G2400WD vs V2400W

Which BenQ?

  • G2400WD

    Votes: 5 26.3%
  • V2400W

    Votes: 7 36.8%
  • I don't know either

    Votes: 7 36.8%

  • Total voters
    19

astyler

Gawd
Joined
Mar 7, 2007
Messages
921
Deciding between these two monitors from BenQ and need some help.

Main uses will be gaming and programming, nothing requiring color accuracy or anything.

Money isn't an issue cause I'll be picking this up in Taiwan. Any input is appreciated, and I've seen the reviews here on the [H].

Thanks.
 
I never had G2400WD but I have owned V2400WD for about 4 months. I am very happy with my V2400W and will recommend to anyone who does not mind TN. Speed(Response time) matters to me so this is one of the reasons I went to TN. I know some people don't like TN but I would think V2400W is one of the best TN you can get today. The viewing angle is much better than my expectation(I had 1 IPS and 1 MVA so I know how other panel types look like) and the color is actaully very vivid.
I heard G2400WD is similar to V2400W so I would think either one should be good. I also like V's sleek design which makes it look different from most other monitors on market and save some space on my desk since it is very slim. V2400WD seems to be an exclusive model to BenQ store now, and they are promoting it $359 freeship. You can also get G2400WD from BenQ and don't forget to use thankyou10 to save extra 10% ff but you need to pay the shipping for G.

http:store.benq.us
 
I never had G2400WD but I have owned V2400WD for about 4 months. I am very happy with my V2400W and will recommend to anyone who does not mind TN. Speed(Response time) matters to me so this is one of the reasons I went to TN. I know some people don't like TN but I would think V2400W is one of the best TN you can get today. The viewing angle is much better than my expectation(I had 1 IPS and 1 MVA so I know how other panel types look like) and the color is actaully very vivid.
I heard G2400WD is similar to V2400W so I would think either one should be good. I also like V's sleek design which makes it look different from most other monitors on market and save some space on my desk since it is very slim. V2400WD seems to be an exclusive model to BenQ store now, and they are promoting it $359 freeship. You can also get G2400WD from BenQ and don't forget to use thankyou10 to save extra 10% ff but you need to pay the shipping for G.

http:store.benq.us

I appreciate the reply and I've seen the coupon in other posts by you as well :D, I'll be sure to use it.

Is the maximum refresh rate on both monitors 75 Hz, or can the G2400WD get 85 Hz? I can't find the info anywhere, but each monitor lists Horizontal and Vertical refresh rates (and the G2400WD vertical goes up to 85)

Also I'm not seeing the free shipping on the V2400W in their store, only the 399 (359 after coupon))
 
Hi~I will check for you to see if my V2400WD can do 85 HZ and will let you know maybe tomorrow. As for the V2400W $359 you need to use promo code: V2400W which will get you $40 off.
 
Hi~I will check for you to see if my V2400WD can do 85 HZ and will let you know maybe tomorrow. As for the V2400W $359 you need to use promo code: V2400W which will get you $40 off.

If anyone has a G2400WD can you see if you can get 85Hz for the refresh rate?
 
hmmm note sure if any lcd does 85Hz....
my understanding was that they are capped at 60 even, otherwise you run into problems (unless you mod or something)

got the V because of its slimmer profile, i have a stand that allows adjustment on all axis, but i barely ever use them.
 
Same screen inside, different aesthetics outside.

To try higher than 75hz you need to use VGA connection. DVI doesn't have the bandwidth in single-link mode to go 1920x1200 @ 75hz, but VGA might work because it's analog and the only limit is what the video card can put out, and monitor's Analog to digital controller will do.
 
They are supposed to have identical image quality, but I recall some people who've seen both monitors saying there's some minor differences in image quality.
 
I tried on my V2400W, (NVDIA 8600M GS graphic card), HDMI, VGA, D-Sub are all fine when resolution is 1920X1200 st 75 Hz. But I don't think it can go higher than 75Hz. At least not on my current setting.
 
I tried on my V2400W, (NVDIA 8600M GS graphic card), HDMI, VGA, D-Sub are all fine when resolution is 1920X1200 st 75 Hz. But I don't think it can go higher than 75Hz. At least not on my current setting.

Great. Just the info I was looking for. Thanks bbi. VGA and D-Sub are the same though, right?

The poll is very split and it's no surprise with the panels in these two being the same. I think I'll go with whichever one I can get for less.
 
Yes...you are right VGA = D-Sub. I was meaning HDMI/D-Sub/DVI.
Good luck with your monitor hunting!
 
Back
Top