Google Health Beta Test Begins

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
How many people think allowing Google to store all your health records is a good idea? I mean, it sounds convenient but there are so many things that could go wrong, is it really a good idea?

To join, users must agree to various terms of use, including this: "When you provide your information through Google Health, you give Google a license to use and distribute it in connection with Google Health and other Google services."
 
My company has several medical practices as customers. We provide their IT support. I am willing to bet that your records are far more secure with Google than most practices around. Several of the hospitals had pretty poor security as well. We warn them of the HIPAA compliance issues, but in the end, it's up to them to approve the changes. Security isn't something that doctors think about, or even try to understand.
 
My company has several medical practices as customers. We provide their IT support. I am willing to bet that your records are far more secure with Google than most practices around. Several of the hospitals had pretty poor security as well. We warn them of the HIPAA compliance issues, but in the end, it's up to them to approve the changes. Security isn't something that doctors think about, or even try to understand.

+1

How many data leaks have you heard of comming from Google? Despite most likely being one of the most attacked targets in the world, they've held their own. If any of thousands of hospitals and clinics took 5% of the heat that Google does those records would be widely distributed on the Internet.
 
Now introducing Google DNA.

Yeah, you're pretty much fucked. ;)

You said my words exactly.

+1

How many data leaks have you heard of comming from Google? Despite most likely being one of the most attacked targets in the world, they've held their own. If any of thousands of hospitals and clinics took 5% of the heat that Google does those records would be widely distributed on the Internet.

All it takes is one person on the inside. Our records are most likely already out there and have been sold for money numerous times. Wonder how Google makes so much money?


They take photos of your house and your personal belongs in your garage for the world to see without our permission, why not let them have everything else? I'm waiting for them to show credit card numbers and naked family photos when you click an address. A live video camera for each address is on the way too I'm sure.
 
My company has several medical practices as customers. We provide their IT support. I am willing to bet that your records are far more secure with Google than most practices around. Several of the hospitals had pretty poor security as well. We warn them of the HIPAA compliance issues, but in the end, it's up to them to approve the changes. Security isn't something that doctors think about, or even try to understand.

Exactly, Google will still be bound by HIPAA requirement and with some of the fly by night electronic record repositories that have been popping up in the past few years i would much rather my records be in the hands of google who surely has taken the time to understand HIPAA as well securly implement it, than 2 guys in their garage looking to make an easy buck off of a medical center that has little understanding of technology.

You said my words exactly.



All it takes is one person on the inside. Our records are most likely already out there and have been sold for money numerous times. Wonder how Google makes so much money?


They take photos of your house and your personal belongs in your garage for the world to see without our permission, why not let them have everything else? I'm waiting for them to show credit card numbers and naked family photos when you click an address. A live video camera for each address is on the way too I'm sure.

I think your tin foil hat is on a bit too tight there sparky, might want to go down to your doc's and see if they can loosen it a bit for you.
 
I work for a hospital and while I think this new Google product is a terrible idea I don't subscribe to the notion that it only takes one person on the inside.

Technology is mature enough now that Google have enough safeguards in places to prevent wholesale downloading or distribution of records. For me it is a matter of trust. I simply don't trust Google with my medical records, period.
 
+1

How many data leaks have you heard of comming from Google? Despite most likely being one of the most attacked targets in the world, they've held their own. If any of thousands of hospitals and clinics took 5% of the heat that Google does those records would be widely distributed on the Internet.

If you have seen one of their data centers I don't think you would put so much faith in them.

I trust google but I don't see what value (risk assessment here) it would provide me.
 
I ask one question: Would you really trust a company founded on the discovery of information to secure yours?
 
Now Google will know you just saw the doc about hemorrhoids, so guess what your ads will be?

No, thanks.
 
If google wanted to submit bids for the data repository needed to implement that new electronic records law, fine. Just like EDS providing all the computers/software to run the Soc Sec Admin back in the 60's.... that's how Ross Perot got rich....it would be fine for google to operate the infrastructure. But, that is for a national government repository, not a private operation gathering the most intimate details of you life.... down to your very DNA perhaps.

No thanks, Ill pass on the whole private sector path.

Until all the legal protections are established for protecting our rights, I dont want any central electronic repository of such knowledge. On paper in my doctors office is just fine for now.

Eliminate the possibility of getting deny insurance or what not for "pre-existing" and life style issues, etc, etc, and then maybe I'll change my opinion. But right now all this giant corporation shit, poking its nose into my private life is making me want to grab a rifle and start defending myself. :eek::rolleyes::p
 
Until all the legal protections are established for protecting our rights, I dont want any central electronic repository of such knowledge. On paper in my doctors office is just fine for now.

HIPAA, read up on it.

The Privacy Rule took effect on April 14, 2003, with a one-year extension for certain "small plans." It establishes regulations for the use and disclosure of Protected Health Information (PHI). PHI is any information about health status, provision of health care, or payment for health care that can be linked to an individual.[11] This is interpreted rather broadly and includes any part of a patient’s medical record or payment history.

These rules apply to “covered entities” as defined by HIPAA and the HHS. Covered entities include health plans, health care clearinghouses, such as billing services and community health information systems, and health care providers that transmit health care data in a way that is regulated by HIPAA.[9][10]

These are just small peices about HIPAA.

Ask anyone who works around PHI data and they will tell you that the steps taken for HIPAA complience is quite high and there are very large penalties for non-compliance.
 
