German Foreign Office Drops Linux

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Remember all the hoopla about the German Foreign Office switching to Linux? Well, it looks like they are switching back to Windows citing "missing functionality, a lack of usability and poor interoperability."

In response to a question on "the use of open source software in the Foreign Office and other Government departments" submitted in parliament by the SPD (Social Democrats, the main German opposition party), the German government has confirmed that the German Foreign Office is to switch back to Windows desktop systems.
 
So some pencil pushers couldn't figure out Open Office, then?

Maybe not. I recently discovered an sieve of exploits for our network printers in my department here at college... well, possibility of exploits. The IT department is in the same damn college. C'mon, now...
 
Nobody ever got fired for choosing Microsoft (tm)

Linux on the other hand...on the desktop at least. Someone made the sysadmin work too hard, so next refresh he assfucked them all in return ;)
 
Linux is great, it's everything for everyone. But what's the point if you have to reteach everyone how to use a computer? It doesn't make sense in this environment. Someone needs to push OSS from the beginning (early childhood). Developing markets should be Linux's target.
 
bottom line: linux on the desktop won't succeed until games on linux succeeds.
 
Uhhhhhh no shit

You must not use linux?

lack of functionality is very possible though I would be curious to see exactly what problems they came across.

Lack of usability? I would argue that about windows, makes sense this would come up though as 95% of people are not [H] and are not willing to (and would have a hard time) learning something different from what has been drilled into their heads.

Lack of interoperability? I would assume they mean all of their old complex office files that don't work correctly...because Microsoft software was designed that way, so wouldn't that make Widows the OS with lack of interoperability?
 
bottom line: linux on the desktop won't succeed until games on linux succeeds.

But games on linux won't be around until linux on the desktop succeeds ;)

Hopefuly games do succeed on linux though it has been 2 years since I stopped dual booting and the large selection of games is the one thing I miss about windows.
 
Linux is great, it's everything for everyone. But what's the point if you have to reteach everyone how to use a computer? It doesn't make sense in this environment. Someone needs to push OSS from the beginning (early childhood). Developing markets should be Linux's target.

Yeah. Most people only barely manage to use Windows. I don't think at this point you can really change that.

I guess Apple has gotten some people to learn the MacOS, but it's also very idiot proofed, and the core concept hasn't really changed over the decades (just like Windows). I mean, I used Macs very little back in the day or now, but even I know to click up a the top Apple button, where the disk drives are on the desktop, etc.
 
I like linux a lot but theres a reason i dont use it on my main gaming rig. Works fine for my netbook though.
 
This is not really nix's fault. As a rule, people just do not like change. In fact, it is safe to say most abhor it.
Most people know windows. Putting anything else in front of them is bound to cause an issue or two.

It's just a pain in the ass to switch over.
 
I can't really say I blame them. I love Linux, but it just doesn't make a really good, friendly desktop environment (for the non-[H]).

I mean, when was the last time someone had to boot into Linux from Windows to run xxx program? It's pretty much always the other way around. For desktop users (myself included), once they find themselves booting back into Windows to run whatever application it's game over because they just do everything else in Windows too..

You have to go pure, 100% Linux and swear off Windows for Linux on the Desktop to succeed and even then, it's tough.

Riley
 
Is there a reason you don't use windows on your netbook?

Because it came with the piece of restricted crap called windows 7 starter... For only $80 i can legally change my wallpaper!!!! Im not interested in buying a new license for it and linux works fine.
 
Not surprised. I don't think it's a love for windows that brought them back; rather using tools like MS Office and IE (yes, IE. An example is my orgs internal timesheet webapp that can't function without ActiveX; maybe they have something similar). For me, personally, openoffice gets the jobs done. Barely. But if my job was constantly doing things with spreadsheets, PDF's, over-formatted word docs then I'd probably have to dual boot more.

Props for trying though, I'm glad they did and now the community can learn what needs they didn't satisfy and improve.
 
Linux is just hard to use. Simple as it goes. Sure you can candy-coat it a bit with a cute little Windows-clone GUI, but when it comes time where you have to manually install drivers (which is guaranteed at somepoint, with Linux) then the true nature of the OS rears its cryptic head. I remember quite a bad experience with Linux when trying to manually install some nVidia display drivers way back in 2004 or so.

There's a ton of other reasons someone could list about Linux and its career of failure on the desktop, but I think it really just comes down to this: it's just not easy to use.
 
Linux is just hard to use. Simple as it goes. Sure you can candy-coat it a bit with a cute little Windows-clone GUI, but when it comes time where you have to manually install drivers (which is guaranteed at somepoint, with Linux) then the true nature of the OS rears its cryptic head. I remember quite a bad experience with Linux when trying to manually install some nVidia display drivers way back in 2004 or so.

