German Fallout 3 Ban Lifted

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
The ban on Fallout 3 in Germany has been lifted. If you live in Germany and haven't played the game yet, don't wait for the rumored HD remaster, get it and start playing it now. ;)


Bethesda has successfully appealed the ruling by the Federal Department for Media Harmful to Minors (BPjM) restricting the sale of Fallout 3 in Germany, noting that such applications are rarely granted. "In the case of Fallout 3 the request for de-listing was granted even though only seven years passed since the game was banned," the BPjM said in a statement.
 
i bet the game is the most pirated in counties with bans, lol.
 
i bet the game is the most pirated in counties with bans, lol.
I think you have a strong point there....On one hand Germany really has its shit together, and then on the other makes no fucking sense at all....you can bet they all played it....just for free lol
 
I think you have a strong point there....On one hand Germany really has its shit together, and then on the other makes no fucking sense at all....you can bet they all played it....just for free lol


Kinder Surprise Eggs?

Every country has a nice selection of stupid shit to show off.
 
I think you have a strong point there....On one hand Germany really has its shit together, and then on the other makes no fucking sense at all....you can bet they all played it....just for free lol

You must have never lived in Germany if you think they really have their shit together. Also bans really don't mean much in Germany. Just cross the border and pick up the game. That or do like I do, run TunnelBear to buy the game on Steam, then turn it off and start the download.

I also have to use clipconverter to download music videos from Youtube. because of GEMA (aka German version if RIAA).
 
How are they going to do an HD remaster, Fallout 4 doesn't even look good enough to qualify.
 
HD remaster? Didn't the fans already do that with mods?

I bought Fallout 3 on day one and then didn't play it to completion for almost 3 years. Fallout 4 may end up suffering the same fate. Thanks to Steam sales and bundles I have at least a hundred games on my backlog.
 
Just to clarify - the game has been available here since launch. Gore and blood had been removed, though. Plus the game was only available with german voiceovers. The article refers to the international version which should be available here soon.
Our ratings board has been a little less... protective in recent years, so this comes more as an affirmation of a trend. Greetings from the home country of good beer! :)

P.S.: Shit together? Germans? Oh boy... :D
 
I was always struck by the lyrics to a particular polka in a collection that was marketed on TV years ago: "In heaven, they have no beer... that's why we drink it here..."
 
Can anyone provide more detail about the German law about games and their harmfulness to minors?

I'm curious what specifically about Fallout triggered it (I thought the game was mostly harmless from that perspective). I'd be curious what criteria they look for, and what their age groups are.

Also, rather than ban it outright, why not just enforce an age limit?
 
Can anyone provide more detail about the German law about games and their harmfulness to minors?

I'm curious what specifically about Fallout triggered it (I thought the game was mostly harmless from that perspective). I'd be curious what criteria they look for, and what their age groups are.

Also, rather than ban it outright, why not just enforce an age limit?

Ehhh, maybe something to do with the fact that once you get out of the vault into the wasteland, the first town you're supposed to visit (Megaton) gives you the chance to a) detonate a nuke right in the center, and/or b), chat up the friendly local bar skank hooker for a "good time"......
 
Ehhh, maybe something to do with the fact that once you get out of the vault into the wasteland, the first town you're supposed to visit (Megaton) gives you the chance to a) detonate a nuke right in the center, and/or b), chat up the friendly local bar skank hooker for a "good time"......


Right. Forgot about that part :p
 
Can anyone provide more detail about the German law about games and their harmfulness to minors?

I'm curious what specifically about Fallout triggered it (I thought the game was mostly harmless from that perspective). I'd be curious what criteria they look for, and what their age groups are.

Also, rather than ban it outright, why not just enforce an age limit?

Hehe, I'll try and explain as good as I can: the BPJS (the board of people tasked with protection of minors in this context) is basically a byproduct of democratizing Germany after the end of WWII. It was designed as a safeguard against toys and publications that could be used to influence minors into adopting inhuman/fascist/etc. worldviews. Most of its work is in fact to take neo-nazi trash out of public circulation.
Back in the nineties when there was no ratings system for videogames, often when a game popped up on the radar of (usually) a social worker who deals with minors that was rather heavy on the blood and gore (think Mortal Kombat I-III), said social worker could then file a report with the BPJS for them to check the game for certain qualities. Back in the day, the banhammer was swung quite often, then a ratings system was finally established. Today the rules are as follows: games get rated like they do in most other countries and the overwhelming majority will get an age rating and will therefore be legal to buy and sell in Germany. The highest age rating there is would be 18 and up. For rather extreme cases (the movie "Dead Presidents", very graphic Vietnam War movie would be a good example of that) it has to be determined if the depiction of violence is actually in conflict with the law. If it is found to be legal from the standpoint of a state attourney then the movie gets a special seal and may be sold "under the table". Games that get refused an age rating however, are subject to an investigation by a BPJS tribunal, usually consisting of at least three people. If they find the game legally objectionable, it goes on the Index. It may then be no longer put on public display, be marketed in magazines, on TV, etc. and may only be sold "under the counter" when a customer explicitly asks for the game and can provide an ID for age verification. There is also a special subsection of the Index for things that contain outright illegal imagery or idealization of certain idiologies (easiest example would be Nazi imagery like swastikas, which are found in many a Call of Duty game and therefore have prompted special German versions of those games where all the illegal stuff is replaced by generic period-correct alternatives, while the international versions of those games sit happily on the bad subsection of the Index until the end of all time :) ).
As for the specific triggers - those change with the times. Most of the stuff that got on the Index back in the eighties wouldn't be anything to write home about by today's standards. Which is why an ordinary case of indexing will only last for a set amount of years before the publisher may file for a release (prominent example of long-time mainstay on the Index: the original Doom :) ). Generally speaking: the trigger would be excessive depiction of violence while providing little to no moral context. Violence as gameplay driving factor, killing without alternatives or the act of killing as a reward-mechanic in and of itself (think MK's Fatalities!) are typically what sets the BPJS off. A report is filed for each game and is made publicly accessible. I never bothered with it, though, so I can't tell you where to look exactly.
Wall of text notwithstanding: the number of indexed games has dramatically declined over the past few years as a result of A) german ratings boards relaxing a good bit and giving 18+ seals to games that wouldn't have gotten them even five years ago and B) the publishers and gamemakers knowing what to watch out for and making their games easier to swallow for the german market to begin with.
Since Microsoft and Sony make it company policy to respect local laws, games like Gears of War I and II have never even been released here (while also sitting snuggly on the Index).

Sorry for the lengthy post but it is a rather complex subject - consider it german thoroughness. ;)
 
Back
Top