Game Dev Abuses Copyright to Censor Negative Review?

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
Here's an interesting story for all you amateur copyright lawyers out there. Was the developer within his rights or is this a clear cut case of censorship? Either way, it makes you think twice about posting YouTube video reviews. :eek:

Millions of gamers around the world rely on the hard work of professional reviewers in order to decide where to spend their hard-earned cash. Of course, opinions can swing both ways but these days it’s apparently possible for companies to censor the ones they don’t like, Over the weekend TotalBiscuit, a top reviewer with more than a million subscribers, was subjected to a bogus copyright complaint from Wild Games Studio which silenced his highly critical review of their game Day One: Garry’s Incident.
 
So now we know a game studio to completely avoid when looking at games to buy.
 
There is a clear exception to copyright under fair use for reporting. The reviewer may very well win if he took it to court, but he'd have to have the money to retain a lawyer or have someone like the EFF step in on his behalf, and have the time to deal with any legal proceedings.
 
There is a clear exception to copyright under fair use for reporting. The reviewer may very well win if he took it to court, but he'd have to have the money to retain a lawyer or have someone like the EFF step in on his behalf, and have the time to deal with any legal proceedings.

I think the resulting negative publicity will deal with them just fine. Do remember the Streisand effect.

Also, I think we need to start finding alternatives to Youtube. Google is far too willing to kowtow to the imaginary property industry; if I were TotalBiscuit, I'd host my videos on a non-US site.
 
No one seems to complain when it's a highly regarded game. In the days before Bioshock Infinite dropped youtube was very efficiently scrubbed of any videos by normal humans who managed to get their hands on an early copy.
 
No one seems to complain when it's a highly regarded game. In the days before Bioshock Infinite dropped youtube was very efficiently scrubbed of any videos by normal humans who managed to get their hands on an early copy.

thats different.

the Devs gave TB a review game key, with the intention they knew he would make a video about the game and post it on youtube. and when they didnt like the video they claimed copyright infringment and pulled the video.
 
Steve or Kyle, has anything similar ever happened in response to one of your bad reviews? (which tell the truth)
 
I don't think there is any debate, a review is fair use. In this case, the video was very likely a review (I haven't actually seen it), so it's censorship.

There is space for debate about "Let's Play" or gameplay videos being reviews/fair use. That's not the case here.

Anyway, content producers got to understand that once it's out there, it belongs to the people. You can't and shouldn't strive to control any expression that doesn't cost money to access. Any form, even what they call "piracy."

Any money gained should go to the creators. Anything else, no.
 
Looks like someone at Wild Games Studio is unaware of the Streisand Effect; attempting to censor a bad review just got them a thousand times worse negative publicity than a bad review.

Just Google for Wild Games Studio to see what I mean. Ohh, that's ugly.
 
I have to say I tried a handful of games that I ordinarily wouldn't have given a second thought about due to the TotalBiscuit's reviews, it has such became my GO TO place to look for reviews about obscure games who probably don't have anywhere close to the budget to advertise into my life.

I do have to say I'm failing to see how this could even been considered a copyright violation, is it because the game has yet to be released?
 
Well he did bash it for 21 mins straight...If I was the developer I would be upset too.
 
Well he did bash it for 21 mins straight...If I was the developer I would be upset too.
Well I'm surprised he lasted 21 minutes considering how bad the game is. If anything as a developer I'd take the criticism and try to fix the issues rather than cover it up by claiming a copyright infringement.
 
Boycott.

Did they think Totalbiscuit wouldn't throw them to the wolves after this? Like him or not, he is one of the most widely watched gaming personalities out there.
 
Hence why word of mouth is the best. Game reviews are bought, one way or another.
 
There is a clear exception to copyright under fair use for reporting. The reviewer may very well win if he took it to court, but he'd have to have the money to retain a lawyer or have someone like the EFF step in on his behalf, and have the time to deal with any legal proceedings.

In this case he does :D Also hes has Polaris/Maker Studio( His network) backing him up on this.
 
In Google's defense, once a copyright holder invokes the DMCA Sword of Damocles it is a no win situation for them. They can end up sued, prosecuted, some countries their employees can't travel to for fear of jail time, and fines. If you were to really think about most content on Youtube and compare them to Isohunt; there's not much difference. People post movies, videos, music, etc all the time.

Only difference is that Youtube hosts the files and Isohunt hosts the links to files. Which in my opinion makes them more culpable for the illegal content that is stored on their servers. How do you discern bullshit DMCA requests from real requests when people's livelihoods are at stake?

Better question is why are we all living under the Sword of Damocles when we could vote out the SOB's that invoked it upon us?
 
The real problem here is the three strikes auto take down of a channel. Youtube ran into similar muck with Sega and their bullshit recently. I remember they also had a problem with streaming the nebula awards because their shitty AI bot took down their stream even when the awards organizers had copyright permission which was the case with TB.

