FTC Sues Intel for 'Anticompetitive Tactics'

HardOCP News

[H] News
Joined
Dec 31, 1969
Messages
0
It looks like the Federal Trade Commission is moving forward with its lawsuit against Intel for "Anticompetitive Tactics."

The FTC argued in a release that Intel's tactics "have stifled innovation and harmed consumers." The agency also claimed that the company "has waged a systematic campaign to shut out rivals' competing microchips by cutting off their access to the marketplace." "In the process, Intel deprived consumers of choice and innovation in the microchips that comprise the computers' central processing unit, or CPU," the FTC said. "These chips are critical components that often are referred to as the 'brains' of a computer."
 
Another cash grab by the greedy Euros against this obviously innocent American company...

Oh... wait...
 
You know, as long as they keep producing products as good as they do, I could care less.
 
In this case the FTC is correct. Intel does indeed appear to have done monopolistic things in order to keep AMD from getting a better foothold in the CPU market during the Athlon/Athlon64 days.
 
"in recent news: Intels leading products shadow other companies lack-luster efforts"

Maybe I don't follow this stuff enough but what "tactics" are they refering to? it seem to me that others just arent keeping up. AMD holds a completely different position as the "budget" brand. Is that somehow Intels fault?
 
You know, as long as they keep producing products as good as they do, I could care less.
The problem with that logic is to imagine how badly AMD might be kicking Intel's ass right now had Intel behaved itself.
 
"in recent news: Intels leading products shadow other companies lack-luster efforts"

Maybe I don't follow this stuff enough but what "tactics" are they refering to? it seem to me that others just arent keeping up. AMD holds a completely different position as the "budget" brand. Is that somehow Intels fault?

In a way, yes. If they hadn't stifled AMD's ability to innovate with their anti competitive tactics gobbling up market share then AMD could have used their profits for r&d to make parts that would compete. As it is, AMD has to settle into the segment they have as a consequence.
 
But what tactics are those? I guess as far as I can see, isn't Intels market share directly driven by the customer? With the fact that they have been, and continue to, release a better product, thus driving customers to purchase from them?

I'm not usually interested in this kind of subject so I'm totally noob, but this one catches my interest for some reason.
 
But what tactics are those? I guess as far as I can see, isn't Intels market share directly driven by the customer? With the fact that they have been, and continue to, release a better product, thus driving customers to purchase from them?

I'm not usually interested in this kind of subject so I'm totally noob, but this one catches my interest for some reason.

They're talking about 2003-2006 when AMD had a superior product. The allegation is that Intel pressured OEMs into purchasing only Intel products.
 
"in recent news: Intels leading products shadow other companies lack-luster efforts"

Maybe I don't follow this stuff enough but what "tactics" are they refering to? it seem to me that others just arent keeping up. AMD holds a completely different position as the "budget" brand. Is that somehow Intels fault?

This isn't about the current CPU environment - this case is related to the late 90's early 2000's when AMD had the superior CPU architecture, and the business practices Intel employed to keep AMD from gaining marketshare with their superior product(s).
 
Allegation sounds wrong.

More like, "clear fact to anyone who isn't legally blind".


Eagerly looking forward to seeing how Intel ends up in a few years after this is done.
 
I found this interesting from a article on MSNBC.com

"The FTC also said Intel has secretly redesigned critical computer software to hinder the performance of other companies' microprocessors, or CPUs. Although the FTC does not ask for any specific damages in its lawsuit, it wants to force Intel to provide its customers with a substitute software at no additional charge and to compensate them for the cost of distributing the replacement"


I have never heard for "special software" in regards to the CPU. If that were true, could that be the reason the Phenom II can't compete with the i5/i7?


Interesting....
 
That's right, because a company SHOULD help the competition more than itself. :rolleyes:

Ya, because paying OEMs not to buy from AMD, paying retailers not to stock AMD products, and threatening to stall shipments to those who sell AMD are all really just Intel "helping itself" and not blatantly illegal anti-competitive practices.
 
Allegation sounds wrong.

More like, "clear fact to anyone who isn't legally blind".


Eagerly looking forward to seeing how Intel ends up in a few years after this is done.

That funny, I could have sworn that I bought an HP laptop with an AMD processor during that period of time. Oh and my wife's Sony VAIO with an AMD Duron didn't exist either? I must have REALLY been on something heavy to make me hallucinate about the several dozen AMD Sempron, Athlon 64, Athlon X2 systems from 1st and 2nd tier OEM's that I've worked on in the last five years.

If Intel was paying these companies not to use AMD processors in their products, then why in the world were these companies still making products with AMD processors?
 
That's right, because a company SHOULD help the competition more than itself. :rolleyes:

Recently Intel paid billions to the EU for the same practices. As stated earlier it was rather clear. The point is if that Intel ran a business without anti competitive practices then AMD would be farther ahead innovation wise and we would possibly see cpus (and other parts for that matter) that are more technologically advanced due to a level playing field.
 
I found this interesting from a article on MSNBC.com

"The FTC also said Intel has secretly redesigned critical computer software to hinder the performance of other companies' microprocessors, or CPUs. Although the FTC does not ask for any specific damages in its lawsuit, it wants to force Intel to provide its customers with a substitute software at no additional charge and to compensate them for the cost of distributing the replacement"


I have never heard for "special software" in regards to the CPU. If that were true, could that be the reason the Phenom II can't compete with the i5/i7?


Interesting....


When you compile software with Intel's suite it automatically uses the "least-optimized" behaviour if then chip is not a "Genuine Intel" processor/
 
I have never heard for "special software" in regards to the CPU. If that were true, could that be the reason the Phenom II can't compete with the i5/i7?

