Gmail Gets 'Undo Send' Labs Feature

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Google is launching a new Gmail Labs feature called “undo send.” This new feature gives you 5 seconds to press the “undo” button after sending an e-mail, just in case you didn’t really want to send that last e-mail. Kinda cool, but only 5 seconds?

Undo Send is a much smarter feature. We've all regretted pressing "send" on e-mails. Sometimes we realize, too late, that our message is a "reply all" when it shouldn't be. Or that we spelled something wrong. Or that we were angry and shouldn't have sent it at all. Undo Send lets you snatch an e-mail back before it gets sent out. But you have to act fast.
 
Considering that any longer than that and the server will have probably already sent it on its say that makes sense. The only way they could increase the time is hold every email for X amount of time before sending it to the queue to be sent.

I guess I could see a few more seconds not being that bad, however many people expect email to be sent at the exact moment and may not like a 2 or 3 minute delay to their emails being sent.
 
I tend to be playing MMO-games when I'm drunk so I've said some things in the general chat, but never sent any emails I regret.
 
I'm guessing he wasn't thinking 2 or 3 minutes when said "only 5 sec"... it would have made more sense to have it be 10 or 15 seconds, rather than just 5. Hell, first your brain has to register that "oh shit" moment before even attempting to find the "revoke send" button. That alone will take over 5 seconds usually...

15 seconds would have made more sense...
 
But the more time we tack on it, the more we'll be moving away from instant emails. From my work point of view, I don't need the extra wait.

Hey Steve, when are we going to get a 5-second Undo Post feature on this news forum since we don't have edit? ;-)
 
I would agree, 10 seconds would have been more useful, but 5 seconds is probably longer than we think it is.
 
This is basically googles way of saying that "we will give you 5 seconds to undo because really it takes our systems now 5 seconds longer to process the average mail, so now we'll que it to save resources".

That's my two cents.
 
Well, you have to enable the feature, so I'm thinking if they increase the delay for people who have this enabled it would work even better. Remove the delay for those who don't.

I'm guessing he wasn't thinking 2 or 3 minutes when said "only 5 sec"... it would have made more sense to have it be 10 or 15 seconds, rather than just 5. Hell, first your brain has to register that "oh shit" moment before even attempting to find the "revoke send" button. That alone will take over 5 seconds usually...

15 seconds would have made more sense...
 
This is basically googles way of saying that "we will give you 5 seconds to undo because really it takes our systems now 5 seconds longer to process the average mail, so now we'll que it to save resources".

That's my two cents.

I don't think so. If I were implementing this, I'd do it all client side.
Code:
sub fake_send():
  sleep 5
  if not canceled:
    real_send()
sub cancel():
  canceled = True
 
I don't think so. If I were implementing this, I'd do it all client side.
Code:
sub fake_send():
  sleep 5
  if not canceled:
    real_send()
sub cancel():
  canceled = True

Well, they always HAVE been slow to send mail. I think this feature is just taking advantage of that.
 
Would be nice if you could recall it up until the time the recipient opened it. Didn't AOL do that some time ago?
 
Yea, lets teach people to not think/take responsibility before they act.

Make a mistake/send a bad email; your own fault for not being on the ball.
 
Would be nice if you could recall it up until the time the recipient opened it. Didn't AOL do that some time ago?

It would only work if the recipient was also a Gmail address, since then it's all on their servers.

Yea, lets teach people to not think/take responsibility before they act.

Make a mistake/send a bad email; your own fault for not being on the ball.

This isn't just about drunk or angry posting. As others have shown, there's plenty of perfectly legitimate times that this could be used. For instance, accidentally hitting a "send" hotkey, or forgetting to attach something. Please don't jump to conclusions.
 
/sigh...
I've had this for a long time by using rules in outlook. I just set it up to do a 1 min delay on sending an e-mail. If I really need to send something fast I can just go disable the rule and click send/receive and it'll send it instantly. It's saved me several times, usally because I forget to attach an attachment.

As far as stopping "4 letter word e-mails". I don't think anyone ever regrets those till the next morning when the booze wears off.
 
Would be nice if you could recall it up until the time the recipient opened it. Didn't AOL do that some time ago?

That would be possible with email to another user on that same system. however once it gets to the other person on another server there is no telling where it is and there is no way to do something like that unless every mail server had that function added. Which of course would then add possible issues of misuse. I can only imagine that if every server had a special kill off this email switch that people would try to find a way to use it to wipe out every message a person gets. Once it gets to the other person they could be forwarding the email, so you would have to have away to tell it to forward the kill message to other servers. To me that sounds like it would open up far to large of a possible security hole.

I think they sould just leave it how it is now.
 
lol, I just send an email this morning that I realized that I forgot something right after I send it.
 
Something like 15-30 seconds would be better. No one is really expecting e-mails to be instant, they are the new snailmail. So some time is acceptable. If you need someone to know something instantly, you use something else like a text or phone call.
 
AOL did this with same network emails in the 90s. Could unsend up until it was read.
 
This isn't just about drunk or angry posting. As others have shown, there's plenty of perfectly legitimate times that this could be used. For instance, accidentally hitting a "send" hotkey, or forgetting to attach something. Please don't jump to conclusions.

This is exactly why it's valuable to me.
 
I think I like 'Omega 13' better than this... 13 seconds to undo a gigantic mistake.

5 seconds seems too short to do anything, especially when you realize what a mistake you made and frantically try to push the unsend button within that 0.8 seconds remaining. (Especially when you've wasted 4.2 seconds on realizing your mistake)
 
Now, if only Chrome could load the "undo" button in less than 5 seconds, this feature would be useful... J/K
 
Back
Top