There's a ton of other reasons someone could list about Linux and its career of failure on the desktop, but I think it really just comes down to this: it's just not easy to use.

You clearly have not used it again since 2004 then... These days most machines will work right off the bat, at most you have to install restricted drivers which couldn't be any easier.

These days its just as easy to use as windows if not more so. Its getting people to get out of the mentality that something new = something hard.

Just saying, maybe you shouldnt bash something you clearly have no experience with in 7 years. :rolleyes:
 
You clearly have not used it again since 2004 then... These days most machines will work right off the bat, at most you have to install restricted drivers which couldn't be any easier.

These days its just as easy to use as windows if not more so. Its getting people to get out of the mentality that something new = something hard.

Just saying, maybe you shouldnt bash something you clearly have no experience with in 7 years. :rolleyes:

Typical fanboy post. That's funny, I remember the exact same statements you just rehashed being said then, as well. I'm sorry, but Linux has a very long way to go before it can be a true alternative to Windows. And it's hardly changed since then, as friends and co-workers that have dabbled with Ubuntu, the 'noobiest' Linux distro, have experienced my exact issues, particularly with video cards, wireless network cards, etc. The support just isn't there (open source), and many manufacturers don't and won't make Linux drivers.

OpenOffice is the same story, maybe worse off. Have recently had the displeasure of using that for a large thesis.
 
They don't call it LOLnix for nothing.
Server side it's a no brainer in many cases, on the Desktop side Linux just doesn't cut it for the majority of users. Before you reply "But but Ubuntu!" let's just say that reality has already proven me right. ;)
 
Typical fanboy post. That's funny, I remember the exact same statements you just rehashed being said then, as well. I'm sorry, but Linux has a very long way to go before it can be a true alternative to Windows. And it's hardly changed since then, as friends and co-workers that have dabbled with Ubuntu, the 'noobiest' Linux distro, have experienced my exact issues, particularly with video cards, wireless network cards, etc. The support just isn't there (open source), and many manufacturers don't and won't make Linux drivers.

OpenOffice is the same story, maybe worse off. Have recently had the displeasure of using that for a large thesis.

I just cant help but laugh at the sheer ignorance of what you say as i type this in windows 7...

You caught me im just a linux fanboy. :cool:

If you have trouble installing video drivers in ubuntu today then how the fuck do you manage difficult tasks such as turning on your computer?!?! OMG BIG BUTTON OR LITTLE BUTTON??? SOMEONE CALL IT.

Openoffice still sucks though.
 
You must not use linux?

lack of functionality is very possible though I would be curious to see exactly what problems they came across.

Lack of usability? I would argue that about windows, makes sense this would come up though as 95% of people are not [H] and are not willing to (and would have a hard time) learning something different from what has been drilled into their heads.

Lack of interoperability? I would assume they mean all of their old complex office files that don't work correctly...because Microsoft software was designed that way, so wouldn't that make Widows the OS with lack of interoperability?


I do use it, but not as often as Windows... mostly due to gaming, and corporate compliance.


Well, missing certain functions that may or may not have been loaded in the initial image can cause serious issues... we are talking about typical office employees here. Teaching them to click an icon and choose an installation path and hit next in Windows is hard enough. Having them go into a CLI or have them install a package in *nix is miles above their head... so yeah missing functionality is basically a part of the package. (and sometimes desired by *nix users)


Usability touches on the above functionality issue, it is quite difficult to install packages for these types of people.... and a lot of the shortcuts and commands that we all run very easily can be quite complex if you need to learn how to point and click your way through them.


The lack of interoperability I would imagine is most likely due to equipment.... Scanners, printers, copiers, cameras, badge swipes all would have to be compatible and they may not have drivers that work well with them or have the budget to replace the devices with ones from a manufacturer that does.


You have to look at the targeted users here... its not a bunch of geeks sitting around with multiboot systems and 3 monitors with an IRC window open. Its people like my 55 year old aunt who barely navigates through eBay and just have to process monthly expense reports into a spreadsheet or update personnel data for HR.
 
I forgot to add this quote and I can't edit.


"Linux is free if your time is worth nothing"


Training everyone to use linux would be a costly undertaking for these types of large organizations.
 
I do use it, but not as often as Windows... mostly due to gaming, and corporate compliance.


Well, missing certain functions that may or may not have been loaded in the initial image can cause serious issues... we are talking about typical office employees here. Teaching them to click an icon and choose an installation path and hit next in Windows is hard enough. Having them go into a CLI or have them install a package in *nix is miles above their head... so yeah missing functionality is basically a part of the package. (and sometimes desired by *nix users)


Usability touches on the above functionality issue, it is quite difficult to install packages for these types of people.... and a lot of the shortcuts and commands that we all run very easily can be quite complex if you need to learn how to point and click your way through them.


