Galaxy Tab Doesn't Copy Apple Designs

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
With all the bans, unbans, wins, losses, up and downs, injunctions, reprieves and whatever else in the ongoing Samsung versus Apple saga, it is impossible to keep track of who is "winning."

The moves are part of a broader legal skirmish between the two largest smartphone makers in the world, and part of Apple's legal campaign against Android and any company supporting the operating system. Apple and Samsung have lawsuits filed in different courts around the world, and are looking for a ban or decision so devastating that both companies will be forced to sit down and work out a resolution. So far, both sides have only seen minor victories.
 
This wouldn't be so much of an issue if someone other than Apple would invent or make feasible a product first :)

Sure, Apple isn't always first, but they usually the first to be successful because they give people what they want to buy. Once that's out of the way, the other MFR's know what to do and they try again.

Apple - The best R&D money can't buy LOL
 
"This kind of blatant copying is wrong and, as we've said many times before, we need to protect Apple's intellectual property when companies steal our ideas," said an Apple representative.

Straight from the company that built it's foundations on stealing ideas...S#!t I could make a patent, on a f*#king rectangle shape with beveled edges, fortunately the British patent system is a little more thorough on this sort of bollocks Apple is pulling.
 
Straight from the company that built it's foundations on stealing ideas...S#!t I could make a patent, on a f*#king rectangle shape with beveled edges, fortunately the British patent system is a little more thorough on this sort of bollocks Apple is pulling.

They didn't really "steal" ideas. Most of Apple's early employees were working at Xerox Parc before they left. They probably felt that they had a right to continue using the interface ideas they designed while working for their previous employer. At the time, that wasn't as well-protected by layers of legal soup as it is now. Sure, they're a pretty unoriginal company that's a patent troll nowadays, but what got them started was what they thought was innovative even though it was pretty much infringing theft.

And yeah, letting a company patent stuff like slide to unlock or rounded corners is stupid, but you are talking about the nation that generates the most traffic on Twitter so you'll have to cut us some slack. We're all stupid Wal-Mart shoppers. :)
 
Straight from the company that built it's foundations on stealing ideas...S#!t I could make a patent, on a f*#king rectangle shape with beveled edges, fortunately the British patent system is a little more thorough on this sort of bollocks Apple is pulling.

Think apple is a bit pissed when microsoft stole their thunder back in the day, now they're returning the favor by going after anybody trying to do the same.
Although im surprised that tv/refrigerator/over/microwave/clock/car/speaker/printer and among 100's of other device manufacturers aren't suing each other because their products look identical... only apple does it.
 
I think everyone ignores the issue at the core of these lawsuits.

Apple is screwed. They HAD a massively successful marketing strategy based on being cool. A big part of that was good design. There's two problems though.

1) As they become more popular, they become less cool. When I was a kid, the ford escort was the best sellign car in America. It was not cool.

2) They have wildly succeeded in markets that are racing towards the smallest, lightest version of that widget you can get. For phones, it will be the thinnest, lightest rectangle that can fit the screen of a size you would like. For tablets, the same. For laptops, the smallest, lightest rectangle that can encompass the screen of choice and a keyboard of usable size. Arguing over the notion that the slimmest rectangular prism you can craft is some sort of unique design is idiotic.
 
I think everyone ignores the issue at the core of these lawsuits.

Apple is screwed. They HAD a massively successful marketing strategy based on being cool. A big part of that was good design. There's two problems though.

1) As they become more popular, they become less cool. When I was a kid, the ford escort was the best sellign car in America. It was not cool.

2) They have wildly succeeded in markets that are racing towards the smallest, lightest version of that widget you can get. For phones, it will be the thinnest, lightest rectangle that can fit the screen of a size you would like. For tablets, the same. For laptops, the smallest, lightest rectangle that can encompass the screen of choice and a keyboard of usable size. Arguing over the notion that the slimmest rectangular prism you can craft is some sort of unique design is idiotic.

Ford Escort being popular had NOTHING to do with being "cool" and everything to do with being cheap and affordable. I've never met an Escort owner who loved their purchases.
 
Ford Escort being popular had NOTHING to do with being "cool" and everything to do with being cheap and affordable. I've never met an Escort owner who loved their purchases.


You completely missed the point. My point is they are trying to win market dominance. Massive market domination does not come with coolness. In fact after a point, you become "the man", 'the sellout" and any other phrase for the rebels in their own mind point out how cool they are by NOT owning such a thing and reminding you about it constantly.

