GA-P55A-UD3 and Crossfire?

ChristopherB

Weaksauce
Joined
Jan 16, 2010
Messages
70
Does the GA-P55A-UD3 support Crossfire?

In the Newegg specs list it states "Support ATI CrossFireX" and it does as well on GIGABYTEs website. But it also states that it has 1 x16 PCIe slot and 1 x4 PCIe slot...does this mean it's performance will be hampered?

I'm looking to crossfire two 5870's.

http://www.newegg.com/Product/Product.aspx?Item=N82E16813128412&Tpk=GA-P55a-UD3
http://www.gigabyte-usa.com/Products/Motherboard/Products_Spec.aspx?ProductID=3254

The main disadvantage of the P55 chipsets is that they have less available PCIe lanes when compared to the X58 chipset. The NewEgg spec means that you have 2 x16 PCIe slots, 1 running at full x16 lanes and the second one only runs at x4 lanes. Most likely Gigabyte is using some of the lanes to implement their SATA3.0 / USB3.0 support.

The P55 chipsets are more for single GPU configurations. Some vendors might have 2 x16 capable slots, but more typical is a x16/x8 configuration. Watch out for the SATA3.0/USB3.0 board because that can go down to x16/x4 (except for ASUS). This is why I went with a X58 board.

If your mainly planning to use 1 GPU you won't notice any difference between a P55 and X58 and with this Gigabyte board you'll have SATA3.0 and USB3.0. If dual GPU is a must for you then for full performance look for a x16/x16 P55 or get a X58. There are articles out there. This one give you a comparison of x16 vs. x8 vs x4 performance.

http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/p55-pci-express-scaling,2517-6.html?xtmc=x8_pcie_scaling&xtcr=4

I don't see a dual GPU scaling performance which includes x16/x16 vs x16/x8 etc. Maybe this one will go into this more.

http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/p55-crossfire-nf200,2537.html?xtmc=x8_pcie_scaling&xtcr=2

The Xfire support is independent of the number of lanes used. You will need 2 x16 slots (full length) to be able to connect 2 GPUs. Some of these boards also support SLI, but they don't publish it because they would need to pay license fees to Nvidia.
 
Looks like I was wrong. I can't find a P55 board that does x16/x8. They either of x16/ or x8/x8 (split the 16 lanes across 2 slots. The article I posted above will give you the performance impact.

I'm not sure with the x16/x4 boards if they are doing x16/x4 or x8/x4. That would be bad. Try reading the Newegg reviews for the board and see if there is any information on this. If you search on the board on hardforum you might find the info as well.
 
eh, debatable depending on the game and how well it works with Xfire. Remember its PCI 2.0 so the 4X slot is running at the old 8X speed. I have not kept up but a year or so ago it was I think pretty much decided that an 8X slot was not a bottle neck except in a very few rare instances. But things change.

I suggest you post in the video cards forum under ATI cards, put on a full body condom to proctect yourself from the blow back, and see what the inmates in that asylum think.

Now you did not ask but I cannot help shaking my head over the idea of putting north of $800 worth of video card sweetness in a board that mainly supports cpus with on board video. Yes one could put a lynfield in there or go with a cheap i3 but I just dont get it. The X58 board with 2 x 2 honest to god 16x 2.0 lanes is only $50 more. I920 is more but not a whole lot, so unless you are absolutley out of cash I just have to wonder .... But you may have a plan. its your stuff, I just mumbling to myself. Carry on.

Edit: Never mind looks like we have some guys more up on it than me lurking in here. No protection required ! .
 
Wow, thanks for the responses guys.

I think I will just save up for an X58-based system. Triple channel memory, proper x16 Crossfire support, and a host of other features seems worth the extra price premium. As others have said...if you're spending that much on GPUs.... :p
 
Back
Top