Gaming PC Critique

Zoalord

Weaksauce
Joined
Nov 22, 2005
Messages
70
Coolermaster RC-830-SSN2-GP CM Stacker 830 Aluminum Full Tower Case (Silver) Retail $239.99

XFX MB-N680-ILT nForce 680i LT SLI Socket 775 1333MHz DDR2-800 ATX Motherboard Retail $189.99 ($30.00 Mail In Rebate)

Coolmax CW-650T 650W Silent Fan Power Supply Retail ***Free Shipping*** 1 $129.99 ($40.00 Mail in Rebate)

Intel® Core 2 Duo E6600 Conroe Processor 2.4GHz, 1066FSB, LGA775, 4MB Cache Retail $224.90

OCZ OCZ2N800SR2GK DDR2 PC2-6400 800MHz NVIDIA SLI Ready Edition Dual Channel Memory Retail $161 ($40.00 Mail in Rebate)


My Current Build is a P4 3.2Ghz Prescott 1Gig of 2700 DDR2
XFX 7900GT XXX Edition
I am considering dropping the over expensive case above and finding another 7900 card to sli instead of waiting till the fall to buy 2 8800 gt cards for sli purposes.

I'd love for some feedback as to if I should just keep what I have, Or is the core duo chip a worthwhile upgrade?

Is the coolermaster case worth the $$$ or should I stick with the good power supply and just get a 50$ case?
Should I pickup a second 7900 card now or wait and get 2 8800's in the fall?

Now some of your first questions are going to be what I'm doing with this pc. Well obviously games games and more games. I play WoW on occasion. City of Heroes alot. and am a huge Team Fortress Quake veteran. So I'm anticipating Quake Wars and TF2, maybe even Huxley.
I'm probably going to upgrade to 4Gig of Ram when one of those games release in the build above.

So Critique, comment, leave Feedback as to what you think I should do.
Thx.
 
I'm not on the bleeding edge of C2D motherboards, but I know that there are a number of different less expensive alternatives to the 680i chipset, so I'm going to leave that for when Enginurd inevitibly recommends the DS3 or S3 from Gigabyte ;)

First off, swap out that PSU for the Corsair 620HX @ $129 after rebate. If you don't really think you'll be doing SLI (remember, SLI is only really worth it when playing games at 1900x1200+ resolutions, and running SLI on low-end cards isn't worth it because the next gen midrange card is usually at least as fast as two previous gen cards), then go for the 520HX @ $97 after rebate.

Secondly, I'm going to speculate that you'll be overclocking. If I'm correct, then you should definitely consider what I think is the best deal for o/c RAM right now: Ballistix Tracers (2x1GB) for $115 after rebate and the $5 "new customer" discount [here]. Eclipse finished up his review of them yesterday, and you can find it [here]

That case is excellent, but only really worth it if you're begging for the size or the little random features it has. A less expensive case with great airflow and good quality construction is the P180 or P180b (the black variant), and those run for $129.

With the amount of money saved from that case (and RAM), I'd then trade up the 7900GT for either an 8800GTS 320/640 or HD 2900XT/XL (depending how the reviews pan out).
 
Couple of points:

1) As mentioned above, SLI is only worth it for its ability to push a lot of pixels. If you're gaming at a resolution below 1900x1200, then you won't need it. Secondly, with the current availability of graphic cards, SLI really only makes sense if you go with current high-end cards. This means the 8800 GTX (the 8800 Ultra is just nonsense.) In almost all other cases, buying a newer and/or more powerful replacement for your current card will prove to offer more performance, and will be cheaper and much less of a hassle than getting a second copy of your current card for SLI. If you decide to go SLI, then the best motherboard on the market is the EVGA nForce 680i A1 model. It's a bit more expensive than the XFX LT, but it's a proven design and is known to be a great overclocker with both dual core and quad core chips. EVGA's tech support and warranty is also best in the business.

If you decide that SLI is not for you, then consider the Gigabyte DS3 based on the P965 chipset. This board is also extremely reliable and holds the crown for top FSB speed. While 680i/LT/650i boards are great overclockers, the DS3 can still pull out ahead.