The lack of interoperability I would imagine is most likely due to equipment.... Scanners, printers, copiers, cameras, badge swipes all would have to be compatible and they may not have drivers that work well with them or have the budget to replace the devices with ones from a manufacturer that does.


You have to look at the targeted users here... its not a bunch of geeks sitting around with multiboot systems and 3 monitors with an IRC window open. Its people like my 55 year old aunt who barely navigates through eBay and just have to process monthly expense reports into a spreadsheet or update personnel data for HR.

About installing packages, have you ever used software center (ubuntu or debian), also in most situations don't those users not even have the permission to install things?

your point about interoperability is very true, likely all their old equipment did not work, I just figured this is something they would have thought about before they switched :)

About the target user base my (about) 55 year old aunt uses linux, I switched her computer to it after she had way to many problems in windows and I got tired of driving all the way to her place. I have it set up now that if she has a problem I just connect remotely to it, but she does not seem to have any problems anymore. Also my girlfriend who can not even install something on windows uses my computer exclusively for her schoolwork. These are just success stories I have had, I also tried to switch my mom but she made me switch her back because the spider solitaire was not as pretty....
 
bottom line: linux on the desktop won't succeed until games on linux succeeds.

Agreed and I'm a die hard linux fan.
All my PRODUCTIVE time on a PC is with linux. And tying to accomplish the same in Windows a PITA.
I have a dual boot with windows for playing games only.
 
Linux is just hard to use. Simple as it goes. Sure you can candy-coat it a bit with a cute little Windows-clone GUI, but when it comes time where you have to manually install drivers (which is guaranteed at somepoint, with Linux) then the true nature of the OS rears its cryptic head. I remember quite a bad experience with Linux when trying to manually install some nVidia display drivers way back in 2004 or so.

There's a ton of other reasons someone could list about Linux and its career of failure on the desktop, but I think it really just comes down to this: it's just not easy to use.

Wow, if the last time you touched a linux distro was 7 years ago you are way behind the times.
That is kind of like only having experience on Windows95 and saying "windows is junk" based on that.
But I'm sure many have had a similar experience.
The more I use Linux the more I'm pleasantly surprises how easy things are to accomplish once you get past the "linux is complicated" bugaboo.
 
I find it odd that most people who are Linux fans really don't use it in a corporate environment. Some facts about Linux. It is a niche product and excels on the server side with some great tools that are easy to use and work well, there is a push in the open source community to provide these tools for the server community, but even here it is limited. What Linux does well it does very well. The problem is that what I does well is to damn little to be viable in most corporate environments baring specific functions.

Some things fan boys forget.
1. If I deploy Linux I still will likely want to buy a support contract from someone as the chance that I have multiple Linux experts on staff is minimal. Now I'm not talking about the fact that you can install Linux or support simple problems. I'm referring to a major system failure that needs to be resolved right away and you don't have 2-5 days to dick around with it to fix it. You have never seen this problem and you can't wait until someone on a forum somewhere gives you a hint as to what just went wrong in your production environment. so suddenly the cost of your free os just went way up.

2. As workstation replacement forget it. If your users cant find everything they are used to and find it easily production suffers. Telling your ceo that I'm sorry but Linux doesn't let you do that is not an answer. Or how well do you think things will sit with senior management when they are preparing a presentation and no matter what they do it just looks ok in open office(yes I know PowerPoint is the devil). Or they forget to save it correctly then it sends to someone and then gets a reply back that they can't open it so they are stuck re-saving and resending the same file. While these sound like training issues they are really human factors issues and if you make this hard or problematic I guarantee the net result is going to be diminished productivity. And heaven forbid you have any sort of one off device on the workstations. Unless the vendor provides a driver you are downright shafted. cost of developing a driver in house will run 20k to 75k for one driver and I guarantee it wont have everything the driver the vendor provides.

3. Legacy applications and drivers. Some one drops 50k on a plotter printer and no one has written drivers for. So now you have to spend either time or money developing a driver kit for that device this costs time and lots of money. Now multiply this by many devices and suddenly your open source solution is costing you 2 to 3 times what your out of the box solution form Microsoft or Mac provided. This also does not include specialty software such as VPN/financial/hr software. All of these software products may not work on your Linux box so now you have to duel boot the system and you just pissed any cost savings into the wind. People will argue that hey Linux rocks at doing VPN. and you are correct it does but there are some real shortcomings to the Linux VPN. Most of these have been addressed by vendors but guess what their solutions aren't free so cost saving is nil.

Suffice it so say Linux is a great product but it doesn't have the money or the support the systems traditional off the shelf products do. In the corporate world its about money and productivity and sadly Linux doesn't save you money or increase productivity. And arguing that all we need to do is retrain people is not a valid argument if the product isn't at least a little bit intuitive forget it.
 
