisan, especially with Fox's new ownership and management directives. Almost everything on that chart should be moved over at least 1 column to the left, with convincing exceptions to WP, NYT, RedState, InfoWars, and DailyCaller.
 
LOL, that entire chart 'skews left'. The AP and NPR have even banned use the legally correct term "illegal alien", the AP in particular has had to issue public retractions many times for filing false stories, and 99% of the time the 'error' is one that either attacks conservatives or defends liberals. There's a new version of that chart, and nearly every "Hyperpartisan Left" media sources is a regular contributer to the "reliable" sources in the middle, while NONE of the "Hyperpartisan right" sources are.

That chart leans so far to the left it should be horizontal. Just goes to show how bad the leftist bias is today. What would have been far left 20 years ago, is now considered in the middle by too many people.

Over the last 20 years the myth of the "liberal media" has been pushed so hard in conservative circles that many just take it for granted, and blame any news story they don't like as "liberal bias" by people who haven't even read (or listened to) the sources they are accusing of bias.

The biggest myth about the "liberal media", is all the people who say it doesn't exist.
Any one with open eyes, who has been watching/reading the news for the past 20-30 years, can see the how much has changed.
 
If you're an extremist, the goal is to shift the definition of centrist your way, to make your views appear more normalized and palatable. On what planet was Bush Jr. a rightwing extremist? I hated Obama for many reasons, but I never thought him a flat-out communist.
 
I presume you are referring to our current presidents never ending feud with them?

Quoting a public official, and confirming that what he or she is saying is not in line with observable fact is not political bias. CNN doesn't even do much in the way of opinion pieces, which is what you'd need in order to have bias. They just do headlines with sparse details to support them.

Horse shit. Most can agree our POTUS is FAR from infallible, but CNN is hardly more than opinion pieces. Most of their quotes are far out of context.

Dissenting voices constantly "have technical problems." They've been caught staging several fake rallies over the last few decades. "Two scoops of ice cream" is a worthy headline. They even buried Bernie Sanders coverage during the primaries for their coronated Queen. :(

Hardly "better than nothing," firmly "don't read/watch this.."
 
We are going to have to agree to disagree on this one.

When someone's personal views fall so strongly on one side or another of the political spectrum, fact based non-partisan reporting will seem biased by comparison. It all has to do with the norms of the group you find yourself in.

Over the last 20 years the myth of the "liberal media" has been pushed so hard in conservative circles that many just take it for granted, and blame any news story they don't like as "liberal bias" by people who haven't even read (or listened to) the sources they are accusing of bias.

You live in a strongly conservative part of the country, and likely find yourself surrounded by conservative friends, family and colleagues on a regular basis, just like many, myself included, find ourselves in strongly liberal portions of the country. These norms color our views.

IMHO, when news sources piss off both extremes, (like many of those in the center grey circle do) it probably suggests that they are getting something right.
Thing is that chart is BS. Its got the BBC slap bang in the middle, believe me when I say they are biased & heavily to the left
 
You have to remember ALL news organizations, even independent ones like Huff Po want to make money.

How do you generate money? Generate sensationalist headlines, cherry pick, bend or skew the facts, and pander to specific groups who engage in confirmation bias.

Case in point: CNN was caught on tape admitting the whole Russia Trump link was a hoax used to generate hits. (Available on tons of news sites) http://yournewswire.com/cnn-producer-trump-russia/

News stop being objective a long time ago. They hire reporters with agendas to generate sensationalism, then to pander to people with biases and work off those fears to make the most money. And they aren't afraid of generating fear, division, and dissent to do so.

BTW: I'm conservative on the political spectrum but neutral to hostile on most news sources (Minus HardOCP which I highly regard). I just can't accept mindless self righteous bullshit that shows a lack of critical thinking. If it's conservative and bull crap, I'll call you just as much on it, as it being liberal and bull crap.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
If you're an extremist, the goal is to shift the definition of centrist your way, to make your views appear more normalized and palatable. On what planet was Bush Jr. a rightwing extremist? I hated Obama for many reasons, but I never thought him a flat-out communist.