2) The RAM you've listed is very expensive. Remember that SLI ready is a marketing term and will have almost no value to you if you follow one of the many great guides on how to properly overclock a C2D machine. 2 gigs of DDR2-800 RAM is often going for $99 on newegg these days. Look at the G.Skill PC-6400 C5 model, and even Buffallo Firestick or Cruxial Ballistic sticks with D9 chips (which can overclock to 1000Mhz) have been seen for $99.

3) Keep in mind that if you upgrade to 4 gigs of RAM, you will need a 64-bit OS to use it all. Otherwise, you'll be limited to, at most, 3.2 gigs (2.5 gigs if you have an 8800 GTX SLI setup.)

Good luck with the build,

Mark.
 
Some more points to be made:

1) With the E6600, you can get away with using cheap DDR2-667 or DDR2 800 RAM for overclocking. A good cheap set of RAM is the G.Skill 2 x 1GB GNBQ set for around $95 or so. However, if you can find a cheaper set of DDR2 667 or DDR2 800 RAM, then go for it.

2) I've recommended the DS3 to a lot of people here on the forums, I'm gonna do the same for you: Grab the DS3 from clubit.com and you'll get some decent overclocks with it.

3) Go with any of quadnad's suggestions for the PSU. Corsair PSU's are basically rebadged Seasonic power supplies , some of the best quality power supplies out there, that have been screened for better quality by Corsair.

4) As for computer cases, choose whatever one you like and can live with for a while. Cases are a personal choice item so it's up to you whether or not that case is worth it. But do remember that the more you spend on a case, the less money you'll have to spend on better parts.
 
Ahh... well, everyone already mentioned everything, I think. I started my post earlier in the day, then continued at the end of the day, but forgot to refresh for new posts, lol.

So, the main question still remains, what size monitor will you be gaming on?

Also, I'd rather have better parts than an uber-expensive, nice case. Coolermaster makes one of the best budget cases around, too... the Centurion series. Check it out if you want to drop to the $50 price range on cases.
 
The power supply they're suggesting isn't just better - Coolmax is on the stickied list of power supply brands not to use because there's a decent chance of them blowing up and frying your parts.
 
ive got dual 19inch lcd's
but i also have a 60inch hdtv that i hook up from dvi-> hdmi occasionally when my wife would rather i spend my time gaming in the living room instead of huddled away in the bat cave also known as my office.

From what I have read it would seem that sticking with the vid card I have and purchasing to 8800GTX for SLI in Quarter 03 or 04 would do the trick.

I've also swapped the case to a Thermaltake Armor JR.
Swapped the power supply as suggested and changed the ram to the crucial ballistix.

I've never overclocked a pc before for the simple reason that I want the pc to stay alive as long as it is normally supposed to. I might however overclock this one.
The only question that didn't get answered from my original post is how will it compete against what I currently have.

a P4 Prescott 3.2Ghz vs Core 2 Duo 2.66Ghz (will I see a performance increase in games or just OS)
DDR2 533 1Gb vs DDR2 800 2Gb (obviously faster)
vid card would remain the same.
 
The Core 2 Duo is a revolutionary upgrade over your P4. You should see a very noticeable performance upgrade with both the processor and the added RAM.

Mark.
 
ive got dual 19inch lcd's
but i also have a 60inch hdtv that i hook up from dvi-> hdmi occasionally when my wife would rather i spend my time gaming in the living room instead of huddled away in the bat cave also known as my office.

From what I have read it would seem that sticking with the vid card I have and purchasing to 8800GTX for SLI in Quarter 03 or 04 would do the trick.

I've also swapped the case to a Thermaltake Armor JR.
Swapped the power supply as suggested and changed the ram to the crucial ballistix.

I've never overclocked a pc before for the simple reason that I want the pc to stay alive as long as it is normally supposed to. I might however overclock this one.
The only question that didn't get answered from my original post is how will it compete against what I currently have.

a P4 Prescott 3.2Ghz vs Core 2 Duo 2.66Ghz (will I see a performance increase in games or just OS)
DDR2 533 1Gb vs DDR2 800 2Gb (obviously faster)
vid card would remain the same.