I find it odd that most people who are Linux fans really don't use it in a corporate environment. Some facts about Linux. It is a niche product and excels on the server side with some great tools that are easy to use and work well, there is a push in the open source community to provide these tools for the server community, but even here it is limited. What Linux does well it does very well. The problem is that what I does well is to damn little to be viable in most corporate environments baring specific functions.

Some things fan boys forget.
1. If I deploy Linux I still will likely want to buy a support contract from someone as the chance that I have multiple Linux experts on staff is minimal. Now I'm not talking about the fact that you can install Linux or support simple problems. I'm referring to a major system failure that needs to be resolved right away and you don't have 2-5 days to dick around with it to fix it. You have never seen this problem and you can't wait until someone on a forum somewhere gives you a hint as to what just went wrong in your production environment. so suddenly the cost of your free os just went way up.

2. As workstation replacement forget it. If your users cant find everything they are used to and find it easily production suffers. Telling your ceo that I'm sorry but Linux doesn't let you do that is not an answer. Or how well do you think things will sit with senior management when they are preparing a presentation and no matter what they do it just looks ok in open office(yes I know PowerPoint is the devil). Or they forget to save it correctly then it sends to someone and then gets a reply back that they can't open it so they are stuck re-saving and resending the same file. While these sound like training issues they are really human factors issues and if you make this hard or problematic I guarantee the net result is going to be diminished productivity. And heaven forbid you have any sort of one off device on the workstations. Unless the vendor provides a driver you are downright shafted. cost of developing a driver in house will run 20k to 75k for one driver and I guarantee it wont have everything the driver the vendor provides.

3. Legacy applications and drivers. Some one drops 50k on a plotter printer and no one has written drivers for. So now you have to spend either time or money developing a driver kit for that device this costs time and lots of money. Now multiply this by many devices and suddenly your open source solution is costing you 2 to 3 times what your out of the box solution form Microsoft or Mac provided. This also does not include specialty software such as VPN/financial/hr software. All of these software products may not work on your Linux box so now you have to duel boot the system and you just pissed any cost savings into the wind. People will argue that hey Linux rocks at doing VPN. and you are correct it does but there are some real shortcomings to the Linux VPN. Most of these have been addressed by vendors but guess what their solutions aren't free so cost saving is nil.

Suffice it so say Linux is a great product but it doesn't have the money or the support the systems traditional off the shelf products do. In the corporate world its about money and productivity and sadly Linux doesn't save you money or increase productivity. And arguing that all we need to do is retrain people is not a valid argument if the product isn't at least a little bit intuitive forget it.

So much truth here.

I work in a very large enterprise environment as a *nix/AD/Exch admin. All of our webservers/DBs/middleware is *nix based. All of our intranet applications are windows/IIS/AD/sharepoint/exch/Office etc based. You know why? Because in a large environment, linux fucking SUCKS for desktop use and everyday usability for the end-users who are 95% retarded. It would be a logistical nightmare to manage these systems if they were all linux.

Bottom line is that everyone uses microsoft, so its standard.
 
I find it odd that most people who are Linux fans really don't use it in a corporate environment. Some facts about Linux. It is a niche product and excels on the server side with some great tools that are easy to use and work well, there is a push in the open source community to provide these tools for the server community, but even here it is limited. What Linux does well it does very well. The problem is that what I does well is to damn little to be viable in most corporate environments baring specific functions.
.

You are exactly right. When you are dealing with an office full of mostly computer illiterate people, any change in "they way they always did it" is a death sentence.
But for the self supporting "computer professional" who does not depend on a corporate infrastructure, linux is a great alternative to windows. The problem is most people think you will spend all you time fixing thing that don't work right.
I have various linux distros installed on several 2 PCs and 2 laptops. All found working drivers for all devices, bluetooth, wireless networking, Ethernet, embedded device, etc, etc. Ubuntu even scanned the network and found my sharp color copier, found drivers for it and installed it.
My first reaction was "Yeah right, lets see how well this works" It freaking worked BETTER than the windows driver.
Like I said before, the only thing I use windows for now is gaming. Call me a fanboy if you want, but it is for a good reason. It works for me without compromise.
 
bottom line: linux on the desktop won't succeed until games on linux succeeds.

I tried to get my nephew to use linux.

He whined to much about not being able to use net flicks without using wine.
 
Biggest thing for my company is unique windows software. We do have two linux computers that are old P4's, but they are web-access only. Everything else is Windows. There's no way our niche software we use could work in Linux.

Sure, I can build a Linux box for work and make it *LOOK* like Windows, but it won't *BE* Windows.

It all depends upon a few things, namely how well people are trained in the transition to Linux, and the ability of Linux to completely replace all functionality of Windows. If the software can't run, and the training takes too long or is ineffective, why switch?
 
Back
Top