I would bet "special software" means "Intel Optimizing C++ Compiler" which does pretty much give the shaft to AMD procs. Not the Phenom II can't compete, though. I'd personally blame "suckage" for that.
 
But what tactics are those? I guess as far as I can see, isn't Intels market share directly driven by the customer? With the fact that they have been, and continue to, release a better product, thus driving customers to purchase from them?

I'm not usually interested in this kind of subject so I'm totally noob, but this one catches my interest for some reason.

Basically they told retailers don't carry AMD products or we'll hike prices on you. I'm not to sure on the details, but they also seemed to commissioned software that would actually run slower if it detected an AMD processor.

Modred189 said:
You know, as long as they keep producing products as good as they do, I could care less..

The idea here is that AMD would have even better products out now if this didn't happen. This translates good for consumer, because it promotes competition, which has a tendency to lower prices and force better products onto the market. If AMD went belly up, you can be sure Intel would not be producing more powerful chips as fast as they currently are. And I think Intel's response to the Athlon 64's successfulness shows that competitiveness drives better products.
 
[Quote
Originally Posted by Lollipop View Post
That's right, because a company SHOULD help the competition more than itself. [/QUOTE]




[QUOTENemesis999;1035060736]Ya, because paying OEMs not to buy from AMD, paying retailers not to stock AMD products, and threatening to stall shipments to those who sell AMD are all really just Intel "helping itself" and not blatantly illegal anti-competitive practices.[/QUOTE]

Also don't forget about tweaking your compiler to run non intel cpu's slower....:mad:
 
Ya, because paying OEMs not to buy from AMD, paying retailers not to stock AMD products, and threatening to stall shipments to those who sell AMD are all really just Intel "helping itself" and not blatantly illegal anti-competitive practices.

Then don't do business with them.
 
That funny, I could have sworn that I bought an HP laptop with an AMD processor during that period of time. Oh and my wife's Sony VAIO with an AMD Duron didn't exist either? I must have REALLY been on something heavy to make me hallucinate about the several dozen AMD Sempron, Athlon 64, Athlon X2 systems from 1st and 2nd tier OEM's that I've worked on in the last five years.

If Intel was paying these companies not to use AMD processors in their products, then why in the world were these companies still making products with AMD processors?

Because people were demanding them, so there was money to be made. Not as much as if they'd taken Intel's money, however, so they didn't push the AMD systems much or overpriced them. How long was Dell an Intel-only shop? How long before anyone noticed Athlons were in their mix?
 
[Quote
Originally Posted by Lollipop View Post
That's right, because a company SHOULD help the competition more than itself.




[QUOTENemesis999;1035060736]Ya, because paying OEMs not to buy from AMD, paying retailers not to stock AMD products, and threatening to stall shipments to those who sell AMD are all really just Intel "helping itself" and not blatantly illegal anti-competitive practices.[/QUOTE]

Also don't forget about tweaking your compiler to run non intel cpu's slower....:mad:[/QUOTE]

The nature of business is to win and profit.
 
Then don't do business with them.

Ah, so they should just switch to that other x86 producer that could handle the volume...

ohh... wait...

:rolleyes:

Seriously, do you live in some black-and-white delusion where this stuff you're coming up with actually makes sense?
 
[QUOTENemesis999;1035060736]Ya, because paying OEMs not to buy from AMD, paying retailers not to stock AMD products, and threatening to stall shipments to those who sell AMD are all really just Intel "helping itself" and not blatantly illegal anti-competitive practices.

Also don't forget about tweaking your compiler to run non intel cpu's slower....:mad:[/QUOTE]

The nature of business is to win and profit.[/QUOTE]

So you are okay with price-fixing?
 
Ah, so they should just switch to that other x86 producer that could handle the volume...

ohh... wait...

:rolleyes:

Seriously, do you live in some black-and-white delusion where this stuff you're coming up with actually makes sense?

Would you try to run a business that didn't do everything in its power to conquer the competition?
 
Make a better product and the masses will buy it. Don't and you lose.

Yes, I can make a better product and then the monopoly can just do what Intel did and tell carriers to not carry it before it takes off.
 
Make a better product and the masses will buy it. Don't and you lose.

Not too sharp huh.

Please tell me how the "masses will buy it" when Intel actively pays stores and oems NOT TO SELL IT.

Moreso, explain how the average person is going to know the performance characteristics of the dozens of available microprocessors when 99% of the can't even tell you what is in their computer right now.

Do you spew this kind of verbal diarrhea in real life? or do you just like to make yourself feel good on the Internets by spewing uneducated unrealistic crap based solely on your lack of understanding of reality?
 
Would you try to run a business that didn't do everything in its power to conquer the competition?

I'll tell you how to increase profit: Ignore every compliance regulation in every region in which you operate.

Happy?
 
Did Intel use a gun to the retailers? It's strategy. Where do you guys learn about free markets?
 
Did Intel use a gun to the retailers? It's strategy. Where do you guys learn about free markets?

I learned they don't work when monopolies suppress them. You apparently learned not much of anything since you seem to have a micro-economics 101 level of understanding.

Here's some reality for you. Despite all the idiotic bullshit you choose to spew, AMD HAD THE BETTER PRODUCT for years and was unable to raise their market share. So obviously you're wrong. Why do people argue theoretical results when they obviously don't match with reality? Are you that delusional that you believe that your theories are right and reality is wrong?
 
Would you try to run a business that didn't do everything in its power to conquer the competition?

I would... so if you cant beat em go blow up their factories... anything to win right? Legal or not, who cares right? So long as you dont get caught... bribe steal cheat murder all's fair as long as your making a buck right?

Intel broke the law period. Intel had an inferior product and used their position as market leader to intimidate, blackmail and coerced folks to hold onto market share.

Companies do not have the right to break the law in search of profit.
 
Back
Top