Game Dev Abuses Copyright to Censor Negative Review?

The way I see it, if the dev or publisher truly felt that their copyright was being infringed on, they would demand TB to take ALL of his reviews down - the positive ones too. If they only take down the negative ones, then it's a clear case of abusing the law - copyright and fair use.
 
There is space for debate about "Let's Play" or gameplay videos being reviews/fair use.

No, there isn't. There would be if those were marketed as movies, but they clearly state games. I know they are movies, but their producers/publishers claim they're making games... so fuck them.
 
Hardware reviews are the worst, but I don't want to get into that shit pile of fuck. Let me put it like this, how you think everyone has reviews ready as soon as a product is released?

You're not lumping Kyle and the [H] crew in with this are you? :eek:
 
Reviewers accept NDAs and receive some sort of reviewer's kit outlining information that the manufacturers wishes to be relayed in the review and suggestions on how to approach the review process. This in no way binds reviewers to producing only a favorable review.

There are certainly bad manufacturers who'll cut you out the first time a word like 'horrendous' is thrown around, but they're the exception, not the rule. Most are just looking for honest evaluation. The manufacturer confident enough in a hardware product to partner with the press on pre-release products would like for a gushing review, but rarely expects one.
Yea that's not how it works. You give enough negative reviews and suddenly nobody gives you hardware to review. Most hardware review sites don't have enough money to buy each piece of hardware to review. They live off reviewer kits, which essentially get handed around. Most of those review kits are hand picked, and don't accurately show the hardware.

A good example is OCZ SSD's. The company is ready to go belly up, but anyone who's ever bought one knows why. Damn things are unreliable and crash with BSOD. Plus OCZ's technical support is junk. But most reviews are just a benchmark-o-thon. Which is why even I go by Amazon reviews, or even Newegg reviews. Yea a lot of them can be fake, but those are easy to spot. If you know how to shift the crap from the good, these reviews are the best. They won't tell you how the product will perform, but those reviews are plentiful. There's no lack of benchmarks, but almost nothing on reliability.
 
As an Amazon Associate, HardForum may earn from qualifying purchases.
Well, gotta love being able to read up on a game at the Steam forum and see how much negative feedback games like this are getting before a "scandal" where the dev fakes copyright infringement to pull a bad review.
The review is harsh, but he does point out several valid points like issues with the screen popping, the player and npcs just dying for absolutely no reason.
Really, if I tried to play this game and the same things happened to me I wouldn't be talking about good points because there don't seem to be.
 
we already had a thread, glad this made the front page Steve

TB has a law degree, we could hardly ask for a better test case for fair use, we'll see what happens I guess
 
Back
Top