from e6320 to e6750, from 680i to p5k-e...

joshlet

n00b
Joined
May 8, 2007
Messages
42
recently i purchased a new computer with a 680i a1 revision motherboard and an e6320. i was not too pleased with the overclocking capability of the CPU, i only hit 3.1 stable (using a thermalright ultra 120). couple weeks later (bout 3 weeks ago), i took back the e6320 thinking it was the CPU, and grabbed one of the new g0 e6750's. i managed to overclock it to 3.5, which seems respectable, but not compared to what I've heard people could get with it. at this point i realized my motherboard was bottlenecking my overclocking capacities.

fast forward to yesterday. i went and grabbed a p5k-e, and WOW did that make a difference. right now I'm sitting at 3.75 ghz, temps are 29/28 idle, and max 58 degrees load. ran dual orthos last night, and these settings are seemingly stable.

Needless to say, I'm very impressed with this overclock, but I'm not too impressed with the 680i. as amatter of fact, im quite disappointed. for a motherboard that claims to be one of the best gaming solutions on the market, it really doesn't allow for that great of an overclock. or maybe it was just the specific motherboard I got. who knows. all i know is I'm sitting at 3.75 at 1.5 volts STABLE.

i'm a happy man.
 
The lesson to be learned here is, ask the right questions BEFORE you buy.

If you would have asked beforehand, you would have found out that the 680i and 975x can't clock that high, so would be best paired with a CPU with a higher multiplier than 7x (E6320). They're better off with an 8x or 9x CPU, since they can only reach around 450Mhz.

If you would have asked about the CPU beforehand, you would have found out that the E6320 was best paired with P965 Express, P35 Express, or 650i SLI/Ultra chipsets, since they can reach 500Mhz. Such a high FSB with such a low CPU multiplier would yield 3.5Ghz, with the proper ram.

The 680i SLI is the best gaming board because for gaming, you need a good graphics solution... and the 680i SLI provides the best possible platform for the best possible graphics solution. With any CPU with a higher multiplier, it will OC just fine. An E6420 would have gotten to 3.6Ghz, with the proper RAM and some luck.
 
if the 680i can't clock that high, why is it considered the best gaming board? SLI is a big waste, since there are single GPU solutions that will be better than anything i can SLI right now. i have an 8800 gts 640 mb, and i've read that the new 9800 will be better than SLI'ed 8800 gts's. big waste of money.

all in all though, i only lost around 60 bucks in switching pieces of hardware. i would take this p5k-e over the 680i any day, simply because it overclocks better.
 
I would just like to point out that I have an e6750 paired with an EVGA 680i mobo, and I'm running great @ 3.6 with a load temp of ~55 (Tuniq tower). That at 8 x 450. I feel like I've got more room in mine, but I don't want to push it any farther without lapping at least the bottom of the Tuniq, if not the IHS of the 6750 too. I'll probably wait till it gets a little cooler outside too :D
 
hm then how come i can't overclock the 6750 higher than 3.5? could it be i have a bad mobo?
 
It's is possible. Overclocking is definitely not a guaranteed thing. One thing you might have not done, which I'm sure helps, is to change out the thermal goop that they have on the NB and SB. That stuff was like silly putty, I don't see how there could be any heat transfer. So anyway, I removed that stuff and slapped on some AS5, and tossed the heatpipe back on. It's possible that your NB was getting too hot. But really, overclocking is a luck of the draw for the most part coupled with the proper knowledge and technique.
 
I really do hate it when people has high expectations of something without doing some research.

First of all, when it comes to OCing', it's a matter of luck and research. Mostly luck. Getting a CPU that overclocks pretty high is a matter of luck. It may turn out that mrmetal_53 got an E6750 that can OC to 3.6 while you may have gotten an E6750 that can only do 3.5Ghz. You can take two CPUs from the same batch and I can guarantee you that neither will OC the same as the other. Like I said, it's luck.

As for the research part, mrmetal_53 may have done his research and got RAM that could OC that high while you may have gotten RAM that doesn't OC well. He also may have tweaked a few settings here and there. Speaking of which, which RAM are you guys using?

The 680i is considered a great gaming board because it provides a slight boost to SLI video cards. A great gaming board does not have to OC well in order to be considered a great gaming board. People don't OC just for increased FPS in video games. Some do it for their 3D rendering, movie editing and other actions of that nature that could benefit from an OC'd CPU.
 
Danny, I would agree with you, but with the new board, he said he was able to get his e6750 up to 3.75 ghz. So that rules it being a bad chip out. Same with his ram.

Anyway, I've got DDR2-800 Firestix (running at DDR2-900, obviously :cool:) I'm almost 100% sure I can push the ram to DDR2-1000 speeds, but I haven't done any testing yet because I don't see the need to OC past 3.6 ghz right now.
 
well danny, i doubt this has anything to do with research, since i did research my choices prior to purchasing them, and i'm well aware of the discrepancy between overclocking potential with regards to certain weeks of the same CPU. i took this into consideration when i made my purchases, but now i know it isnt my CPU bottlenecking my overclock, since i can boot at 4.0 ghz and remain at 3.75 stable with the p5k-e.

all of the parts i purchased are excellent overclockers, and work well in synergy with one another. have 4 gigs of ocz pc2-8500 ram and it's overclocked right now.

i understand OC is a matter of luck and research. i selected the 680i board because it was, supposedly, a great overclocking device. sadly, it pales in comparison to the overclocking beast that is the p5k-e. but again, it could just be a bad motherboard. i should RMA it just becasuse i can.
 
if the 680i can't clock that high, why is it considered the best gaming board?

The eVGA 680i SLI is the best overclocking dual 16x SLI board out there... period. Its as simple as that. The other boards that can OC higher don't support SLI. Dual 16x SLI is the best platform you could have for SLI, and SLI is the best thing for gaming at super high resolutions. While the margin of superiority may be small, it is still the best. Therefore, the 680i SLI board is the best gaming motherboard out there right now.

SLI is a big waste, since there are single GPU solutions that will be better than anything i can SLI right now.

What single GPU solution can beat an Ultra SLI setup? There are no current single card solutions that will outperform two 8800Ultra cards in SLI, at 2560x1600. SLI is only worth it if you need more performance than the fastest single card solution available, and for high resolutions (1920x1080 or higher). Didn't your research show you all this?

well danny, i doubt this has anything to do with research, since i did research my choices prior to purchasing them...

SLI/Crossfire boards are KNOWN to not OC as high as the other boards (P965, P35, 650i). So, you obviously missed something while doing your research. SLI/Crossfire boards are best paired with CPUs that have high multipliers. Buying an E6320 and 680i SLI board with the goal of reaching 3.5Ghz proves you didn't do enough research, since its widely known that the 680i boards can't reach 500Mhz (7*500=3.5Ghz).

...have 4 gigs of ocz pc2-8500 ram and it's overclocked right now.

FYI, an E6750 @ 4Ghz with PC2-8500 ram, does not need to OC the ram at all. An E6750 at 4Ghz means its 8 * 500 = 4Ghz. At 500Mhz base FSB, your RAM is UNDERCLOCKED, running at DDR2-1000. If it were overclocked, it would need to run faster than DDR2-1066.

...i selected the 680i board because it was, supposedly, a great overclocking device...

It is a great overclocking device... as far as SLI boards go, lol.
 
Back
Top