Bush Jr bought into the whole "Project for the New American Century" bs. hook line and sinker, or he just surrounded himself with true believers and wasn't competent enough to realize it. The result of which was a hyperconservative and hawkish foreign policy. He also pursued many traditional good old boy measures like unfunded tax cuts for high income earners, that ballooned the deficit, and deregulation efforts that may (or may not) have resulted in the financial collapse, depending on who you ask.

There were also other issues (like the topic of immigration) where he had much more moderate, or by modern Trumpian standards, possibly even liberal views.

Like any presidency his was complex and multifaceted. This showcases the problem with placing organizations and people on a straight left-right line.
 
I presume you are referring to our current presidents never ending feud with them?

CNN doesn't even do much in the way of opinion pieces, which is what you'd need in order to have bias. They just do headlines with sparse details to support them.

Ignoring one party's scandals and only reporting conservative hit pieces is also bias
 
We are going to have to agree to disagree on this one.

When someone's personal views fall so strongly on one side or another of the political spectrum, fact based non-partisan reporting will seem biased by comparison. It all has to do with the norms of the group you find yourself in.

Over the last 20 years the myth of the "liberal media" has been pushed so hard in conservative circles that many just take it for granted, and blame any news story they don't like as "liberal bias" by people who haven't even read (or listened to) the sources they are accusing of bias.

You live in a strongly conservative part of the country, and likely find yourself surrounded by conservative friends, family and colleagues on a regular basis, just like many, myself included, find ourselves in strongly liberal portions of the country. These norms color our views.

IMHO, when news sources piss off both extremes, (like many of those in the center grey circle do) it probably suggests that they are getting something right.

Except youd be wrong . CNN wasn't "affectionately" called the Clinton News Network because they owned it...

I, sadly, live in a very liberal part of the country (socialist republic of maryland) and even here most people will say CNN has liberal biases.

EDIT: Also uh wtf CNN doesnt do much Opinion pieces? I call BS - whats your definition of " a lot". I think hosting an article written by one of the candidates shows a pretty large bias...
 
When Atlantic, Slate, HuffPo, Guardian, and Vox are categorized as skewed but reputable, complex, and analytical, then we have bona fide confirmation that this chart was made by someone that doesn't know how to read an article and differentiate between the buzzwords that enshroud blatant agenda-based opinion and bias, versus actual factual info. FFS, I have outspoken left-wing friends that won't touch Slate, HuffPo, and Vox because they consider them all to be sensationalist airheads.

Same for them categorizing Fox towards hyper-partisan, especially with Fox's new ownership and management directives. Almost everything on that chart should be moved over at least 1 column to the left, with convincing exceptions to WP, NYT, RedState, InfoWars, and DailyCaller.

If you want "off the reservation", Mother Jones (left) and InfoWars (right) are where it's at (if anything, InfoWars is straight-up conspiracy theory, with a heavy helping of Alex Jones' own political opinions).

If you're an extremist, the goal is to shift the definition of centrist your way, to make your views appear more normalized and palatable. On what planet was Bush Jr. a rightwing extremist? I hated Obama for many reasons, but I never thought him a flat-out communist.

Bingo.

True Nazi and many Alt-Right websites qualify as Socialist. At least anti-capitalist. Also a lot of the Left wing sites are getting dinged for discussing examples of Far Right Content.

Of course if you a far left website that is also violence advocacy internet presence, like BAM and Antifa, don't be suprised when open call for violence get shutdown.

Not for nothing in Weimar Germany (Germany between the time of WWI and Hitler's taking power in 1933) was there the fact that the Weimar Republic was the sworn enemy of all radicals, from the Communist KPD to the Nazi SA (stormtroopers). Both sides engaged in bloody street brawls with each other and the police, but both sides also (occasionally) formed tactical alliances (alliances of convenience) in order to hinder and discredit the Weimar Republic (which was a much more open and free republic than the US ever was).

Of course, upon assuming power in 1933, Hitler then had to purge his party of those who really believed in the "socialist" aspect of National Socialism, as well as "undesireables": Roehm, Daleuge, Strasser, etc. (all formerly big names within the Nazi party). In some parts of Germany, over two-thirds of new SA members were former Communists.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Madoc
like this
Back
Top