Google Execs to be Charged For 2006 Video

Terry Olaes

I Used to be the [H] News Guy
2FA
Joined
Nov 27, 2006
Messages
4,646
Italian prosecutors are charging four Google execs over a video that was posted on Google Video. The video, posted in 2006, depicted 4 youths taunting a disabled teenager in a classroom in Turin, Italy. Prosecutors state that this is a breach of privacy and is defamatory. Google took down the video within hours of being notified of its existence.

A Google spokesman was quoted as saying that there was no basis for the legal action because under EU legislation - which has been incorporated into Italian law - Google isn't required to monitor third-party content on its sites. It must only take down offending content when it is notified.
 
Is this really Google's fault though? Sure it was on there site, but they cant control what is put on it. They just take things down if its not permitted, which in case they did. Maybe im missing something?
 
Looks like the "prosecutors" are just looking for a way to get paid. They gotta eat too ya know.
 
Is this really Google's fault though? Sure it was on there site, but they can't control what is put on it. They just take things down if its not permitted, which in case they did. Maybe I'm missing something?

Google couldn't and can't police every last video that goes up, No site like that could as there aren't enough people in the world to police YouTube completely, So being notified and then complying seems like the right thing to do, But charging Google Execs?

Ludicrous.

As the charges are a Joke as no country on earth will extradite them I'd think. :p
 
Looks like the "prosecutors" are just looking for a way to get paid. They gotta eat too ya know.

Prosecutors don't make money based on what cases they try or what convictions they get. It is more likely they are just looking for publicity, which is a common ploy for those looking to get elected positions. The whole thing is retarded though. I hope Google's lawyers crush them.
 
invasion of privacy? shit i thought they were going to charge them with making fun of the kid even though they had nothing to do with it... :rolleyes:
 
Maybe they should go after the kids that posted/participated in the video and not google, but I could be wrong :confused:
 
google = rich, italians want to get rich! aim for google! the kids in the video have no money! :D
 
Why do companies even bother doing business in Europe anymore, or allow Europeans to use their services. The governments of Europe are so anti-business its not even funny. Everyday they are passing some absurd law that costs companies millions. And if its not some law being passed, it's some absurd lawsuit.
 
Where is the notion that they are after money coming from? I am certainly not familiar with Italian law, but criminal prosecutions in the U.S. will almost NEVER result in positive cash flow for the government. Even when there are large fines for the crime, the cost of litigation almost always outweighs the actual penalty. And you better believe fighting Google will be an expensive undertaking. Italy is not "suing" them. They can't just seek whatever money damages they want. They can only seek the maximum penalty allowed for this crime.

* I am assuming Italian law is somewhat similar to U.S. law.
 
Where is the notion that they are after money coming from? I am certainly not familiar with Italian law, but criminal prosecutions in the U.S. will almost NEVER result in positive cash flow for the government. Even when there are large fines for the crime, the cost of litigation almost always outweighs the actual penalty. And you better believe fighting Google will be an expensive undertaking. Italy is not "suing" them. They can't just seek whatever money damages they want. They can only seek the maximum penalty allowed for this crime.

* I am assuming Italian law is somewhat similar to U.S. law.

Imagine in some wacky, bizarro parallel universe, Italy actually wins this publicity stunt of a case. What will be the penalty?
Jail time? I Doubt it.
Fines? Most likely.

Seeing as the fines might be enough to cover the costs of the trial they have a snowball's chance in hell of winning, it begs the question: WTF?:confused::confused::confused:
 
Looks like the "prosecutors" are just looking for a way to get paid. They gotta eat too ya know.

Also, they gotta pay off them leases of the Lamborghini's and Ferrari's.
 
Back
Top