Although, this particular developer is probably not concerned with copyright at all since they haven't shut down any other critical reviews on Youtube... it's either a personal grudge against TB or they are gaslighting their own business (i.e. making their business fail catastrophically by "burning" it down to collect insurance and/or to provide a reason to shutter their doors, not pay their employees and debts in order to re-org under bankruptcy) I'm not sure how the laws work in the developers home country regarding this but I have seen it before here in the US.
 
The problem is there really is no real penalty for false DMCA claims, only penalties for non-compliance of any claim. If that changed to something where the risk of filing a false DMCA claim was at least equal to the penalties for non-compliance then it would be a start.

If you think about it, who would file a clearly false DMCA claim like was done in this case, if the penalty for a false claim was a minimum of 3/4 of the gross income generated by the copyrighted content in question? So if a game company made a gross of $1m on a game and filed a false DMCA claim like in this case, were taken to court and lost, they'd have to pay a min of $750k. It scales well to every industry even those represented by the **AAs. It would also stop the practice of using bots to search for videos and then sending out auto-DMCA letters and also get YouTube/Google to actually protect it's users given the amount of money they could generate even if they filed suit for the user's content with even a 70/30 split in google's favor of the settlement/win of the case.

Unfortunately that is just a dream, there is no way something sensible like that would ever get past the lobbyists who control congress.
 
In other news, Wild Games Studio sales of games came to a screeching halt when customers found out how thin skinned the company was.
 
There is a clear exception to copyright under fair use for reporting. The reviewer may very well win if he took it to court, but he'd have to have the money to retain a lawyer or have someone like the EFF step in on his behalf, and have the time to deal with any legal proceedings.
Yup, not only would I favor on the side of the reviewer, but I would wager that the reviewer gets ad revenue from Youtube and so not only would his court fees need to be paid but he should be compensated for his lost work time and lost revenue from the video being taken down by a clearly bogus malicious censorship move.
 
Hence why word of mouth is the best. Game reviews are bought, one way or another.

So are Hardware reviews.

Along with reviews of movies, books, toys...everything. Websites and Internet "reviewers and journalists" lol are all offered deals. Shills are everywhere and widespread.

Best practice is read several dozen reviews about a product and forums, even though they are filled with shills as well.
 
Damn, fucked up situation.

I like the CEO's response on the Steam Forums. As if they didn't know ahead of time that Total Biscuit would make ad revenue dollars.

Fuck these guys. I don't even want to try their game.

Also, wow. They are getting MURDERED on Metacritic.
 
No one seems to complain when it's a highly regarded game. In the days before Bioshock Infinite dropped youtube was very efficiently scrubbed of any videos by normal humans who managed to get their hands on an early copy.

Reviews and critiques are a very different beast than gameplay videos or "Let's Play" videos. Reviews and critiques are protected by the fair use clause of copyright for this exact reason. Of course you still have to have the money to hire a lawyer to argue fair use in the event that someone decides to use their copyright against you.

Gameplay videos and "Let's Play" videos exist at the discretion of the publisher and developer. Technically they are considered public displays of a copyrighted work and the publisher/developer has every legal right to have them taken down as they see fit. Most publishers have worked up a gray area system where people are allowed to post gameplay videos after a game's street release date but anything posted before release will be pulled on copyright grounds. Some will also have videos pulled that only show the cinematics of the game as a long movie. Large networks like Machinima actually pay the publishers a small fee for blanket rights to make gameplay and "Let's Play" videos and they extend that coverage to anyone in their network. If you're not covered under one of those agreements though your gameplay videos can be pulled any time the copyright owner wants them taken down.
 
Just watched the review, he's right, that game is a POS, I haven't seen anything that bad since Zoldner.
 
So are Hardware reviews.

Along with reviews of movies, books, toys...everything. Websites and Internet "reviewers and journalists" lol are all offered deals. Shills are everywhere and widespread.

Best practice is read several dozen reviews about a product and forums, even though they are filled with shills as well.
Some aren't, but even then they have to play nice and make their reviews more like manufacturer commercials if they plan to be successful.

I can't name names, but there was a recent case where an automotive journalist friend of the family was essentially blacklisted from getting a test vehicle because of a negative (but very honest IMO) review of one of their other vehicles in the past. Worse yet, in constant emails and phone calls he was blatantly ignored and they wouldn't even tell him he was blacklisted and he had to find out through a friend of a friend that it was the case, so there was no way for him to even make it right.

If you want to have access to a car in a timely fashion and given more than a few seconds with it, you have to represent yourself to the manufacturer as the person most likely to reach the largest number of people with the most helpful review to their purpose as possible. Otherwise you have to wait for the vehicle to go on sale and find some way to borrow one on your own, which is expensive and hardly anyone will care about your review when competitors have their reviews out months earlier.