SLI only supports a single monitor, and with a 19" monitor, you won't need SLI unless you'll be gaming on your 60" TV. Actually, your 60" will only need a single GTX, too, since its resolution is only 1920x1080, at best (slightly less than a 24" LCD Monitor). Save your money and don't bother with SLI if you don't need it. Try a single GTX first, before buying the second.

The Core 2 Duo is a revolutionary upgrade over your P4. You should see a very noticeable performance upgrade with both the processor and the added RAM.

Mark.

Indeed.

Here, play with this:
http://www23.tomshardware.com/cpu.html?modelx=33&model1=461&model2=432&chart=166
 
Zoalord said:
so your pick would be the gigabyte ds3 965 chipset even though for 20$ more you can get the XFX 680i LT with all of the bells and whistles that it does for ram?

and gives me the option to do sli if TF2 or Quake Wars is written to take advantage of sli.

I don't believe SLI performance improvement is a software limited thing. Therefore, on a 19" monitor, no, I dont believe you'll see a huge improvement with SLI, especially considering the cost of another videocard, regardless of the game. I believe SLI is transparent to the game/software, thats the whole point of bridging two cards to act as one. Please, someone correct me if I'm wrong.

Keep in mind, videocards depreciate the fastest out of all the other computer components.

That XFX 680i LT board is $185, compared to the DS3, which is only $115. Sure, theres a rebate that brings it down to $155, but thats still more than a $20 difference... in fact, its double the difference you stated... $40. If you don't need SLI, then I wouldnt spend any extra money for it unless you plan on upgrading your monitor to a size that will take advantage of SLI. The DS3 is one of the best boards out there for non-dual vidcard setups. If you feel that for $40 more, the XFX is worth it, then by all means, go for it. I'm just here to let you know what you're spending your money on.
 
I don't believe SLI performance improvement is a software limited thing. Therefore, on a 19" monitor, no, I dont believe you'll see a huge improvement with SLI, especially considering the cost of another videocard, regardless of the game. I believe SLI is transparent to the game/software, thats the whole point of bridging two cards to act as one. Please, someone correct me if I'm wrong.
Usually one of the SLI modes will work for all games, but oftentimes new games need to wait for another driver release until an actual performance increase is seen.

To the OP: I wouldn't bother with SLI if I were you; just save the money like Enginurd said with the non-SLI board and put it towards a far more capable videocard.
 
thx all for the help. After consideration from the past couple of two-three posts. The DS3+different powersupply would have saved 80$ which could have then gone towards a sound card or saved it for a rainy day.

The 80$ really wasn't a big deal so I kept the xfx mobo and the 620HX power supply and went for it.

This at least gives me the option of going sli at a later date if i get a new monitor or if i really wanna throw some money at two video cards for my future TF2 addiction.

Plus it also gives me a reason to look at a 2nd 7900gt card for my pc and if it doesn't do any better in performance throw it in my wife's computer which would be a huge upgrade from a 9600XT ATI card.
I'll let you all know how this pc turns out after I receive all the parts.
So far 826$ minus 80$ for rebates.
 
Plus it also gives me a reason to look at a 2nd 7900gt card for my pc and if it doesn't do any better in performance throw it in my wife's computer which would be a huge upgrade from a 9600XT ATI card.

Umm, wasn't the 9600Xt an AGP card? Does your wife's PC come with both an AGP and PCI-E port?
 
no it does not but my current pc does have pci-e which i was going to temporarily make it a httpc for dvr purposes.

but if and when i do get a second 7900 i can reactivate my pc and then make hers the dvr box.
 
but if and when i do get a second 7900 i can reactivate my pc and then make hers the dvr box.

If you sell the 7900GT for $150, instead of buying a used one for $150, that gives you $300. With that $300, you could pickup an 8800GTS, which would outperform the 7900GTs in SLI, all by itself (non SLI).
 
Back
Top