Give me your opinion

vict0r

[H]ard|Gawd
Joined
Jul 11, 2005
Messages
1,027
I'm on an Socket 939 AMD X2 4200+ with 1 Gig of memory and a geforce 9600gt

I want a full new system..and since i7's are out I think that it would be the right choice after so long...

I was thinking on going with the i7 920, asus p6t deluxe , corsair 3x2 gig ,corsair 650tx watt psu, wd 6400aaks hdd ,sata dvd rom,with the 9600gt i already have..might get a new video down the road...

what do you think? good upgrade?
 
What size monitor do you have?
What games are you playing?
What else will you be doing with this PC besides gaming?
 
i just feel like its time to jump on newer technology
with this build i will stay for the next 3 to 4 yrs ... maybe do some tiny upgrades but thats it..

im planning on getting a 22 or 24 inch monitor...

im just wondering if that setup is alright..and i am wondering if the msi platinum which is like $70 cheaper will do as good as the p6t..
 
What would be your total budget on this new build? Any parts you will be reusing?
 
9600gt is the only part i will be reusing..
my limit would be around $1300
 
i must add that i dont mind overclocking..i7 2.66 ghz would be plenty..down the road once i start using it..i might get better air cooling and start ocing..
 
My opinion for $1300 with a monitor.

CPU/Mobo(Combo Deal)- Asus P5Q Pro + Intel Core 2 Quad Q9550(2.83ghz) for $400($15 MIR on Asus Mobo)
RAM - OCZ Fatalty Edition 4GB(2x2GB) DDR2 800 for $43 w/free shipping
Video - EVGA Geforce GTX 260(216 stream processor) for $290($20 MIR) w/free shipping and Free FarCry2 w/purchase & register at Manuf.
HDD - WD 6400AAKS 640gig for $75 w/free shipping
Optical Drive - Samsung 22X DVD+/-RW Sata drive for $25 w/free shipping
PSU - Antec EA 650 for $70 w/free shipping
O/S - Windows Vista Home Premium SP1 64bit for $100 w/free shipping
Monitor - LG L227WTG-PF 22" for $260 at Best Buy

Total: $1,263. Under your $1300 budget. This is already a HUGE performance gain over your existing setup. I mean really HUGE gain!

Shucks, I forgot the case hehe Antec 300 case for $55 w/free shipping. Meh.. over $1300 at $1,313. Minor. LoL
 
what about the i7 build that is supposed to last me for the next 3 to 4 years?
 
what about the i7 build that is supposed to last me for the next 3 to 4 years?
Whether or not a system will last 3 to 4 years is dependent on the user most of the time. For gamers and enthusiasts, it's very very hard to say whether or not a Core i7 or C2D will last 3 to 4 years. Two years yes.

Besides your $1300 budget with monitor does not allow for a Core i7 build anyway without doing some serious cost and as well as quality cutting. hardwareGuru barely managed to fit in a C2D build with monitor with that budget. You need at least another $200 to $250 in order to fit in a Core i7.

is that Antec for $70 a good quality psu?
Yes
 
ok..so the Q9550 is good enough compared to an i7 920?

about the psu..i still prefer the corsair 650tx over the antec
 
... about the psu..i still prefer the corsair 650tx over the antec

Which Antec? The Neo? They're both made by Seasonic. They're both good. The Corsair is slightly better and its cables are sleeved.
 
ok..so the Q9550 is good enough compared to an i7 920?

about the psu..i still prefer the corsair 650tx over the antec

Factoring in the cost of motherboard and RAM, the Q9550 is a good choice compared to the i7 920 price wise. Performance wise, the Q9550 will be beaten by the Core i7.

The 650TX is a poor buy as well considering that you can get the 750TX for the same price:
Corsair 750TX 750W PSU - $105

You still have room in your budget, if you go with hardwareGuru's EXCELLENT build for the Corsair 750TX.

@ Enginurd
He's talking about the Antec EA650. That's Delta made, not Seasonic made. Still a good quality PSU nonetheless.
 
so that antec EA650 is enough to power up the system mentioned?

I think that the P5q Pro + Q9550 + 2x2 Gig memory is good enough indeed..especially for someone coming from a s939 x2 4200+ ..
 
so that antec EA650 is enough to power up the system mentioned?

to be honest, Im in such a dillema, now i feel like i could get the E8500 and get it over with and save me some money...

More than enough.

E8500? Well, you could get the E8400 instead, since it has a combo deal with the P5Q Pro. Or, you could save even more money and get the E7200 instead. Do you see where I'm going with this?
 
lol... yes or save more and go with the e5200 or even more and go with the celeron..

i think that the setup that Guru mentioned would suffice me..
and about the psu .. i know that 650w is more than enough but i wanted to know if its a good psu since its so cheap..
 
Here's how I look at the Core i7 cpu compard to a Q9550 cpu. Overall, the Core i7 920 at 2.66ghz is overall faster than a Q9550 at 2.83ghz. However, it is an entry level Core i7 cpu. I know it is overall faster than a Q9550 but, it is pricey considering it's the lowest model Core i7 cpu. I would wait on the Core i7 where it matures more and have more mobo supporting the new CPU. I am looking at at where you're coming from, an X2 4200+ cpu, 1gig DDR RAM and a 9600GT video card. What is it you will be primarily doing with this PC that you will take advantage of the Core i7 architecture? If you say gaming, it does not blow away a Q9550 cpu where I would jump on it. It does show a difference in games at lower resolution like 1024 x 768 where the cpu plays a factor. But, why would you play games at this resolution anyway? As you go higher in res 1680 x 1050 the Core i7 920 does not really blow a Q9550 at that resolution as the GPU comes more into play. A Q9550 + Asus P5Q Pro mobo for $400 is pretty good considering that when the 45nm Q9550 cpu first came out, it was like $550. Your're not paying that amount now. The Asus P5Q Pro mobo was priced at $150+ when it first came out. $550 cpu + $150 mobo = $700. You pay only $400 now for these 2. Imagine the people who paid that much before. LoL. However though, if you looking at primarily gaming, go even cheaper, E8400 dual core + Asus P5Q Pro for $250. Do you really need Core i7 quad cpu to play, Fallout 3, Left 4 Dead, Crysis, Far Cry 2 at 1680 x 1050res and above? The answer is obviously no.
 
Back
Top