DO a google for "las vegas endoscopy" and see whats happening now, I liked doctors before and after stuff like that just makes more of a point, and yes i trust google much more then, I trust anyone at a hospital, come on guys you have been there 90% of the people working there are fucking retarded, I dont see how google can be any worse then them
 
HIPAA, read up on it.





These are just small peices about HIPAA.

Ask anyone who works around PHI data and they will tell you that the steps taken for HIPAA complience is quite high and there are very large penalties for non-compliance.

Pentalties are reactive, once your data gets out, it's out. Fines scares business from bad practices, but does nothing to bring your data back or your personal information.

The less people who have your data the more secure your data will be.
 
My company has several medical practices as customers. We provide their IT support. I am willing to bet that your records are far more secure with Google than most practices around. Several of the hospitals had pretty poor security as well. We warn them of the HIPAA compliance issues, but in the end, it's up to them to approve the changes. Security isn't something that doctors think about, or even try to understand.

This is something I hadn't even considered. My first reaction was "NO WAY" to Google holding health records, so I appreciate your POV here.
 
As a doctor, it is certainly helpful to have access to records from other docs you've seen. If you show up in the middle of the night or on the weekend, we have no access to your old information.

While I don't trust google any more than I trust microsoft, cerner, etc., I I think that eventually we'll need some kind of universal database. These systems are in high demand from hospitals, and will likely be required by medicare/medicaid eventually. Google, microsoft, etc all want to license their system to as many places as they can, and that's why these systems are popping up.

Isolation and protection of data is important. As noted above, google targeting hemorrhoid ads at a patient based on their records would be wrong, and hopefully illegal...
 
As noted above, google targeting hemorrhoid ads at a patient based on their records would be wrong, and hopefully illegal...

Likewise, but Steve's quote is unsettling.

To join, users must agree to various terms of use, including this: "When you provide your information through Google Health, you give Google a license to use and distribute it in connection with Google Health and other Google services."
 
I wouldn't be worried about the service at all. I mean, really, what can someone do with your medical records? "Umm, no, I don't know his mother's maiden name, but I do know that he had an MRI on the fourteenth. Is that good enough?"

And what's wrong with targeted ads, anyway? I would much rather see ads that might interest me rather than the hundreds of ads for things that don't even apply to me that I see every day now.
 
But then Google will know you bought Preparation H, and will subsequently email all of your Gmail contacts with the good news.
 
Hell no, this is not a good idea. How soon until employers pay a monthly fee to access applicants' information, or it is broken into/hacked, or identity thieves take your medical info, or it is used for discrimination for pretty much anything, or any other number of possibilities? There's a reason they say honeypots are bad...
 
Hell no, this is not a good idea. How soon until employers pay a monthly fee to access applicants' information, or it is broken into/hacked, or identity thieves take your medical info, or it is used for discrimination for pretty much anything, or any other number of possibilities? There's a reason they say honeypots are bad...

Remember that this is Google we're talking about. Their history is much better than most other corporations (and hospitals) on those issues.
 
"When you provide your information through Google Health, you give Google a license to use and distribute it in connection with Google Health and other Google services."

kiss my dick google.
 
I hope you guys realize that this kind of thing has been out there forever. In fact the company I work for during the summer is the largest medical records archive in the world with almost 2 billion images alone archived. I also hope you realize how absolutely bulletproof these are. First of all, the records are not on the open internet. Second, there are mirrored datacenters on both coasts in case of an earthquake or hurricane or something. Third, we spend tens of thousands or dollars per month on security. Fourth, in order to get into either datacenter, you need a magnetic key and fingerprint recognition. There is biometric security everywhere. People try to hack us on a 24/7 basis, mostly from china, but they don't realize that even if they get into our network they won't get to the images since they are not on the internet.

It would literally take someone deciding to sell your records for their security to be breached. And due to hippa, every single person that enters into the datacenter has to sign various papers and is kept track of very carefully. And don't forget - not just anyone has access to the datacenters.

http://insiteone.com/index.php
 
Basically the point I am trying to make is saying "I am not trusting anyone with my data" is a terribly naive viewpoint. What do you think the hospitals do with your records? The hospitals that are not going filmless and digital are getting left behind due to costs.

Did you know that in some cases, your social security numbers are imbedded in your medical images?
 
Basically the point I am trying to make is saying "I am not trusting anyone with my data" is a terribly naive viewpoint. What do you think the hospitals do with your records? The hospitals that are not going filmless and digital are getting left behind due to costs.

Did you know that in some cases, your social security numbers are imbedded in your medical images?

why would google need to share my info with "other Google services"? its bad enough we have security breeches at stores allowing credit card numbers to be seen. we don't need some other company coming in thinking they're doing us a favor. we have companies specifically for storing records and i think it should stay that way. this whole "jack of all trades, master at none" is getting old and makes things worse. so google, go take a hike and stick to internet searching.
 
If they hack banks then how much likely that it'll be hacked eventually. Not to mention when China decides to 'ask' for some info then they sell it to the highest bidder. Cause we know Google would never hand over information to anyone ever.
 
Also as far as

When you provide your information through Google Health, you give Google a license to use and distribute it in connection with Google Health and other Google services

I looked on googles site and could not see that or anything like it anyone else able to find it or is it more just me?
 
Back
Top