Galvanic Corrosion Experiment (2 large images)

Arcygenical

Fully [H]
Joined
Jun 10, 2005
Messages
25,066
Due to the recent interest in the phenomena of Galvanic Corrosion, I've decided to set up a test...

Three different glasses, filled with 450ml of tap water and various additives. I decided to use tap water rather than distilled + salt to accomplish 2 things:
  1. Greater Conductivity
  2. No chance of salt corrosion on the Aluminum

The three groups:
  1. 450ml tap water + 40ml Pentosin G11 with common ground
  2. 450ml Tap water with common ground
  3. 450ml Tap water with no electrical ground

In each glass there is a cleaned penny (5 minute soak in 25% HCL followed by a bath in 99.9% iso. alcohol and left to air dry) and a 2" long section of anodized aluminum L bracketing. The edge of each piece of L bracketing was then SEALED with a silicone sealant, as this is not an anodized surface:

IMGP0867.jpg


The anodized sides, however, were left barren, in direct contact with the water. All sides were free of scratches when entering the solution, and were exposed to a 5% concentration of HCL for cleaning. The alligator leads are not touching the solution. The temperature of the solutions should remain at exactly 27c (as per my growing room) in a completely dark condition. The relative humidity (that shouldn't matter, given the glasses are sealed with plastic wrap) remains around 60% at all times.

IMGP0868.jpg

(from left to right: Water with ground, Water with no ground, Water with Pentosin and ground)

I'll be updating this post when I come back to school... next September. I'll post pics of the anodes/cathodes through the sides of the glasses whenever I get to my apartment this summer, but we'll see how this turns out.



Should be interesting :)
 
Uhhhm. Wow...

The grounded aluminum is already turning slightly brown... That was alot faster than I expected. There was a point of weakness on the side of that part of the L bracket... the anodization flaked off (from what I can tell).

I need to find a good source of un-anodized aluminum stock-rod... That way I can bend them and andodize them myself

If anyone's interested...

The cell produces around 300mv and pushes a good 11ma through my multimeter.
 
Thanks, subscribed with e-mail updates because i know i will forget come fall.
 
I'll be updating this post when I come back to school... next September. I'll post pics of the anodes/cathodes through the sides of the glasses whenever I get to my apartment this summer, but we'll see how this turns out.

we have to wait a while
 
She's active, but I unfortunately see quite a bit of salt corrosion on my pieces (brown).

The pennies in the connected loops are turning bright red... The penny in the disconnected loop isn't changing colour at all. The pentosin cup has decreased the corrosion by quite a bit so far.

I think i'll have to restart this with an anodized rod, that can bent to shape, rather than cutting some L brackets :eek:
 
She's active, but I unfortunately see quite a bit of salt corrosion on my pieces (brown).

The pennies in the connected loops are turning bright red... The penny in the disconnected loop isn't changing colour at all. The pentosin cup has decreased the corrosion by quite a bit so far.

I think i'll have to restart this with an anodized rod, that can bent to shape, rather than cutting some L brackets :eek:



"Salt corrosion"

Salt is the ingredient that makes the water such a good electrolyte. Specifically a soluble salt. There are a few of them but the three main ones are; Chlorides, Sulfates and Nitrates.

:edit: did you measure the conductivity of the solution in each container first?
 
"Salt corrosion"

Salt is the ingredient that makes the water such a good electrolyte. Specifically a soluble salt. There are a few of them but the three main ones are; Chlorides, Sulfates and Nitrates.

:edit: did you measure the conductivity of the solution in each container first?

Yes, conductivity was measured, with data taken every 10 seconds for 5 minutes, and averaged out. The water measured about 320k ohms with probes at 1", the solution with pentosin had a higher conductivity with a resistance of only 240k ohms at 1".

As for the salt corrosion, yes, I'm fully aware of how water is conductive... I'm thinking when I re-do this test at the beginning of the summer with 5 groups (control, pentosin, hard anodize, soft anodize, soft andoize + no path) instead of 3, I'll be using a 3% solution of sulfuric acid... This shouldn't disrupt the anodized surface as much as whatever's in my town water.

Honestly, I don't know WHY it's discolouring (and my camera can't take a good shot through the beveled glass, so I can't upload one) but my hunch is that it's due to chlorine discoloration... there's lots of chlorine in my water (you can TASTE it all year round) and it's a known attacker of al.
 
Back
Top