The only way to get around that is to be like Consumer Reports. They won't accept any handouts and purchase or rent any vehicle they review. This means that their reviews take a while to come out though, but luckily they have enough of a reputation and viewer base that they can afford to be slow.

Your average Joe can't, and that's why if they want to be honest you REALLY have to read between the lines on the nice things they say about the car.
 
That video says oodles though, and while they do continue to bash the Garry's Incident guys they also go a step further in saying how Youtube/Google's system is fundamentally broken because there's an auto-infringe system in place. IMO, they go to great lengths to make sure that someone with "Three strikes" gets punished by losing all their videos, but they don't do anything against companies who abuse the system, which IMO should have a one strike system.
 
Damn, fucked up situation.

I like the CEO's response on the Steam Forums. As if they didn't know ahead of time that Total Biscuit would make ad revenue dollars.

Fuck these guys. I don't even want to try their game.

Also, wow. They are getting MURDERED on Metacritic.

From reading the MetaCritic reviews, it seems like the developers wish to silence any one who says anything about the game on the Steam forums. Yikes!
 
Bottom line I guess..

If a website/reviewer/self proclaimed journalist lol.. gets a product directly from a publisher, developer or manufacturer. Take with a massive heaping of salt. Biting the hand that feeds it is very rare and everyone gets worn down after time.

If a website/reviewer/self proclaimed journalist lol.. buys the product themselves or acquires it independent from the publisher/manufacturer/developer. Take with a portion of salt. They may be looking to be business partners with some companies for juicy swag, favors and $$$. Positive reviews and vibs get them that.

Forums are filled with fanboys, paid and unpaid shills that's harder to watch for.
Fanboys are such a mindless waste of skin.
 
this DCMA stuff is starting to get out of control. Just a matter of time before it goes to the courts. Blame the movie and record industry for changing law to make this happen.
 
I just did a search for Wild Games Studio and came across their Facebook page. Apparently, the TotalBiscuit video was put back up a short while ago. But as posters on their FB page say, it's too little too late.
 
So are Hardware reviews.

Along with reviews of movies, books, toys...everything. Websites and Internet "reviewers and journalists" lol are all offered deals. Shills are everywhere and widespread.

Best practice is read several dozen reviews about a product and forums, even though they are filled with shills as well.

Hardware reviews are the worst, but I don't want to get into that shit pile of fuck. Let me put it like this, how you think everyone has reviews ready as soon as a product is released?

When I say word of mouth, I mean people you know that have actually played the game. There's also meme's. For example, when Skyrim was the big thing, everyone had the meme "arrow to the knee". That's how I got into Dark Souls with videos and comics about how difficult it is. That's also how I got into Minecraft with the sheer amount of fan videos that flood the internet.

If people really like the game, there's going to be fan videos and comics. The best indications that the game is worth a damn.
 
Bottom line I guess..

If a website/reviewer/self proclaimed journalist lol.. gets a product directly from a publisher, developer or manufacturer. Take with a massive heaping of salt. Biting the hand that feeds it is very rare and everyone gets worn down after time.

If a website/reviewer/self proclaimed journalist lol.. buys the product themselves or acquires it independent from the publisher/manufacturer/developer. Take with a portion of salt. They may be looking to be business partners with some companies for juicy swag, favors and $$$. Positive reviews and vibs get them that.

Forums are filled with fanboys, paid and unpaid shills that's harder to watch for.
Fanboys are such a mindless waste of skin.
You know who the big wastes of skin are? Those who give reviews based on the mentality that if they "bite the hand" they may lose out on future "free shit" or business relationships. This is exactly why there are FTC laws that state you MUST state whether or not you received anything from the company you're doing the product review over including the product that you're reviewing.

Fanboys are one thing, they're really harmless like internet trolls and fairly easy to pick out. Reviewers though are supposed to be a stopgap between advertising bullshit saying how awesome a product is and having to fork over your money to find out the product is no where close to what was advertised. Take GameSpot and the whole Kane & Lynch fiasco, I know what people would say "hur hur hur you're an idiot to trust gamespot reviews" but that's exactly why the fuck they're there.
 
Hardware reviews are the worst, but I don't want to get into that shit pile of fuck. Let me put it like this, how you think everyone has reviews ready as soon as a product is released?
Reviewers accept NDAs and receive some sort of reviewer's kit outlining information that the manufacturers wishes to be relayed in the review and suggestions on how to approach the review process. This in no way binds reviewers to producing only a favorable review.

There are certainly bad manufacturers who'll cut you out the first time a word like 'horrendous' is thrown around, but they're the exception, not the rule. Most are just looking for honest evaluation. The manufacturer confident enough in a hardware product to partner with the press on pre-release products would like for a gushing review, but rarely expects one.
 
Back
Top