If you don't like the escort analogy, try the taurus or camry. Plenty of people love theirs. Nobody thinks they are cool.

When you have been selling the idea of being different, cool, having taste, etc. it all boils down to the notion that you are selling the idea that you are better than most people for having said product. If everyone has one, that idea is very hard to sell.
 
You completely missed the point. My point is they are trying to win market dominance. Massive market domination does not come with coolness. In fact after a point, you become "the man", 'the sellout" and any other phrase for the rebels in their own mind point out how cool they are by NOT owning such a thing and reminding you about it constantly.

If you don't like the escort analogy, try the taurus or camry. Plenty of people love theirs. Nobody thinks they are cool.

When you have been selling the idea of being different, cool, having taste, etc. it all boils down to the notion that you are selling the idea that you are better than most people for having said product. If everyone has one, that idea is very hard to sell.

I think the word you're thinking of is "subversive", you know, being outside the mainstream and therefore intended to be "attractive".
 
If you don't like the escort analogy, try the taurus or camry. Plenty of people love theirs. Nobody thinks they are cool.

Depends on your definition of cool.
I think it's cool that outside of normal maintenance (oil/tires/belts/brakes) I've spent less than $100 on parts for my 10 year old Camry.
 
Depends on your definition of cool.
I think it's cool that outside of normal maintenance (oil/tires/belts/brakes) I've spent less than $100 on parts for my 10 year old Camry.

What is "normal" anyway?
 
Think apple is a bit pissed when microsoft stole their thunder back in the day, now they're returning the favor by going after anybody trying to do the same.
Although im surprised that tv/refrigerator/over/microwave/clock/car/speaker/printer and among 100's of other device manufacturers aren't suing each other because their products look identical... only apple does it.

You don't see anyone suing each other over the design of the shovel, lawnmower or 95% of the other tools out there, heck the washing machine is the same damn thing regardless of who made it.
 
I think everyone ignores the issue at the core of these lawsuits.

Apple is screwed. They HAD a massively successful marketing strategy based on being cool. A big part of that was good design. There's two problems though.

1) As they become more popular, they become less cool. When I was a kid, the ford escort was the best sellign car in America. It was not cool.

2) They have wildly succeeded in markets that are racing towards the smallest, lightest version of that widget you can get. For phones, it will be the thinnest, lightest rectangle that can fit the screen of a size you would like. For tablets, the same. For laptops, the smallest, lightest rectangle that can encompass the screen of choice and a keyboard of usable size. Arguing over the notion that the slimmest rectangular prism you can craft is some sort of unique design is idiotic.

A++++++ post, would read again :).
 
I think everyone ignores the issue at the core of these lawsuits.

Apple is screwed. They HAD a massively successful marketing strategy based on being cool. A big part of that was good design. There's two problems though.

1) As they become more popular, they become less cool. When I was a kid, the ford escort was the best sellign car in America. It was not cool.

2) They have wildly succeeded in markets that are racing towards the smallest, lightest version of that widget you can get. For phones, it will be the thinnest, lightest rectangle that can fit the screen of a size you would like. For tablets, the same. For laptops, the smallest, lightest rectangle that can encompass the screen of choice and a keyboard of usable size. Arguing over the notion that the slimmest rectangular prism you can craft is some sort of unique design is idiotic.

Love this post. The car analogy may be debatable but it made me laugh, brought back many memories of how "cool" we looked cruising around in my friends Escort.

Apple produces some of the highest quality products, but their success and fan base is built on hype and nothing more. It's not like the 80's when educators and professionals loved MACs because they were innovative and useful, much more so than the DOS clones that were proliferating the market.

In many ways Apple is still innovative, but their primary strengths lie in their marketing strategies.
 
Fortunately, we are not using BOSE and Monster as analogies to Apple yet... but should the day where Apple no longer has technical merits come to pass, we might do just that.
 
Fortunately, we are not using BOSE and Monster as analogies to Apple yet... but should the day where Apple no longer has technical merits come to pass, we might do just that.

You will NEVER convince me that the 1s and 0s travelling through my $10k HDMI monster cable aren't in every way superior to the 1s and 0s travelling through a $5 monoprice.com HDMI cable. Noel Lee has irrefutably proven that his 1s and 0s are better.
 
Back
Top